Over a splitting field for finite group representations of characteristic , the irreducible Brauer characters form a complex basis of the class functions on the p-regular elements. Independence is the character form of the Brauer–Nesbitt theorem. To obtain spanning, extend such a class function by zero on the p-singular classes. Ordinary irreducible characters form a basis of all class functions by character orthogonality. Restricting them to p-regular elements yields Brauer characters of reductions of an integral form of a group representation in a compatible splitting p-modular system; if needed, first extend scalars, which does not change the simple-module list under the splitting hypothesis. Each restriction is a nonnegative integral sum of simple Brauer characters by exact-sequence additivity and the Jordan–Hölder theorem. Thus these restrictions span, proving the assertion. Consequently the number of simple modules equals the number of p-regular conjugacy classes, and evaluation identifies the complexified modular representation ring with the product of one copy of for each such class.
A complex class function on a finite group is a generalized character if and only if is a generalized character of every elementary subgroup. Equivalently, for every such and . Ordinary characters additionally have nonnegative global irreducible multiplicities; integrality of the virtual-character lattice is the conclusion of this criterion.
Character inner product 2026-10-03
For complex class functions on a finite group , the character inner product is
If is irreducible, this inner product is its multiplicity in the representation with character .
Normalized Haar measure makes this averaging a norm-one projection onto continuous class functions. Averaging a trace coefficient replaces its coefficient endomorphism by . On an irreducible summand this average is by Schur lemma. It follows that averaging finite-dimensional matrix coefficients yields finite linear combinations of irreducible characters. Together with the Peter-Weyl theorem, this proves uniform density of those characters among continuous class functions.
Heat trace Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-10-14
For the positive Laplace-Beltrami operator on a closed compact Riemannian manifold, the heat trace is . It records every eigenvalue with multiplicity. In a finite free isometric quotient it equals . The orbital integrals form a class function of the ambient finite isometry group, so Gassmann equivalence gives equal quotient heat traces and hence Sunada theorem.
The irreducible characters of a finite group form a basis of its complex class functions. Equality of every irreducible character value therefore forces equality of every class-function value, including indicators of conjugacy classes, and hence conjugacy. The converse follows from the class-function property.
Modular representation ring Created 2026-10-05 Updated 2026-10-14
The modular representation ring is the Grothendieck group of finite-dimensional group representations, with relations for every short exact sequence , and multiplication using the tensor product of group representations. The Jordan–Hölder theorem makes the classes of simple modules a free integral basis. Tensoring over a field is exact, so this multiplication is well defined. When is a splitting field for finite group representations, Brauer characters identify with the algebra of complex class functions on p-regular elements. The splitting hypothesis is essential: has two simple modules, although has three -regular conjugacy classes.
For a compact Lie group , the complex representation ring of a compact group is the Grothendieck group of finite-dimensional continuous complex group representations, with the relations . Multiplication is , and the unit is the trivial one-dimensional representation. The ring of class functions is
with pointwise addition and multiplication. The character of is . The trace identities for direct sums and tensor products make
a well-defined ring homomorphism .
Normalize Haar measure by . Averaging a positive definite Hermitian inner product gives
which is positive definite and -invariant. This proves unitarization of a compact-group representation. In a unitary representation the orthogonal complement of an invariant subspace is invariant. Induction on dimension therefore gives complete reducibility of compact-group representations. Hence every element of is a finite integral linear combination of irreducible classes.
We establish the needed character orthogonality for compact groups carefully. For irreducible unitary representations , let act on by
Its average is a projection onto : averaging makes every image invariant, and it fixes every intertwiner. The trace of this action is , since the inverse of a unitary matrix has conjugate trace. Taking the trace of the projection gives
For completeness, Schur's lemma follows here from invariance of the kernel and image of an intertwiner. A nonzero intertwiner between irreducibles is an isomorphism. An endomorphism of an irreducible complex representation has an eigenvalue ; the noninvertible intertwiner must vanish. Thus the last dimension is one for isomorphic irreducibles and zero for inequivalent ones.
If a virtual character vanishes, integrating it against gives for every irreducible . The irreducible multiplicities therefore distinguish the classes, and
This also proves that two finite-dimensional representations with the same character are isomorphic.
