For basic shear with a resting lower boundary, the rigid-boundary buoyancy condition for quasi-geostrophic waves and the decaying vertical exponential give
This is real. The edge wave propagates in the same laboratory direction as the basic flow above its resting lower wall. If the basic buoyancy is , then .
The hydrostatic buoyancy anomaly is , and its leading adiabatic evolution is . The small vertical velocity advects the background stratification; vertical advection of the perturbation buoyancy is higher order. Consequently
The impermeability condition at a stationary lower boundary is . Using gives the topographic buoyancy boundary condition for quasi-geostrophic flow
For application at the reference plane, the actual small-height condition is . Slopes scaled by are of Rossby-number order, so this topographic contribution is retained alongside the small ageostrophic vertical velocity. The dimensional slope should not be compared to the Rossby number without also specifying the aspect ratio.
The basic quasi-geostrophic streamfunction is . It gives , basic buoyancy gradient , and spatially constant interior quasi-geostrophic potential vorticity. Linearizing its conservation law therefore gives
The printed equation omits the shear-advection term. This cannot be omitted for general disturbances: an interior anomaly proportional to is materially conserved but not independent of time at a fixed location. The intended zero-interior-PV Eady model modes do have and satisfy both expressions; the ensuing mode calculation is valid in that subspace.
At either boundary, linearizing the geostrophic material derivative includes . Let
The two boundary equations are
These are exactly the respective bottom and top slope corrections to the rigid-boundary buoyancy condition for quasi-geostrophic waves.
Assume periodicity horizontally and first consider . Multiply its defining equation by and integrate over the layer. The two horizontal Laplacian terms vanish by integration by parts; the remaining volume term after one vertical integration is an -derivative. Therefore
For nonzero , the boundary equations give
The top advection term integrates to zero. Subtracting proves conservation of the boundary pseudomomentum of a sloping Eady layer:
The original PDF uses squared vertical derivatives and the upper slope in the first denominator; these details are corrupted in the converted TeX. For arbitrary nonzero interior PV the same calculation instead gives , which need not vanish. For example, at an instant take , independent of ; the zonal average of is . Thus the boundary-only conservation statement also needs the zero-interior-PV qualification.
For an exponentially growing smooth normal mode, this qualification is automatic: the interior equation is , and a phase speed with nonzero imaginary part cannot equal the real basic velocity. Therefore . If , the conserved boundary quadratic form is definite, so a nonzero exponentially growing boundary amplitude is impossible. Instability consequently requires
for . When one vanishes, the corresponding boundary derivative is simply advected and must vanish for a growing mode. The other boundary then yields a real single-edge-wave speed; if both vanish, the zero-interior-PV Neumann problem has no nonzero growing mode. These degenerate cases are neutral and should not be handled by dividing by zero.
For equal slopes, put , , , and . The normal-mode interior equation is for the zero-interior-PV modes. Thus
The coefficient equations are
Setting their determinant to zero, without dividing by or , gives
so the Eady model with parallel sloping boundaries has
For positive , is the printed , and is the printed . The expression is even in the sign of that vertical scale. For the radicand is at least , so both speeds are real and these modes have no exponential growth. For equal slopes the earlier necessary condition is merely , which is satisfied in many stable cases and is not sufficient. At the speeds are and ; the invariant with nonzero denominators cannot be used, but the determinant still correctly gives neutral modes. No claim excluding transient amplification is needed.
Define the quasi-geostrophic streamfunction by . Leading horizontal geostrophic balance, , gives . The hydrostatic approximation gives , hence
Thus is the material derivative along the leading geostrophic flow, and the vertical derivative of pressure determines the buoyancy perturbation. This also gives thermal wind: and .
The balanced regime is favored by small Rossby number, a shallow aspect ratio, and a Burger number of order one. Equivalently the stratified Froude number is small. On a beta plane, require , and take slow, initially balanced motion away from the equator. Under the traditional approximation, the horizontal Coriolis force generated by vertical velocity is small because vertical velocity is small, while the vertical rotational force is small compared with the leading hydrostatic pressure and gravity terms. Strong stratification and small aspect ratio justify retaining only the vertical component of Earth's rotation in this regime; this argument is not uniform near the equator.
