For fixed , a geometric mutation count in a coalescent epoch with mean has third moment . The centered absolute third moment is at most , so its sum is . The total variance is asymptotic to , making the Lyapunov condition with hold. Rescaling by the harmonic sum gives the displayed limit. At the estimator is identically zero and the limit is degenerate. The variance of the Watterson estimator decreases only logarithmically with sample size at a fixed nonrecombining locus.
The Watterson estimator is
The expectation above makes it an unbiased estimator. Its variance, given by the variance of the Watterson estimator, is
Indeed, the harmonic sum satisfies and stays bounded. This proves mean-square convergence; the Chebyshev inequality then shows that it is a consistent estimator, since .
Use and normalized measure . The Fourier partial sum at zero is the real linear functional
where the Dirichlet kernel is
The quotient follows by summing the finite geometric progression, with its removable value . It is a real continuous periodic function. If
then . This bound is its exact operator norm even on the real continuous functions. Indeed, for set
It is real, continuous and periodic with norm at most one, and
by dominated convergence. At zeros of the kernel the integrand is zero, and elsewhere its limit is .
For , . Using evenness and putting gives
For the last inequality, split into the first complete intervals : their sine integrals are two and . The harmonic sum tends to infinity. This proves the Dirichlet kernel harmonic lower bound.
Choose with , then choose sufficiently small that . Thus
This constructs continuous near-maximizers, rather than using the discontinuous sign of the kernel as the desired function.
Expand the two Dirichlet polynomials, keeping the complex conjugate on . The diagonal contributes exactly . If , the exponential integral is
whose absolute value is at most . Thus the mean-value formula is
This also covers .
For , integration of over gives ; the analogous inequality holds with exchanged. Hence . This gives the requested first bound .
For the weighted bound, put and . The inequality
reduces the estimate to a row sum and its symmetric counterpart. For a fixed , the preceding logarithm bounds give
Here , and each resulting harmonic sum is . The symmetric row sum is bounded by . Therefore the second error bound is
Expand the finite Euler product into geometric series. By unique prime factorization, it is the sum of over positive integers whose prime factors do not exceed , and hence contains every term up to . The harmonic sum satisfies
The last inequality uses , including when is an integer. For each prime number ,
The telescoping series over all integers bounds the sum of these remainders by . Taking logarithms of the product bound therefore gives
This explicit constant suffices; no asymptotic theorem about the distribution of prime numbers is needed.
Write
uniformly for . The accumulated error from to tends to zero, while the corresponding harmonic sum tends to . Hence .