Let be the homogeneous density. A Lagrangian coordinate volume contains the same mass as its image under the Zeldovich approximation, so mass conservation gives
Since , the density contrast is
For , the deformation tensor is
Equality of mixed partial derivatives makes it a real symmetric matrix. The real spectral theorem therefore supplies an orthonormal eigenbasis and real eigenvalues, which we denote by . In that basis,
and hence
Before the first crossing all factors are positive, allowing the absolute values to be omitted.
When , the map loses rank in the corresponding principal direction. Its Jacobian determinant vanishes, trajectories meet, and shell crossing creates a cosmological caustic. The single-stream pressureless density formally diverges and the approximation no longer describes the subsequent multistream dynamics. If only one is positive, one axis first collapses while the other two remain extended, producing a sheet or pancake. Collapse along a second and then a third principal axis produces filaments and nodes. Spatial variation of the eigenvalues joins these objects into the cosmic web around underdense voids.
The approximation succeeds because it reproduces linear growing-mode evolution exactly, preserves the initial tidal displacement and anisotropic collapse, and follows matter along nearly inertial comoving trajectories instead of expanding only the density at a fixed point. Large scales remain weakly nonlinear and are insensitive to the detailed dynamics after crossing. Its limitations begin at shell crossing: it permits streams to pass through one another, cannot produce virialized halos, and omits velocity dispersion, vorticity, gas pressure, shocks, feedback, and strongly nonlinear self-gravity.
For the one-dimensional displacement,
so mass conservation gives
The earliest crossing occurs where the cosine is maximal:
for integers . The denominator vanishes at these isolated points.
Write at . The Taylor series gives
Thus and
The first caustic is therefore a cubic cusp with
In a partial derivative, the variable held fixed matters. Holding fixed gives . To find , hold fixed and invert the Jacobian matrix:
Thus
The second formula holds on each local inverse branch away from , where the Jacobian determinant vanishes. These are planar parabolic coordinates; the pairs and represent the same , so no global choice of inverse is implicit.
The annulus is in polar coordinates. Their Jacobian determinant supplies , so
The triangle is . In polar coordinates this becomes
because the outer side is . The vector field and the Jacobian determinant give
Evaluate the double integral component by component:
Consequently,
The origin causes no ambiguity in this double integral: the continuous extension from part (a) is bounded there, and changing a value at a single point does not change the integral.
Put . The definitions of the parabolic polar coordinates give and . Subtracting and multiplying these equations yields
Since , taking the nonnegative square root gives
The Jacobian matrix has columns and . Its Jacobian determinant is therefore
Here the displayed fraction denotes the Jacobian determinant, as in the paper. The change of variables formula consequently gives . The Jacobian determinant is positive except at the origin, and the definitions supply the unique nonnegative inverse throughout the region .
The inequalities become the rectangle , in parabolic polar coordinates. The change of variables formula and the Jacobian determinant from a give the area
The middle panel in b shows the curved region in Cartesian coordinates; its straight edges in parabolic polar coordinates explain the simple integration limits.
The first boundary is . On in the first quadrant, the inverse parabolic polar coordinates give . To identify the remaining curve, put . Its Cartesian coordinates satisfy
Hence and , so this boundary is . The condition on this curve requires . Its endpoints are and , while meets at . These three arcs enclose exactly
Every point in this region has , and therefore , as required. Using the Jacobian determinant, the area is
Use the change of variables , . Its Jacobian determinant in the first quadrant is , and the inverse is uniquely determined by
Both are positive for , so the transformation is one-to-one on the region. It becomes the rectangle , . The integrand is , and . Thus
Use polar coordinates with and . The Jacobian determinant gives , so the area is
The trigonometric identity
reduces the integral to its constant term: both cosine terms have zero integral over this interval. Therefore
Express the position vector in the suggested orthonormal basis as . Then
This orthogonal transformation preserves and has Jacobian determinant of absolute value one, so . The basis actually reverses orientation; the absolute value of the Jacobian determinant is why no minus sign enters the volume integral. Also , so the half-space becomes .
At each fixed , the section is the disk , of area . Its reflection symmetry in makes the integral of vanish. Hence the required triple integral is
The negative sign is also consistent with the cap lying in the direction , where its average coordinate is negative.
The partial derivatives are
Thus the Jacobian determinant is
This vanishing reflects the functional dependence found next.
The region is the part of the disk in the first quadrant above . In polar coordinates, it is and . The integrand becomes , and the area Jacobian determinant contributes another . Thus
The inverse change of variables is , . Thus the triangular region becomes
The upper limit depends on : the new region is not a rectangle. The absolute inverse Jacobian determinant is , so the change of variables formula cancels the rational factor in the integrand:
Although the original integrand is undefined at the vertex , its nonnegative improper integral exists. One can apply the change of variables formula on and let by the monotone convergence theorem; the transformed integrand has the finite integral just computed.
The Jacobian determinant is
The change of variables is defined only for . On the interior of the integration region, and , so this Jacobian determinant is negative and nonzero.
Differentiate both algebraic constraints at fixed or fixed :
The multivariable chain rule for therefore gives
Divide the first identity by and the second by , and add. The terms cancel, leaving
The Jacobian determinant of is , so the calculation is valid on real branches with . This explicitly supplies the local independence assumption underlying the change of coordinates.
Let . Positivity allows the squared integral to be written as a first-quadrant double integral. In polar coordinates the Jacobian determinant is , so
Using integration by parts, with the boundary term vanishing at both endpoints,
The substitution also gives the two antiderivatives
These values also follow from the Gaussian moment recurrence and can be checked by differentiation.
The coordinate partial derivatives are , , , and . Apply the multivariable chain rule to :
All partial derivatives of are evaluated at . This is a logarithmic polar coordinate change; its Jacobian determinant is , so it is locally invertible away from the origin. A full angular turn repeats the same point, as usual for polar coordinates.
Use spherical polar coordinates with measured from the positive axis and around that axis:
The standard full-space ranges are , , . The factor is the absolute Jacobian determinant and gives the volume element.
The region lies in the first quadrant, inside the unit circle and above the positive branch of . In polar coordinates, , so its radial bounds are . Such an interval exists when , hence
At the intersections with the circle, and , giving exactly the two stated polar angles. Their Cartesian coordinates are and the swapped pair.
Figure 1.
The first-quadrant region between a hyperbola and the unit-circle arc
. Original shaded integration region. The dashed rays pass through the two intersections, at polar angles and . Details.
The Jacobian determinant contributes , while . Thus the double integral is
Its antiderivative is . Evaluating the bounds gives
In first-quadrant polar coordinates, , , and the Jacobian determinant contributes . The integrand and area element together become . Hence
The radial integral follows by integration by parts from the Gaussian integral. The isolated undefined ratio at the origin does not affect this convergent double integral.