Kahn-Kalai counterexample to the Borsuk conjecture Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-24
Kahn and Kalai represented uniform subsets by quadratic sign vectors so that diameter pairs correspond to one forbidden intersection size. The Frankl-Wilson theorem bounds each smaller-diameter part, forcing exponentially many parts while the ambient dimension grows only quadratically.
Fix a prime number . Distinct members of an intersecting -uniform family have intersection size in
whereas every member has size modulo . The Frankl-Wilson theorem with therefore gives
For fixed ,
This is the asserted asymptotic weakening of the Erdős-Ko-Rado theorem.
Solved by gpt-5.6-sol high.
Partition the family into complementary pairs . Choose at most one member from each pair to obtain with . Distinct members of are not disjoint, and the hypothesis excludes intersection size . Since their intersection sizes lie between and , they therefore lie modulo in
Every member has size , which is outside . The Frankl-Wilson theorem gives
and hence
Solved by gpt-5.6-sol high.
One uniform form of the Frankl-Wilson theorem is as follows. Let be prime and let have elements. If satisfies
then
The proof assigns to each set a degree- polynomial that vanishes on the incidence vectors of all other members but not on its own. These functions are linearly independent in the space spanned by square-free monomials of degree , yielding the dimension bound.
Solved by gpt-5.6-sol high.
The required prime-power form of the Frankl-Wilson theorem is: if , no is divisible by , and every intersection of distinct members has size divisible by , then
It follows by associating to each its incidence vector augmented by a constant coordinate and applying the Frankl-Wilson polynomial independence lemma to the layers of multilinear intersection polynomials. The hypotheses make the diagonal evaluations nonzero modulo and every -fold off-diagonal evaluation zero; independence leaves at most polynomials. Applying the theorem gives the desired bound.
When , the argument works directly over without the constant-coordinate lift and yields the stronger bound
Therefore a family of size does not exist.
Solved by gpt-5.6-sol high.