The preceding parts give a simple Specht module for each partition and show that different partitions give nonisomorphic simples. The conjugacy classes of are indexed by partitions of , namely cycle types. We use the standard finite-group character theorem: the number of irreducible complex characters equals the number of conjugacy classes, and they form an orthonormal basis of complex class functions. Consequently the are the complete list of irreducible characters of .
By Maschke's theorem, the Young permutation module decomposes as a direct sum of these simple modules. For a semisimple complex module, Schur lemma makes the multiplicity of a simple module equal to the dimension of the homomorphism space from that simple; character orthogonality identifies the same number with the character inner product. Hence
Part (ii) makes unless , and gives . Taking characters proves
Thus the permutation-character decomposition is triangular in the dominance order on partitions, with diagonal multiplicity one. These are the dominance and diagonal-multiplicity consequences of Young's rule, obtained here without assuming its full multiplicity formula.
Take . Since is odd, its sign is , so . Define to fix and reverse the other cyclic labels: it interchanges with , with , and so on. Then , while
The centralizer of an -cycle in is : a commuting permutation is determined by the image of one point, and that image fixes the corresponding power of the cycle. All its elements are even, because is even. Any other conjugator taking to differs from by a centralizer element and therefore remains odd. Thus and are not conjugate in . This is the parity obstruction described by inversion of an odd cycle in an alternating group.
For any complex character of a finite group, a unitary realization gives
If every had real value at , all these characters would take equal values on and . But irreducible characters separate conjugacy classes: they form a basis of class functions, so equality of every irreducible value would also give equality of the class indicator functions. The two distinct conjugacy classes cannot have that property. Consequently
In other words, these alternating groups are not ambivalent groups, even though all symmetric-group irreducible characters are integer-valued.
In character theory, a p-elementary group is a finite group isomorphic to , where is a -group and is cyclic of order coprime to . Either factor may be trivial. An elementary group is p-elementary for at least one prime ; it need not be an elementary abelian group.
A generalised character means an integer linear combination of irreducible complex characters. Brauer's characterisation of characters states that a complex class function on a finite group is a generalised character if and only if is a generalised character for every elementary subgroup . Equivalently,
An ordinary character additionally requires nonnegative coefficients in its global irreducible decomposition. We use the virtual-character criterion just stated.
For the extension construction, set . The determinant character is linear. Since its extension has the same value at the identity, is also a linear character. For any , the subgroup has cyclic quotient , hence a solvable quotient. The invariant character has degree coprime to , since this index divides , and extends its determinant. The permitted coprime-degree determinant extension theorem therefore gives a unique character with
Define a function on by . We next verify that these individually defined values form a compatible class function.
If , conjugation carries to . Transporting by this conjugation gives a character extending , because is -invariant, and with determinant restricted to the conjugate subgroup, because is a class function. Uniqueness identifies the transported character with . Consequently .
Now take an elementary subgroup and let . A finite -group is solvable, a cyclic group is solvable, and a direct product of solvable groups is solvable. Thus is solvable, and so is . Again the index divides , so the same extension theorem gives extending with determinant .
For , we have . The restriction is irreducible: an invariant subspace for would be invariant for , whose restriction already affords the irreducible . Its determinant is . By uniqueness on , it equals . Therefore
an ordinary character and hence a generalised character of . Brauer's characterisation of characters now makes a generalised character of . If , then and , so . We have proved, by gluing determinant-normalized character extensions,
Only the intermediate quotients and were required to be solvable; no solvability assumption on has been added.
For the prime-set assertion, let be p-elementary, and split the cyclic group as , where each factor has the indicated prime divisors in its order. If , put and . If , put and . In both cases the factors commute, have trivial intersection and have orders with disjoint prime spectra. This proves the prime-set decomposition of elementary groups
Here a pi-group has order divisible only by primes in , and a pi-element has such an element order; the identity qualifies for both complementary prime sets.
Finally, suppose satisfies the given element-order condition. The sets are unions of conjugacy classes and are disjoint, because membership in both would force every prime divisor of the element order into , hence force order . Let be elementary and use . If both factors were nontrivial, choose in the first and in the second. They commute and have coprime orders, so has order , containing primes from both and . It would belong to neither nor nor , contrary to the hypothesis. Thus every elementary subgroup is entirely a pi-group or entirely a complementary-prime group.
Write and for the two prime parts of , so and . The Chinese remainder theorem supplies an integer satisfying
Define the class function
For an elementary -subgroup , its order divides . Let be the character of its regular representation, equal to at and zero elsewhere. Then
with integral coefficient because . For an elementary -subgroup, its order divides , and
again has integral coefficient. The trivial subgroup satisfies either formula. Every elementary restriction is therefore a generalised character. A second application of Brauer's characterisation of characters proves
The freely chosen identity value, fixed by the two congruences, makes the restrictions integral. This construction also covers the cases , , or , using modulus-one congruences where appropriate.
