Ciro Santilli @cirosantilli 34

 Incoming links: Binutils

The best articles by Ciro Santilli  Updated 2024-12-15  +Created 1970-01-01

 View more

These are the best articles ever authored by Ciro Santilli, most of them in the format of Stack Overflow answers.

Ciro posts update about new articles on his Twitter accounts.

A chronological list of all articles is also kept at: Section "Updates".

Some random generally less technical in-tree essays will be present at: Section "Essays by Ciro Santilli".

Trended on Hacker News:
- CIA 2010 covert communication websites on 2023-06-11. 190 points, a mild success.
- x86 Bare Metal Examples on 2019-03-19. 513 points. The third time something related to that repo trends. Hacker news people really like that repo!
  - again 2020-06-27 (archive). 200 points, repository traffic jumped from 25 daily unique visitors to 4.6k unique visitors on the day
- How to run a program without an operating system? on 2018-11-26 (archive). 394 points. Covers x86 and ARM
- ELF Hello World Tutorial on 2017-05-17 (archive). 334 points.
- x86 Paging Tutorial on 2017-03-02. Number 1 Google search result for "x86 Paging" in 2017-08. 142 points.
  Figure 1.
  BIOS bare metal hello world running on a Lenovo ThinkPad T430
  . Source.
x86 assembly
- What does "multicore" assembly language look like?
- What is the function of the push / pop instructions used on registers in x86 assembly? Going down to memory spills, register allocation and graph coloring.
Linux kernel
QEMU
gcc and Binutils:
- How do linkers and address relocation works?
- What is incremental linking or partial linking?
- GOLD (-fuse-ld=gold) linker vs the traditional GNU ld and LLVM ldd
- What is the -fPIE option for position-independent executables in GCC and ld? Concrete examples by running program through GDB twice, and an assembly hello world with absolute vs PC relative load.
- How many GCC optimization levels are there?
- Why does GCC create a shared object instead of an executable binary according to file?
C/C++: almost all of those fall into "disassemble all the things" category. Ciro also does "standards dissection" and "a new version of the standard is out" answers, but those are boring:
- What does "static" mean in a C program?
- In C++ source, what is the effect of extern "C"?
- Char array vs Char Pointer in C
- How to compile glibc from source and use it?
- When should static_cast, dynamic_cast, const_cast and reinterpret_cast be used?
- What exactly is std::atomic in C++?. This answer was originally more appropriately entitled "Let's disassemble some stuff", and got three downvotes, so Ciro changed it to a more professional title, and it started getting upvotes. People judge books by their covers.
- notmain.o 0000000000000000 0000000000000017 W MyTemplate<int>::f(int) main.o 0000000000000000 0000000000000017 W MyTemplate<int>::f(int)
  Code 1.
  nm outputs showing that objects are redefined multiple times across files if you don't use template instantiation properly
  . From: What is explicit template instantiation in C++ and when to use it?

IEEE 754

What is difference between quiet NaN and signaling NaN?
In Java, what does NaN mean?

Without subnormals:

          +---+---+-------+---------------+-------------------------------+
exponent  | ? | 0 |   1   |       2       |               3               |
          +---+---+-------+---------------+-------------------------------+
          |   |   |       |               |                               |
          v   v   v       v               v                               v
          -----------------------------------------------------------------
floats    *    **** * * * *   *   *   *   *       *       *       *       *
          -----------------------------------------------------------------
          ^   ^   ^       ^               ^                               ^
          |   |   |       |               |                               |
          0   |   2^-126  2^-125          2^-124                          2^-123
              |
              2^-127

With subnormals:

          +-------+-------+---------------+-------------------------------+
exponent  |   0   |   1   |       2       |               3               |
          +-------+-------+---------------+-------------------------------+
          |       |       |               |                               |
          v       v       v               v                               v
          -----------------------------------------------------------------
floats    * * * * * * * * *   *   *   *   *       *       *       *       *
          -----------------------------------------------------------------
          ^   ^   ^       ^               ^                               ^
          |   |   |       |               |                               |
          0   |   2^-126  2^-125          2^-124                          2^-123
              |
              2^-127

Code 2.

Visualization of subnormal floating point numbers vs what IEEE 754 would look like without them

. From: What is a subnormal floating point number?

