Seidel coma pupil mapping ($w=h{\rho }^3\cos \theta$)

Consider an original, explicitly normalized model of primary coma, rather than a prescription for a particular optical lens. Let $(u,v)$ be Cartesian coordinates in a circular optical pupil divided by its radius $a$, with $u^2+v^2\le 1$. Let $h=\alpha /{\alpha }_0$ be a signed small field angle divided by an arbitrary positive reference angle. With polar coordinates $u=\rho \cos \theta$, $v=\rho \sin \theta$, prescribe the wavefront errorHere $W_0$ is an arbitrary positive optical path difference scale, not a measured error. The cubic optical pupil dependence and linear field dependence are the classical Seidel form.^[ref]

In the paraxial approximation, light ray direction errors follow the transverse gradient of wavefront error. For a reference sphere a distance $L$ from the exit optical pupil in a uniform image medium of refractive index $n$, the corresponding image-error scale is $s=L{W}_0/(na)$. Choose image-error coordinate signs so the normalized displacement is $\nabla w$; reversing the convention reverses the plotted orientation. Image coordinates below are errors relative to the ideal image of this particular object point, rather than positions of different objects:The partial derivatives explain the asymmetry: opposite optical pupil points $(u,v)$ and $(-u,-v)$ land together, rather than on opposite sides of the ideal image. For $h>0$, every $X$ is nonnegative, while $Y$ can have either sign. The figures stipulate this single wavefront error, omit other optical aberrations and diffraction, and assign no instrument dimensions.

For a ring of fixed optical pupil radius $\rho$, the double-angle formulas for trigonometric functions giveThus each ring maps into a circle of radius $|h|{\rho }^2$ whose centre is displaced by $2h{\rho }^2$. Doubling $\rho$ quadruples both sizes; for $h=1$, the edge ring has centre $(2,0)$ and radius $1$, while the half-radius ring has centre $(1/2,0)$ and radius $1/4$. Superposing these displaced circles produces the comet-like envelope.

For uniform irradiance over the circular optical pupil, equal area samples give an equal-weight geometrical image. Its centroid is $(h,0)$ because $⟨u^2⟩=⟨v^2⟩=1/4$ and $⟨uv⟩=0$. Moving the coordinate origin to that centroid translates the image; it does not remove its asymmetric shape. Adding a linear term to $w$ likewise translates all light rays equally. These origin choices must be distinguished from changing the optical aberration itself.

The model's full transverse extent is $3|h|$ along $X$ and $2|h|$ along $Y$. Halving the field angle halves the blur, and reversing it reverses the pattern about the ideal image. This isolates why coma matters for an optical camera's usable field of view: collecting more light does not ensure that off-axis points remain compact. Near diffraction-limited resolution, a physical optics calculation of the point spread function is needed instead of interpreting the geometrical tip as an infinitely sharp image.^[ref]