Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2003 / iii / Paper 6 (Introduction to Banach Spaces and Algebras)

Put $C=R/(1-k)$. The hypothesis scales to every residual $r\in F$: if $r\ne 0$, apply it to $r/\Vert r\Vert$ and multiply the resulting vector by $\Vert r\Vert$ to obtain an approximate preimage of norm at most $R\Vert r\Vert$ with error at most $k\Vert r\Vert$. For $r=0$, choose zero.

Start with $r_0=y$. Inductively choose $u_j\in E$ so thatThen $\Vert r_j\Vert \le k^j\Vert y\Vert$ and ${\sum }_j\Vert u_j\Vert \le R\Vert y\Vert /(1-k)$. Completeness of the Banach space $E$ gives $x={\sum }_j{u}_j$. Boundedness of $T$ givesThusThis geometric correction for approximate surjectivity uses no completeness assumption on $F$: every infinite sum was formed in $E$.

To establish the completeness forced by uniformly bounded lifting, let $(y_n)$ be a Cauchy sequence in $F$. Choose a subsequence $(y_{n_j})$ with $\Vert y_{n_{j+1}}-y_{n_j}\Vert \le 2^{-j}$. Lift $y_{n_1}$ to $v_0\in E$ and each difference to $v_j\in E$ with $T{v}_j=y_{n_{j+1}}-y_{n_j}$ and $\Vert v_j\Vert \le C{2}^{-j}$. The series $v_0+{\sum }_j{v}_j$ converges in $E$, and its image under $T$ is the limit of the subsequence. The original Cauchy sequence has that same limit, by the triangle inequality. Hence $F$ is complete.

The open mapping theorem states that a bounded surjective linear map between Banach spaces is open. In particular, a bounded linear bijection has a bounded inverse. This is the theorem the question permits us to state without proof.

For the closed graph theorem, suppose $T:E\to F$ is everywhere-defined and linear with closed graph $G(T)$. The product norm $\Vert (x,y)\Vert =\Vert x\Vert +\Vert y\Vert$ makes $E\times F$ a Banach space, so its closed subspace $G(T)$ is complete. Projection $\pi :G(T)\to E$, $(x,Tx)\mapsto x$, is a bounded linear bijection. Its inverse is bounded by the open mapping theorem; thereforeIt follows that $T$ is bounded, proving the closed graph theorem rather than assuming it.

For the final clause, $S$ is the separating space of a linear map. It contains zero, and if $x_n\to 0$, $T{x}_n\to y$ and $z_n\to 0$, $T{z}_n\to w$, then $\alpha x_n+\beta z_n\to 0$ and its image tends to $\alpha y+\beta w$. Thus $S$ is a vector subspace. If $y_j\in S$ and $y_j\to y$, choose one vector $w_j$ from a witnessing sequence for $y_j$ withThen $w_j\to 0$ and $T{w}_j\to y$, so $y\in S$: it is closed. If $T$ is continuous, every defining image limit is zero, hence $S=\{0\}$. Conversely, if $S=\{0\}$ and $x_n\to x$, $T{x}_n\to y$, then $x_n-x\to 0$ and $T(x_n-x)\to y-Tx\in S$, so $y=Tx$. The graph is sequentially closed and therefore closed in the normed, metrizable product. The proved closed graph theorem now gives continuity. ConsequentlyThe original PDF places $S$ in $F$; the TeX's first reference to a subset of $E$ is a transcription error.

An extreme point $x$ of a convex set $K$ is one for which $x=(1-t)y+tz$, $y,z\in K$ and $0<t<1$ imply $y=z=x$. It is enough to test midpoint decompositions: a nontrivial interior point of a segment is itself the midpoint of a shorter nontrivial segment contained in that segment.

We prove the Krein-Milman theorem. Assume first that $K$ is nonempty. A face of a convex set $K$ means a convex subset $F$ with the property that whenever an interior point of a segment in $K$ belongs to $F$, both endpoints belong to $F$. The family of nonempty compact faces of $K$, including $K$ itself, has a minimal member by the Zorn lemma: every inclusion-decreasing chain has a nonempty intersection by compactness and the finite intersection property, and that intersection is again a compact face.

