Helicity spectrum of a massless supermultiplet Created 2026-10-05 Updated 2026-10-14
For a four-dimensional massless supermultiplet with independent supercharges and highest helicity , level has helicity and multiplicity . The total is states and the helicity range has width , before any necessary CPT completion of a supermultiplet.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2001 iii Paper 65 2 ii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For a massless supermultiplet, put the momentum along the third axis. The matrix in the supersymmetry algebra has rank one, so only one fermionic oscillator acts nontrivially. It relates states whose helicities differ by . Including the antiparticles required by CPT completion of a supermultiplet gives the following complete spectra.
A chiral multiplet contains a complex scalar and a Weyl spinor . Its scalar particle and antiparticle have helicity ; its fermion particle and antiparticle have helicities and . Therefore , with maximum absolute helicity .
A supersymmetric vector multiplet contains a massless gauge vector , with helicities , and a Majorana spinor gaugino , with helicities . Again , now with maximum absolute helicity . The chiral and vector auxiliary fields contribute no on-shell states.
The Higgs mechanism is compatible with unbroken supersymmetry. A supersymmetric vacuum may have nonzero scalar vacuum expectation values that break the internal gauge symmetry while obeying both F-flatness and D-flatness. For example, oppositely charged chiral superfields with , no Fayet–Iliopoulos term and equal nonzero scalar magnitudes have but break the Abelian gauge group. In the supersymmetric Higgs mechanism, a massless vector multiplet combines with the chiral multiplet along the broken gauge direction. One real scalar becomes the longitudinal vector polarization; the other remains a physical real scalar, and the gaugino combines with the Higgsino into a Dirac spinor. The resulting massive vector multiplet has bosonic and fermionic states with a common mass, as in part (i). Any other uneaten chiral multiplets remain separately in the spectrum.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2002 iii Paper 68 1 b Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For physical finite-spin one-particle states, a positive-energy Poincaré group representation is labelled by mass and spin when , or mass and helicity when massless. The individual states also carry their four-momentum and a spin projection. For four-dimensional N=1 supersymmetry, the irreducible labels become , with the superspin, or , with a chosen superhelicity convention. The constituent representation labels arewith the last entry omitted for , andA required CPT completion of a supermultiplet adds the conjugate labels and conjugates any internal charges.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2002 iii Paper 68 2 Solution 2026-10-14
Choose the extended supersymmetry normalizationThe central charge in supersymmetry is antisymmetric in , because the full anticommutator is symmetric and is antisymmetric. In a massive one-particle state rest frame, , and the first anticommutator becomes .
A unitary skew-diagonalization of an antisymmetric matrix puts into blocks , with a remaining zero direction if is odd. For one block write , and label its two supersymmetries . The combinationshaveFor example the mixed contribution to the first expression is . This is the phase-aligned version of taking a supercharge minus a unitary combination of its adjoints, as suggested by the hint.
For every operator and normalized state ,Applying this to in every block proves the BPS boundIf the algebra is instead written with on its right side, the same result is ; the factor is purely a central-charge convention.
