Past exam of the quantum condensed matter course of the University of Cambridge / 2021 / Section B / 5

For a degenerate Fermi gas, the Pauli exclusion principle restricts thermally changed occupations to an energy shell of width $k_{B}T$ around the Fermi energy. The number of active Electrons is of order $g(E_F)k_{B}T\sim N{k}_{B}T/E_F$; each carries an excitation energy of order $k_{B}T$. Thus the thermal energy grows as $N(k_{B}T{)}^2/E_F$ and the electronic heat capacity is proportional to $T$.

More precisely, the fixed-particle-number Sommerfeld expansion givesHere $g$ is the total spin-summed density of states for the sample. For a three-dimensional parabolic band, $g(E_F)=3N/(2E_F)$, yieldingThe linear law concerns the electronic contribution; the low-temperature lattice heat capacity usually adds a $T^3$ term.

Let $n=N/\mathcal{V}$ and $c_e=C_e/\mathcal{V}$ be the carrier density and electronic heat capacity per unit volume. In isotropic kinetic theory, the angular average $⟨v_x^2⟩=v_F^2/3$ gives the electronic thermal conductivitywhere ${\ell }_Q=v_F{\tau }_Q$ is the mean free path associated with the heat-current relaxation time. With $v_F^2=2E_F/m^{\ast }$,The Drude model gives the electrical conductivity $\sigma =n{e}^2{\tau }_{\sigma }/m^{\ast }$, where ${\tau }_{\sigma }$ is the momentum relaxation time. ThereforeWhen the same approximately elastic collisions relax heat and charge currents, ${\tau }_Q={\tau }_{\sigma }$. Using $A={\pi }^2/2$ gives the Wiedemann-Franz law$L_0$ is the Lorenz number. Degenerate electrons move at the Fermi velocity, not the classical thermal velocity; using classical equipartition would give the wrong coefficient.

The Wiedemann-Franz law applies to a normal degenerate metal when the same itinerant Electrons carry heat and charge, scattering is approximately elastic over the thermal shell, and the transport probability varies slowly across the energy interval $k_{B}T$ around the Fermi level. The comparison uses the electronic thermal conductivity $K_e$, with any lattice contribution removed.

It works particularly well as $T\to 0$ when elastic impurity or defect scattering dominates. It also often holds approximately for ${\Theta }_D\ll T\ll T_F$, where thermally populated phonons act as a nearly elastic classical scattering field. Room temperature need not lie above the Debye temperature for every metal.

At intermediate temperatures, inelastic small-angle electron-phonon scattering can relax heat much more efficiently than charge. Then ${\tau }_Q\ne {\tau }_{\sigma }$ and $K_e/(\sigma T)$ can be smaller than $L_0$. Strong energy dependence of scattering, additional neutral heat carriers, or a transition out of the normal metallic state also invalidates the simple derivation. An observed deviation alone does not identify which assumption failed.

For one conduction electron per atom, let $n_a$ be the atom density. State counting in a Bloch band gives the Fermi wavevector $k_F=(3{\pi }^2{n}_a{)}^{1/3}$. The Debye model preserves the three vibrational modes per atom by a spherical Debye wavevector cutoff $q_D=(6{\pi }^2{n}_a{)}^{1/3}$, soBoth wavevectors are of order the inverse atomic spacing. The numerical factor uses the spherical Debye approximation; a real zone boundary and the largest-frequency mode depend on direction and branch. Because $q_D<2k_F$, short-wavelength acoustic phonons can scatter Fermi surface electrons through substantial angles. For nearly elastic scattering within a spherical Fermi surface,Near room temperature, when a substantial fraction of the phonon spectrum is occupied, electron-phonon scattering is often the main source of electrical resistance. For $T\gg {\Theta }_D$, the phonon population and scattering rate are approximately proportional to $T$, giving $\rho \propto T$, $\sigma \propto T^{-1}$ and roughly constant $K_e$ when the Wiedemann-Franz law holds.

For small-angle electron-phonon transport at low temperature, thermally active acoustic modes instead haveThey predominantly scatter forward. The factor $1-\cos \theta$ makes such collisions inefficient at relaxing an electrical current, while a phonon energy of order $k_{B}T$ can still substantially change an electron's thermal excitation. Heat-current relaxation therefore need not share the charge-current relaxation time. In the clean three-dimensional acoustic-phonon model this gives ${\tau }_Q^{-1}\propto T^3$ but ${\tau }_{\sigma }^{-1}\propto T^5$, so the phonon-limited electrical resistivity scales as $T^5$ and $K_e\propto T^{-2}$. These laws describe the regime before residual elastic scattering takes over; at sufficiently low temperature impurities give nearly constant residual resistivity and $K_e\propto T$, restoring the usual Lorenz number.^[ref]

Phonons also transport heat themselves, with $K_{\mathrm{ph}}\simeq c_{\mathrm{ph}}{c}_s{\ell }_{\mathrm{ph}}/3$. At low temperature their population decreases and their phonon mean free path can become boundary- or defect-limited. At higher temperature Umklapp scattering can relax the phonon heat current. Such lattice conduction is an additional contribution, not the quantity constrained by the electronic Wiedemann-Franz law.