The induced character construction extends any class function on by
Frobenius reciprocity for class functions is . It follows directly by substituting this sum into the left inner product, writing , and using the conjugacy invariance of . If is a character, its inner product with every restricted irreducible character is a nonnegative integer, a multiplicity in its complete reducible decomposition. Expanding in the orthonormal irreducible-character basis therefore makes a nonnegative integer sum of irreducible characters: it is a character of .
If affords , a concrete induced representation is , with acting by left multiplication on the first factor. Choosing coset representatives decomposes it into copies of . An element permutes these copies; only fixed cosets contribute trace, and the contribution from is . Summing fixed cosets gives exactly the displayed induced class function.
Sunada's theorem states that if a finite group acts isometrically on a closed Riemannian manifold , and two Gassmann equivalent subgroups act freely, then and are isospectral for the function Laplace-Beltrami operator. Gassmann equivalence means for every conjugacy class of . For each Laplace-Beltrami operator eigenspace , its invariant subspace has dimension
The character of a representation is a class function, so the two multiplicities agree. A necessary condition for nonisometry is that the subgroups are not conjugate in : conjugation by an ambient deck transformation would induce an isometry. This is not sufficient when the common covering has additional geometric symmetries.
Use the oriented hyperbolic triangle group
and the epimorphism given by , . Its base orbifold is the doubled hyperbolic triangle with angles , having signature . Let and .
The groups are torsion free. Indeed, torsion elements in an oriented triangle group are conjugate to nontrivial powers of its three vertex rotations. Such powers map either to elements of order three, which cannot lie in a subgroup of order , or to the order-two cube . The latter is central and absent from both , so it is absent from every conjugate as well. Thus the degree-twelve orbifold covers
are smooth, closed, connected orientable surfaces. The common cover is smooth too; act freely on it. Orbifold Euler characteristic gives
For example, this formula follows by triangulating the base and weighting a vertex of order by before multiplying by the cover degree. Equivalently, each doubled triangle has hyperbolic area , so has area and Gauss-Bonnet theorem gives the same genus.
There is one extra issue in obtaining the same hyperbolic limit on a single marked surface: the two limiting hyperbolic covers must themselves be isometric. Nonconjugacy and the displayed element orders alone do not prove this. An explicit realization of the supplied example resolves the issue. The group seed is recorded in the original genus-two construction; the following coset actions and reflection identities give a direct verification. Label the twelve sheets so that the two right-coset actions of are
These are concrete permutation data for an order- realization with the required two subgroups. The permutation
satisfies, by direct substitution,
Reflection of the doubled triangle reverses both vertex rotations. Apply this reflection on every fundamental domain and relabel sheets by . The two identities ensure that identified edges go to identified edges, so this descends to a hyperbolic isometry . Fix , let be its hyperbolic metric, and use to mark by the same smooth surface. Thus both pulled-back limiting Riemannian metrics are exactly . The explicit reversed-action check is what makes the common limit justified, rather than treating it as a consequence of Sunada's theorem.
Choose smooth orbifold Riemannian metrics on the base converging to its hyperbolic metric , with no nonidentity local isometry on the regular part. The density assertion in Sunada's local isometry lemma applies in orbifold charts as well: use equivariant perturbations at the finitely many cone points and ordinary local perturbations elsewhere. Smoothness here is orbifold smoothness, so the lifted Riemannian metrics on and the two smooth covers are ordinary smooth Riemannian metrics. Such choices can be made in successively smaller smooth neighbourhoods of ; cone orders and the topological coverings stay fixed.
For area separation of convergent Sunada families, adjust each by a constant positive factor so that
Explicitly, multiply the initially chosen Riemannian metric by the ratio of the desired area to its actual area. In dimension two this ratio is exactly the area multiplier. The ratios tend to one, so smooth convergence persists, and constant scaling preserves the absence of local isometries. Lift these adjusted Riemannian metrics to and pull them back by the fixed markings to obtain , for . The three required properties follow below.
We use the Dirichlet density form of the Chebotarev density theorem, the version directly proved by the permitted information at . If is a finite Galois extension of number fields with group and is a conjugacy class, let be the unramified prime ideals of whose Frobenius conjugacy class is . Then
The same conclusion holds for a union of conjugacy classes, replacing by the size of that union. The denominator may equivalently be the sum over all primes of . Here and below is real. This specifies the density being proved; an unweighted prime-counting asymptotic is a stronger formulation and is not being inferred merely from a limit at one.