For SU(2), the irreducibles are , , of dimension . One can see this classification through the usual operators : a highest-weight vector has , , and the relations , , give, by induction,
The torus weights are integers. If but , the identity at forces . The vectors span an invariant irreducible module, which in an irreducible representation is the whole space. This is the symmetric-power module. Conversely its successive monomial weight vectors are linked by with nonzero coefficients, proving its irreducibility. Thus the classification of finite-dimensional representations of SU2 gives every irreducible, rather than just a list of examples.
On the maximal torus , their characters are
With , multiplication gives , starting with . Hence each is a monic integral polynomial of degree in . For example and . They form a basis over , so
The character map realizes this ring as the finite integral polynomials in , interpreted as continuous class functions. Its image is not the whole infinite-dimensional ring of continuous class functions; injectivity is the assertion being proved.
A maximal torus in a compact connected Lie group is a compact connected abelian Lie subgroup maximal among such subgroups. By the connected abelian classification it is isomorphic to a product of circles. Such subgroups exist: choose one of largest dimension among compact connected abelian subgroups; a proper inclusion of connected Lie subgroups would increase dimension. Write for its Lie algebra.
Here are the main steps of the conjugacy assertion, with the critical arguments supplied. Average an inner product on over the adjoint action to obtain an -invariant positive definite inner product. It defines a bi-invariant Riemannian metric. Compactness makes this metric complete, and the Hopf-Rinow theorem joins the identity to any by a geodesic. For a bi-invariant metric the Levi-Civita connection on left-invariant fields is , so the geodesic starting with is . Consequently every has the form .
The Lie-algebra centralizer of is exactly . If commutes with , its one-parameter subgroup commutes with . The closure of the subgroup generated by and is compact, connected and abelian, so it is a torus; maximality forces it to equal , giving . The torus action on decomposes into finitely many character weight spaces. The zero-weight space is . Choose outside the finitely many kernels of the nonzero weight differentials. Then the centralizer of is exactly .
For an arbitrary , the continuous function attains a maximum. Put at a maximizer. Differentiating along gives
Hence , so . Exponentiating gives . This adjoint-orbit criterion for maximal-torus conjugacy proves
Restriction of representations is a ring homomorphism . If a virtual representation restricts to zero, its character vanishes on . Since characters are class functions and every element is conjugate into , it vanishes on all of . The injectivity of the character map proved in Question 3 then gives
The Weyl group is . For , the operator intertwines the restriction of with its twist by . Therefore every restricted representation, and every virtual difference of them, is fixed by :
For the special orthogonal group , take
where is a real planar rotation. It is a maximal torus: its Lie-algebra centralizer consists of the independent infinitesimal rotations in those planes. Its character lattice is , so, writing ,
Indeed commuting unitary torus matrices diagonalize simultaneously into one-dimensional characters, and the characters of the circle are exactly the integral powers.
The normalizer permutes the real rotation planes and can reverse each angle independently. Permutations of whole two-dimensional blocks have determinant one. A reflection in one rotation plane reverses its angle and has determinant minus one; combining it with reflection of the remaining fixed line gives an element of . Thus all independent inversions occur. Conversely a normalizer must permute the distinct nontrivial torus character pairs and preserve the fixed line, so there are no additional actions. The kernel of this action is exactly , giving
It follows that the restriction identifies with a subring of the signed-permutation-invariant Laurent polynomials. In this case we can prove equality. Invariance under individual inversions first gives
For one variable, every invariant is an integral combination of and , and these satisfy the recurrence . Applying this one coordinate at a time proves the assertion over the other Laurent coefficient rings. Permutation invariance and the Fundamental theorem of symmetric polynomials then give
where are the elementary symmetric polynomials.
Let be the complexification of the defining -dimensional real representation. Its torus weights are . The characters of its exterior powers obey
For , choosing linear terms and quadratic terms shows that the coefficient is
Its leading term is with coefficient one; all other terms use with . By induction lies in the restriction image, because is the character of a genuine representation and all smaller already lie in the image. Hence every invariant polynomial lies there, proving the representation ring of an odd-dimensional special orthogonal group description
The triangular change of generators is integral, so are algebraically independent polynomial generators. For , and this reduces to , with the three-dimensional defining representation as generator. These are genuine representations of the orthogonal group, not the half-integral spin weights of its simply connected double cover.
