If is a derivation of a Lie algebra, then its generalized eigenspaces satisfy
Apply a sufficiently large power of and use the binomial theorem together with the derivation rule.
The space becomes a Lie algebra under the commutator
A Lie subalgebra is abelian when ; nilpotent when its Lower central series of a Lie algebra reaches zero; and soluble when its derived series of a Lie algebra reaches zero.
If and is nilpotent, choose the least with . Then , while
Thus the normalizer of a Lie subalgebra strictly contains . If is maximal proper, its normalizer must be all of , so is an ideal. Solubility is insufficient: in the two-dimensional affine Lie algebra with , the maximal subalgebra is not an ideal.
A derivation of a Lie algebra is a linear map satisfying
It is inner when for some .
Every nonzero finite-dimensional nilpotent Lie algebra has an outer derivation of a nilpotent Lie algebra. Choose a codimension-one maximal subalgebra ; it is an ideal by the result above, and write . The centralizer is nonzero because it contains . Let be largest such that
and choose . Define
Because is an ideal and centralizes , the derivation identity holds on and on , hence everywhere. If , then would put in , so
contrary to the choice of . Thus is outer.
The analogous assertion fails for soluble algebras. In the affine example, a derivation has
and equals . Thus every derivation is inner although is nonzero and soluble.
Write . The generalized eigenspace decomposition of the linear map is
for any sufficiently large . Because is a derivation, the generalized-eigenspace bracket lemma gives
Consequently is a Lie subalgebra.
The set is the normalizer of a Lie subalgebra . Certainly . Conversely, if , then gives
On the direct sum of the nonzero generalized eigenspaces, is invertible. Hence the nonzero-eigenvalue component of vanishes, and
Now let be a Lie subalgebra containing . Since , the subspace is -invariant. The generalized zero eigenspace of the induced map on is the image of , hence is zero. If , then , so lies in that zero eigenspace. Thus and
A Nilpotent Lie algebra is one whose lower central series
eventually reaches zero. Suppose is nilpotent and . Choose the least for which . Then , and any
satisfies . Therefore , proving the normalizer condition for a nilpotent Lie algebra
It remains to prove the converse needed here. The Engel lemma states that if a finite-dimensional Lie algebra of linear maps consists of nilpotent maps, then the maps have a common nonzero vector in their kernels. To prove it, induct on the dimension of the algebra. For a maximal proper subalgebra , induction applied to the action of on produces with . Thus is an ideal of codimension one. Induction also gives a nonzero common kernel
The ideal property makes invariant under ; a nilpotent representative of a basis of has a nonzero kernel on , yielding a vector killed by all of .
Apply the lemma to the Adjoint representation. It produces a nonzero element of the Center of a Lie algebra. Induction on , followed by passage to the quotient by this center, proves Engel theorem: if every is nilpotent, then is nilpotent. The hypothesis says exactly that every is nilpotent, so