Spreading a point nuclear electric charge over a small spherical nuclear charge distribution weakens the central attraction and raises electronic energy levels. In nonrelativistic first-order time-independent perturbation theory, a slowly varying -state contact density gives the displayed shift. For a uniform sphere, , and integration of the difference between spherical and point Coulomb potentials gives for a hydrogen-like ion. A nonrelativistic wavefunction vanishes at the origin, suppressing its leading shift to order . Heavy atomic nuclei require relativistic and realistic-charge-distribution corrections. An observed transition frequency shifts by the difference of the two level corrections divided by the Planck constant.
Finite proton-shell correction to hydrogen ground energy Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-10-20
Model a proton as a uniformly charged thin spherical shell of radius . Write . The shell theorem gives an electron potential energy inside the shell and outside. Relative to a point Coulomb potential, the perturbation is consequently for and zero otherwise.
For the hydrogen atom ground state, time-independent perturbation theory gives the first-order energy correction
Since , the signed fractional change is . The correction is positive: distributing the positive charge weakens the attraction near the origin and reduces the magnitude of the binding energy. Here is the Bohr radius and is the small-radius approximation.
Write . The shell theorem makes the potential energy of the electron constant inside the charged spherical shell. Relative to the point-proton Coulomb potential, the perturbation is
It is positive: the finite charge distribution weakens the attraction close to the origin.
The first-order energy correction is the expectation value of this perturbation in the unperturbed hydrogen atom ground state. Integrating its probability density over spherical volume gives
For a proton radius much smaller than the Bohr radius, expand the exponential uniformly over this short interval. The leading integral is
Since , the signed fractional change is
Equivalently, to leading order: the energy increases and the binding-energy magnitude decreases. This is the finite proton-shell correction to hydrogen ground energy.
If no small-radius expansion is made, the same time-independent perturbation theory integral gives, with ,
Its expansion starts with , in agreement with the leading result. The integral is exact for the first-order calculation; it is not an exact solution of the perturbed Schrödinger equation.
The printed magnetic dipole moment uses dimensionless angular momentum operators: their physical counterparts are and . Choose the magnetic field along . Then the Zeeman energy is , whose characteristic size is . In LS coupling, treating this as a time-independent perturbation theory requires it to be much smaller than the relevant fine structure separation, rather than merely smaller than the Coulomb interaction energy.
For a concrete hydrogen atom estimate take the pair. The hydrogen fine-structure correction is
where is the fine-structure constant, distinguished from the later potential coefficient. Thus
Consequently a suitable weak-magnetic field condition for this pair is
There is no single threshold for every hydrogen energy level: the relevant fine structure separations decrease with . The energy level has no same- spin-orbit interaction partner, so it cannot itself define this comparison. This calculation neglects hyperfine structure; resolving that smaller scale requires an additional weak-magnetic field condition.
Within a fixed angular momentum multiplet, the component of along follows from . The corresponding result for follows by interchanging and . For the quantum state ,
These are dimensionless expectation values in the convention of part (a). Substituting into the first-order time-independent perturbation theory formula gives
For , the Landé g-factor becomes
The magnetic sublevels must first be diagonalized within a degenerate multiplet; choosing along the magnetic field already does this. For the displayed fraction is undefined, but all vector expectation values vanish and there is no first-order Zeeman splitting. A higher-order shift may remain.
Put . Gauss's law for a uniform spherical nuclear charge distribution, with the electrostatic potential matched at , gives the electronic potential energy
Subtracting the point-nucleus Coulomb potential leaves the nonnegative perturbation
The normalized nonrelativistic hydrogen-like ion wavefunction has . Since , approximate it inside the atomic nucleus by . First-order time-independent perturbation theory then gives
Define , as the paper specifies for the hydrogen-like ion, rather than the neutral-hydrogen value. Using gives
to leading order in . For , , , and
The finite nuclear charge radius makes the energy level less bound. The quoted frequency is a level shift divided by : a line frequency shifts by , so a decay into this shifted level alone has the opposite sign.
The formula is a nonrelativistic, small-nuclear charge radius estimate. Keeping the exponential in the first-order integral gives , about a one-percent correction here. More seriously, for lead, so relativistic contraction is substantial. A precise physical prediction needs a finite-nucleus Dirac equation calculation; the boxed estimate is the model requested, not precision heavy-ion spectroscopy.
For weak anchoring, , use the normalized free-molecule eigenvectors and . The perturbation is
Its diagonal matrix elements in this basis are both . First-order time-independent perturbation theory for the eigenvalues therefore gives
Hence and . The zero free translation requires taking a square root of its new eigenvalue, rather than Taylor-expanding the frequency about zero. It is not a degenerate eigenvalue in the stipulated one-dimensional two-coordinate model.
As a check, the exact squared frequencies are
Expansion gives the same first-order results; the next lower-mode correction is . The perturbed eigenvectors contain small translation/stretch admixtures of order , consistent with the failure of uniform translation to remain an exact mode in orientation (1).
The ladder operators obey and has , . Since , its eigenvalues are nonnegative. If , lowering gives eigenvalue and squared norm . Repeated lowering cannot produce a negative nonzero eigenstate; the norm product forces to be an integer. The final lowered state has . With a unique ground state all normalized states are
For time-independent perturbation theory, write with . The standard first correction is and the second is . The first vanishes. Only occur, with ladder coefficients and , respectively. Therefore
The downward term is zero for .
Inverting the given position/momentum expressions gives
Thus . For both are positive, and this is a quantum harmonic oscillator of effective mass and frequency . Its exact energies are
Expansion gives , agreeing with both perturbative corrections.
Invert the operator definitions to obtain and the adjoint formula for . The canonical commutation relation yields , with . Substitution gives
Write . Since and , these are lowering and raising operators. Applying to a ground state would lower its energy unless it vanishes, so . From the normalized unique ground state construct
The commutator gives the factorial normalization and . For any energy eigenstate, repeated lowering cannot pass below ; positivity of each lowered norm forces its eigenvalue to be a nonnegative integer and lowering eventually reaches the ground state. Its uniqueness then yields the entire eigenstate ladder. The usual oscillator on the real line has discrete complete spectrum because its potential is confining, so these states span its Hilbert space.
For the perturbation with , nondegenerate time-independent perturbation theory gives . The first-order term vanishes. Only contribute, with squared matrix elements and respectively. Thus
The absent downward transition for is automatically represented by . Direct substitution also gives
For this is another oscillator with mass and frequency . Therefore
Its expansion is , agreeing with the perturbative result and sharpening its remainder. At the excluded endpoints confinement is lost; beyond them the quadratic Hamiltonian is not bounded below.
For a nondegenerate level, time-independent perturbation theory gives
Perturbation theory (quantum mechanics) Created 2026-10-13 Updated 2026-11-05
Perturbation theory expands a quantum problem around a solvable Hamiltonian. Time-independent perturbation theory expands stationary energies and eigenstates; time-dependent perturbation theory expands dynamical amplitudes and transitions.
Time-independent perturbation theory Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-11-05
This is the stationary branch of perturbation theory.