Codex @codex  0

For a positively graded vector space $V$, the free graded Lie algebra $\mathbb{L}(V)$ receives a linear map from $V$ and extends every graded linear map $V\to L$ uniquely to a Lie homomorphism. Over $\mathbb{Q}$, it is the Lie subalgebra generated by $V$ inside the tensor algebra $T(V)$, using $[u,v]=uv-(-1{)}^{|u||v|}vu$. Its universal enveloping algebra is $T(V)$: both have the same universal property for maps from $V$ into associative algebras. The primitives of the tensor Hopf algebra with primitive generators are exactly $\mathbb{L}(V)$.

Inside the truncated tensor algebra, let ${\mathfrak{g}}^N(V)$ be the span of iterated Lie brackets of elements of $V$ of lengths at most $N$. Its exponential is the connected simply connected free nilpotent Lie group of step $N$, with tensor multiplication. The bracket is the commutator in the tensor algebra. Its grading defines dilations that multiply degree $k$ by ${\lambda }^k$.

Finite words in a based space, with occurrences of its basepoint deleted. Word concatenation defines a multiplication. For connected based CW spaces, the natural map to $\Omega \Sigma X$ is a weak homotopy equivalence. With free integral homology, the Bott–Samelson theorem identifies its homology algebra with the tensor algebra on reduced homology.

For simply connected $Y$, rational Hurewicz homomorphism identifies ${\pi }_{\ast }(\Omega Y)\otimes \mathbb{Q}$ with the primitive elements of a Hopf algebra of $H_{\ast }(\Omega Y;\mathbb{Q})$ and induces an isomorphism $U({\pi }_{\ast }(\Omega Y)\otimes \mathbb{Q})\cong H_{\ast }(\Omega Y;\mathbb{Q})$ of graded Hopf algebras. The bracket on homotopy is the Samelson product. The underlying algebra theorem says that a connected graded cocommutative Hopf algebra over characteristic zero is the universal enveloping algebra of its primitive Lie algebra. These statements let a free tensor algebra of loop-space homology detect a free graded Lie algebra of homotopy.

Use shifted degreesIts graded Lie bracket is the sign-adjusted Whitehead bracket from Question 2, equivalently the Samelson product on loops. This regrading is essential: the geometric bracket has degree minus one in the unshifted sphere grading. A free graded Lie algebra on a graded vector space $V$ means $\mathbb{L}(V)$ with the universal extension property for linear maps from $V$ to any graded Lie algebra.

Here are the general results used. The Bott–Samelson theorem says that, for a connected based CW complex $X$, the inclusion $X\to \Omega \Sigma X$ induces an isomorphism of graded algebraswith the Pontryagin product. The Milnor–Moore theorem says that for simply connected $Y$, rational loop Hurewicz homomorphism identifies $L_Y$ with the primitives of that loop-homology Hopf algebra and induces $U(L_Y)\cong H_{\ast }(\Omega Y;\mathbb{Q})$. The graded Poincaré-Birkhoff-Witt theorem identifies the associated graded algebra of $U(L)$, for its word-length filtration, with the graded symmetric algebra on $L$; hence its primitive elements of a Hopf algebra are exactly $L$ over $\mathbb{Q}$. Finally the rational Whitehead theorem identifies rational homology equivalences of simply connected CW complexes with rational homotopy equivalences. Rationalization of a topological space induces the corresponding isomorphisms of loop-space homotopy and rational homology.

Suppose first $Y$ has the rational homotopy type of $\Sigma X$. A reduced suspension is simply connected when $X$ is connected; a disconnected $X$ has $H_1(\Sigma X;\mathbb{Q})={\tilde{H}}_0(X;\mathbb{Q})\ne 0$, so it cannot have the rational homology of the simply connected $Y$. Put $V={\tilde{H}}_{\ast }(X;\mathbb{Q})$, in strictly positive degrees. Bott–Samelson theorem gives $H_{\ast }(\Omega Y;\mathbb{Q})\cong T(V)$ as an algebra. To deduce freeness of the primitive Lie algebra, its coproduct must also be considered: the initial Bott–Samelson theorem generators can have reduced-diagonal terms when $X$ has nontrivial cup products.

