Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2002 / iii / Paper 64 / 2

Write ${\beta }_T=(k_{B}T{)}^{-1}$ for inverse temperature to distinguish it from the order-parameter critical exponent. A normalized blocking kernel $B_b({\sigma }^{\prime },\sigma )$ is a nonnegative conditional distribution of coarse spins given the fine spins, normalized byFor deterministic blocking it can impose a majority rule or block average, with a Dirac delta replacing the sum constraint for continuous coarse variables. Each block occupies $b^D$ original cells, so the new lattice spacing and number of sites areThe physical volume $N{a}^D$ is unchanged. After $p$ blockings, $a_p=b^{p}a$ and $N_p=b^{-pD}N$.

Define the coarse statistical Hamiltonian by the exact Boltzmann-weight identityThe operator family must include all generated interactions for this renormalization-group transformation to be exact; restricting it to a few couplings is an approximation. The scalar $g(u)$ has energy units and is the contribution per original site that is independent of ${\sigma }^{\prime }$. Restoring the original constant term $NC$ giveshenceThis convention measures $g$ per original site; defining a constant per new site would move a factor $b^D$ into its definition.

The identity-operator contribution to renormalization-group free energy $C_p$ records the configuration-independent normalization generated by the eliminated spins. It includes their contribution to free energy, including entropy and measure factors, and need not be independent of temperature. It has no effect on normalized probabilities of the retained spins, but is indispensable for the total partition function and its temperature derivatives. Iterating its recursion givesThus $N_p{C}_p$ is the original constant $N{C}_0$ plus the accumulated free-energy contributions of the eliminated degrees of freedom.

To obtain the additive free-energy recursion under blocking, use energy-valued free energy per current lattice site,The blocking kernel normalization impliesSubstituting the recursion for $C^{\prime }$ cancels $C$, givingA second step gives $f_0(u_0)=b^{-2D}{f}_0(u_2)+g(u_0)+b^{-D}g(u_1)$, and induction provesFor dimensionless free energy $-\log Z/N$, multiply $F,f_0,g,C$ throughout by ${\beta }_T$.

The singular free-energy density must be distinguished from the exact per-site representative $f_0$. If $a(u)$ is a regular background and $f_s=f_0-a$, thenThus the same displayed inhomogeneous recursion holds with $f_s,g_s$ after subtraction. When a suitable analytic background solves $a(u)=g(u)+b^{-D}a(Ru)$, it leaves a homogeneous singular recursion. Analytic subtraction of an inhomogeneous renormalization recursion explains this separation. A renormalization-group free-energy resonance can obstruct analytic subtraction and produce a logarithm. The original function $g$ originates in the short-distance spins that were summed out, rather than in an extra external interaction.

Near a renormalization-group fixed point $u_{\ast }$, linearize the transformation:An eigenvector of $\mathsf{A}$ with eigenvalue $b^{y_i}$ defines a scaling coordinate $t_i$ with $t_i^{\prime }=b^{y_i}{t}_i$ to leading order. A relevant operator has $y_i>0$: its coupling grows towards large distances, so it must be tuned to reach the fixed point. An irrelevant operator has $y_i<0$ and dies away; a marginal operator has $y_i=0$ and requires higher-order flow analysis. An operator of scaling dimension $x_i$ has $y_i=D-x_i$.

The coarse spins also require a multiplicative normalization. In continuum notation, writewhere ${\varphi }_{<}$ is the retained field and $\eta$ is its anomalous dimension. This restores the normalization of the critical long-distance connected correlation function. Since a uniform field conjugate to an order parameter enters through $\int d^{D}xH\varphi$, it has eigenvalue exponent $y_h=D-x_{\varphi }=(D+2-\eta )/2$.

Let $t$ be the thermal relevant coordinate with exponent $y_t>0$. After regular backgrounds have been removed, the leading singular free-energy density obeysfor a large total scale factor $B=b^p$. Choosing $B=|t{|}^{-1/y_t}$ gives the scaling hypothesis for critical phenomenaTwo temperature derivatives give the heat-capacity critical exponent; one conjugate-field derivative gives the order-parameter critical exponent; two such derivatives give the magnetic-susceptibility critical exponent. Scaling the correlation length gives $\xi (t)=B\xi (B^{y_t}t)$. Consequently,At $t=0$, instead choose $B=|H{|}^{-1/y_h}$; differentiating gives $\delta =y_h/(D-y_h)$. These scaling relations for critical exponents assume that irrelevant variables can be set to their fixed-point values without singular consequences. A dangerously irrelevant coupling or logarithmic correction requires keeping the corresponding dependence.

For the Gaussian field theory, integrate out the Fourier modes in $\Lambda /b<|q|<\Lambda$ and retain ${\varphi }_{<}$. The modes are independent at zero external field, so this Gaussian thinning transformation changes the normalization by a Gaussian determinant and leaves a quadratic statistical Hamiltonian for the retained modes. Restore the cutoff withIn the integrated statistical Hamiltonian, the volume element contributes $b^D$, each gradient contributes $b^{-1}$, and each field contributes $b^{-(D-2)/2}$. Thus the coefficient ${\kappa }^{-1}$ of the gradient energy is unchanged, whileIn particular $y_t=2$, $y_h=(D+2)/2$ and $\eta =0$. The Gaussian critical exponents and the Gaussian order-parameter scaling index therefore give the requested indicesThe sign convention $+h\varphi$ corresponds to the physical conjugate field $H=-h$ and does not affect these powers.

There are physical qualifications to these Gaussian indices. The strictly quadratic Gaussian field theory is stable for positive $m^2$ and has no stable ordered phase for negative $m^2$; its purported spontaneous $\beta$ is therefore the formal Gaussian order-parameter scaling index. A stabilizing quartic term gives an actual ordered phase. Below four dimensions that term is relevant and changes the exponents; above four dimensions it is a dangerously irrelevant coupling and gives the actual mean-field $\beta =1/2$, rather than the Gaussian hyperscaling value.

The heat capacity power can also be checked directly. Apart from constants, the zero-field Gaussian free-energy density isIf $m^2\propto t$, its singular second temperature derivative is controlled by $\int d^{D}q(q^2+\kappa m^2{)}^{-2}$. For $0<D<4$, rescaling $q=\sqrt{\kappa m^2}k$ gives a power $t^{D/2-2}$, as above. At $D=4$ there is a logarithm, and for $D>4$ an analytic background dominates the heat capacity. The negative formal Gaussian $\alpha$ then describes the subleading singular piece, with logarithmic resonances at appropriate even dimensions. This is the Gaussian specific-heat infrared threshold, and it prevents confusing singular indices with the entire observable.