Computer science
- Algorithms
  - Figure 5.
    Average insertion time into heaps, binary search tree and hash maps of the C++ standard library
    . Source. From: Heap vs Binary Search Tree (BST)
- Is it necessary for NP problems to be decision problems?
- Polynomial time and exponential time. Answered focusing on the definition of "exponential time".
- What is the smallest Turing machine where it is unknown if it halts or not?. Answer focusing on "blank tape" initial condition only. Large parts of it are summarizing the Busy Beaver Challenge, but some additions were made.

Git

  | 0           | 4            | 8           | C              |
  |-------------|--------------|-------------|----------------|
0 | DIRC        | Version      | File count  | ctime       ...| 0
  | ...         | mtime                      | device         |
2 | inode       | mode         | UID         | GID            | 2
  | File size   | Entry SHA-1                              ...|
4 | ...                        | Flags       | Index SHA-1 ...| 4
  | ...                                                       |

Code 3.

ASCII art depicting the binary file format of the Git index file

. From: What does the git index contain EXACTLY?

tree {tree_sha}
{parents}
author {author_name} <{author_email}> {author_date_seconds} {author_date_timezone}
committer {committer_name} <{committer_email}> {committer_date_seconds} {committer_date_timezone}

{commit message}

Code 4.

Description of the Git commit object binary data structure

. From: What is the file format of a git commit object data structure?

How do I clone a subdirectory only of a Git repository?

Python
- What is the difference between old style and new style classes in Python?
- What is a mixin in Python, and why are they useful?
- What are the differences between threads and processes in Python?
  Figure 6.
  Python Threads vs Processes with 8 hyperthreads
  . Source.
Web technology
- What does enctype='multipart/form-data' mean?
- JavaScript
  - How does JavaScript .prototype work?
  - What is the difference between .prop() vs .attr() in JavaScript?
OpenGL
- Figure 7.
  OpenGL rendering output dumped to a GIF file
  . Source. From: How to use GLUT/OpenGL to render to a file?
- Figure 8.
  Example of a texture atlas containing glyphs
  . Source.
  Image by Nicolas P. Rougier, author of Freetype GL.
  Used on Ciro Santilli's answer: How to draw text using only OpenGL methods?
- Figure 9.
  OpenGL glFrustrum vs glOrtho
  . Source. From: How to use glOrtho() in OpenGL?
- What are shaders in OpenGL?
- Why do we use 4x4 matrices to transform things in 3D?
- Figure 10.
  Sinusoidal circular wave heatmap generated with an OpenGL shader at 60 FPS on SDL
  . Source.
  From: Is it possible to build a heatmap from point data at 60 times per second?
  Compared CPU vs GPU shaders.
- Image Processing with GLSL shaders? Compared the CPU and GPU for a simple blur algorithm.
  Figure 11. Source.
  Video 1.
  OpenGL GPU GLSL fragment shader real time v4l2 Linux webcam computer vision box blur vs CPU
  . Source.
Node.js
- What's the difference between dependencies, devDependencies and peerDependencies in npm package.json file?
Ruby on Rails
- What is the difference between +<%+, +<%=+, +<%#+ and +-%>+ in ERB in Rails?
POSIX
- What is POSIX? Huge classified overview of the most important things that POSIX specifies.

Systems programming

What do the terms "CPU bound" and "I/O bound" mean?
Figure 12.
Plot of "real", "user" and "sys" mean times of the output of time for CPU-bound workload with 8 threads
. Source. From: What do 'real', 'user' and 'sys' mean in the output of time?

+--------+                  +------------+       +------+
| device |>---------------->| function 0 |>----->| BAR0 |
|        |                  |            |       +------+
|        |>------------+    |            |
|        |             |    |            |       +------+
   ...        ...      |    |            |>----->| BAR1 |
|        |             |    |            |       +------+
|        |>--------+   |    |            |
+--------+         |   |         ...        ...    ...
                   |   |    |            |
                   |   |    |            |       +------+
                   |   |    |            |>----->| BAR5 |
                   |   |    +------------+       +------+
                   |   |
                   |   |
                   |   |    +------------+       +------+
                   |   +--->| function 1 |>----->| BAR0 |
                   |        |            |       +------+
                   |        |            |
                   |        |            |       +------+
                   |        |            |>----->| BAR1 |
                   |        |            |       +------+
                   |        |            |
                   |             ...        ...    ...
                   |        |            |
                   |        |            |       +------+
                   |        |            |>----->| BAR5 |
                   |        +------------+       +------+
                   |
                   |
                   |             ...
                   |
                   |
                   |        +------------+       +------+
                   +------->| function 7 |>----->| BAR0 |
                            |            |       +------+
                            |            |
                            |            |       +------+
                            |            |>----->| BAR1 |
                            |            |       +------+
                            |            |
                                 ...        ...    ...
                            |            |
                            |            |       +------+
                            |            |>----->| BAR5 |
                            +------------+       +------+

Code 5.