Let $M$ be such a minimal face. If it contains two distinct points, the continuous dual of a Hausdorff locally convex space separates them, by the permitted Hahn-Banach theorem. Choose a continuous real linear functional $\ell$ that is not constant on $M$. It attains a maximum on the compact set $M$, andis a nonempty proper compact face of $M$, and hence a face of $K$. Indeed, equality at the maximum in a convex combination forces both endpoint values to be maximal. This contradicts minimality. Thus $M$ is a singleton, and its point is extreme in $K$. The same argument applied within any nonempty compact face proves that every such face contains an extreme point of $K$.

Let $C=\overline{\mathrm{conv}}(\mathrm{ext}K)$. It is contained in $K$, since the latter is closed and convex, and extreme points exist when $K$ is nonempty. If $x_0\in K\setminus C$, the permitted separation theorem provides a continuous real linear functional $\ell$ with $\ell (x_0)>{\sup }_C\ell$. Let $F$ be its maximizer face on $K$. This nonempty compact face contains an extreme point $v$ of $K$, butcontradicting $v\in \mathrm{ext}K\subseteq C$. ThereforeFor empty $K$, the equality holds with the usual empty convex-hull convention. This proves both the extreme-point existence step and the closed-convex-hull step; no compactness of the set of extreme points itself is assumed.

The real absolutely summable sequence space is ${\ell }^1=\{x=(x_j):{\sum }_j|x_j|<\infty \}$ with norm $\Vert x{\Vert }_1={\sum }_j|x_j|$. The real l-infinity sequence space is ${\ell }^{\infty }=\{x=(x_j):{\sup }_j|x_j|<\infty \}$ with norm $\Vert x{\Vert }_{\infty }={\sup }_j|x_j|$. Their completeness is allowed as given; their extreme points still require proof.

For ${\ell }^1$, an interior point of the unit ball is not extreme because small opposite perturbations in one coordinate stay in the ball. At a boundary point with two nonzero coordinates $i,j$, choose $0<\epsilon <\min (|x_i|,|x_j|)$ and putThe two distinct vectors $x+z,x-z$ both have norm one and average to $x$, so $x$ is not extreme. A remaining boundary point must be $\pm e_j$. If $e_j=(y+z)/2$ with $\Vert y{\Vert }_1,\Vert z{\Vert }_1\le 1$, the $j$th coordinate forces $y_j=z_j=1$, exhausting both norm budgets and forcing all other coordinates to zero. The negative case is identical. ThusFor ${\ell }^{\infty }$, if $|x_j|<1$ in even one coordinate, small opposite changes to that coordinate give a nontrivial midpoint decomposition within the ball. If every $x_j=\pm 1$, a midpoint decomposition forces both summands to have that same value in every coordinate, so they equal $x$. HenceThese are precisely the extreme points of real sequence-space unit balls for the two spaces under consideration.

For a nonzero complex unital Banach algebra, defineThis is the spectrum of an element; its complement carries the resolvent of an element $R_x(\lambda )=(\lambda 1-x{)}^{-1}$.

If $|\lambda |>\Vert x\Vert$, the Neumann seriesconverges in $A$. Multiplication of finite partial sums followed by a norm limit gives both inverse identities. Thus the spectrum is bounded by $\Vert x\Vert$. The invertible set is open by the allowed assumption, and $\lambda \mapsto \lambda 1-x$ is continuous, so the spectrum is closed. It is therefore compact if nonempty.

To prove nonemptiness, suppose the resolvent exists for every $\lambda$. At a fixed ${\lambda }_0$, the same series applied locally givesfor $|h|\Vert R_x({\lambda }_0)\Vert <1$, proving norm analyticity. Every bounded complex linear functional $\psi \in A^{\ast }$ therefore gives an entire scalar function $\psi (R_x(\lambda ))$. On compact disks it is bounded by continuity of inversion, and the large-$\lambda$ series givesHere the factor $\Vert 1\Vert \ge 1$ handles an algebra norm whose identity was not normalized to one. The Liouville theorem forces each scalar function to be identically zero. The Hahn-Banach theorem separates points of $A$, so $R_x(\lambda )=0$, contradicting $(\lambda 1-x)R_x(\lambda )=1$. HenceThis includes an explicit proof of the nonemptiness of the Banach-algebra spectrum rather than using it as a named result.