A BPS state saturates at least one of these inequalities. The corresponding zero-norm combinations of supercharges and their adjoints annihilate the representation, so part of supersymmetry is preserved. Its massive supermultiplet is shortened: each saturated block removes two complex fermionic oscillators, giving states from a spin- Clifford vacuum when blocks saturate, before any necessary CPT completion of a supermultiplet. It preserves of the real supercharges. Its mass is tied to the central charges in supersymmetry and remains protected while it stays on the same short branch. Stability is not unconditional: a wall of marginal stability can permit a charged BPS state to decay into other BPS states with the same total charge.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2004 iii Paper 50 1 a Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Positive-energy one-particle Poincaré group representations have labels for , and for finite-helicity massless states; individual massive polarizations add . An massive supermultiplet is labelled by mass and superspin , with constituent labelsA massless supermultiplet has constituent labelsA CPT completion of a supermultiplet additionally supplies , with conjugated internal charges where applicable. Constituent spins/helicities are the labels here, not counts of polarizations.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2005 iii Paper 55 1 a Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For null four-momentum, has rank one in its spinor indices. Positivity makes the null combinations act trivially; the remaining normalized pairs obey . Acting with distinct lowering operators on a highest-helicity state gives the helicity spectrum of a massless supermultiplet:A CPT completion of a supermultiplet adds the opposite helicities if needed. Interpreting the physical spin bounds as , the width fits inside only if . A literal one-sided bound on helicity without CPT would not give this maximum. The maximal spectra areandThus the maxima are (N=4) for spin at most one and (N=8) for spin at most two, with 16 and 256 states. Dimensional reduction of ten-dimensional super Yang-Mills theory on a six-torus gives the first: the vector yields one four-dimensional vector and six real scalar fields, and its Majorana-Weyl spinor yields four Weyl spinors. Reducing eleven-dimensional supergravity on a seven-torus gives the second: metric components supply one graviton, seven vectors and 28 scalars; the three-form supplies 21 vectors, 35 scalars and seven dualized two-form scalars; the gravitino supplies eight gravitini and 56 spin-half fields. These total 28 vectors and 70 scalars, with 128 boson and 128 fermion states.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2006 iii Paper 54 1 ii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
In four dimensions, extended supersymmetry has independent Weyl spinor supercharges, or real generators. With the ordinary particle Super-Poincaré algebra,The central charges in supersymmetry commute with spacetime generators and the supercharges; an R-symmetry can act on their internal indices. Antisymmetry makes a scalar central charge impossible for .
At positive timelike momentum, the rest-frame supercharges act as fermionic oscillators. Without central charges, a spin- Clifford vacuum generates states. For a massless supermultiplet, positivity makes half the supercharges act trivially. The remaining creation operators generate states with helicity levels and multiplicities . A separate CPT completion of a supermultiplet may be necessary. Keeping all helicities between and gives for a theory without gravity; allowing helicity two gives .
A nonzero central charge in supersymmetry changes the oscillator norms. For an central-charge block, write . Suitable combinations of a charge and the adjoint of the other have anticommutators and . Their positivity givesA BPS state saturates this BPS bound in supersymmetry. The combinations with zero anticommutator annihilate it, preserving part of supersymmetry and giving a shortened BPS supermultiplet. In this example a scalar-seeded massive multiplet has four states instead of sixteen, before any required CPT completion. More central-charge blocks allow different fractions of preserved supersymmetry. The mass-charge relation is protected as long as the short state exists; this does not guarantee stability against decay everywhere in parameter space.
The main obstruction to unbroken extended supersymmetry at low energies is the chirality constraint on extended supersymmetry. An vector multiplet contains an additional adjoint complex scalar. A full hypermultiplet contains two matter chiral superfields in conjugate gauge representations and . Its charged fermion spectrum is therefore vectorlike. Half-hypermultiplets in pseudoreal representations do not supply genuinely complex chirality. The gauge multiplet is still more restrictive: it has four adjoint Weyl spinors and six adjoint real scalars. These spectra and their constrained interactions cannot directly reproduce the chiral electroweak matter and arbitrary Yukawa couplings of the Standard Model.
At most unbroken supersymmetry can directly describe the observed chiral four-dimensional gauge spectrum. Extended supersymmetry can be useful in a higher-energy theory, in an internal sector or before compactification, but it must be reduced or broken to obtain that low-energy spectrum. This is a statement about unbroken symmetry of the relevant sector, not a prohibition on extended supersymmetric ultraviolet descriptions.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2006 iii Paper 54 2 Solution 2026-10-14
Use , and , where are the Pauli matrices. The translation and Lorentz generators obey the Poincare algebraOne can derive the additional relations by realizing the supercharges as differential operators on superspace. With left Grassmann derivatives and , takeUsing , the two mixed derivative-coordinate terms each give . The remaining terms cancel by Grassmann anticommutation. Equal-chirality terms cancel in the same way. HenceAll coefficients are independent of , so direct differentiation gives . This also shows that supercharges commute with translations and preserve the four-momentum of a state.
