Neutron Stern-Gerlach splitting 2026-10-18
An electrically neutral neutron still has a magnetic moment . A collimated beam passing through an inhomogeneous magnetic field experiences the force derived from . In a region whose field axis is approximately fixed, a spin one-half neutron has two field-axis spin eigenstates, producing two allowed transverse forces and two separated beam components after a drift. A homogeneous field can cause Larmor precession but cannot separate positions through this force.
The neutron's negative gyromagnetic ratio interchanges which spin projection moves toward increasing field; it does not change the number of branches. An unpolarized beam gives equal ideal populations. A beam prepared in one field-axis eigenstate populates only one branch, so splitting into two observed spots presupposes both components and sufficient spatial resolution.
Use for a product of the two individual spin-one spin eigenstates, with magnetic quantum numbers . Total requires , leaving preciselyHere these are product labels, not labels of the total angular momentum. Write their coefficients in this order as . With physical spin ladder operators , each nonzero individual step has amplitude , soBoth must vanish for a singlet state. The independent product states therefore require . Wavefunction normalization gives the spin-one singlet stateup to an overall quantum phase. Conversely, implies through , so these conditions really select total spin zero. Distinguishability imposes no additional exchange restriction. The ladder hint uses dimensionless angular momentum units; restoring its common factor does not change the coefficient ratios.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2018 Paper 1 Section A A3 Solution 2026-10-18
In the orthonormal eigenbasis , the spin one-half operator is . An eigenvector with eigenvalue obeys and . A nonzero vector requires . Choosing normalized quantum phases givesThese spin eigenstates are orthogonal and have unit norm because and do.
In the eigenbasis, let a candidate eigenvector be . The eigenvalue equation is and , so a nonzero vector requires . Choosing normalized phases givesThe two spin eigenstates are orthogonal, as required for distinct eigenvalues of a self-adjoint operator.
Put , including its sign. The initial vector is the eigenstate of ; it is not an energy eigenstate of . In terms of the spin eigenstates found above, . Each energy eigenstate acquires its own unitary time evolution phase:Equivalently, follows from . The Born rule givesThe expectation value of the spin angular momentum is , a rotation around the axis. Its direction follows the specified sign of the Hamiltonian; changing the magnetic coupling sign reverses the precession.
A Stern-Gerlach experiment uses an oven and slits to produce a collimated atomic beam, conventionally of neutral silver atoms, and sends it through an inhomogeneous magnetic field onto a position-sensitive detector. The unpaired outer electron supplies the effective spin one-half magnetic dipole moment; neutral atoms avoid the ordinary Lorentz deflection of a charged beam. For an analysing direction , the spatial gradient produces a force approximately . The resulting separated beam positions measure the allowed projections of angular momentum. A spin one-half beam gives two branches, rather than the continuous distribution expected from classical dipoles with arbitrary orientations. A uniform magnetic field can rotate a spin but does not itself provide this spatial separation.
To measure the rotation, first use a -directed Stern-Gerlach experiment and an aperture to transmit only the branch. Pass this prepared spin eigenstate through a region of approximately uniform field in the direction, then use a second analyser to separate and count the two populations. For a field region of length and beam speed , the precession angle is , and the predicted fractions areVarying or the transit time gives complementary oscillations, demonstrating coherent Larmor precession. Velocity selection and a sufficiently uniform rotation field keep different particles from accumulating different phases and washing out the contrast. Detection should compare the branch fractions after allowing for losses and analyser efficiency.
An observable is represented by a self-adjoint operator. For an ideal projective measurement, let be its spectral projector for outcome . The Born rule gives , or for a density matrix . Conditional on obtaining , the Lüders rule givesFor a degenerate outcome this projects onto the whole associated eigenspace, rather than arbitrarily selecting a vector within it. An immediate repeated ideal measurement returns the same outcome, provided there is no intervening evolution or disturbance.
Commuting finite-dimensional observables admit a common orthonormal eigenbasis; their projectors commute and ideal joint measurements are compatible. Noncommuting observables generally have no complete common eigenbasis, and measurement order can affect the subsequent statistics. Particular common eigenvectors can nevertheless exist, so a nonzero commutator does not mean that every state has a nonzero uncertainty in both quantities.
For a quantitative constraint, apply the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality to and . The imaginary part of their inner product is , giving the Robertson uncertainty principleThe canonical commutation relation gives . Retaining the real part of the same inner product gives the stronger Robertson-Schrödinger uncertainty relation, including a covariance term. These are constraints on the preparation of a quantum state, not simply statements about a poorly calibrated instrument.
A sequential spin one-half example makes the change in statistics explicit. Prepare . An immediate measurement is certainly positive. If an measurement is inserted first, its outcomes each have probability and leave states . Each then yields either result with probability , so the final positive fraction is . The change reflects projection onto incompatible spin eigenstates, even with ideal measuring apparatus. The theory of measurement in quantum mechanics allows more general state-update rules, but the operator description and the Born rule still constrain their probabilities.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2021 Paper 1 Section A 3 Solution 2026-10-18
A Stern-Gerlach experiment sends a collimated beam through an inhomogeneous magnetic field and then measures its transverse position after a drift region. The neutron is electrically neutral but has a nonzero magnetic moment proportional to its spin, . A predominantly -directed field gives the interaction Hamiltonian operator and transverse forceSince a neutron has spin one-half, its spin component along the local field has only two eigenvalues, . Hence there are two opposite force branches, corresponding to , and a beam containing both spin components gives two displaced detector spots. This is neutron Stern-Gerlach splitting, not an electric-charge Lorentz force. A uniform magnetic field can cause Larmor precession but does not provide the required separating magnetic field gradient.
The neutron's gyromagnetic ratio is negative, so its magnetic moment points opposite to its spin; this reverses which spin label goes to which spot without changing the two-way splitting. Equal populations occur for an initially unpolarized beam. A beam prepared entirely in one field-axis spin eigenstate gives only its corresponding branch, explaining the qualification “in general”.

