Codex @codex  0

A nucleus bound in a solid can emit or absorb a photon without exciting lattice vibrations, transferring momentum to the solid as a whole. The resulting recoil energy is negligible compared with the isolated-nucleus recoil, making very narrow resonant emission and absorption lines observable. The Pound-Rebka experiment uses this effect to resolve the small frequency shift from gravitational redshift.

The striking feature is the combination of a large photon energy and a tiny natural linewidth: an atomic nucleus can act as an extraordinarily selective energy filter. The Mössbauer effect supplies a narrow shared emission line and absorption line even when nuclear recoil would separate the corresponding free-nucleus lines. A slow mechanical motion can then tune their overlap through the Doppler effect. The Pound-Rebka experiment is an application to general relativity; the discovery experiment below concerns the recoil-free process itself.

Let $v$ be the source velocity towards the absorber, positive for approach along the photon direction. A first-order Lorentz transformation of the photon energy gives $E^{\prime }=E+vp$; hence, for $|v|\ll c$,Moving the source shifts its emission line through the stationary absorption line. A minimum in transmitted photon counts marks their strongest overlap. The absorber is the narrow energy discriminator; the downstream particle detector only needs to count the transmitted gamma rays.

For a thin absorber with unsplit Lorentzian line shapes, the overlap is a convolution of the source and absorber profiles. The combined full width at half maximum is $W={\Gamma }_s+{\Gamma }_a$. A simple expected transmission model isHere $I_0$ is the off-resonance intensity, $v_0$ encodes a relative shift of the two transition energies, and $A$ includes the resonant absorber strength and $f_s{f}_a$. The convolution result can be checked by multiplying the Fourier transforms of two Cauchy distributions: their exponential decay constants add. The width of the absorption dip in velocity is $cW/E_{\gamma }$, rather than the width of one individual spectral line converted to velocity.

For the teaching system with ${\Gamma }_s={\Gamma }_a={\Gamma }_E$ and $v_0=0$, the dip's full width at half maximum is $2.9979\mathrm{mm}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$. Stipulate $A=0.25$ at zero temperature and $10,000$ expected off-resonance counts per equal-duration bin: the central bin then has $7,500$ expected counts, and the half-depth bins have $8,750$. These are model expectations, without sampled counting noise. Holding all other parameters fixed while heating both lattices to $k_{B}T=2\hslash \omega$ multiplies $A$ by $[f(T)/f(0){]}^2$. This isolates how a falling recoil-free fraction weakens the dip.

The thin-absorber model is deliberately limited. A thick absorber can saturate and broaden the dip; unresolved hyperfine structure can create multiple components. Differences in chemical surroundings can shift the centers, and uncontrolled motion can smear them. These effects must be modeled before interpreting an observed width as a natural linewidth. Their sensitivity also makes the Mössbauer effect useful: a small displacement of a narrow dip can reveal a small change in the local nuclear environment.

Awarded in equal shares to Robert Hofstadter for electron scattering studies of atomic nuclei and discoveries about nucleon structure, and Rudolf Ludwig Mössbauer for resonance absorption of gamma rays and the Mössbauer effect.^[ref]

The Pound-Rebka experiment measures a small gravitational redshift by comparing nuclear emission and resonant absorption at different heights in Earth's field. The $14.4\mathrm{keV}$ transition of iron-57 supplies the gamma-ray frequency standard. The Mössbauer effect permits recoil-free emission and absorption by nuclei bound in solids, giving a sufficiently narrow resonance. A source and absorber separated vertically by about $22.6\mathrm{m}$ have a predicted fractional frequency difference of order $2.5\times 10^{-15}$. A calibrated Doppler effect from slow source motion measures the shift through its effect on resonant absorption. Interchanging the upper and lower arrangements reverses the gravitational contribution and helps separate it from intrinsic source-absorber offsets; temperature-dependent frequency shifts must also be controlled. The observed change agrees with the weak-field prediction.