For the Lorentz generators, define the left-handed spinor matricesThe identity gives their Lorentz commutation relations. Acting on the spinor superspace coordinates and their dual derivatives then gives, in a column-component convention,Here dotted index values are identified with the conjugate undotted values, and . The second formula also follows directly by taking the adjoint of the first, using Hermitian . For example, , so and for . This explicit component convention avoids reversing signs by mixing state matrices with operator-component matrices. Covariance of the mixed anticommutator follows by applying these matrices to .
These are the minimal Super-Poincaré algebra relations. In the ordinary particle algebra a possible scalar term in would be proportional to , but an anticommutator is symmetric in its two labels; with only one supersymmetry such a central term vanishes. Extended algebras can instead use an antisymmetric internal index tensor. Tensor charges associated with extended objects are not part of this minimal particle algebra.
For a positive-energy massless supermultiplet, choose with , so andPositivity of the Hilbert-space norm implies that both and annihilate every state: their squared norms sum to zero. SetFor momentum along the positive third axis, helicity is . The Lorentz commutators give and . Choose a highest-helicity Clifford vacuum with . Its partner has unit norm if the first state does and has helicity . No further state is generated because . ThereforeThe two states have opposite fermion parity. A CPT completion of a supermultiplet adds helicities and conjugate internal charges when necessary. Taking produces a complex scalar and a Weyl spinor after CPT completion; taking produces the massless vector multiplet. This construction assumes ordinary finite-helicity particle representations, rather than continuous-spin representations.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2008 iii Paper 53 4 c Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Choose a positive-energy massless momentum . Then , so the Super-Poincaré algebra givesUnitarity forces and its adjoint to vanish on this representation: the sum of their squared state norms is zero. Set . The surviving operators obeyThe helicity operator is for this momentum. In the component convention above, and . A highest-helicity state with therefore generates exactly two states,one bosonic and one fermionic. This is the helicity spectrum of a massless supermultiplet. The CPT theorem reverses helicity and conjugates internal charges, so CPT completion of a supermultiplet adds when that pair is not already present.
For the usual integer and half-integer helicities up to spin two, the CPT-complete contents areThe chiral superfield describes one complex scalar and one Weyl fermion; the vector multiplet has a massless gauge vector and its gaugino. The gravitino multiplet contains a spin-one vector and a spin-three-halves field, while the supergravity multiplet contains the graviton and gravitino. All have two physical bosonic and two physical fermionic helicity states after CPT completion. The general two-state construction also describes higher-helicity formal multiplets; their existence as representations alone does not establish a consistent interacting higher-spin theory.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2010 iii Paper 40 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
A BPS state is a state whose mass saturates a lower bound set by conserved charges in the Super-Poincaré algebra. Saturation leaves some linear combinations of supercharges unbroken and produces a shortened massive supermultiplet. Both statements follow from the positivity of the physical Hilbert-space norm, rather than from an assumed classical field configuration.
For four-dimensional extended supersymmetry, choose the normalizationThe conjugate algebra is obtained by Hermitian conjugation. The antisymmetry of the central charge in supersymmetry matrix follows because the anticommutator is symmetric in the combined labels while is antisymmetric. These central charges commute with momentum and supercharges, so their eigenvalues are fixed in an irreducible massive representation. In the rest frame, and .
For any operator and physical state ,Apply this to , where is unitary. This is the rest-frame version of the positive operator constructed from . Summing over spinor and internal labels givesThe two diagonal terms each contribute , because ; each mixed term contains . For , write and choose . Then , so . The factor of one-half reflects the stated convention with , rather than , in the equal-chirality anticommutator.
To obtain the sharp general bound and exhibit the shortening, use unitary skew-diagonalization of an antisymmetric matrix to put into two-by-two blocks , with a possible zero row and column for odd . In one block, relabel its two internal indices and write . DefineDirect substitution, using , givesand all annihilator-annihilator anticommutators vanish. The minus operators must have nonnegative norm in every block, hence the BPS bound in supersymmetry isEquivalently, defining gives . Applying the positive construction to each block gives the same bound; applying only its full trace need not isolate the largest block. For and no central charge saturation, each operator can be normalized by to an ordinary fermionic annihilation operator. The unmatched internal index, if any, contributes two more such operators.