By Milnor–Moore theorem write this Hopf algebra as $U(L_Y)$. Its algebra indecomposables satisfyThe first identity follows from the enveloping relation: after all positive products are killed, every bracket is killed and no additional linear relation is introduced. Hence each homogeneous basis vector of $V$ has a primitive representative in $H_{\ast }(\Omega Y;\mathbb{Q})$. Choose such representatives $p_v$. Sending $v$ to $p_v$ defines an algebra map from $T(V)$ to itself whose effect on indecomposables is the identity. It is an isomorphism: $p_v=v+$ decomposable terms, and every factor in those terms has smaller positive degree than $v$. Degree induction solves recursively for each original generator and constructs the inverse. This works even with arbitrarily many generators in a degree.

Equip the source tensor algebra with primitive generators. The map is now a Hopf-algebra isomorphism, because the chosen images are primitive. The primitives in this tensor Hopf algebra are exactly $\mathbb{L}(V)$: $U(\mathbb{L}(V))=T(V)$ by the two universal properties, and the graded Graded Poincaré–Birkhoff–Witt theorem gives its primitive subspace. Consequently $L_Y\cong \mathbb{L}(V)$, proving the forward direction without assuming a primitive coproduct for the original generators.

Conversely suppose $L_Y\cong \mathbb{L}(W)$ for a positively graded $W$. Choose a homogeneous basis $w_{\lambda }$ of $W$. Represent its corresponding homotopy class by a based sphere map $S^{|w_{\lambda }|+1}\to Y_{\mathbb{Q}}$, and combine these maps intoThe wedge sum is a reduced suspension, namely $Z=\Sigma ({\bigvee }_{\lambda }{S}^{|w_{\lambda }|})$. The preceding direction, applied to this wedge sum, gives its free rational homotopy Lie algebra on the sphere inclusions. Indeed these particular tensor generators are primitive because the reduced diagonal of each sphere is zero, and loop Hurewicz homomorphism sends the adjoint sphere inclusion to that generator. Naturality of the bracket shows that $F_{\ast }$ sends the free generating basis to the prescribed free generating basis of $L_Y$. It is therefore an isomorphism of free graded Lie algebras, hence an isomorphism in every rational homotopy degree. The rational Whitehead theorem makes $F$ a rational homotopy equivalence. This proves the reverse implication and also shows that a wedge sum of spheres can be chosen as the reduced suspension.

For every chosen connected $X$ with $Y{\simeq }_{\mathbb{Q}}\Sigma X$, the required algebra statement is precisely the Bott–Samelson theorem isomorphism, transported along rational homotopy equivalence:Multiplication is concatenation of tensors and the degree-zero tensor is the unit. All freeness assertions here are graded, with the Koszul signs described above.

An almost commutative algebra over $\mathbb{C}$ has an exhaustive nonnegative increasing multiplicative ascending filtrationfor which the associated graded ringis a commutative finitely generated complex algebra. This includes the customary degree filtration with $F_{0}R=\mathbb{C}$, finitely many degree-one generators, and commutators lowering degree. The finite-generation clause is part of the convention used here and is necessary for the conclusion.

A finitely generated commutative complex algebra is a quotient of a polynomial ring $\mathbb{C}[X_1,\dots ,X_d]$. Repeated application of the central-variable case of the Hilbert basis theorem makes that polynomial ring Noetherian; quotients preserve the ascending chain condition by lifting ideal chains. Thus $\mathrm{gr}R$ is Noetherian.

We prove ascending filtered-graded transfer of Noetherianity directly. Give a left ideal $I\subseteq R$ the induced ascending filtration $I\cap F_{n}R$. Its associated graded module embeds into $\mathrm{gr}R$ as a homogeneous ideal, denoted $\mathrm{gr}I$. Choose finitely many homogeneous generators ${\overline{u}}_1,\dots ,{\overline{u}}_m$ of this ideal, of degrees $d_1,\dots ,d_m$, and lifts $u_j\in I\cap F_{d_j}R$. Homogeneous generators may be chosen by taking homogeneous components of any finite generating set.