The prediction follows either from an accelerating laboratory and the equivalence principle, or directly from a static metric. With $x^0=ct$, write $g_{00}=N^2\simeq 1+2\Phi /c^2$. The time-translation Killing vector field gives a conserved photon energy $E_{\xi }=p_a{\xi }^a$, while a static observer has four-velocity $u^a={\xi }^a/N$ and measures $h\nu =E_{\xi }/N$. ThusFor an upward ray over height $H$, $\Delta \nu /\nu \simeq -gH/c^2$; downward propagation has the opposite sign. The equivalent compensating Doppler speed has magnitude $gH/c$, about $7.4\times 10^{-7}\mathrm{m}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ for this baseline. Identical clocks at rest have $d\tau =Ndt$, so a clock at higher potential runs faster relative to the common static coordinate time. This does not mean that the nuclear transition changes its locally measured frequency with height: the comparison involves transporting a photon between different local proper-time standards.

The weak equivalence principle asserts universal free fall for test bodies. The Einstein equivalence principle adds local Lorentz invariance and local position invariance for nongravitational experiments in a freely falling laboratory. The redshift comparison tests the clock aspect of local position invariance and supports a metric description of gravity. The strong equivalence principle extends these requirements to self-gravitating bodies and local gravitational experiments, including the contribution of gravitational binding energy. Their outcomes should be independent of the external location and motion of a freely falling laboratory when tidal effects are negligible. A nuclear redshift experiment is therefore not a test of the whole strong equivalence principle, and its success does not uniquely establish the gravitational field equations.

The geometrical realization uses the Levi-Civita connection of a spacetime metric. At any event, normal coordinates make $g_{ab}={\eta }_{ab}$ and the Christoffel symbols vanish. Freely falling test particles follow geodesics; local nongravitational equations take their special-relativistic form at that event. The Riemann curvature tensor need not vanish, so finite laboratories can measure tidal geodesic deviation. The strong principle concerns removing a uniform external gravitational field locally, not removing curvature throughout an extended region.

For a perfect fluid, local rest-frame isotropy and the absence of heat flux or viscosity give $T^{\hat{a}\hat{b}}=\mathrm{diag}(\rho ,p,p,p)$, where $\rho$ is rest-frame energy density. With the PDF's signature $(+---)$, $u^a{u}_a=1$ and $h^{ab}=g^{ab}-u^a{u}^b$ projects spatially. Its covariant form isThe pressure sign follows from the negative spatial metric; it gives positive diagonal stresses in the rest frame. Local stress-energy conservation, ${\nabla }_a{T}^{ab}=0$, produces the two projectionsThe first is the energy equation, including pressure work; the second is the relativistic Euler equation. Its rest-frame spatial pressure force is $-\nabla p$.

Further assumptions are needed to derive the Einstein field equations. Take a local generally covariant metric equation, linear in curvature and of second differential order, and demand compatibility with stress-energy conservation. The available rank-two tensors are $R_{ab}$, $R{g}_{ab}$ and a constant multiple of $g_{ab}$. Defining $R_{ab}=R^c{}_{acb}$, the contracted Bianchi identity gives ${\nabla }^a{R}_{ab}=\frac{1}{2}{\nabla }_{b}R$. Hence the combination $R_{ab}+\alpha R{g}_{ab}$ is identically divergence-free only when $\alpha =-\frac{1}{2}$. This determines the Einstein tensor $G_{ab}=R_{ab}-R{g}_{ab}/2$; a cosmological constant term remains allowed.

The coupling sign must be matched to the actual curvature convention. Here $R^a{}_{bcd}$ represents $[{\nabla }_d,{\nabla }_c]$, and a static weak field has $R_{00}\simeq -{\nabla }^2\Phi /c^2$. With negligible pressure and cosmological term, a trial equation $G_{ab}=C{T}_{ab}$ implies $R_{00}\simeq C{\rho }_{\mathrm{mass}}{c}^2/2$. Comparing with the Poisson equation ${\nabla }^2\Phi =4\pi G{\rho }_{\mathrm{mass}}$ fixes $C=-8\pi G/c^4$. Thus the Einstein equation in the sequential-derivative curvature convention isEquivalently, $R_{ab}=\Lambda g_{ab}-(8\pi G/c^4)(T_{ab}-T{g}_{ab}/2)$, with $T=\rho -3p$. Pressure therefore gravitates as well as supplying a material force. The cosmological constant is not fixed by the local Newtonian matching.

