Complete positively curved paraboloid 2026-10-14
The graph in Euclidean three-space has the displayed induced Riemannian metric and positive Gaussian curvature. It is smooth at its vertex; the polar-coordinate singularity is only a coordinate artifact. The metric dominates the Euclidean plane metric, so upward stability of Riemannian completeness proves completeness. It has infinite diameter. In dimension two Ricci curvature equals Gaussian curvature times the metric, so this is a counterexample to compactness under merely pointwise positive Ricci curvature. Its curvature tends to zero at infinity.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2004 iii Paper 19 4 b Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Pointwise positive Ricci curvature does not imply compactness or a finite diameter. The complete positively curved paraboloid has induced metricand Gaussian curvatureFor example, this follows from the graph formula . The metric dominates the Euclidean plane metric, so it is complete by upward stability of Riemannian completeness. Its diameter is infinite since its distance dominates Euclidean distance. On a surface the Ricci tensor is , so it is strictly positive everywhere, but has no uniform positive lower bound.
There is no positive-Ricci metric on . If one existed, compactness of the unit tangent bundle would give for some . The lifted metric on the universal cover is complete by Q2 and satisfies the same positive lower bound. Part (a) makes this cover compact. A covering fiber is closed and discrete and therefore finite, implying a finite fundamental group. Butwhich is infinite. This is the finite fundamental group from a uniform positive Ricci bound obstruction; it rules out every possible metric, not just the standard product metric.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 15 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
A Riemannian metric is a smooth field of positive-definite symmetric bilinear forms on the tangent spaces, equivalently a smooth section of with that positivity. Its musical isomorphism isNondegeneracy makes every fiber map an isomorphism. In coordinates the map has matrix , and its inverse has matrix . Smoothness of the inverse follows from the inverse-matrix formula and the nonvanishing determinant. Both maps cover the identity on , giving a smooth vector bundle isomorphism.
For local flattening of a Riemannian metric, choose a manifold chart neighborhood around with closure contained in , and let on . Choose a smooth bump function , with compact support in and equal to one on a smaller neighborhood of . SetThe formulas glue smoothly because the modification is supported strictly inside . A convex combination of positive-definite forms is positive definite. On the metric is exactly , so gives an isometry to a Euclidean open subset. Outside the original metric remains unchanged.
Geodesic completeness means that every geodesic with arbitrary initial point and tangent vector extends for every real affine parameter. On each connected component, the Hopf-Rinow theorem equates this with completeness of the Riemannian distance.
The Euclidean-end claim needs a compact-core interpretation that is absent from its literal hypotheses. Indeed, with , and satisfy those hypotheses. The geodesic reaches the missing unit sphere at and cannot continue within . Thus the printed assumptions alone do not prove completeness.
Here is the intended compact-core completeness for a Euclidean end. Write for the end coordinates and assume additionally thatis compact for every sufficiently large . Choose such an beyond the metric transition and large enough to include the initial point of a geodesic. Its speed is constant. On every segment outside , the Euclidean radius changes at a rate at most , so over a finite parameter interval it cannot exceed . The full segment therefore stays in the compact set . Its velocities also stay in a compact subset of , since their metric norm is fixed and the base set is compact. The smooth geodesic ordinary differential equation consequently extends past any supposed finite endpoint. The reversed-time argument is identical. This proves completeness under the compact-core condition, and explains exactly what the exterior-of-a-ball counterexample lacks.
For upward stability of Riemannian completeness, lengths of all curves satisfy , hence . A -Cauchy sequence is therefore -Cauchy and has a limit because is complete. Smooth positive-definite metrics induce the manifold topology. More explicitly, on a small coordinate ball around , has a bounded largest matrix eigenvalue, so the coordinate straight segment gives . Thus convergence to is also in . That distance is complete, and Hopf-Rinow yieldsFor disconnected , apply this argument on each component.