Past exam of the physics course of the year 1 of the natural sciences course of the University of Cambridge / 2013 / Paper 1 / Section B / B8 / Solution

Take inertial axes parallel, with frame $S^{\prime }$ moving at $+v\hat{\mathbf{x}}$ relative to $S$ and origins coincident at zero time. The Lorentz factor is ${\gamma }_v=(1-v^2/c^2{)}^{-1/2}$; $\Delta x,\Delta y,\Delta t$ are separations of the same pair of events in $S$, and primed quantities are their separations in $S^{\prime }$. The transverse coordinates are unchanged. For two events on an inertial clock's worldline,The proper time $\Delta \tau$ is that clock's elapsed time; uniform speed $w$ gives $\Delta t={\gamma }_w\Delta \tau$. Coordinate intervals between spatially separated events must instead be Lorentz-transformed with their spatial separation included.

For the round trip in the station frame, the rendezvous distance is $u{t}_{\mathrm{out}}$, and the return has the same speed and distance. Thus $t_{\mathrm{round}}=2t_{\mathrm{out}}=10a/(\sqrt{7}c)$. Its departure and arrival both occur at the station, so $\Delta x=0$ for these endpoints:This uses the return speed as measured by the station. The elapsed time aboard A, apart from an ideal instantaneous turn, would be $\Delta t_{S,\mathrm{round}}/{\gamma }_u$.

For the crash, A's station-frame velocity components are $(3c/5,\sqrt{7}c/5)$, while B's are $(3c/5,0)$. Here ${\gamma }_u=5/3$ and ${\gamma }_v=5/4$. Four-momentum conservation, with no separately escaping radiation, gives the wreckage totals in the station frame:In B's original inertial frame the same totals areThe invariant wreckage mass is $m\sqrt{14/3}$, exceeding $2m$ because internal energy remains in the wreckage. Its momentum cannot be specified without naming a frame; both natural frames have been given.