Past exam of the astrophysical fluid dynamics course of the University of Cambridge / 2012 / Paper 1 / 1

The equation describes small plane-wave perturbations of a uniform, stationary plasma in ideal magnetohydrodynamics, with propagation parallel to the background magnetic field. The nonzero field defines $\hat{\mathbf{b}}={\mathbf{v}}_A/v_A$; $c_s$ is the sound speed for the assumed thermodynamic closure. Neglect viscosity, electrical resistivity, gravity and microscopic dispersive effects. A uniform background flow would instead introduce its Doppler-shifted frequency.

Decompose $\mathbf{u}={\mathbf{u}}_{\perp }+u_{\parallel }\hat{\mathbf{b}}$. The displayed matrix equation then becomesThus there are two independent transverse Alfvén wave polarizations with ${\omega }^2=k^2{v}_A^2$, restored by magnetic tension, and a longitudinal acoustic mode with ${\omega }^2=k^2{c}_s^2$, restored by pressure. The transverse modes have no first-order density compression; a strictly longitudinal displacement along the field does not bend it. These are the parallel-propagating ideal magnetohydrodynamic wave branches. In the general oblique problem, fast and slow magnetosonic modes mix compression and magnetic response; their parallel limits coincide with the faster and slower of these speeds. If $c_s=v_A$, all three velocity polarizations share the same frequency magnitude. The velocity equation alone does not enumerate nonpropagating entropy perturbations.

Take positive $\dot{Q}$ to mean net cooling per unit mass. At fixed pressure for an ideal gas of unchanged composition, $\rho \propto T^{-1}$, so $\dot{Q}=C{T}^{\alpha -1}-H$ with $C>0$. At thermal equilibrium, $C{T}_0^{\alpha -1}=H$. Because expansion work is included at fixed pressure, the perturbed temperature obeysThis isobaric stability criterion for density-dependent power-law cooling gives stability for $\alpha >1$ and instability for $\alpha <1$. For optically thin bremsstrahlung, $\alpha =1/2$, soA slightly cooler parcel becomes denser and cools faster; a slightly hotter parcel has reduced cooling and heats further. The conclusion assumes the sound-crossing time is short enough to maintain nearly common pressure, with conduction and other stabilizing processes omitted.

Using a center-to-edge sound-crossing time $t_s=R/c_s$ and the pressureless uniform-sphere free-fall time of a uniform sphere $t_{\mathrm{ff}}=\sqrt{3\pi /(32G\rho )}$, equality givesOn scales larger than this estimate, pressure information cannot cross the region before its gravitational dynamical evolution. It therefore identifies the order of the Jeans length and separates gravity-dominated from pressure-supported behavior in the simple comparison. It is not an exact normal-mode stability calculation: with the standard Jeans wavelength ${\lambda }_J=c_s\sqrt{\pi /(G\rho )}$, this radius is $\sqrt{3/32}{\lambda }_J$. Using the diameter rather than the radius as the crossing distance changes the numerical coefficient. Boundary conditions, density structure, turbulence and magnetic support also matter for an actual cloud.