The displayed torus-only Weyl integration formula needs to be a class function, meaning . This hypothesis is implicit in the usual formula but is not printed here. We prove the general version for a continuous function, then specialize:
Here and are probability Haar measures; is the invariant probability measure on the homogeneous space ; and is the finite Weyl group.
We use the following standard maximal-torus facts, as permitted: every element of a connected compact Lie group lies in some maximal torus; all maximal tori are conjugate; two elements of a fixed are conjugate in exactly when they are in the same -orbit; and the complexified Lie algebra decomposes into and one-dimensional root spaces. Opposite roots of a root system give real two-dimensional planes in . At an element for which no root character has value one, the identity component of its centralizer is .
Choose a positive root system . Regard each root as a character through the Adjoint representation. A convenient globally defined denominator is
The usual Weyl denominator additionally has a unit-modulus factor , with half the sum of positive roots. Where that half-weight is not a global torus character, it may be interpreted on a covering torus; the squared modulus is nevertheless unambiguous. In either convention,
Average an inner product on over the Adjoint representation to make it invariant. It defines a bi-invariant Riemannian metric on and the quotient metric on . Consider the conjugation map
At , identify the source tangent directions with and , and translate the target tangent vector to the identity by . Differentiating gives
The two summands are orthogonal. On a real root plane, is a rotation with complex eigenvalues . Thus the absolute real Jacobian determinant on this plane is . The torus direction contributes one. Therefore the conjugation Jacobian for a compact Lie group is
This is also the Jacobian for the normalized measures: the Riemannian submersion has fibers isometric to , so ; the probability-volume normalization factors cancel.
Let be the elements for which . The restriction of is a local diffeomorphism onto the regular elements of . It is -to-one. Indeed, fixing , any pair with has , because conjugation identifies the identity components of the two centralizers. Thus , and there is exactly one pair for each coset in . This argument does not require the full centralizer of to be connected.
The nonregular locus has measure zero. In it is a finite union of sets of smaller dimension; their conjugation images are images of smaller-dimensional manifolds under , and hence have zero volume in . The change-of-variables formula for the regular covering therefore gives
For a class function, the inner integral is , proving the required formula with its correct hypothesis.
Without conjugation invariance, the torus-only expression can be false. For with diagonal , take . It vanishes on , whereas its group integral is : the two squared coordinates of a Haar-distributed unit column have equal means and sum to one. Thus the conjugacy average cannot simply be dropped.
Let denote the irreducible characters of finite-dimensional complex group representations of . A generalized character, or virtual character, is an integral linear combination of these irreducible characters. A class function is a function constant on conjugacy classes. For class functions use the character inner product
A p-elementary group is a direct product of groups , where is a p-group and is a cyclic group of order coprime to . An elementary subgroup is a subgroup of this form for some prime . Either factor may be trivial. This notion is different from an elementary abelian group.
Brauer's characterization of characters says that a complex class function on is a generalized character exactly when its restriction to every elementary subgroup is a generalized character there. Equivalently,
The character orthogonality relations make these inner products the coefficients of the restrictions in their irreducible bases. The theorem detects the integral character lattice. An ordinary character of a representation additionally requires every global irreducible coefficient to be nonnegative; integrality alone characterizes virtual characters, not necessarily actual representations.
If is empty, take the zero generalized character; if is empty, take the trivial character. Otherwise let be the set of primes dividing the orders of elements of . The coprimality hypothesis makes every element of a -element. Thus every nonidentity element of is either a pi-element in or a complementary-prime element in . In particular these sets are unions of conjugacy classes, since conjugation preserves element order.
Put and . Their greatest common divisor is one, so the Chinese remainder theorem supplies an integer such that
Define the class function by , on and on . We verify Brauer's characterization of characters directly.
For an elementary subgroup , the cyclic factor can be split into its -part and -part. Attach to the part containing its prime. This expresses . Both factors cannot be nontrivial: choosing a nonidentity element in each would give a commuting product of mixed prime order, whereas every element of has order involving only one of the two prime sets. Hence is wholly a -group or wholly a -group.
Let be the character of the regular representation of , with value at the identity and zero elsewhere. In the two cases respectively,
The coefficients are integers because divides or . Thus both are generalized characters. The trivial subgroup causes no difficulty since is an integer. By Brauer's characterization of characters, is a generalized character of .
Taking gives the required values.
This is a generalized character separating complementary prime elements; the freely chosen value at the identity is what makes all elementary restrictions integral.