First establish the necessary pole for a general base field. The Dedekind zeta function as a permutation Artin L-function gives it using exactly the allowed assumptions. Take a finite normal closure of , and let be the permutation representation on . Its trivial constituent has multiplicity one: an invariant function on the transitive set of embeddings is constant. At a rational prime, a basis of consists of the sums over inertia orbits of embeddings. Frobenius automorphism permutes these orbit sums. Within the decomposition-group orbit belonging to a prime of , the resulting cycle has length , because the residue embeddings are permuted cyclically by finite-field Frobenius. A cycle of length has determinant . Consequently the local factor of an Artin L-function gives
including at ramified primes. Decomposing gives
All factors after are holomorphic and nonzero at one by the allowed hypothesis. Thus has a simple pole there and
This argument also explains why the trivial relative Artin L-function is , rather than always the Riemann zeta function.
Now let be an irreducible character of , of degree . At an unramified prime the Euler product has local factor , where is a Frobenius representative. The eigenvalues of are roots of unity, since has finite order. Expanding the logarithm for therefore gives
where the finitely many ramified local factors contribute a function bounded as . They are nonzero and finite near one because their eigenvalues have modulus one while .
The terms are uniformly bounded. Indeed , and for and ,
There are at most primes of above each rational prime and each has norm at least that prime. Hence . Isolating proves the character prime sums in the Chebotarev proof identity
For nontrivial , the allowed holomorphy and nonvanishing at one give a local holomorphic logarithm and a bounded right side. The logarithm specified by the Euler series differs from that local branch by a constant multiple of on the real interval near one, so it too is bounded. For the trivial character, the right side is by the pole of . Thus
Expand the conjugacy-class indicator by character orthogonality. For ,
To see the coefficient, take its inner product with : . The irreducible characters form an orthonormal basis of class functions, so this is the full expansion. Substituting the prime-sum estimates leaves only the trivial character's logarithmic term:
Division by the diverging logarithm proves the theorem. The same trivial-character calculation shows that all primes of have density one; adding or removing finitely many primes does not change a Dirichlet density.
There is a necessary qualification for the final polynomial application: the printed claim is false for degree one. For example, is monic and irreducible in , yet has the root zero modulo every prime. We prove the intended assertion for degree .
Let be the splitting field of the monic irreducible polynomial over , and let be its roots. The Galois group acts transitively on . There is a derangement in a transitive group action: count the pairs satisfying . The orbit-stabilizer theorem gives
If every fixed at least one root, the identity, which fixes , would make this sum at least , a contradiction. Therefore some fixes no root, and neither does any conjugate of .
For completeness, relate this group action to reduction without assuming the desired splitting result. All roots are algebraic integers, since the polynomial is monic. Exclude the finitely many primes ramifying in or dividing the nonzero polynomial discriminant. At a prime over any remaining , the roots reduce to distinct elements of and give all roots of the reduced polynomial. Arithmetic Frobenius permutes them by . A reduced root belongs to exactly when it is fixed by this map. Because reduction is injective on the original root set, this happens exactly when the Frobenius permutation fixes an original root. This proves the Frobenius permutation and roots modulo a prime criterion.
The Chebotarev density theorem assigns the conjugacy class of our fixed-point-free the positive Dirichlet density . All but finitely many of these primes have rootless reduction, so there are infinitely many. More precisely, applying the same argument to the union of all fixed-point-free classes gives
Take to be a closed compact Riemannian manifold and use the positive Laplace-Beltrami operator. Its Riemannian heat kernel is the integral kernel of :
It solves for and tends to the identity kernel as . For an orthonormal eigenbasis, the spectral expansion of the Riemannian heat kernel is
The bar is required for a complex basis. With boundary, a specified invariant boundary condition must also be included in this definition.
For the quotient formula use the covering-space interpretation: acts freely and properly discontinuously by Riemannian isometries. On compact such a discrete group is finite. Freeness alone, without this covering hypothesis, does not justify the image sum: an infinite dense subgroup of circle rotations, for example, acts freely but has no manifold quotient. Positive-dimensional group actions require a different quotient analysis.
For lifts of , the heat kernel on a finite isometric quotient is
Invariance of under simultaneous Riemannian isometries and reindexing the sum show that this is independent of both lifts. A local isometry commutes with the Laplacian, so the sum satisfies the quotient heat equation. For its initial condition, integrate over a fundamental domain against a lifted function. The terms combine into the integral over all of , whose initial limit is . Uniqueness of the heat evolution proves the formula. There is no factor in this kernel formula.
On the diagonal the sum is -invariant. Its integral over is therefore times its integral over , giving the heat trace
Thus the normalization factor appears in the trace, not the kernel. Put . For any finite isometry group , changing variables proves : it is a class function on .
For Gassmann equivalent subgroups , their intersections with each conjugacy class have equal size, and their orders are equal. If both act freely, the heat traces of their quotients satisfy
so they agree for every . Since , equality determines the spectrum with multiplicities: take to recover the smallest eigenvalue and its multiplicity, subtract that term, and repeat. This proves Sunada theorem. Equivalently, projection onto -invariant functions averages the group action, and the quotient eigenvalue multiplicity is , with the eigenspace character of a representation. Almost conjugacy equalizes these averages.