For the algebra of entire functions, choose the compact-disk algebra norm on entire functionsIt is finite by continuity on a compact disk, satisfies the norm axioms, and is submultiplicative. If the norm is zero, $f$ vanishes on the open disk, so the identity theorem gives $f=0$ on the plane. Thus it is an actual algebra norm, not merely a seminorm.

No complete algebra norm is possible. For the coordinate function $Z(z)=z$, the function $Z-\lambda 1$ has a zero at $\lambda$ for every complex $\lambda$ and hence cannot have a multiplicative inverse among entire functions. Thus its algebraic spectrum is all of $\mathbb{C}$, independently of any chosen norm. Were an algebra norm complete, the spectral theorem just proved would make that spectrum bounded, a contradiction. Therefore entire functions admit an algebra norm but no complete algebra norm. This distinguishes failure of every complete algebra norm from failure of just the displayed disk norm.

For continuous functions on the plane, construct disjoint plateaux explicitly. LetThe supports of ${\chi }_n$ lie in the disks $|z-n|\le 1/4$, so they are pairwise disjoint and form a locally finite family. Thus $f$ is continuous. On the support where $g_n$ is nonzero, ${\chi }_n=1$ and all other bumps vanish, giving $f{g}_n=n{g}_n$; also $g_n(n)=1$, so no $g_n$ is zero. If an algebra norm existed, submultiplicativity would implyso $n\le \Vert f\Vert$ for every positive integer, impossible. Consequently the algebra of all continuous functions on the plane admits no algebra norm, with no completeness hypothesis needed.

Write $K={\sigma }_A(x)$ and $R(\lambda )=(\lambda 1-x{)}^{-1}$. Choose a bounded finite union of small polygonal regions $V$ with $K\subset V$, $\overline{V}\subset U$ and $\partial V\cap K=\varnothing$. Its positively oriented boundary cycle $\Gamma$ has winding number one on $K$ and zero outside $V$; boundaries of holes have negative orientation. Such regions can be obtained from a sufficiently fine grid around the compact set $K$. This accommodates disconnected spectra and neighborhoods with holes.

Define the holomorphic functional calculus by the norm-convergent contour integralThe integrand is continuous on a finite rectifiable cycle, so the integral exists in the Banach space $A$. Its value is independent of the chosen cycle: on $U\setminus K$ the integrand is holomorphic, and cycles with the stated winding numbers are homologous there. Apply the scalar Cauchy integral theorem to every bounded linear functional and then use the Hahn-Banach theorem to recover equality of the algebra-valued integrals. Equivalently, a common refinement of the polygonal regions gives the same contour-deformation argument.

Linearity is immediate. For the entire functions $1,Z$, enlarge the integration cycle to a sufficiently large circle in the resolvent set, using their entire extension. Integrating the uniformly convergent Neumann series term by term givesTo prove multiplicativity, choose two nested admissible cycles, ${\Gamma }_o$ outside ${\Gamma }_i$, both surrounding $K$ and lying in $U$. The resolvent identity givesUse ${\Gamma }_o$ for $f$ and ${\Gamma }_i$ for $g$, multiply the two integrals, and insert this identity. In the term with $R(\mu )$, the outer Cauchy integral formula replaces $f(\lambda )/(\lambda -\mu )$ by $f(\mu )$. In the term with $R(\lambda )$, the inner integral of $g(\mu )/(\lambda -\mu )$ is zero because $\lambda$ is outside the inner region. ThusThe exchanges of integrals are justified by continuous integrands on compact separated cycles. This proves the unital algebra-homomorphism property, not just an identity of algebra character values.

For continuity in local uniform convergence, fix one cycle and boundThe last supremum is a defining compact-set seminorm of $\mathcal{O}(U)$. Hence the map is continuous.

