The best articles by Ciro Santilli

These are the best articles ever authored by Ciro Santilli, most of them in the format of Stack Overflow answers.

Ciro posts update about new articles on his Twitter accounts.

Some random generally less technical in-tree essays will be present at: Section "Essays by Ciro Santilli".

Trended on Hacker News:
- CIA 2010 covert communication websites on 2023-06-11. 190 points, a mild success.
- x86 Bare Metal Examples on 2019-03-19. 513 points. The third time something related to that repo trends. Hacker news people really like that repo!
  - again 2020-06-27 (archive). 200 points, repository traffic jumped from 25 daily unique visitors to 4.6k unique visitors on the day
- How to run a program without an operating system? on 2018-11-26 (archive). 394 points. Covers x86 and ARM
- ELF Hello World Tutorial on 2017-05-17 (archive). 334 points.
- x86 Paging Tutorial on 2017-03-02. Number 1 Google search result for "x86 Paging" in 2017-08. 142 points.
  Figure 1. BIOS bare metal hello world running on a Lenovo ThinkPad T430. Source.
x86 assembly
- What does "multicore" assembly language look like?
- What is the function of the push / pop instructions used on registers in x86 assembly? Going down to memory spills, register allocation and graph coloring.
Linux kernel
QEMU
gcc and Binutils:
- How do linkers and address relocation works?
- What is incremental linking or partial linking?
- GOLD (-fuse-ld=gold) linker vs the traditional GNU ld and LLVM ldd
- What is the -fPIE option for position-independent executables in GCC and ld? Concrete examples by running program through GDB twice, and an assembly hello world with absolute vs PC relative load.
- How many GCC optimization levels are there?
- Why does GCC create a shared object instead of an executable binary according to file?
C>/C++: almost all of those fall into "disassemble all the things" category. Ciro also does "standards dissection" and "a new version of the standard is out" answers, but those are boring:
- What does "static" mean in a C program?
- In C++ source, what is the effect of extern "C"?
- Char array vs Char Pointer in C
- How to compile glibc from source and use it?
- When should static_cast, dynamic_cast, const_cast and reinterpret_cast be used?
- What exactly is std::atomic in C++?. This answer was originally more appropriately entitled "Let's disassemble some stuff", and got three downvotes, so Ciro changed it to a more professional title, and it started getting upvotes. People judge books by their covers.
- ```
notmain.o
0000000000000000 0000000000000017 W MyTemplate<int>::f(int)
main.o
0000000000000000 0000000000000017 W MyTemplate<int>::f(int)
```
  Code 1. nm outputs showing that objects are redefined multiple times across files if you don't use template instantiation properly. From: What is explicit template instantiation in C++ and when to use it?

What is difference between quiet NaN and signaling NaN?
In Java, what does NaN mean?

Without subnormals:

          +---+---+-------+---------------+-------------------------------+
exponent  | ? | 0 |   1   |       2       |               3               |
          +---+---+-------+---------------+-------------------------------+
          |   |   |       |               |                               |
          v   v   v       v               v                               v
          -----------------------------------------------------------------
floats    *    **** * * * *   *   *   *   *       *       *       *       *
          -----------------------------------------------------------------
          ^   ^   ^       ^               ^                               ^
          |   |   |       |               |                               |
          0   |   2^-126  2^-125          2^-124                          2^-123
              |
              2^-127

With subnormals:

          +-------+-------+---------------+-------------------------------+
exponent  |   0   |   1   |       2       |               3               |
          +-------+-------+---------------+-------------------------------+
          |       |       |               |                               |
          v       v       v               v                               v
          -----------------------------------------------------------------
floats    * * * * * * * * *   *   *   *   *       *       *       *       *
          -----------------------------------------------------------------
          ^   ^   ^       ^               ^                               ^
          |   |   |       |               |                               |
          0   |   2^-126  2^-125          2^-124                          2^-123
              |
              2^-127

Code 2. Visualization of subnormal floating point numbers vs what IEEE 754 would look like without them. From: What is a subnormal floating point number?

Computer science
- Algorithms
  - Figure 5. Average insertion time into heaps, binary search tree and hash maps of the C++ standard library. Source. From: Heap vs Binary Search Tree (BST)
- Is it necessary for NP problems to be decision problems?
- Polynomial time and exponential time. Answered focusing on the definition of "exponential time".
- What is the smallest Turing machine where it is unknown if it halts or not?. Answer focusing on "blank tape" initial condition only. Large parts of it are summarizing the Busy Beaver Challenge, but some additions were made.