Let afford the given group representation of . Its induced representation is the left -module
Choose representatives of the left cosets ; then it is the direct sum of the spaces . If with , the action sends to . This is independent of the representatives up to equivalence, and its dimension is .
Only cosets fixed by contribute to its trace. Their contribution is , giving the induced character formula
For an arbitrary class function on , the same averaging formula defines its induced class function on . Equivalently, extend by zero outside and average . This definition is linear and does not require to be an actual character.
For a complex character of a finite group afforded by a representation , its determinant character is
Multiplicativity of the determinant makes this a linear character; it does not mean the determinant of the scalar value . The definition depends only on the character because characters determine the equivalence class of a finite-dimensional complex representation. In particular the determinant character is trivial on the derived subgroup .
Frobenius reciprocity is the adjointness of character induction and restriction: for class functions on and on ,
For characters this says that the multiplicity of an irreducible -character in an induced character equals the corresponding multiplicity after restriction. To prove the identity directly, insert the induced class function formula and interchange the two finite sums. For each , substitute with . Since is constant on conjugacy classes,
This proves the theorem for all class functions, not just irreducible characters.
For the group-theoretic conclusion, suppose that divides . A central element of order lies in every Sylow p-subgroup: adjoining it to a Sylow subgroup gives a p-subgroup, so maximality forces it into that subgroup. Hence there is a subgroup of order . Choose a nontrivial linear character of .
Since is abelian, extends to a linear character of . One direct justification is to extend from an abelian subgroup to one generator at a time: if is the least positive exponent with , choose a complex th root of as the value at . The formula on is then well defined and multiplicative. Iteration yields the claimed extension to .
The induced character has degree , which is prime to . In its decomposition into irreducible characters, at least one constituent must have degree prime to ; otherwise the total degree would be divisible by . Frobenius reciprocity also gives for this constituent. Restriction to the central subgroup forces
Indeed, the induced representation itself restricts to as copies of , because conjugation by every coset representative is trivial on ; alternatively this follows from Schur's lemma and the positive multiplicity after restriction.
Each consequently acts in the representation affording as the scalar . Taking its determinant character gives
The left side is trivial since and every linear character kills . The right side is nontrivial since has order and . This contradiction proves
The argument is the central commutator has no torsion from an abelian Sylow subgroup determinant obstruction.
Interpret as a continuous finite-dimensional complex group representation, so its values lie in , and interpret approximation in the uniform norm. Assume the usual Hausdorff convention for the compact topological group. The following argument proves the required form of the Peter-Weyl theorem without first assuming that is a Lie group.
Start with normalized Haar measure. It is both left- and right-invariant on a compact group. Average any Hermitian inner product to make a finite-dimensional representation unitary. The left regular action is already unitary on .
Choose a continuous nonnegative function supported in a small symmetric identity neighbourhood, with and . Such functions are obtained from a nonzero continuous bump near the identity, symmetrizing and normalizing. Define
The convolution operator commutes with left translations. Its continuous kernel is Hermitian, hence it is self-adjoint. It is compact on : approximate the continuous kernel uniformly by finite sums of separated functions of and , using the Stone-Weierstrass theorem on the compact product. The corresponding operators have finite rank and converge in operator norm. It also maps into and satisfies
by the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality; continuity follows from the uniform continuity of the translated kernel.
The spectral theorem for compact self-adjoint operators decomposes the orthogonal complement of its kernel into finite-dimensional eigenspaces with nonzero eigenvalues. Every such eigenspace is left-translation invariant, and all its elements are continuous, since there. If is one of these invariant spaces, write . Evaluation at the identity gives
Thus is a matrix coefficient of the dual representation. This identifies each finite spectral sum with finite-dimensional representation data.
To get uniform rather than just approximation, let project onto increasing finite sums of the nonzero eigenspaces. For , is orthogonal to the kernel, so in . Applying the displayed smoothing bound gives
Meanwhile, choosing the support of sufficiently small makes uniformly close to , by uniform continuity under small translations. Since , it also makes uniformly close to . Every belongs to a finite sum of invariant eigenspaces, hence is a finite sum of matrix coefficients. This completes the convolution proof of uniform Peter-Weyl approximation.