If another continuous unital algebra homomorphism $\Psi$ sends $Z$ to $x$, its values on polynomials are forced. For every $\zeta \notin U$, the function $(Z-\zeta {)}^{-1}$ exists in $\mathcal{O}(U)$, so multiplicativity forcesTherefore $\Psi$ and ${\Theta }_x$ agree on all rational functions with poles outside $U$. The permitted Runge theorem makes these functions dense in $\mathcal{O}(U)$ for local uniform convergence, including when $U$ is disconnected. Continuity makes the maps agree everywhere. ThusThis proves the continuity and uniqueness of holomorphic functional calculus with the exact topology required.

For an algebra character $\varphi$, multiplicativity and nonzeroness give $\varphi (1)=1$. An invertible element cannot have zero algebra character value, so $\varphi (x)\in {\sigma }_A(x)$. The same observation for each algebra element and the spectral bound from Question 3 gives $|\varphi (b)|\le \Vert b\Vert$; thus a algebra character is automatically a bounded linear functional. In particular,Apply $\varphi$ inside the contour integral and use the Cauchy integral formula with winding number one at $\varphi (x)$:No separation of algebra elements by algebra characters is used; such separation can fail for a general commutative Banach algebra.

For the final clause, the two closed spectral pieces $X,Y$ are compact and have positive distance. Choose disjoint open neighborhoods $U_X,U_Y$ and let $f$ be identically one on $U_X$ and zero on $U_Y$. This locally constant function is holomorphic on their union, and $f^2=f$. Set $e={\Theta }_a(f)$. Multiplicativity gives $e^2=e$, and the proved algebra character formula givesThis is the spectral idempotent from a separated spectrum. It is also nontrivial without assuming that algebra characters separate points. If $e=0$, choose $\lambda \in X$ and define $g=0$ on $U_X$, $g(z)=1/(z-\lambda )$ on $U_Y$. Then $(Z-\lambda )g=1-f$, so $(a-\lambda 1){\Theta }_a(g)=1$, with commuting factors, making $a-\lambda 1$ invertible despite $\lambda \in {\sigma }_A(a)$. This is impossible. If $e=1$, exchange the two pieces and use $\lambda \in Y$ for the analogous contradiction. Hence $e\ne 0,1$.

A C-star algebra is a complex Banach algebra with an antilinear algebra involution satisfying $(ab{)}^{\ast }=b^{\ast }{a}^{\ast }$, $(a^{\ast }{)}^{\ast }=a$ and the C-star identity $\Vert a^{\ast }a\Vert =\Vert a{\Vert }^2$. First take a nonzero unital algebra. Its identity has norm one, since $\Vert 1{\Vert }^2=\Vert 1\Vert$. Alsoand exchanging $a,a^{\ast }$ proves $\Vert a^{\ast }\Vert =\Vert a\Vert$. Thus the algebra involution is continuous. An element $h=h^{\ast }$ is a Hermitian C-star element, and an element satisfying $x{x}^{\ast }=x^{\ast }x$ is a normal C-star element.

We establish the spectral facts needed for the representation, to avoid assuming the conclusion. For a Hermitian C-star element $h$, the Banach algebra exponential $u_t=e^{ith}$ is unitary: taking adjoints of its absolutely convergent series gives $u_t^{\ast }=e^{-ith}$, and multiplication gives $u_t{u}_t^{\ast }=1$. Hence $\Vert u_t\Vert =1$. If $\lambda \in \sigma (h)$, then $e^{it\lambda }\in \sigma (u_t)$. Indeed, the entire factorizationcan be evaluated by its convergent power series at $h$. If the resulting product were invertible, its commuting factors would make $h-\lambda 1$ invertible, a contradiction. The spectral bound therefore gives $|e^{it\lambda }|\le 1$ for every real $t$. Both signs of $t$ force $\mathrm{Im}\lambda =0$. Thus Hermitian elements have real spectrum.