There are consequently complex creation operators in a generic massive supermultiplet. Starting with a spin- Clifford vacuum, each creation operator can be occupied zero or one times, so the long representation contains states. If precisely central-charge blocks saturate , then the two and their adjoints have zero anticommutator. The norm identity forces each of them to annihilate every physical state in that representation. Removing these complex oscillators givesThus a massive BPS supermultiplet is half-BPS. For , its four states consist of two spin-zero states and a spin-one-half doublet, instead of the sixteen states of a long representation. A charged representation generally needs its conjugate for CPT completion of a supermultiplet, doubling this four-state count; this yields the eight states of a full charged hypermultiplet. For , one saturated block gives a quarter-BPS representation and two give a half-BPS representation. This rest-frame argument assumes ; massless multiplets follow instead from the null-momentum algebra.
The same bound has a geometric realization for solitons. Consider a static magnetic monopole in an gauge theory with an adjoint Higgs field , asymptotic magnitude , vanishing scalar potential and magnetic field . For magnetic charge , the energy can be writtenThe second equality uses the covariant magnetic Bianchi identity to turn the cross term into the surface integral . Choosing its sign proves the Bogomolny bound . Equality gives the first-order Bogomolny equations . In a suitable supersymmetric embedding, the surface charge is the appropriate central charge and the soliton obeys precisely the algebraic BPS bound in supersymmetry. Its fermionic variation vanishes for the preserved supersymmetry parameters, while the broken supercharges supply its fermionic zero modes.
Shortening is useful because an isolated short multiplet cannot continuously acquire the additional states of a long representation. While the state exists and stays short, its exact mass is determined by the exact central charge, so masses of strongly interacting solitons can be found without computing a generic interacting-particle self-energy. This does not mean that its numerical mass is independent of coupling or vacuum expectation values: those can enter the central charge itself. Supersymmetric indices and the reduced fermionic state content provide ways to count protected states, subject to possible recombination or continuum effects.
For example, in rank-one Seiberg–Witten theory the electric and magnetic charges enter through periods . In the normalization above, , so a BPS state has . A magnetic monopole can become massless where , even though the original electric description is strongly coupled. Including this light magnetic hypermultiplet supplies a useful local description there; states with both electric and magnetic charge are dyons. Thus the protected spectrum identifies important singularities of the vacuum space and tests electric-magnetic dual descriptions.
The charge bound also controls stability. For any proposed decay with additive complex charges , each daughter satisfies . A BPS parent satisfiesEnergy conservation permits decay only if both inequalities are equalities: all daughters must be BPS and their nonzero complex charges must have the same phase. With nonaligned phases the parent lies strictly below the multiparticle threshold. A wall of marginal stability is a locus where such phases align, and a short bound state can disappear across it. Therefore BPS saturation protects a mass-charge relation and short representation, while stability and existence still depend on the spectrum and parameters.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 iii Paper 307 1 i Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
Choose a null four-momentum with and orient the third axis so that . The Super-Poincaré algebra givesFor every state in a unitary representation, the second anticommutator is the sum . Thus both operators act trivially. A central charge in supersymmetry also vanishes in this massless supermultiplet: its mixed-spinor anticommutator contains the now-trivial . The remaining pairs, normalized by , satisfy the canonical anticommutation relationsLabel a Clifford vacuum by its highest helicity and choose the lowering convention . Acting with distinct fermionic creation operators produces the fermionic Fock spaceThis proves the helicity spectrum of a massless supermultiplet and the state count. If the internal charges or helicities do not already make the spectrum invariant under the CPT theorem, add its conjugate using the CPT completion of a supermultiplet.
The spin bound for massless supermultiplets follows directly from the width of this helicity interval. Requiring gives , achieved by the four-dimensional N=4 super Yang-Mills theory vector multiplet with multiplicities at helicities . These helicity bounds are necessary spin restrictions for the usual interacting renormalizable quantum field theory; they do not by themselves establish renormalizability for an arbitrary action. Requiring gives . The four-dimensional N=8 supergravity supergravity multiplet attains this bound with highest helicity and multiplicities . There is one state and one state, the two polarizations of a single graviton.
