Past exam of the biological physics course of the University of Oxford / 2019 / 6 / i / Solution

The hydrophobic core of a lipid bilayer makes transfer of a hydrated ion into bare lipid energetically costly. An ion channel supplies a water-accessible route across that barrier. Its narrow selectivity filter presents coordinating chemical groups that compensate for loss or rearrangement of the ion's hydration shell. Selectivity depends on the free-energy balance of hydration, coordination, electrostatics and geometry, rather than a sieve that passes all smaller ions.

A potassium-channel filter presents backbone carbonyl oxygens in a geometry favourable for potassium; smaller sodium does not automatically gain the same energetic compensation. Sodium and calcium channels use different filter architectures: charged side chains and their coordination environments favour particular ions, with ion occupancy and competing species also affecting permeation. In canonical vertebrate voltage-gated sodium channels, the DEKA selectivity ring illustrates chemical discrimination distinct from potassium-channel carbonyl coordination. The precise mechanism therefore depends on the channel family.

Rapid flux requires low successive free-energy barriers, not permanent binding of the preferred ion. Several occupied sites, nearby water and ion–ion interactions can facilitate passage without requiring the ion to cross the lipid. For scale, a $100\mathrm{pS}$ open channel driven by $100\mathrm{mV}$ carries $10\mathrm{pA}$, approximately $6\times 10^7$ monovalent ions per second. A nanometre-scale route with favourable coordination can support such rapid, thermally driven motion. An ion channel is not an ATP-driven pump: net flux follows the electrochemical potential difference,which vanishes at the species' Nernst equilibrium potential. ATP-consuming pumps maintain the gradients that make sustained channel currents possible.

Permeation selectivity and opening probability are separate properties. Voltage-sensor movement, ligand binding or mechanical tension can regulate access to the pore, while inactivation can terminate conduction during a maintained stimulus. Patch-clamp unitary currents establish discrete conducting states; reversal potentials under changed ionic compositions quantify selectivity. Structure determination locates the filter and gates, and mutations or specific blockers test their functional roles. Agreement between these measurements is stronger evidence than structure or current shape alone.