Put . The buoyancy equation gives . Substitution into the vertical vorticity equation yields
There is an important commutator cancellation. With ,
Also for . Adding terms therefore proves potential-vorticity conservation:
This is the three-dimensional quasi-geostrophic potential vorticity.
At an impermeable stationary lower boundary , the kinematic condition is . For small elevation and slope, evaluate this at the reference level to leading order. Combining it with the buoyancy equation gives the rigid-boundary buoyancy condition for quasi-geostrophic waves
The quantity in parentheses is the boundary displacement plus its buoyancy-equivalent displacement.
Now take constant and the mean quasi-geostrophic streamfunction . Its mean buoyancy perturbation is , consistent with thermal wind, and its interior potential vorticity is constant. In the boundary condition, the perturbation velocity advects the mean boundary buoyancy gradient. Keeping this contribution gives
In particular the term must not be omitted.
The linear interior potential-vorticity equation is . Starting with zero interior perturbation potential vorticity, and with forcing only through the boundary, it remains zero. For a steady solution this is also the regular zero-interior-PV choice, continued through any isolated zero of . The inversion equation for a horizontal mode is
The printed convention takes ; for either hemisphere the decay rate is defined using . Boundedness aloft selects the decaying mode. Write
with real part understood. The linear boundary condition becomes
For , a steady quasi-geostrophic mountain wave is therefore
On , its real meridional velocity is
For the positive-parameter convention and , the velocity minimum lies one quarter wavelength downstream of each topographic maximum; its maximum lies one quarter wavelength downstream of each topographic minimum. If the velocity prefactor changes sign, maxima and minima interchange. The condition alone does not fix that prefactor if is allowed to be negative. The upper panel shows the positive-current convention.
Figure 1.
Meridional velocity relative to topography for a steady mountain wave and a resonantly growing edge wave
. Details.
At , the free boundary Eady edge wave has zero frequency in the ground frame. If , a steady amplitude cannot satisfy the forced amplitude equation. With , integration gives
Consequently
The symbol multiplying here is the horizontal wavenumber , as in the PDF. Taking the real part and differentiating in gives
For , positive , and , the meridional-velocity minima coincide with topographic maxima, and its maxima with topographic minima. This is the lower panel. The change from quadrature to opposition is the phase of a resonantly forced topographic edge wave.
The stationary relief continuously excites a boundary Rossby wave whose intrinsic propagation exactly cancels mean advection. The forcing therefore remains coherent with that wave; with no damping or radiation loss for this trapped mode, its linear amplitude grows secularly. This is a resonant topographic quasi-geostrophic wave. Unlimited growth is a conclusion of the linear idealization: eventually the small-disturbance approximation fails.
The assertion that resonance must be unsteady needs nonzero forcing. If , then and the boundary current does not cross the relief; if , the forcing also vanishes. In either case the zero disturbance is a steady solution even if . For example, choose , , and ; this is a concrete exception to an unconditional resonance claim. When both horizontal wavenumbers vanish, and the stated decaying-wave ansatz itself does not apply.
The interior potential-vorticity equation alone does not determine the frequency. Use the rigid-boundary buoyancy condition for quasi-geostrophic waves. Linear adiabatic buoyancy conservation about the basic state gives
At , the impermeability condition sets and the basic velocity is zero. Therefore
Substitution of yields the dispersion relation of a semi-infinite Eady edge wave
For , this is . The sign is fixed by both the thermal-wind relation and the lower-boundary buoyancy budget.
The steering height of a semi-infinite Eady edge wave is obtained by cancelling the phase-speed term against the basic advection in the wave-following frame:
Thus the phase velocity equals the basic thermal-wind velocity at one penetration depth. For nonzero they have the same sign in the laboratory frame. If “exactly opposes the thermal wind” is read literally as , it instead gives , outside the fluid: there is no positive physical height with opposite laboratory velocities. The positive height above is the physically meaningful critical level, where the and contributions to the wave-frame material derivative oppose and cancel. This distinction resolves the ambiguous printed wording without reversing the derived wave speed. If , the shear and vanish, so there is no distinguished steering height.