Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge / 2022 / Paper 2 / Section B / B6

A nondispersive wave has a linear dispersion relation $\omega =vk$ over the relevant range, so every Fourier transform component has the same phase velocity $v_p=\omega /k=v$ and group velocity $v_g=d\omega /dk=v$. A wave packet then translates without spreading in an ideal homogeneous lossless medium.

For wave dispersion, $v_p$ depends on frequency or wavenumber. Different components accumulate different phases, and in general the group velocity differs from the phase velocity; variation of group velocity across the spectrum produces spreading of a wave packet. The membrane material can be nondispersive while confinement in a membrane waveguide introduces wave dispersion along its length.

Twice differentiating the proposed normal mode givesIt therefore solves the two-dimensional wave equation precisely whenThe fixed-edge boundary conditions require $z(x,0,t)=z(x,b,t)=0$. The first is automatic, and the second requires $\sin (k_{y}b)=0$. The nonzero normal modes are thereforeThe apparent $n=0$ choice gives identically zero displacement for this sine solution. There are no imposed end conditions in $x$, so $k_x$ is continuous rather than quantized by a second length. For a propagating mode it is real; the plus sign in the stated $\cos (\omega t-k_{x}x)$ convention describes propagation in $+x$. Each positive integer $n$ labels a transverse standing wave across the strip.

For a fixed transverse normal mode, define its cutoff angular frequencyThe longitudinal phase velocity and group velocity, for propagation in $+x$, areThus $v_p{v}_g=v^2$, $v_p>v$ and $v_g<v$. The large longitudinal phase velocity reflects the geometry of the transverse standing wave and does not imply faster transport of energy than the membrane wave speed.

The cutoff frequency of a membrane waveguide for mode $n$ isAt cutoff $k_x=0$ and $v_g=0$; the longitudinal phase velocity has no finite value. Below cutoff,and a bounded field excited at $x=0$ decays as $e^{-{\gamma }_{n}x}$. It is an evanescent wave, rather than a freely propagating mode carrying net time-averaged energy flux down an indefinitely long uniform strip. A finite section can still transmit through coupling of evanescent fields.

The natural interpretation is the fundamental transverse normal mode, $n=1$. Indeedso only $n=1$ propagates over the main part of the given Gaussian distribution of angular frequencies. Its centre travels atDifferentiate the group velocity with respect to angular frequency:At the centre this is $0.010149\mathrm{m}$. The one-standard-deviation group velocity spread is consequentlyOver the central travel time the associated spatial shear isEquivalently, use representative components at ${\omega }_0\pm {\sigma }_{\omega }$, for which $v_g(95)=1.5001\mathrm{m}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ and $v_g(105)=1.6024\mathrm{m}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$. Their separation after $t_0$ isAt a fixed detector $10\mathrm{m}$ away, the corresponding arrival-time difference is $10/v_g(95)-10/v_g(105)=0.426\mathrm{s}$.

The paper asks for an estimate of spreading, without specifying a spatial width convention or the initial spectral phase. A Gaussian distribution has no finite full range. Thus $0.326\mathrm{m}$ is a one-standard-deviation dispersive contribution, whereas about $0.65\mathrm{m}$ describes the separation of the $\pm {\sigma }_{\omega }$ representatives. Neither is automatically the increase in the packet's original width. For an initially unchirped Gaussian wave packet in the narrow-band approximation, independent initial and dispersive contributions combine as ${\sigma }_{x,f}^2\simeq {\sigma }_{x,0}^2+{\sigma }_{x,\mathrm{disp}}^2$; a packet with an initial chirp can behave differently. The modal assumption and width convention must accompany the numerical answer.

Different transverse normal modes have different cutoff frequencies and group velocities. A pulse exciting several of them reaches the output in delayed modal components, causing intermodal dispersion, pulse distortion and overlap of successive signals. Their interference also makes the transverse wave intensity pattern depend on propagation distance; irregularities can transfer energy between modes.

Mitigations are to operate between the first and second cutoff frequencies of a membrane waveguide, excite only the desired mode shape with a suitable source, and use smooth uniform boundaries or gradual transitions to reduce mode conversion. Reducing the signal bandwidth keeps its spectrum inside the single-mode interval and reduces group velocity dispersion within the selected mode. Single-mode operation removes intermodal dispersion but does not remove the dispersion derived in part (b).