Logical struture PCIe device, functions and BARs

. From: What is the Base Address Register (BAR) in PCIe?

Electronics
- Raspberry Pi
  - Figure 13.
    Raspberry Pi 2 directly connected to a laptop with an Ethernet cable
    . Image from answer to: How to hook up a Raspberry Pi via Ethernet to a laptop without a router?
    Figure 14.
    Raspberry Pi 2 connected to a laptop with an USB UART adapter
    . Image from answer to: How to hook up a Raspberry Pi via Ethernet to a laptop without a router?
    Figure 15.
    Raspberry Pi OS being emulated on QEMU 2.5.0 on Ubuntu 16.04 with a modified kernel
    . Image from answer to: How to emulate the Raspberry Pi 2 on QEMU?
    Figure 16.
    Bare metal LED blinker program running on a Raspberry Pi 2
    . Image from answer to: How to run a C program with no OS on the Raspberry Pi?
Computer security
- Why is the same origin policy so important?
Media
- Video 2.
  Canon in D in C
  . Source.
  From: How is audio represented with numbers in computers?.
  The original question was deleted, lol...: How to programmatically synthesize music?
- How to resize a picture using ffmpeg's sws_scale()?
- Is there any decent speech recognition software for Linux? ran a few examples manually on vosk-api and compared to ground truth.
Eclipse
- How to set up the Eclipse for remote C debugging with gdbserver?
Computer hardware
- Are there good open source standard cell libraries to learn IC synthesis with EDA tools?
Scientific visualization software
- Figure 17.
  VisIt zoom in 10 million straight line plot with some manually marked points
  . Source. From: Section "Survey of open source interactive plotting software with a 10 million point scatter plot benchmark by Ciro Santilli"
Numerical analysis
- Video 3.
  Real-time heat equation OpenGL visualization with interactive mouse cursor using relaxation method by Ciro Santilli (2016)
  Source.
Computational physics
- Figure 18.
  gnuplot plot of the y position of a sphere bouncing on a plane simulated in Bullet Physics
  . Source. From: What is the simplest collision example possible in a Bullet Physics simulation?
Register transfer level languages like Verilog and VHDL
- Verilog:
  Figure 19.
  Interacgive ASDF-controlled demo with core logic written in Verilog using Verilator
  .
  From: Is it possible to do interactive user input and output simulation in VHDL or Verilog?
  See also: Section "Verilator interactive example"
Android
- Figure 20. Source. From: How to compile the Android AOSP kernel and test it with the Android Emulator?
- Video 4.
  Android screen showing live on an Ubuntu laptop through ADB
  . Source. From: How to see the Android screen live on an Ubuntu desktop through ADB?
Debugging
Program optimization
- What is tail call optimization?
- Figure 21.
  gprof2dot image generated from the gprof data of a simple test program
  . Source.
  From: How can I profile C++ code running on Linux?
  The answer compares gprof, valgrind callgrind, perf and gperftools on a single simple executable.
Data
- Figure 22.
  Mathematics dump of Wikipedia CatTree
  . Source.
Mathematics
- Figure 23.
  Diagram of the fundamental theorem on homomorphisms by Ciro Santilli (2020)
  
  Shows the relationship between group homomorphisms and normal subgroups.
  From: What is the intuition behind normal subgroups?
- Section "Formalization of mathematics": some early thoughts that could be expanded. Ciro almost had a stroke when he understood this stuff in his teens.
- Figure 24.
  Simple example of the Discrete Fourier transform
  . Source. That was missing from Wikipedia page: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discrete_Fourier_transform!
Network programming
- How to make an HTTP get request in C without libcurl?
Physics
- What is the difference between plutonium and uranium?
- Figure 25.
  Spacetime diagram illustrating how faster-than-light travel implies time travel
  . From: Does faster than light travel imply travelling back in time?
Biology
- Figure 26.
  Top view of an open Oxford Nanopore MinION
  . Source. From: Section "How to use an Oxford Nanopore MinION to extract DNA from river water and determine which bacteria live in it"
- Figure 27.
  Mass fractions in a minimal growth medium vs an amino acid cut in a simulation of the E. Coli Whole Cell Model by Covert Lab
  . Source. From: Section "E. Coli Whole Cell Model by Covert Lab"
Quantum computing
- Section "Quantum computing is just matrix multiplication"
- Figure 28.
  Visualization of the continuous deformation of states as we walk around the Bloch sphere represented as photon polarization arrows
  . From: Understanding the Bloch sphere.
Bitcoin
- Section "Cool data embedded in the Bitcoin blockchain"
GIMP
- Figure 29.
  GIMP screenshot part of how to combine two images side-by-side in GIMP?
  .
Home DIY
- Figure 30.
  Total_Blackout_Cassette_Roller_Blind_With_Curtains.
  Source. From: Section "How to blackout your window without drilling"
China
- What would happen if I walked around Beijing with a t-shirt that said "freedom of speech is pretty great"?

