Past exam of the quantum theory course of the University of Oxford / 2015 / 2 / b

From $H=a_{+}{a}_{-}/(2m)+\hslash \omega /2$ and the commutator product rule,Consequently, if $H\psi =E\psi$,Thus the creation operator raises the energy eigenvalue by $\hslash \omega$, and the annihilation operator lowers it by $\hslash \omega$, provided the resulting vector is nonzero. The zero vector is not an eigenstate; in particular the ground state will be annihilated by $a_{-}$. The displayed operator identity holds even in that case.

The squared norm is obtained by moving the adjoint operator to the other side of the inner product:For an energy eigenstate, this isSince a squared norm is nonnegative, every nonzero energy eigenstate has $E\ge \hslash \omega /2$. Moreover $a_{-}\psi =0$ exactly when $E=\hslash \omega /2$.

Write $E_0=\hslash \omega /2$. Repeated application of the annihilation operator lowers the energy eigenvalue in steps of $\hslash \omega$. The lower bound from part (ii) forces this process to stop. To see why it also quantizes the starting energy, writeThe first $n$ lowering steps have positive squared norms. If $\delta >0$, the next step is also nonzero by part (ii), and its energy would be $E_0+(\delta -1)\hslash \omega <E_0$, contradicting the bound. Thus $\delta =0$, andExistence of the ground state can also be checked directly in the position representation. The equation $a_{-}{\psi }_0=0$ iswhose solution is proportional to $e^{-m\omega x^2/(2\hslash )}$. This Gaussian function is square-integrable, so it gives an actual ground state. Its normalization can be chosen using the Gaussian integral.

All the displayed levels occur: for a nonzero state at $E_n$,Thus repeated raising creates a nonzero energy eigenstate at every $E_n$.

Let $\psi$ have energy $E_n$ and put $\gamma =2m\hslash \omega$. The lowering norm formula gives, inductively,In particular $(a_{-}{)}^n\psi$ is a nonzero ground state. By the assumed nondegeneracy, it equals $c{\psi }_0$ for some $c\ne 0$.

It remains to show that raising this vector recovers $\psi$, rather than merely another state at the same energy. On an energy eigenstate at $E_n$, factorization gives $a_{+}{a}_{-}\psi =\gamma n\psi$. Iterating the factorization down the ladder yieldsApplying $(a_{+}{)}^n$ to $(a_{-}{)}^n\psi =c{\psi }_0$ therefore provesFor $n=0$ this is the original ground-state assumption. This proves nondegeneracy propagated by an oscillator ladder: every energy eigenspace is one-dimensional if the ground state is nondegenerate.