A coefficient equals for the rank-one endomorphism . Finite sums of coefficients can be combined using a direct-sum representation and a block-diagonal . Therefore the conclusion has exactly the requested form:
For a class function , apply conjugation averaging on a compact group,
It fixes and is a contraction in the uniform norm, so averaging an approximation preserves its error bound. A trace coefficient averages to , where
This endomorphism commutes with the representation. A finite-dimensional unitary representation splits into irreducibles by repeatedly taking invariant orthogonal complements. On each irreducible diagonal block, Schur lemma makes its average a scalar multiple of the identity, namely its trace divided by the block dimension. Off-diagonal blocks do not contribute to the total trace. Thus the averaged coefficient is a finite linear combination of irreducible characters. Consequently irreducible complex characters span a uniformly dense subspace of the continuous class functions.
Let be a finite normal Riemannian covering, so acts freely by deck isometries. With any lifts of , the heat kernel on a finite isometric quotient satisfies
There is no factor in this kernel formula. Simultaneous invariance of under isometries proves independence of the lifts, by reindexing . Each term solves the lifted heat equation. If is a fundamental domain and a function on , the integral of the right side against over equals
because the translates tile up to sets of measure zero. This converges to as , proving the initial condition. Uniqueness of the heat equation solution on the closed manifold gives the formula. For a noncompact finite cover, use the minimal heat kernels, or compatible Friedrichs heat realizations. The normalized pullback is unitary onto the deck-invariant subspace and preserves the Dirichlet energy, so it intertwines the heat semigroups and yields the same kernel formula. No uniqueness of unrestricted noncompact heat-equation solutions is needed.
Set for an isometry . Diagonal integration and the covering degree give
Unlike the kernel formula, the trace formula has an averaging factor: integration of a quotient function over is times integration over .
Suppose now , with any larger group of isometries of the closed manifold . Change variables and use simultaneous heat-kernel invariance to obtain
Thus is a class function, and the Sunada orbital heat-trace formula can be grouped by conjugacy classes of :
Only classes meeting the finite subgroup contribute, so this class sum is finite even if the larger isometry group is infinite.
For finite , Gassmann equivalence means for every conjugacy class. Summing these counts gives , so the displayed formula gives identical heat traces. Their spectra, with multiplicities, agree: as , the constant limit identifies the multiplicity of zero; after subtracting it, the slowest-decaying exponential identifies the least positive eigenvalue and its multiplicity. Repeating determines every subsequent eigenvalue. This proves the Sunada theorem in the stated covering situation.
There is an important convention when the universal cover has an infinite deck group . For compact quotient manifolds, the subgroups must have finite index; the appropriate generalized Gassmann condition is equality of the characters of the finite coset permutation representations, not equality of possibly infinite cardinalities of conjugacy-class intersections. Let be the intersection of the two subgroup cores. Each core is the kernel of the corresponding finite coset action, so is normal and of finite index in , and . The manifold is then a compact finite normal cover of . The finite group acts on , and have equal coset permutation characters in . For a finite group, the fixed-coset count is
Equality at the identity gives equal subgroup orders, and then equality for all gives almost-conjugacy. Applying the proved finite theorem to establishes isospectrality also in this finite-index interpretation. It avoids taking the divergent heat trace of a noncompact universal cover.
To realize a finitely presented group , begin with the closed smooth four-manifold , whose fundamental group is free on the . Represent the relator words by disjoint smoothly embedded circles; general position permits this in dimension four, including separating self-intersections of representatives. Their oriented normal rank-three bundles are trivial, so perform framed surgeries replacing by . Removing the circles' tubular neighborhoods leaves the fundamental group unchanged, by codimension-three general position. The Seifert-van Kampen theorem shows that each replacement kills exactly the normal closure of its relator. The resulting closed smooth has . This gives a concrete closed-manifold realization of a finitely presented fundamental group. Equip it with any smooth Riemannian metric and lift that metric to the universal and intermediate covers; all covering maps become local isometries.
To ensure nonisometry, one must choose nonconjugate subgroups. If , or they are conjugate, the quotients are isometric for every lifted metric, so Gassmann equivalence alone cannot imply nonisometry. For nonconjugate subgroups, choose the base metric to have no nonidentity local isometry between open sets, using the Sunada local isometry lemma in dimension at least two. If were an isometry, a local inverse of the first covering followed by and the second covering would be a local isometry of , hence the identity. Thus the covering maps satisfy everywhere. Classification of connected covers then forces to be conjugate in , a contradiction. Therefore nonconjugate almost-conjugate subgroups and a locally rigid base metric give isospectral nonisometric quotients.