 Read the full article

Mailing list  Updated 2024-12-15  +Created 1970-01-01

 View more

It boggles Ciro Santilli's mind that people use mailing list to collaborate on projects!

The only explanation is that the dinosaurs who created the projects are unable to adapt to new superior technologies.

Yes, Ciro is talking to you, big fundamental projects from last century: Linux kernel, GNU Compiler Collection (gcc.gnu.org/lists.html), Binutils (sourceware.org/binutils/), etc.

Some of you are already using Bugzilla for the bugs, so kudos. But if you've seen their benefit, why you still use the mailing list for patches?

Advantages of mailing lists:

threaded replies, which almost no issue tracker has. GitHub feature request: github.com/isaacs/github/issues/837

Disadvantages: everything else:

cannot subscribed to a single thread. Which forces you to create an email filter for each one of them you subscribe to.
no metadata, notably the notion of closing / merging, but also upvotes
You have to read thirty messages before you can know if the bug was solved or not.
it is insanely hard to reply to messages from before you were subscribed: webapps.stackexchange.com/questions/23197/reply-to-mailman-archived-message/115088#115088
This forces everyone to subscribe to all lists, and then set up email filters to not be flooded with emails.
hard to apply patches locally to test them out: stackoverflow.com/questions/5062389/how-to-use-git-am-to-apply-patches-from-email-messages/49082916#49082916
Unless they use Patchwork, which adds one more website on top of the mess.
And then Gmail corrupts your patches, and you are forced to use git send-email, which does not work on some network configurations: stackoverflow.com/questions/28038662/how-to-solve-unable-to-initialize-smtp-properly-when-using-using-git-send-ema or setup ThunderBird.
often have to subscribe to post at all, thus cluttering your inbox further
you can edit posts to make them clearer.
Yes, people could vandalize their answers when they get mad, and threads might stop making sense after edits. But this can be solved with an undeletable post history like Stack Overflow has (but not any other tracker does).
Or archive.org :-)
In any case, what do you think will happen more often and have greater impact:
- people vandalize their posts
- people fix their silly typos and improve content
searchable by author, keyword, etc. without Google. Yes, mailing list trackers could have decent implementations to overcome that. But no, GNU Mailman which everyone uses does not have it. Google barely indexes it.
And I don't think Google properly indexes many of the mailing list archives for some reason: I never get hits for my own posts a week later, while I often do on GitHub issues.
people have to learn about top posting vs inline posting, and this requires infinite education of new users
Line comments in code reviews like GitHub and GitLab.
On mailing lists: either put a comment in the middle of a huge patch and let other people find it, or (more likely) copy paste the part of the patch that you are talking about.
most mail web UIs suck.
OK, this is not an unsolvable or intrinsic problem, but still a problem.
E.g.: ezmlm it is not possible to see the entire content in a single page: gcc.gnu.org/ml/gcc/2015-07/threads.html.
Unless you like reading threads backwards and with 4 levels of > quotations.
The alternative: do like LLVM and send attachments. Yes, I we all love opening up attachments on our browsers.
The real solution: everyone can create branches and pull requests. Also has the benefit of running CI on the pull requests.

Not sure:

you can have infinitely many trackers to replicate data in case apocalypse happens in some part of the world.
Although I'm not sure this is an advantage, as you don't know anymore which one is the canonical trackers an advantage, as you don't know anymore which one is the canonical tracker.
And all web interfaces already have an API to export messages, and someone has already scripted it to import from any web UI to any web UI for you.
And GitHub offers infinite precise history transparently on its API.

Smart people who agree with Ciro:

 Read the full article