For completeness, the spectral radius formula needed below follows from the same resolvent theory. Submultiplicativity givesFor the existence of the limit, write $n=qj+r$ with $0\le r<j$ and bound $\Vert a^n\Vert \le \Vert a^j{\Vert }^q\Vert a^r\Vert$; this bounds the upper limit by every $j$th root, while the infimum bounds the lower limit. If a power vanishes, the conclusion follows directly. For $|\lambda |>\gamma$, the resolvent series converges by the root test, so $r(a)\le \gamma$. Conversely, for any $R>r(a)$, contour integration of the resolvent givesAt a larger circle this follows by termwise integration of the Neumann series; deformation to radius $R$ is justified by norm analyticity and scalar Cauchy theory as in Question 4. Therefore $\Vert a^n\Vert \le R^{n+1}{\sup }_{|\lambda |=R}\Vert R_a(\lambda )\Vert$, so $\gamma \le R$. Letting $R\downarrow r(a)$ proves $r(a)=\gamma$.

For a normal C-star element $a$, its adjoint commutes with it. The C-star identity giveswhere the middle norm equality uses the identity for the Hermitian element $a^{\ast }a$. Every power is again normal, so $\Vert a^{2^j}\Vert =\Vert a{\Vert }^{2^j}$. The spectral-radius formula yieldsThis derives the spectral radius norm equality for normal elements from the axioms.

Now let $A$ be commutative and unital. Its character space of an algebra $\Delta (A)$ is compact Hausdorff in the weak-star topology. Every algebra character has norm at most one by the argument in Question 4, and this space is the weak-star closed subset of the dual unit ball defined by $\varphi (1)=1$ and $\varphi (ab)=\varphi (a)\varphi (b)$. Compactness follows from the Banach-Alaoglu theorem; weak-star separation makes it Hausdorff.

We also need the full character-spectrum correspondence, not just one inclusion. Every proper ideal is contained in a maximal ideal. Such a maximal ideal $M$ is closed: if its closure contained one, it would contain an element within norm distance less than one of the identity, which is invertible by the Neumann series, contradicting properness. Its closure is therefore proper and maximality gives equality. The quotient $A/M$ is a complex Banach division algebra. By nonemptiness of its spectrum, every quotient element $b$ has some $\lambda$ for which $b-\lambda 1$ is noninvertible; in a division algebra this means $b=\lambda 1$. Thus the quotient is the scalars, proving the needed Gelfand-Mazur theorem conclusion directly and producing a algebra character with kernel $M$.

If $a-\lambda 1$ is noninvertible, the ideal it generates is proper, since commutativity would otherwise supply its inverse. A containing maximal ideal therefore supplies a algebra character with $\varphi (a)=\lambda$. The converse inclusion was already proved. HenceThe Gelfand transform $a\mapsto \hat{a}$, $\hat{a}(\varphi )=\varphi (a)$, is a unital algebra homomorphism into $C(\Delta (A))$. If $h=h^{\ast }$, the reality of its spectrum makes $\varphi (h)$ real. Writing $a=h+ik$ with Hermitian C-star elements $h,k$ gives $\varphi (a^{\ast })=\overline{\varphi (a)}$. Thus the transform respects the algebra involution. Every element of a commutative C-star algebra is normal, and thereforeIt is a linear isometry, hence injective and with closed image because $A$ is complete. The image contains constants, separates algebra characters by their definition, and is closed under complex conjugation. The complex Stone-Weierstrass theorem makes that image dense in $C(\Delta (A))$, and closedness makes it all of that space. We have proved the Commutative Gelfand--Naimark theorem:These steps show exactly how completeness, the algebra involution and the C-star norm identity enter the theorem. A general Banach algebra need not have an injective or norm-preserving Gelfand transform.

The general commutative theorem also has a nonunital form. Here is an elementary construction of the necessary C-star unitization, without assuming the representation theorem. Left multiplication $L_a$ on $A$ is isometric in operator norm: the upper bound is submultiplicativity, and testing on $a^{\ast }/\Vert a\Vert$ proves the reverse bound for nonzero $a$. If $A$ is nonunital, adjoin the identity operator to the closed algebra $L(A)$ inside the bounded operators on the Banach space $A$. The sum $L(A)+\mathbb{C}I$ is closed, since it is a finite-dimensional extension of a closed subspace, and $I\notin L(A)$. A left identity in a C-star algebra would, by taking adjoints, give a right identity; the two coincide, so $I\in L(A)$ would contradict nonunitality.

