Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge / 2017 / Paper 1 / Section C / C11 / b / Solution

Ehrenfest theorem relates the dynamics of quantum expectation values to operator commutators. For a normalized state obeying $i\hslash |\dot{\psi }⟩=\hat{H}|\psi ⟩$ and a possibly time-dependent observable $\hat{A}$, differentiate $⟨A⟩=⟨\psi |\hat{A}|\psi ⟩$. Using the adjoint Schrödinger equation for the bra givesThusThe identity assumes a common domain on which the required products and derivatives are defined.

For $H=p^2/(2m)+V(x)$, the canonical commutation relation gives $[x,H]=i\hslash p/m$ and $[p,H]=-i\hslash V^{\prime }(x)$. ThereforeThese resemble Hamilton's equations and Newton's second law, but generally $⟨V^{\prime }(x)⟩\ne V^{\prime }(⟨x⟩)$. If the state is localized about $\overline{x}=⟨x⟩$, a local expansion givesThe classical trajectory equation for the mean is accurate when the force changes little across the wave packet. For a quadratic harmonic potential, $V^{\prime }$ is linear and this closure is exact for every state with the relevant finite moments: $m{d}^2⟨x⟩/d{t}^2=-m{\omega }^2⟨x⟩$. This exact classical evolution of the centroid does not eliminate its quantum position uncertainty or make every state a point particle.

The correspondence principle is broader: quantum predictions recover classical ones in an appropriate limit, such as large action compared with $\hslash$ and observations that cannot resolve individual quantum levels. It is not the assertion that every large quantum number automatically makes every possible state classical. Delocalized superpositions and interference can remain significant unless the physical preparation and measurement justify a classical description.

A spectral example is useful. For a quantum harmonic oscillator, neighboring levels differ by $\hslash \omega$, giving transition frequency $\omega /(2\pi )$, equal to its classical oscillation frequency. A coherent state makes the connection more concrete: its mean position and momentum oscillate classically while the finite-width Gaussian profile retains its quantum uncertainty. For hydrogenic Bohr levels $E_n=-A/n^2$, transitions between nearby large $n$ have $\Delta E/\hslash \simeq 2A/(\hslash n^3)$, which equals the classical circular orbital angular frequency in that model. Ehrenfest's theorem supplies an exact expectation-value bridge; a classical trajectory follows only when the force can also be evaluated at the mean position.