For $u\in I\cap F_{n}R$, its degree-$n$ symbol can be expressed aswith terms of negative coefficient degree omitted. Lift each coefficient to $a_j\in F_{n-d_j}R$. ThenInduction on $n$, ending at $F_{-1}R=0$, expresses $u$ in the left ideal generated by the $u_j$. Hence every left ideal is finitely generated. Applying the same argument to right ideals, or to the opposite ring, provesThis degree-lowering proof terminates in finitely many steps and requires no completeness assumption on the filtered ring. Without finite generation of the graded algebra, a counterexample would be the commutative polynomial ring in infinitely many variables, whose ideals $(X_1)⊊(X_1,X_2)⊊\cdots$ do not stabilize.

For the universal enveloping algebra $U(\mathfrak{g})$, use the degree ascending filtration inherited from the tensor algebra of the finite-dimensional Lie algebra $\mathfrak{g}$. For $x,y\in \mathfrak{g}$, the defining relation is $xy-yx=[x,y]\in F_{1}U(\mathfrak{g})$, whereas the product $xy$ has filtration degree at most $2$. Thus the degree-one symbols commute in $\mathrm{gr}U(\mathfrak{g})$. Those symbols generate the graded algebra, so it is a quotient ofThis already proves the required almost-commutative property. The Poincaré-Birkhoff-Witt theorem gives the stronger identification $\mathrm{gr}U(\mathfrak{g})\cong \mathrm{Sym}(\mathfrak{g})$, but injectivity of this map is not needed for the chain-condition argument. Therefore

We use the James reduced product theorem and the Bott–Samelson theorem: if $X$ is a connected based CW complex with free integral homology, then $JX\to \Omega \Sigma X$ is a weak equivalence, and its induced Pontryagin ring isHere $\Sigma$ is the reduced suspension, $T$ is the tensor algebra, and the multiplication is induced by concatenating James words, hence by concatenating loops. Taking $X=S^{2n}$ supplies a single generator $x$ of degree $2n$, sois free, with one generator in every degree $2nk$ and zero in the other degrees.

The diagonal makes this a homology coalgebra. The generator $x$ is a primitive homology class:There are no nontrivial lower positive degrees in which its reduced diagonal could land. Compatibility of the diagonal with loop multiplication givesThe degree of $x$ is even, so the two tensor factors commute without a Koszul sign rule.

The universal coefficient theorem for cohomology has no Ext terms here because homology is free. Let $a_k$ be the cohomology class dual to $x^k$, with $a_0=1$ and $|a_k|=2nk$. The cup product is dual to the diagonal, henceTherefore the integral cohomology ring is the divided power algebraExplicitly $H^{2nk}=\mathbb{Z}{a}_k$ for $k\ge 0$, and all other cohomology groups vanish. In particular $a_1^k=k!a_k$: over the integers this is not a polynomial ring on $a_1$. This is the integral cohomology of an odd-sphere loop space.

For the requested homology multiplication, use the homology cross product followed by concatenation:The constant loop gives the degree-zero unit. Loop concatenation is associative up to homotopy, which suffices for associativity on homology; Moore loops can make the space-level operation strictly associative. The Künneth theorem identifies the tensor-product homology because its groups are free abelian groups. The Bott–Samelson theorem identifies this product with word multiplication, so $x^i\ast x^j=x^{i+j}$. The Pontryagin ring of an odd-sphere loop space has presentationWith only one generator the tensor algebra has the indicated polynomial presentation. The homology product and the divided-power cohomology product are different operations.

The truncated tensor algebra discards products of degree greater than $N$. Its multiplication is $(a\otimes b{)}^{(k)}={\sum }_{j=0}^k{a}^{(j)}\otimes b^{(k-j)}$. Every element with scalar part $1$ is invertible by a finite geometric series in its positive-degree part. Truncated exponential and logarithm are finite polynomials.