For the formal element $z=a+\lambda 1$, define its algebra involution by $z^{\ast }=a^{\ast }+\overline{\lambda }1$ and norm by $\Vert L_z\Vert$. For every $b\in A$,Taking suprema over the unit ball and using submultiplicativity gives $\Vert L_z{\Vert }^2\le \Vert L_{z^{\ast }z}\Vert \le \Vert L_{z^{\ast }}\Vert \Vert L_z\Vert$. Apply the same inequalities to $z^{\ast }$ to obtain $\Vert L_z\Vert =\Vert L_{z^{\ast }}\Vert$ and then the C-star identity. This is the C-star unitization by left multiplication. The original algebra is a closed ideal in it.

For commutative nonunital $A$, apply the proved unital theorem to $\tilde{A}$. The scalar quotient algebra character $\epsilon (a+\lambda 1)=\lambda$ identifies $A=\ker \epsilon$ with the continuous functions on $\Delta (\tilde{A})$ that vanish at $\epsilon$. Removing this one algebra character gives a locally compact Hausdorff space; those functions are exactly its continuous functions vanishing at infinity. Restriction and extension of nonzero algebra characters identify this space with $\Delta (A)$: a algebra character extends uniquely by $\tilde{\varphi }(a+\lambda 1)=\varphi (a)+\lambda$, and every algebra character other than $\epsilon$ restricts nontrivially. Thus the full nonunital conclusion is $A\cong C_0(\Delta (A))$.

Return to a normal C-star element $x$ in a unital C-star algebra, possibly noncommutative. Let $B=C^{\ast }(1,x)$, the closed unital star algebra generated by $x$ and $x^{\ast }$. It is commutative because the two generators commute. We first prove the spectral permanence for C-star algebras needed to use the ambient spectrum rather than a potentially larger subalgebra spectrum.

If $h=h^{\ast }\in B$, both its ambient and subalgebra spectra are real. The complement of the compact real set ${\sigma }_A(h)$ is connected. Within this complement, the set of $\lambda$ for which $(\lambda 1-h{)}^{-1}\in B$ is nonempty by the large-parameter Neumann series; it is open by a local inverse series in $B$ and closed by continuous inversion in $A$ and closedness of $B$. It is therefore the entire complement, proving ${\sigma }_B(h)={\sigma }_A(h)$. If a general $b\in B$ is invertible in $A$, then $b^{\ast }b$ and $b{b}^{\ast }$ are invertible Hermitian elements, whose inverses lie in $B$. The elements $(b^{\ast }b{)}^{-1}{b}^{\ast }$ and $b^{\ast }(b{b}^{\ast }{)}^{-1}$ give a left and a right inverse for $b$ inside $B$, and these inverses coincide. Applying this to every $b-\lambda 1$ proves ${\sigma }_B(b)={\sigma }_A(b)$ for all $b\in B$.

By the proved commutative theorem, $B\cong C(\Delta (B))$. The mapis onto by the character-spectrum correspondence and spectral permanence. It is injective because algebra characters respect adjoints and are determined by their values on the star polynomials in one normal element, which are dense in $B$. It is a continuous bijection from a compact space to a Hausdorff space, hence a homeomorphism. Consequently the inverse Gelfand transform, under this identification, suppliesIt is a continuous unital star homomorphism and a linear isometry. Its image is exactly $B$. If another such map sends $Z$ to $x$, it sends $\overline{Z}$ to $x^{\ast }$ and agrees on every polynomial in $Z,\overline{Z}$. These functions contain constants, separate points of the compact spectrum and are closed under conjugation; Stone-Weierstrass gives their uniform density. Continuity proves uniqueness on all of $C({\sigma }_A(x))$. This is the requested continuous functional calculus, including its isometry and image assertion.

