Take the formula saying that a set is transitive:
This is a bounded formula in set theory. If , transitivity of ensures that every and every is already in , and the same holds in . Both structures therefore run through exactly the same bounded witnesses and use the same actual membership relation. They agree on for every , proving set-theoretic absoluteness.
The collapse is a bijection, so . Every and every element of belong to . The transitive collapse fixes transitive subsets lemma therefore gives , so every ambient countable ordinal belongs to .
Moreover, correctly regards each such as countable. An injection has rank below , so a witness belongs to . Elementarity gives “ is a countable ordinal”. Transporting this statement across the collapse, which fixes , gives the same statement in .
The collapse also fixes the element . No injection exists externally, hence none belongs to ; together with the countability witnesses below it, this shows that correctly identifies as its first uncountable ordinal. Elementarity and the collapse preserve that identification. Thus the construction gives
For the model constructed in part (a), the collapsing map is a bijection. The Downward Lowenheim-Skolem theorem supplied countable , so is externally countable. It is infinite because it satisfies the axiom of infinity. Consequently
This is external cardinality. A countable transitive model still regards many of its own sets and ordinals as uncountable, because external enumerations need not belong to it.
We construct the two transitive models together, taking care that the later collapse really retains the earlier model. First, a worldly cardinal is greater than : ZFC in contains the full power set , and the axiom of choice there gives a bijection between it and an ordinal . That power set is externally uncountable by Cantor theorem, so . Infinity rules out the finite cardinals and before this argument is applied.
By the Downward Lowenheim-Skolem theorem, choose a countable elementary substructure . Its inherited membership is a well-founded relation, and elementarity transfers extensionality from . Apply the Mostowski collapse theorem to obtain a countable transitive model of ZFC. Because is a countable transitive set, it is a hereditarily countable set and its rank of a set is below . In particular, .
Now take the Skolem hull in of the seed
Call it . The seed has external cardinality and lies inside . The hull is an elementary substructure of with : closure under countably many finitary Skolem functions gives the upper bound, and gives the lower bound. Let be its Mostowski collapse theorem map. Then is a transitive model of ZFC.
The transitive collapse fixes transitive subsets lemma gives for every , since is transitive. Since also , the collapse sends that element to itself. Thus , and transitivity of yields the required inclusion:
This is the construction of nested transitive models from a worldly cardinal; the next two parts verify its size and ordinal requirements.
A formula has set-theoretic absoluteness between these structures when both directions hold for every :
Equivalently, it is both a downward absolute formula and an upward absolute formula between them.
For every tuple of parameters , an upward absolute formula transfers truth from the smaller structure to the larger one:
These definitions of directional set-theoretic absoluteness do not themselves require the structures to be transitive.
For every tuple of parameters , a downward absolute formula transfers truth from the larger structure to the smaller one:
The condition concerns every parameter tuple from , not merely parameter-free sentences.
By the preceding sections, is a nowhere-zero closed differential form and . Injectivity of gives . The definition of de Rham cohomology then gives
for a smooth , with no critical points. If the boundary were connected, would make constant there. A nonconstant function on a compact manifold attains both extrema; a value differing from the common boundary value gives an interior extremum, contradicting . If were constant everywhere there would be the same contradiction. Empty boundary is also impossible, because an extremum would necessarily be interior. Thus , the boundary obstruction for commuting volume-preserving vector fields.
The solid torus retracts onto its first circle. Its degree-one de Rham cohomology is generated by that circle's angular one-form, which restricts to a nonzero class on ; hence the restriction map is injective. Its boundary is connected. Extensions of the two specified coordinate vector fields would be tangent there and would satisfy all the forbidden conditions. Therefore no such pair of extensions exists, for any volume form.
Let be the local flows of . The derivative of the pullback of by is . Therefore makes invariant under the flow. For fixed , the two curves and then solve the same initial-value problem for . Uniqueness gives commuting flows wherever both compositions are defined. Conversely, commutation implies invariance of under , and differentiation at gives . This proves vanishing Lie bracket is equivalent to commuting local flows.
For the contraction , commute each Lie derivative past the other interior products using . Each is zero by volume preservation. Cartan's magic formula , applied successively, now gives
The last term vanishes since has top degree. Hence .
At any point, the linearly independent vectors can be completed by to a basis of . A nowhere-zero volume form is nonzero on every basis, so
Thus . In particular, if it is an exact differential form , its potential has no critical points. This is the role of pointwise independence in the boundary obstruction for commuting volume-preserving vector fields.
If the spectrum has one point, the preceding part gives , and the linear span of any nonzero vector is a closed proper invariant subspace because .
Otherwise choose distinct points and disjoint nonempty relatively open neighborhoods . The open-set result gives and , while
Thus . Set . As the range of an orthogonal projection, is closed, and the preceding observations give . The Borel functional calculus for a normal operator gives , so
In fact both and its orthogonal complement are invariant.
If , the projection-valued measure satisfies . Its integral representation therefore reduces to
Thus a normal operator with a singleton spectrum is a scalar multiple of the identity operator. Normality is essential: a nonzero nilpotent matrix has spectrum but need not be zero.
First construct the spectral measure of a normal operator and prove the open-set assertion needed for all three numbered conclusions. The algebra generated by and is commutative because is a normal operator. The Gelfand transform identifies with . By spectral permanence for C-star algebras,
is onto: its image is the spectrum of in , which is also its spectrum in . It is injective because a character is determined by its values on and , and . Thus is a homeomorphism. Apply part (a) and set
This is a projection-valued measure with and
The associated continuous functional calculus is isometric: for .
If is nonempty and relatively open, choose and a nonzero continuous supported inside , for example a small continuous bump about in the metric of . If , then , contradicting . Therefore
This proves the claim from faithfulness of the representation rather than assuming it as part of the spectral theorem.
