Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge / 2018 / Paper 1 / Section C / C11 / a

Indistinguishable particles have the same intrinsic properties and cannot be assigned physically observable permanent labels. Exchanging their mathematical coordinates leaves all physical predictions unchanged. In ordinary three-dimensional quantum mechanics the total state, including spin, obeysThe Spin-statistics theorem associates integer spin with bosons and half-integer spin with fermions. Exchange does not mean physically transporting two particles along some prescribed trajectories; it is the symmetry of the many-particle state under permutation of its arguments.

For orthonormal one-particle states $u,v$, normalized two-particle spatial combinations are $[u(1)v(2)\pm v(1)u(2)]/\sqrt{2}$. They illustrate coherent exchange amplitudes. If both fermions have the same complete one-particle state, the antisymmetric combination vanishes. This is the Pauli exclusion principle: a fermionic mode has occupation zero or one. Bosonic modes can have arbitrarily large occupation. A many-fermion product basis is antisymmetrized by a Slater determinant.

It is the full spin-spatial state that must have the appropriate symmetry. For two electrons, an antisymmetric spin singlet state can accompany a symmetric spatial orbital, so opposite-spin electrons can occupy the same spatial orbital. A symmetric spin triplet instead needs an antisymmetric spatial state. Thus exclusion concerns identical complete states, not an unconditional prohibition on sharing a position or spatial orbital.

Counting allowed occupations gives Bose-Einstein statistics and Fermi-Dirac statistics. For an ideal gas in thermal equilibrium,Bosonic accumulation permits Bose-Einstein condensation; exclusion gives a filled Fermi sea and degeneracy pressure even at zero temperature. In the dilute classical limit the occupations are small and both expressions approach the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution. Exchange effects become important when wavepackets overlap appreciably, often characterized by number density times the cube of the thermal wavelength.

Composite particles follow their total exchange statistics while remaining intact. The composite statistics of neutral atoms depend on electrons as well as nucleons, as in the two lithium isotopes above. Symmetrization can produce bunching or antibunching in joint detection probabilities even in the absence of an interaction potential; it is not an additional classical force.