Two conventions in the printed statement need to be made explicit. A unital map into $A$ requires $A$ to have an identity. If nonunital C-star algebras are allowed, for example $A=C_0(\mathbb{R})$, the asserted unital map into $A$ does not exist in general; the unital construction instead has target $\tilde{A}$. Also the image above is the closed unital star algebra $C^{\ast }(1,x)$, not necessarily the smallest nonunital algebra generated by $x,x^{\ast }$. For $x=0$ in $A=\mathbb{C}$, the former is $\mathbb{C}1$ and the latter is $\{0\}$. Thus the intended assertion is correct if “generated” includes the identity; without that convention, this is a counterexample. The distinction is the unital versus nonunital generation by a normal element.

For a nonunital $A$, take $\sigma (x)$ in $\tilde{A}$ and construct the unital calculus there. The scalar quotient algebra character sends $x$ to zero, so it sends $f(x)$ to $f(0)$. Functions with $f(0)=0$ therefore give elements of $A$. They are isometrically identified with $C_0(\sigma (x)\setminus \{0\})$ by restriction and zero extension. Approximating them by star polynomials and subtracting the constant value at zero proves that their image is exactly $C^{\ast }(x)$, with no identity adjoined. This proves the nonunital continuous functional calculus as well as specifying the corrected form of the original claim.

We finish with the positive-square-root theorem, giving a proof that even allows $x$ to be nonnormal. Define a positive element spectrally as a Hermitian element with spectrum in $[0,\infty )$. The calculus of a Hermitian element shows its square is positive. Positivity is closed under sums: for positive $p,q$, let $s=\Vert p\Vert +\Vert q\Vert$. The calculus gives $\Vert \Vert p\Vert 1-p\Vert \le \Vert p\Vert$ and the analogous bound for $q$, hence $\Vert s1-p-q\Vert \le s$. Since $p+q$ has real spectrum, the spectral norm bound forces it into $[0,2s]$. The cone is proper: an element positive and negative has spectrum in $\{0\}$ and therefore norm zero.

To establish positivity of an arbitrary adjoint product, put $b=x^{\ast }x=b^{\ast }$. Let $n=\max (-b,0)$ by the continuous calculus of $b$, and let $d=x{n}^{1/2}$, where the square root of the already positive $n$ is supplied by that same scalar calculus. Multiplicativity givesThus $d^{\ast }d$ has nonpositive spectrum. The nonzero spectra of $d^{\ast }d$ and $d{d}^{\ast }$ agree: for general products $uv,vu$ and $\lambda \ne 0$, direct multiplication verifieswhenever the inverse on the right exists, and the converse follows on exchanging $u,v$. Hence $d{d}^{\ast }$ is also nonpositive. Write $d=u+iv$ with Hermitian C-star elements $u,v$. Thenis positive, as a sum of Hermitian squares, and nonpositive, as a sum of the two nonpositive elements. Properness makes it zero. Therefore $d^{\ast }d=-d{d}^{\ast }$ is both positive and nonpositive, hence zero. The C-star identity gives $d=0$, and $n^2=0$ then implies $n=0$. Thus $b=x^{\ast }x$ is positive. This proof does not use positivity of adjoint products in establishing an earlier step.

Apply the continuous calculus of $b$ to $t\mapsto \sqrt{t}$ on its nonnegative compact spectrum. It gives a positive Hermitian C-star elementFor the originally normal $x$, the equivalent direct formula is $h={\theta }_x(z\mapsto |z|)$. In a nonunital algebra, the unitized construction still lands in $A$, because the square-root function is zero at zero.

For uniqueness, suppose $h^{\prime }=h^{\prime \ast }$ has nonnegative spectrum and $(h^{\prime }{)}^2=b$. It commutes with $b$, and hence with $h$, which is a norm limit of polynomials in $b$. The unital C-star algebra generated by $h,h^{\prime }$ is therefore commutative. Its Gelfand transform, together with spectral permanence, gives two nonnegative continuous functions whose squares are equal. Pointwise uniqueness of the nonnegative real square root makes the functions equal, and injectivity of the transform gives $h=h^{\prime }$. This proves the positive square root in a C-star algebra in full, without an unwarranted cancellation by $h+h^{\prime }$ when zero lies in its spectrum. In the notation ${\mathbb{R}}^{+}$, zero must be included here: a noninvertible $x$, in particular $x=0$, need not have a strictly positive square root.