Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Oxford / 2017 / Prelims / Mathematics IV / 4

Put $C=q^2/(4\pi {ϵ}_0)>0$. The spring exerts the force $k(\ell -x)$ by Hooke's law, while Coulomb's law gives the attractive force $-C/x^2$. Newton's second law therefore gives the equation of motionFor $x>0$, the derivative is $f^{\prime }(x)=-k+2C/x^3$. Thus $f$ increases up to $x_{\ast }=(2C/k{)}^{1/3}$ and decreases thereafter. Also $f(x)\to -\infty$ at both ends of the positive half-axis. Its unique maximum isThere are therefore two equilibrium points precisely whenWriting them $x_{-}<x_{\ast }<x_{+}$, the linearization $m\ddot{\eta }=f^{\prime }(x_{\pm })\eta$ has exponentially growing solutions at $x_{-}$ and oscillatory solutions at $x_{+}$. Equivalently, the potential energy has a strict local maximum at $x_{-}$ and a strict local minimum at $x_{+}$. Hence the smaller equilibrium point is an unstable equilibrium; the larger is a stable equilibrium, with no damping to make it attracting.

At equality $\ell ={\ell }_1$ there is one degenerate equilibrium point $x_{\ast }$; it is unstable, since a displacement to its left gives a leftward force. For $\ell <{\ell }_1$ there are no equilibrium points.

Multiply the equation of motion by $\dot{x}$ and integrate. The conserved mechanical energy isThe initial conditions $x=\ell$, $\dot{x}=0$ give $E=-C/\ell$, soInitially $\ddot{x}=-C/(m{\ell }^2)<0$, so the particle starts moving towards the origin. For $0<x<\ell$, factor its kinetic energy asThe quadratic function $x(\ell -x)$ has maximum ${\ell }^2/4$ at $x=\ell /2$. Consequently kinetic energy is strictly positive throughout $0<x<\ell$ exactly when $k{\ell }^3<8C$. Thus the collision threshold isFor ${\ell }_1<\ell <{\ell }_2$ there is no intervening turning point, and the particle collides with the fixed particle. The collision takes finite time: near zero, $|\dot{x}|\sim \sqrt{2C/(mx)}$, so the remaining time is bounded by a constant times ${\int }_0^{\delta }\sqrt{x}dx$.

For $\ell >{\ell }_2$, the first turning point encountered isThe particle oscillates periodically between $x_T$ and $\ell$, around the larger stable equilibrium, without collision. The zeros of $E-V$ at the two endpoints of this allowed region are simple, so travel to each turning point takes finite time. At the boundary $\ell ={\ell }_2$, $x=\ell /2$ is a double zero of $E-V$ and an unstable equilibrium; the inward trajectory approaches it only as $t\to \infty$.