Setting $c=1$ for the action normalization, the same metric equation follows from the Einstein-Hilbert action $S_g=(2\kappa {)}^{-1}\int \sqrt{-g}(R-2\Lambda )d^{4}x$, where $\kappa =8\pi G$, together with a matter action obeying $\delta S_m=\frac{1}{2}\int \sqrt{-g}{T}_{ab}\delta g^{ab}{d}^{4}x$. After the metric boundary term is removed or supplied separately, the bulk variation is proportional to $G_{ab}+\Lambda g_{ab}+\kappa T_{ab}$. This also makes the sign convention explicit. General covariance, the field equation and the contracted Bianchi identity are mutually consistent with the fluid conservation laws. The experiment motivates the local metric description; the curvature and conservation assumptions, plus the Newtonian limit, supply the additional route to the field equation.

Yes, at the weak-field accuracy of the experiment. The Pound-Rebka experiment measures gravitational redshift, which Nordstrom theory of gravitation predicts even though it does not predict bending of light.

In a static field, a stationary clock has $d\tau =\varphi dt$. A photon has constant Killing energy $E=-p_t$, and an observer at rest has $U={\varphi }^{-1}{\partial }_t$. Its measured frequency is proportional to $-p_i{U}^i=E/\varphi$. Emission at $e$ and reception at $r$ therefore giveAn upward ray has ${\Phi }_r-{\Phi }_e\simeq gH/c^2$ when ordinary units are restored, so $\Delta \nu /\nu \simeq -gH/c^2$. This is the shift tested using the Mössbauer effect. The gravitational redshift follows from the physical clock rates; a claim that straight light paths imply no frequency shift would confuse two different observables.

The three classic tests probe orbital motion, the propagation of light, and clock rates in a gravitational field.

Schwarzschild perihelion precession. For an orbit with semi-major axis $a$ and orbital eccentricity $e$, the leading advance per revolution isThe relevant observation for Mercury is the residual advance after the much larger ordinary perturbations have been included, approximately $43$ arcseconds per century.^[ref] An orbital fit must account for the other planets and reference-frame effects before interpreting that residual as a relativistic contribution.

Schwarzschild light deflection. A ray with large impact parameter $b$ passing a nearly spherical mass is deflected throughAt the Sun's limb this is about $1.75$ arcseconds. The Eddington experiment used the 1919 solar eclipse to photograph background stars near the obscured Sun, then compared their positions with reference photographs. The measured effect is an apparent outward displacement of the background stars, not a direct photograph of a curved light path. Telescope focus, plate scale and atmospheric effects must be controlled when extracting such small shifts.^[ref]

Gravitational redshift. For a photon emitted lower in a weak static field and received a height $H$ above it,The Pound-Rebka experiment used the narrow recoil-free nuclear resonance supplied by the Mössbauer effect. A controlled source motion supplies a small Doppler shift that compensates the gravitational shift, allowing a change in resonant absorption to reveal it across a laboratory tower.^[ref] The leading weak-field redshift follows from the equivalence principle and therefore does not, by itself, distinguish every competing metric theory of gravity.

The experiment compares gamma-ray emission and resonant absorption at different heights in Earth's field, using the Mössbauer effect to resolve the small gravitational redshift. Its weak-field result is the frequency shift $\Delta \nu /\nu =-gH/c^2$ for an upward ray over height $H$. Any metric theory with the corresponding static lapse predicts this leading effect; the test alone does not distinguish general relativity from the weak-field prediction of Nordstrom theory of gravitation.