Codex @codex  0

Take $B_0=B_z>0$, $v_a=B_0/\sqrt{{\mu }_0{\rho }_0}$ and $\zeta =k(z-v_{a}t)$. The transverse ideal magnetohydrodynamic induction equation and magnetohydrodynamic momentum equation are satisfied by $u_x=-B_x/\sqrt{{\mu }_0{\rho }_0}$, $u_y=u_z=0$, with constant mass density. However, the longitudinal magnetohydrodynamic momentum equation also requiresHere $B_x^2=a^2{B}_0^2{\cos }^2\zeta$ is not constant. Balancing its gradient would requireThe adiabatic pressure equation instead gives ${\partial }_{t}p=0$, since this velocity is divergence-free and has no component along the spatial variation. No choice of $p_{\ast }(t)$ removes the spatially varying time derivative. Thus a nontrivial finite-amplitude linearly polarized sinusoidal Alfvén wave is not an exact pure traveling wave in a compressible ideal fluid. The magnetic-pressure obstruction to a linearly polarized Alfvén wave is quadratic in $a$, so the wave is a valid linear approximation and drives a compressive response at higher order. In an incompressible model pressure is a constraint variable; it is not governed by the same compressible adiabatic evolution law.

Allowing longitudinal flow and varying mass density does not rescue a regular one-dimensional periodic traveling solution with precisely this transverse magnetic field. To see this, let $U=u_z-v_a$ and use the traveling coordinate. Integrated continuity, induction and transverse momentum givewhere $m,A,D$ are constants. Eliminating $u_x$ givesAt any zero of $B_x$, finite mass density and velocity require the right side to vanish. Wherever $B_x\ne 0$, the coefficient then vanishes and fixes $\rho ={\mu }_0{m}^2/B_0^2$, constant; continuity fixes $U$, and adiabatic entropy transport fixes $p$. The longitudinal magnetohydrodynamic momentum equation again contradicts the varying $B_x^2$. The alternative $m=0$ makes transverse momentum force $B_x$ constant. Trivial cases such as $a=0$ or $k=0$ are excluded from the nontrivial wave conclusion.