 Ising ring magnetization fluctuations

Define the instantaneous spin magnetization $m=\frac{1}{4}{\sum }_i{\sigma }_i$. Global reversal sends $m$ to $-m$ without changing the zero-field energy. Pairing every microstate with its reversed partner proves $⟨m⟩=0$ at every positive temperature, even when almost all probability lies on the two fully aligned patterns. A vanishing mean does not imply weak alignment: the limiting probability distribution is half at $m=+1$ and half at $m=-1$.

The Ising ring magnetization fluctuations measure this distinction through variance. In the $d=0$ class, both patterns have $m^2=1$. Among the $d=2$ patterns, eight have $m^2=1/4$ and four have $m^2=0$; the two $d=4$ patterns also have $m^2=0$. ConsequentlyIt equals $6/17$ at $K=(\ln 2)/4$, approaches $1/4$ for four independent fair Ising spins at $K\to 0$, and approaches $1$ as $K\to \infty$. Unlike the energy variance, the spin magnetization variance remains large in the low-temperature symmetric mixture.

The same thermal fluctuation controls the field response. Allow $h$ to vary before setting it to zero; differentiating the Boltzmann distribution inserts $\beta {\sum }_i{\sigma }_i=4\beta m$, givingThis is a spin-normalized magnetic susceptibility with respect to the energy-valued parameter $h$; conversion to physical magnetization and magnetic field requires the magnetic moment and sample volume factors.

For finite $N$, $Z$ is a finite positive sum of exponential functions. Its free energy $-k_{B}T\log Z$ is a real analytic function for $T>0$, so the smooth heat capacity peak here is not a critical phase transition. Spontaneous magnetization concerns the order of limits: first a thermodynamic limit, then removal of a symmetry-breaking field. The four-spin Ising ring alone establishes neither that limit nor any two-dimensional Ising model result.^[ref]