For an integer tuple , the monomial alternant is
Negative exponents require nonzero coordinates; all exponents in the character expansion below are nonnegative. The power-sum symmetric polynomial is . Put , so is the Vandermonde determinant.
Let a conjugacy class of have cycles of length , with , and put . The product is an alternating polynomial homogeneous of degree . In an alternating polynomial, a monomial with two equal exponents has zero coefficient, since interchanging those variables fixes the monomial and reverses its sign. Grouping the remaining monomials by their permutation orbits gives a unique expansion in alternants with .
Such tuples of the indicated total degree are exactly for partitions of an integer of with at most parts. Define the class function
The displayed monomial occurs with coefficient in and in no other ordered alternant, so
This proves the expansion and explicitly defines its coefficients. They depend only on the cycle counts and hence are class functions. Identifying these coefficients with Specht module characters is the Frobenius alternant character formula, which the remaining parts allow us to assume.
The roots-of-unity criterion for a splitting field for finite group representations says that the assumed th roots of unity make a splitting field for . Fix a multiplicative identification of the group with the complex th roots of unity. For a p-regular element , its order divides ; the operator is diagonalizable because has distinct roots in . If its eigenvalues, counted with multiplicity, are , define the Brauer character by
where hats denote the chosen complex lifts. This defines a class function on the p-regular elements, not on arbitrary elements of .
A short exact sequence can be represented by block triangular matrices, so the eigenvalue multiset is the union of those on its submodule and quotient. Thus Brauer characters are additive on short exact sequences. If are the simple -modules, the Jordan–Hölder theorem gives
We use the standard Brauer–Nesbitt theorem in its character form: over a splitting field the Brauer characters of the nonisomorphic simple modules are linearly independent over . Therefore
Both the modular splitting-field criterion and this independence theorem are the representation-theoretic results used here.
There is a missing hypothesis in the original PDF: must be a splitting field for finite group representations. For example,
because and the quadratic factor is irreducible. This algebra has two simple modules, whereas has three conjugacy classes, all -regular. Thus the printed assertion for an arbitrary field is false.
Under the intended splitting hypothesis, fix compatible lifts defining Brauer characters. Let be the set of conjugacy classes of p-regular elements. Character additivity and the tensor-product formula define the unital algebra homomorphism
We use the Brauer character basis theorem: over a splitting field the irreducible Brauer characters form a complex basis of the class functions on the p-regular conjugacy classes. Therefore maps the basis bijectively to a basis and is an algebra isomorphism. Comparing dimensions gives
Isomorphism classes are understood in the count.
A group representation is a homomorphism . It is a reducible representation if there is a nonzero proper invariant subspace of preserved by every , and an irreducible representation otherwise. With invertible,
so changing basis gives another representation. Its character of a representation is , and cyclicity of the trace gives .
A conjugacy class consists of as varies. Since , a power equals the identity exactly when does. Thus conjugation preserves element order, including infinite order.
For the square, let be rotation by and reflection in a horizontal symmetry axis. The dihedral group has the eight elements
The conjugacy classes of a finite dihedral group specialize to
The two central rotations are singletons. Reflection conjugation reverses rotations, while conjugation by shifts a reflection exponent by two, giving the two reflection classes.
For finite groups over , character orthogonality and completeness make the irreducible characters a basis of the class functions. The latter space has one independent value per conjugacy class. Hence the square group has five inequivalent irreducible complex representations. The sum of squares of irreducible representation dimensions is eight, forcing four one-dimensional representations and one two-dimensional representation. The four scalar choices , supply the former; the ordinary action on the plane supplies the latter.
For a finite subgroup of a group of Riemannian isometries of a closed manifold , assume acts freely and define . Invariance of the Riemannian heat kernel and change of variables show that is a class function on . For , the heat kernel on a finite isometric quotient and integration over a fundamental domain give the displayed heat trace formula. Grouping by conjugacy classes proves equality for Gassmann equivalent subgroups. More generally the same argument allows fixed points of outside the freely acting subgroups; only the quotient under consideration must be smooth.
Weyl integration formula 2026-10-14
Let be a connected compact Lie group, a maximal torus, and its Weyl group. With normalized Haar measures and , every continuous class function satisfies . For a general continuous function, replace by its average . Conjugation from covers the regular elements times, and its real Jacobian determinant is .
For a class function on SU(2) and normalized Haar measure, the displayed formula reduces a group integral to its conjugacy-class angle. The weight follows by identifying SU(2) with the unit sphere in four real dimensions: writing a unit quaternion as gives spherical volume proportional to . Since , normalization gives .