For pressureless matter in a Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker metric with negative spatial curvature of an FLRW universe and no cosmological constant, set . A decaying linear growth factor is . Reduction of order gives the regular growing linear growth factor
Its Wronskian with is , so the modes are independent. The limits are during matter domination and in a curvature-dominated universe. Multiplying by normalizes the early mode to . Negative spatial curvature of an FLRW universe thus stops late linear amplification even though the model contains no dark energy.
The cosmological principle permits a Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker metric. The Friedmann equation, with vanishing cosmological constant, is
For separately conserved pressureless matter, the cosmological continuity equation gives : its rest energy is conserved while its physical volume grows as . Define the present critical density and matter density parameter by
Evaluating the Friedmann equation today gives . Thus the model has negative spatial curvature of an FLRW universe; the second contribution to represents that spatial curvature of an FLRW universe, rather than another material fluid. Taking the expanding branch gives
Here . At early times, , matter domination gives , hence, measuring cosmic time from the Big Bang,
At late times the term dominates the Friedmann equation. This curvature-dominated universe has and therefore
The late expansion approaches the coasting Milne model. The early limit belongs to this idealized matter-only model; including radiation in cosmology would alter the sufficiently early evolution.
Introduce the positive dimensionless quantity and the time scale . The Friedmann equation gives the separable relation
For , , the hyperbolic function identities give
Choose the constant of integration so that at . The resulting parametric equation for the open matter-dominated Friedmann solution is
For , the Taylor series give
Eliminating yields , exactly the early matter-dominated universe result. For , , whereas . The ratio of the two parametric expressions tends to , recovering the curvature-dominated universe result including its coefficient.
To construct the regular open dust linear growth mode, use reduction of order, writing and denoting the coefficient of by . Since solves the homogeneous linear differential equation, its terms cancel and leave
The integrating factor for this first-order equation in is , so
Choose and the lower integration endpoint zero. This selects the mode regular at early times without adding a multiple of :
Its Wronskian with is , proving linear independence.
No explicit antiderivative is needed for the limits. For , the integrand is , whence its integral is . For , the integrand tends to one, so its integral divided by tends to one, while . Consequently
Early matter domination permits gravitational instability to amplify the density contrast in proportion to the scale factor. Later, the matter density parameter tends to zero and Hubble friction suppresses further amplification. Indeed, for , neglecting the matter source in the linear matter perturbation growth equation gives , whose modes are a constant and . These agree with the late limits of the two exact modes.
Figure 1.
Linear density growth saturates when spatial curvature dominates
. The regular mode tends to during matter domination and to one during curvature-dominated universe. Here marks equal contributions of matter and spatial curvature of an FLRW universe to the Friedmann equation. The normalization is the one in part (d). Details.
Insert the component-density laws into the Friedmann equation, using and . Multiplying by gives
The radiation in cosmology and pressureless matter contributions add; the printed first formula has lost the plus sign between them. In the Friedmann acceleration equation, , so
Evaluating the first equation today gives .
Now remove dark energy and assume a positive pressureless matter or radiation in cosmology density, starting on an expanding branch. Let . It decreases from infinity to zero, and , while . This immediately distinguishes all three cases of spatial curvature of an FLRW universe.
The early small- solution has if radiation in cosmology is present, and for pressureless matter alone. The figure isolates the effect of curvature in three matter-only examples, rather than comparing models with the same present density parameters.
Figure 1.
Matter-only scale-factor evolution: closed recollapse, flat power-law expansion, and open expansion tending to a constant speed.
Details.
For the open matter-dominated Friedmann solution, write , so . The present Friedmann equation gives . With and , the expanding equation becomes
Choose the hyperbolic substitution
Then and . Their product gives
Take the Big Bang to be , , and integrate. The parametric solution is
The parameter is determined explicitly by
Thus is conformal time multiplied by , with its origin at the Big Bang; it is not equal to unscaled cosmic time. In particular today . Small gives and , hence . Large gives , in agreement with the curvature-dominated universe limit.
Under the stated approximation the perturbation equation is
During radiation domination, , so and
Matter perturbations therefore have only logarithmic growth of matter perturbations during radiation domination.
In a curvature-dominated universe, , so and
The nondecaying mode is constant: curvature domination gives freezing of matter perturbations during curvature domination, rather than continued growth.