Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2009 / iii / Paper 74 / 2

One normalization of the Papkovich–Neuber representation uses a harmonic vector $\mathbf{\Phi }$ and harmonic scalar $\psi$:These formulae give $\nabla \cdot \mathbf{u}=0$ because ${\nabla }^2(\mathbf{x}\cdot \mathbf{\Phi })=2\nabla \cdot \mathbf{\Phi }$, and give $\mu {\nabla }^2\mathbf{u}=\nabla p$. Rescaling the potentials gives the other common normalizations of the representation.

A point force requires a decaying, rotationally covariant field linear in $\mathbf{F}$, with no length scale. Thus choose the harmonic monopole $\mathbf{\Phi }=c\mathbf{F}/r$, $\psi =0$, for $r>0$. Differentiating givesThe Newtonian fluid stress tensor is ${\sigma }_{ij}=-p{\delta }_{ij}+\mu ({\partial }_i{u}_j+{\partial }_j{u}_i)$, which simplifies to ${\sigma }_{ij}=-3\mu c(\mathbf{F}\cdot \mathbf{x})x_i{x}_j/r^5$. Its traction resultant on a sphere, using an outward normal from the origin, is $-4\pi \mu c\mathbf{F}$. Momentum balance with the force $\mathbf{F}\delta (\mathbf{x})$ therefore fixes $c=1/(4\pi \mu )$. The resulting Stokeslet isAn arbitrary constant pressure may be added. The stress has purely radial traction on concentric spheres, and its integrated traction $-\mathbf{F}$ supplies the required distributional point-force normalization.

Take the upward direction as ${\mathbf{e}}_z$, with polar angle $\theta$ measured from it. The liquid is quiescent at infinity. On a translating clean inviscid bubble, the kinematic boundary condition is $(\mathbf{u}-U{\mathbf{e}}_z)\cdot \mathbf{n}=0$, and the stress-free boundary condition is zero tangential traction. The normal traction must balance uniform gas pressure and any constant-curvature surface-tension jump.

For a vertical Stokeslet of strength $F$, the radial velocity is $u_r=F\cos \theta /(4\pi \mu r)$. Its traction on a concentric sphere is purely normal, so zero tangential traction is automatic. The kinematic condition at $r=a$ givesThe singularity is only a device for generating the exterior solution; there is no liquid point force inside the actual bubble. The integrated dynamic traction on the bubble is $-F{\mathbf{e}}_z$, giving the clean-bubble Stokes drag. The upward buoyancy is $4\pi \rho g{a}^3/3$, hence force balance gives

The normal stress also shows that surface tension is not required for this particular spherical solution. Let the ambient hydrostatic pressure at the bubble centre be $p_c$, so on its surface $p_h=p_c-\rho ga\cos \theta$. Adding the Stokeslet's dynamic normal traction giveswhere the terminal buoyancy value of $F$ cancels the dipole. This is the spherical clean bubble without surface tension balance: an initially spherical bubble can remain spherical in this ideal steady Stokes solution even when surface tension is zero. With uniform surface tension $\gamma$, choose gas pressure $p_b=p_c+2\gamma /a$; with $\gamma =0$, $p_b=p_c$. This proves compatibility of the spherical shape, not stability of arbitrary deformations or validity when inertia matters.

The force scale is $F\sim \rho g{a}^3$. At the distant free surface, the Stokeslet's pressure and viscous normal-stress scales are $F/d^2$. Gravity restores a displaced surface by a pressure change $\rho gh$, soThus $h/d=O((a/d{)}^3)\ll 1$, consistent with treating the boundary as approximately flat and impermeable at leading order. This uses the stipulated gravity-dominated restoring balance.

The liquid-air interface has negligible tangential traction. The stress-free image of a normal Stokeslet places an opposite point force at the reflection point, a distance $2d$ above the bubble centre. Across the flat surface the combined normal velocity is odd and the tangential velocity is even, so the normal velocity and tangential stress vanish there. A same-radius inviscid drop of density $2\rho$ has downward excess weight $4\pi \rho g{a}^3/3$, exactly opposite the bubble's upward buoyancy. Its exterior Stokeslet therefore supplies this image, giving the asserted full-space comparison to leading order in $a/d$.

The image's incident axial velocity at the bubble isTo first reflection, the bubble translates with this locally uniform incident velocity plus its isolated rise speed $F/(4\pi \mu a)$. Hence the bubble rise near a distant stress-free free surface isOnly the first relative correction is retained; the image's spatial variation and additional reflections affect higher terms.

The customary capillary-controlled small-deformation condition is a small capillary number,equivalently a small Bond number $\mathrm{Bo}=\rho g{a}^2/\gamma$. This is a sufficient condition, not a necessary condition for the special isolated spherical solution in part (b). More precisely, the image's strain is $O(F/(\mu d^2))$, so its deformation-producing normal stress compared with $\gamma /a$ is $O(\mathrm{Bo}(a/d{)}^2)$. When exploiting the exact isolated solution, that smaller combination controls the leading boundary-induced distortion. If capillarity at the distant free surface is also retained, the gravity-dominated deflection scaling requires $\gamma /(\rho g{d}^2)\ll 1$; $a\ll \sqrt{\gamma /(\rho g)}\ll d$ allows both the usual spherical-bubble criterion and gravity-dominated surface restoration.