The stronger restriction relevant to matter is the chirality constraint on extended supersymmetry. An chiral superfield can contain a left-handed Weyl spinor in a complex gauge group representation . By contrast, a full hypermultiplet consists of matter in , and the gauginos of a vector multiplet are in the real adjoint group representation. Higher unbroken extended supersymmetry retains this pairing. A pseudoreal representation may allow a half-hypermultiplet, but it does not yield net chirality in a genuinely complex gauge group representation. Consequently the chiral gauge spectrum of the Standard Model permits at most unbroken supersymmetry in its four-dimensional low-energy matter sector.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2017 iii Paper 307 1 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
Fix a positive-mass unitary irreducible representation at rest, with . Use the central charge in supersymmetry conventionThe conjugate relation is , with the dotted epsilon tensor the conjugate of the undotted one. The supercharges commute with and the central charges. Their Lorentz transformation is that of a Weyl spinor; together with the ordinary Poincare algebra, these relations specify the Super-Poincaré algebra. Take and write . This makes the normalization of the mass bound explicit: a convention that writes instead has .
When , define four fermionic annihilation operators and their fermionic creation operators byIn the rest frame they obey the canonical anticommutation relations and . Choose a spin-zero Clifford vacuum annihilated by all four . Acting with each distinct creator at most once constructs the fermionic Fock spaceThe five levels have the binomial coefficient multiplicities , so the massive supermultiplet contains states. The four creators are two copies of the spin-one-half SU(2) representation. Their second exterior power isHere the first factor carries physical spin and the second counts the two supersymmetries. Thus level two contains one spin-one triplet and three spin-zero singlets; levels one and three each contain two spin-one-half doublets. The final spin content isEven levels give eight boson states and odd levels eight fermion states, exhibiting boson-fermion degeneracy in a supermultiplet.
For nonzero , pair the two supersymmetries before normalizing. DefineThe rest-frame algebra gives and consequentlyFor , divide by to recover four normalized oscillators. Positivity of the Hilbert space norm proves the BPS bound in supersymmetry, sinceThereforeFor a BPS state saturating this bound, both and their adjoints annihilate every state of the representation. Four of the eight real supercharges act trivially. Only the two oscillators remain, so a scalar Clifford vacuum gives a shortened massive supermultiplet with two spin-zero states and one spin-one-half doublet:This is the irreducible count at fixed central charge. A CPT completion of a supermultiplet can require the charge-conjugate multiplet as well, doubling it to eight states; the full hypermultiplet count must not be confused with this four-state count. Saturation is a representation-theoretic relation between mass and conserved charge: shortening persists while the state remains BPS, although its existence can change across parameter space.
For even , unitary skew-diagonalization of an antisymmetric matrix brings the central-charge matrix to blocks , . Repeat the oscillator construction separately for each block. Every block supplies two oscillators with norm and two with norm , givingIf blocks saturate, complex oscillators disappear, leaving . Starting with spin , the irreducible state count and preserved fraction areThe largest massive shortening, , preserves one-half. The ordinary massive representation has . This rest-frame discussion excludes , where the massless supermultiplet construction uses a null momentum instead.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 iii Paper 307 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
Use a positive-energy unitary representation with finite helicity states, excluding continuous-spin representations. In the specified frame the Pauli matrices giveFor every and every state ,Positivity therefore gives on this massless supermultiplet. The equal-chirality anticommutator then shows that every central charge in supersymmetry vanishes on this superalgebra representation.
Normalize the remaining supercharges as fermionic raising and lowering operators:They obey the canonical anticommutation relationsChoose a Clifford vacuum of helicity annihilated by every . Such a vector exists because the commuting fermion number operators have eigenvalues and , and lowering every occupied mode produces a nonzero empty state. In an irreducible representation this empty space has dimension one; multiple empty states produce a direct sum of copies. The states areThe canonical anticommutation relations make these states orthonormal for a normalized Clifford vacuum. In the helicity convention , its adjoint has . Thus the Clifford vacuum is the highest-helicity state andReversing the rotation convention reverses the displayed ordering and leaves all counts unchanged. The level- states form the exterior power , which explains the binomial coefficient. Summing the binomial coefficients gives the helicity spectrum of a massless supermultiplet:Each application of a fermionic raising and lowering operator reverses fermion parity. The even and odd levels each contain states, so a physical massless supermultiplet has boson and fermion states.