Git

  | 0           | 4            | 8           | C              |
  |-------------|--------------|-------------|----------------|
0 | DIRC        | Version      | File count  | ctime       ...| 0
  | ...         | mtime                      | device         |
2 | inode       | mode         | UID         | GID            | 2
  | File size   | Entry SHA-1                              ...|
4 | ...                        | Flags       | Index SHA-1 ...| 4
  | ...                                                       |

Code 3. ASCII art depicting the binary file format of the Git index file. From: What does the git index contain EXACTLY?

tree {tree_sha}
{parents}
author {author_name} <{author_email}> {author_date_seconds} {author_date_timezone}
committer {committer_name} <{committer_email}> {committer_date_seconds} {committer_date_timezone}

{commit message}

Code 4. Description of the Git commit object binary data structure. From: What is the file format of a git commit object data structure?

How do I clone a subdirectory only of a Git repository?

Python
- What is the difference between old style and new style classes in Python?
- What is a mixin in Python, and why are they useful?
- What are the differences between threads and processes in Python?
  Figure 6. Python Threads vs Processes with 8 hyperthreads. Source.
Web technology
- What does enctype='multipart/form-data' mean?
- JavaScript
  - How does JavaScript .prototype work?
  - What is the difference between .prop() vs .attr() in JavaScript?
OpenGL
- Figure 7. OpenGL rendering output dumped to a GIF file. Source. From: How to use GLUT/OpenGL to render to a file?
- Figure 8. Example of a texture atlas containing glyphs. Source.
  Image by Nicolas P. Rougier, author of Freetype GL.
  Used on Ciro Santilli's answer: How to draw text using only OpenGL methods?
- Figure 9. OpenGL glFrustrum vs glOrtho. Source. From: How to use glOrtho() in OpenGL?
- What are shaders in OpenGL?
- Why do we use 4x4 matrices to transform things in 3D?
- Figure 10. Sinusoidal circular wave heatmap generated with an OpenGL shader at 60 FPS on SDL. Source.
  From: Is it possible to build a heatmap from point data at 60 times per second?
  Compared CPU vs GPU shaders.
- Image Processing with GLSL shaders? Compared the CPU and GPU for a simple blur algorithm.
  Figure 11. Source.
  Video 1. OpenGL GPU GLSL fragment shader real time v4l2 Linux webcam computer vision box blur vs CPU. Source.
Node.js
- What's the difference between dependencies, devDependencies and peerDependencies in npm package.json file?
Ruby on Rails
- What is the difference between +<%+, +<%=+, +<%#+ and +-%>+ in ERB in Rails?
POSIX
- What is POSIX? Huge classified overview of the most important things that POSIX specifies.

Systems programming

What do the terms "CPU bound" and "I/O bound" mean?
Figure 12. Plot of "real", "user" and "sys" mean times of the output of time for CPU-bound workload with 8 threads. Source. From: What do 'real', 'user' and 'sys' mean in the output of time?

+--------+                  +------------+       +------+
| device |>---------------->| function 0 |>----->| BAR0 |
|        |                  |            |       +------+
|        |>------------+    |            |
|        |             |    |            |       +------+
   ...        ...      |    |            |>----->| BAR1 |
|        |             |    |            |       +------+
|        |>--------+   |    |            |
+--------+         |   |         ...        ...    ...
                   |   |    |            |
                   |   |    |            |       +------+
                   |   |    |            |>----->| BAR5 |
                   |   |    +------------+       +------+
                   |   |
                   |   |
                   |   |    +------------+       +------+
                   |   +--->| function 1 |>----->| BAR0 |
                   |        |            |       +------+
                   |        |            |
                   |        |            |       +------+
                   |        |            |>----->| BAR1 |
                   |        |            |       +------+
                   |        |            |
                   |             ...        ...    ...
                   |        |            |
                   |        |            |       +------+
                   |        |            |>----->| BAR5 |
                   |        +------------+       +------+
                   |
                   |
                   |             ...
                   |
                   |
                   |        +------------+       +------+
                   +------->| function 7 |>----->| BAR0 |
                            |            |       +------+
                            |            |
                            |            |       +------+
                            |            |>----->| BAR1 |
                            |            |       +------+
                            |            |
                                 ...        ...    ...
                            |            |
                            |            |       +------+
                            |            |>----->| BAR5 |
                            +------------+       +------+

Code 5. Logical struture PCIe device, functions and BARs. From: What is the Base Address Register (BAR) in PCIe?