Now take an isolated point . Its singleton is relatively open, so . Multiplication of spectral integrals gives
Thus its range is contained in the eigenspace . Conversely, for in that kernel, the positive scalar spectral measure satisfies
It follows that , and hence . Consequently
The identification of this projection with the eigenspace holds even for a non-isolated ; isolation guarantees that it is nonzero.
The all-time conclusion in the original PDF is false. The expanding-flow transformation of a wave equation makes both the correct forward statement and a counterexample transparent. Put
For , the expanded operator from part (i) is . In the new variables and , hence
Thus it is the ordinary wave equation on the half-plane . By the D'Alembert formula, any solution has the form
At , differentiating the zero displacement with respect to and using the zero velocity gives, for ,
Subtracting times the first equation from the second gives , and then . Thus on and on . If and , both arguments remain in those intervals. Consequently the valid forward result is
For negative time the arguments need not stay in the initial intervals. Take and , where . Then
is a global solution, has the prescribed zero initial displacement and velocity on , but . This directly disproves the assertion for .
The connection with part (i) is directional finite propagation speed. At a future point in the strip, the two characteristics traced back to meet it at and , both in . For negative time these intersections can lie outside that interval. The lines are characteristic barriers for this forward domain of dependence, not barriers in both time directions.
Expanding the equation gives
For the hyperbolic partial differential equation discriminant, , , , so
For a curve , the characteristic hypersurface equation is , or . Therefore the two families of characteristic curves are
The values include the characteristic lines and . Every curve in the first family approaches as ; every curve in the second approaches . The two curves through are and , shown as the thick curves below. Equivalently, the characteristic coordinates are and .
Figure 1.
Characteristic families of the variable-coefficient wave equation
. Blue and orange curves show the two families of characteristic curves, with arrows in the direction of increasing time. Dashed lines mark the characteristic lines . The thick curves pass through the origin. The initial segment and shaded forward strip indicate the region where the zero data force vanishing, as proved in the next part. Details.
For , the conormal to its zero set is . The principal symbol of is
A characteristic hypersurface requires on the surface. Thus satisfies the anisotropic eikonal equation
The first-order and zeroth-order terms do not affect this condition.
Take the difference of two weak solutions, so . At the stated regularity, it is not justified simply to test by , which need not belong to the spatial test space . Instead use the antiderivative test underlying uniqueness of Sobolev weak solutions of a wave equation.
Fix and define
These are Bochner integrals in . The function is an admissible space-time test, before , and . The time term in the weak formulation is
because . Symmetry of and integration by parts in time give
For the lower-order part, integration by parts in space gives
Bounded coefficients, the Poincaré inequality for , and the Young inequality now imply
Since ,
For in a sufficiently short fixed interval, absorb the last term into the left-hand side. The Gronwall inequality applied to proves on that interval. The equation gives continuity of in , so both initial traces at its endpoint are again zero. Repeating with the same uniform coefficient bounds covers . Therefore
For each , let
A weak energy solution of a variable-coefficient wave equation is a function with zero lateral trace, equivalently , whose time trace satisfies in and for which
for every with zero lateral trace and . Here has a continuous representative, so the displacement trace is well defined.
The velocity condition is encoded by the boundary term in time; an arbitrary space-time function need not have an trace of . The equation implies , hence has a continuous representative and in that sense. This is the weak formulation obtained by integration by parts once in time and once in space.
First construct the Dirichlet eigensystem. By part (i) and the Lax-Milgram theorem, the inverse exists from into . Elliptic regularity gives , and the Rellich-Kondrachov compactness theorem makes a compact operator on . Symmetry gives
so is a self-adjoint operator. It is injective, and for . The spectral theorem for compact Hermitian operators supplies an orthonormal basis with , , and . Put . Then
Repeated elliptic regularity makes each smooth up to the boundary.
As with part (ii), the stated characterization omits boundary compatibility. At , its right-hand side is finite for every by Parseval identity, whereas its left-hand side would require . At higher orders, the preceding polynomial example is also decisive for the Dirichlet eigensystem: on ,
Although this function belongs to every ordinary , the weighted sum diverges at .
The correct spectral characterization of elliptic Dirichlet domains is
with defined in part (ii). For finite eigenfunction sums the squared norm is exactly the weighted sum: even orders follow from , and odd orders also use . These sums are dense in : if is -orthogonal to every , then , so . They are dense in by construction, and the isomorphisms propagate density to every . Completion in the equivalent norms from part (ii) proves both directions of the corrected equivalence. In particular, the printed characterization is correct for .
The assertion about all is false as printed in the original PDF. Take , , and . This is a nonzero smooth Dirichlet function, but and . In particular
Already at , is not defined on its stipulated domain, because . Extending to for this example would give zero, not an inner product. Additional boundary conditions are essential.
The corrected spaces are the Sobolev domains of powers of an elliptic Dirichlet operator. Let be the Dirichlet realization of an elliptic operator, and set
In particular , , and also requires . The formulas in the question define inner products on these spaces.
Here is the norm-equivalence proof on the corrected domains. The base cases are the inner product at and part (i) at . Standard Dirichlet elliptic regularity, together with invertibility from the Lax-Milgram theorem, gives for every integer
The first estimate applies when ; invertibility absorbs the usual lower-order term. Moreover, is an isomorphism. To see surjectivity, solve with zero Dirichlet trace for ; regularity gives , and for each further required trace. The formulas satisfy
Induction therefore gives
Injectivity of each iterate of gives positive definiteness. These spaces are ; the spectral characterization of elliptic Dirichlet domains in the next part makes the half-powers precise. On the paper's uncorrected spaces the claim is valid at , but fails in general beyond them.

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact