Past exam of the theoretical mechanics course of the University of Oxford / 2008 / B / 8

Let the bed be $z=0$ and the free surface $z=h(x,t)$. In a long, shallow layer, vertical acceleration is smaller than gravity, so the vertical Euler equation gives hydrostatic pressure $p=p_{\mathrm{atm}}+\rho g(h-z)$. Incompressibility makes the vertical speed smaller than the horizontal speed by the aspect ratio; irrotationality then makes the leading horizontal velocity depth-independent. The horizontal Euler equation becomesIntegrating $u_x+w_z=0$ across the depth, using bed impermeability $w(0)=0$ and the surface condition $w(h)=h_t+u{h}_x$, yieldsCombining these gives the conservative momentum equation $(hu{)}_t+(h{u}^2+g{h}^2/2{)}_x=0$. Integral mass and momentum balance across a stationary thin jump therefore requireThese conservation laws still apply across a jump where the smooth hydrostatic/irrotational derivation does not resolve the internal turbulent structure.

Put $A=h_{-}$, $B=h_{+}$ and $q=A{u}_{-}=B{u}_{+}>0$, orienting the flow from minus to plus. For a nontrivial jump the momentum condition gives $q^2=gAB(A+B)/2$. Its change in mechanical-energy flux isA passive jump cannot create mechanical energy, so the change is nonpositive. Since $q>0$, $\boxed{h_{+}>h_{-}}$ for a genuine jump; equality describes no jump. The upstream flow is supercritical and the downstream flow subcritical, since $F{r}_{-}^2=B(A+B)/(2A^2)>1$ and $F{r}_{+}^2=A(A+B)/(2B^2)<1$.

The gas-dynamic analogue is a compressive normal shock: density and pressure increase and flow changes from supersonic to subsonic. Entropy increases; directed mechanical energy is irreversibly converted into internal energy. Total gas energy, including internal energy, is conserved across an adiabatic shock. This distinguishes that total-energy balance from the reduced shallow-water mechanical-energy loss.