Let a compact smooth surface of revolution have exactly two poles, and let be the Clairaut first integral for a surface of revolution of a complete unit-speed geodesic. If , then , so the geodesic avoids open neighbourhoods of both poles. If , then is constant away from the poles and the geodesic lies in a meridian of a surface of revolution, whose complement contains a nonempty open set. Thus no complete geodesic has dense image.
Let
be the Clairaut first integral for a surface of revolution from part a(ii). If , then gives
for every . Since tends to zero at both poles, the geodesic avoids nonempty open neighbourhoods of the poles.
If , then whenever the geodesic is away from a pole. It consequently lies in one meridian of a surface of revolution; after crossing a pole, the angular coordinate changes by but remains in the same plane through the rotation axis. A small surface neighbourhood of any point outside that meridian is disjoint from the geodesic. In either case there is a nonempty open set with
This proves that the geodesic image on a compact two-pole surface of revolution is not dense.
The tangent plane
cuts the hyperboloid in
so its intersection is the pair of straight lines
Their accelerations vanish, hence are normal to the surface, so both lines are geodesics. Their tangent vectors at their intersection are and , whose inner product is zero. They therefore intersect at a right angle, giving the second case of plane-section geodesics of the unit one-sheet hyperboloid.
There are also geodesics entirely contained in . In the coordinates
the metric is
For a unit-speed geodesic, the Clairaut first integral for a surface of revolution is , and the constant-speed equation becomes
Choose and initial height . The geodesic initially tangent to the parallel has , and the displayed identity prevents it from entering . Since the parallel at is not itself a geodesic, the curve turns there and otherwise has . Hence it remains entirely in ; this is a geodesic trapped in one half of the unit one-sheet hyperboloid.
Finally, the waist
is a geodesic and is preserved setwise by every isometry of the hyperboloid. Indeed, its Gaussian curvature is
The value occurs exactly at . Since Gaussian curvature is intrinsic and therefore preserved by isometries, every isometry preserves the waist. Thus the answer to the final question is also yes, with the isometry-invariant waist geodesic of the unit one-sheet hyperboloid as an example.
Figure 1. . Blue meridians are disjoint geodesics in the plane y equals zero, red ruling lines are geodesics meeting orthogonally in the tangent plane x equals one, and the purple waist is an isometry-invariant geodesic.
Take the parallel at height one,
It has constant speed . Its distance from the axis is the constant , and its tangent is parallel to the parallel, so and it satisfies the Clairaut first integral for a surface of revolution.
However,
whereas a normal vector to at is
These vectors are not parallel. By the ambient acceleration criterion for a surface geodesic, is not a geodesic. Thus constant speed together with Clairaut's relation is not sufficient for the geodesic equations.
Write , , , and let be the first fundamental form. Since
differentiating and , or equivalently taking the two inner products of the second formula with , gives
The matrix is invertible because is a regular embedded surface parametrization. Consequently the two geodesic equations hold exactly when is orthogonal to both tangent vectors and , which says precisely that is a normal vector. This is the ambient acceleration criterion for a surface geodesic.
Because is tangent and is normal,
Thus an affinely parametrized geodesic has constant speed, as recorded by constant speed of an affinely parametrized geodesic.
For a surface of revolution, use profile arc length and azimuth . Its Riemannian metric is
The azimuth is an ignorable coordinate, so the corresponding geodesic equation has the first integral
If and is the oriented angle with the parallel, then the component of velocity along the parallel is
Since is constant,
This is the Clairaut first integral for a surface of revolution.
For the metric
the Christoffel symbols needed in the equation are
Thus a geodesic obeys
Multiplication by turns this into
Consequently the Clairaut first integral for a surface of revolution is
It is also the conserved momentum associated with the cyclic coordinate .