Past exam of the thermal and statistical physics course of the University of Cambridge / 2019 / Section A / 2 / Solution

Measure single-particle energy from the lowest state and write ${\epsilon }_k=c{k}^{\alpha }$, with $c>0$. In a homogeneous system, the number of wavevector states in a thin spherical shell is proportional to $k^{d-1}dk$. Changing variables from $k$ to $\epsilon$ gives the density of states per unit spatial volume,where $S_{d-1}$ is the area of the unit sphere in $d$ dimensions; an additional internal state degeneracy would multiply this expression by a constant.

The Bose-Einstein distribution has $\mu \le 0$. At saturation, $\mu \to 0^{-}$, the maximum excited-state number density isOnly the lower endpoint can cause divergence. There the integrand is proportional toThe improper integral converges precisely when its power exceeds $-1$. ThusWhen $d=\alpha$, the divergence is logarithmic; when $d<\alpha$, it is a power divergence. In either case the excited states can accommodate any fixed finite density at every positive temperature, so there is no bulk Bose-Einstein condensation at nonzero temperature.

For completeness, putting $s=d/\alpha >1$ and using the Gamma function and Riemann zeta function givesAt fixed density $n$, the right-hand side reaches $n$ at $T_c$; below it the excess particles occupy the lowest state, with condensate fraction $1-(T/T_c{)}^s$. This is Bose condensation with power-law dispersion in the homogeneous thermodynamic limit. A finite vessel or a trapping potential changes the low-energy state count and must not be silently substituted for that setting.