These formulas describe one irreducible representation of the massless Super-Poincaré algebra at fixed four-momentum. A reducible superalgebra representation can contain several such supermultiplets. Also, the CPT theorem sends helicity to and conjugates internal charges. CPT completion of a supermultiplet may therefore require a second -state supermultiplet, with highest helicity . A necessary condition for the original helicity spectrum of a massless supermultiplet to be self-conjugate is ; internal charges must also admit the conjugation in a realization compatible with the Spin-statistics theorem. Thus this helicity condition alone is not sufficient for CPT completion of a supermultiplet without doubling. In particular, the original irreducible count is not automatically the count after CPT completion of a supermultiplet.
For the conventional bounds on extended supersymmetry, suppose all massless states satisfy . The helicity spectrum of a massless supermultiplet occupies an interval of width , whereas the available interval has width . HenceAn ordinary four-dimensional renormalizable quantum field theory without gravity uses interacting massless fields of spin angular momentum at most one. Massless spin angular momentum requires supergravity, whose gravitational coupling has negative mass dimension and is a nonrenormalizable interaction by power counting in quantum field theory. Setting gives for conventional renormalizable theories. The bound is attained by four-dimensional N=4 super Yang-Mills theory: choosing givesfor its supersymmetric vector multiplet.
Allowing gravity permits , so for conventional theories including gravity. The four-dimensional N=8 supergravity supergravity multiplet attains the bound with :It has states, boson and fermion states. The conventional claim about a maximum “in general” assumes local interacting four-dimensional theories in Minkowski spacetime with a finite spectrum of fields and no massless spin angular momentum above two. It is not a theorem excluding arbitrary free higher-spin angular momentum constructions or all theories in other spacetime settings.
Finally, a chiral gauge spectrum means that the independent left-handed Weyl spinors occur in complex gauge group representations without obligatorily paired conjugate left-handed Weyl spinors. In four-dimensional N=1 supersymmetry, an irreducible matter supermultiplet with helicities can carry a complex gauge group representation . Its CPT completion of a supermultiplet supplies the right-handed antiparticle in , as every left-handed Weyl spinor requires; it does not supply a second independent left-handed Weyl spinor in . Consequently a chiral gauge spectrum is possible.
For , the matter hypermultiplet has helicities before internal charge conjugation. If it carries a complex gauge group representation , its CPT completion of a supermultiplet adds the conjugate hypermultiplet. Equivalently, the resulting full hypermultiplet contains two chiral superfields, one in and one in . These give a vectorlike gauge spectrum. Half-hypermultiplets can occur in pseudoreal representations, which also do not produce genuinely complex chiral gauge spectra. A supersymmetric vector multiplet has Adjoint representation, hence real gauge quantum numbers. Since every algebra contains an subalgebra, the same obstruction applies to greater extended supersymmetry.
Therefore a conventional chiral gauge spectrum is possible only for or . Here means no supersymmetry; among theories with actual supersymmetry, only qualifies. These are necessary structural conditions, not a guarantee that a chosen chiral gauge spectrum satisfies anomaly cancellation.
Shortened massive supermultiplet Created 2026-10-05 Updated 2026-10-07
For supersymmetries and saturated two-by-two central-charge blocks, complex oscillators act trivially. A spin- Clifford vacuum therefore gives states and preserves of the real supercharges. With and a scalar vacuum, the shortened multiplet has two boson states and two fermion states, before any CPT completion of a supermultiplet.
Superhelicity 2026-10-14
For a four-dimensional finite-helicity massless supermultiplet, one complex oscillator changes helicity by one-half. A lower-helicity labelling convention assigns to the pair . A symmetric midpoint convention instead uses ; report the helicity pair when comparing conventions. CPT completion of a supermultiplet pairs with .