For take the diagonal maximal torus
The spectral theorem for unitary matrices says that every element is conjugate to an element of . A diagonal element with pairwise distinct eigenvalues has centralizer exactly . Its conjugates therefore determine its eigenvalues up to permutation, and the normalizer quotient is . The character lattice of a torus is , with . Conjugation on the matrix unit has weight , so these are the roots. Choose positive for ; then
Dominant integral weights are precisely the integer tuples . Negative entries are allowed: they correspond to determinant twists, so polynomial representations alone do not exhaust the irreducible representations of .
Normalize Haar measure on and to have mass one, and put
The Weyl integration formula for U(n) for a continuous class function is
For a general continuous function, replace in the torus integral by , using the normalized invariant quotient measure.
To prove the formula, consider the conjugation map , . On regular torus elements its fibres have exactly points: the possible orderings of the distinct eigenvalues. Equip the group with an invariant inner product on its Lie algebra and split . After translating the derivative back to the identity, its torus directions contribute the identity, while its transverse directions contribute . Each pair supplies a real two-dimensional off-diagonal plane. On that plane is multiplication by , regarded as a plane rotation, so the absolute real determinant of the transverse derivative is
The change-of-variables theorem, divided by the covering multiplicity, now gives the desired weighted integral up to the constant relating the normalized invariant measures. The nonregular locus has measure zero: repeated eigenvalues are the zero-set of the nonzero discriminant, and the torus coincidence sets likewise have measure zero. Thus its omission causes no change to the integral. To determine the normalization, expand as a sum of distinct torus characters. Fourier orthogonality gives . Applying the formula to fixes the coefficient to . This proves both the class-function and conjugacy-averaged forms.
We can now derive the character formula from integration, rather than merely quote it. Use the basic highest-weight theorem: a finite-dimensional irreducible representation has a unique highest weight with a one-dimensional highest-weight space; all its other weights are minus a nonnegative sum of positive roots. Its character is Weyl invariant. Also, character orthogonality for compact groups gives . This orthogonality follows by averaging the representation on : the integral projects onto intertwining operators, whose dimension is one by the Schur lemma.
Let and, for a strictly decreasing integer tuple , put . The finite Laurent polynomial is alternating. Every alternating Laurent polynomial is a linear combination of the : collect its monomials by permutation orbits, and observe that an orbit with repeated exponents has zero coefficient by antisymmetry. Different are orthogonal on and each has squared norm .
The coefficient of in is exactly one. Indeed, a contribution from the term would require a weight in . For , the vector is a nonzero nonnegative combination of the positive simple roots, so that weight lies above and is impossible. The identity permutation supplies the highest-weight coefficient one. Consequently
Apply the integration formula to . Torus orthogonality gives
All the other coefficients vanish, proving
The quotient extends across repeated eigenvalues because its product with the denominator is the already defined continuous character. Equivalently, alternant divisibility makes it a Laurent polynomial invariant under permutations; multiply by a determinant power if negative exponents must first be removed.
Finally, is fixed by the Weyl group, so its common factor cancels in the quotient. Since , the determinant expression is exactly
Using in the derivation avoids treating a possibly half-integral as an actual character of the torus. At the identity, taking the leading Vandermonde term of the two determinants gives the accompanying dimension formula
Use the canonical nonnegative Laplace-Beltrami operator and its Riemannian heat kernel for . For the spectral conclusion we use closed compact manifolds, so the operator has a discrete spectrum and a finite heat trace. The kernel identity itself can also be formulated for the canonical Friedrichs extension on a noncompact manifold; this specifies the heat operator rather than assuming uniqueness among unrestricted solutions of the heat equation.
An isometry preserves the Laplacian, its defining quadratic form and therefore its heat semigroup. Consequently
Set . A different choice of lifts has the form with , because the covering is normal. The resulting sum is
since permutes . This proves independence of both lifts. Local smooth sections of the covering map then show that is smooth for positive time. There are finitely many summands, so spatial and time differentiation commute with the sum, and local isometry gives .
For the integral and initial condition, use the sheet-counting formula
It follows by dividing the base into measurable pieces lying in evenly covered charts and using the locally isometric inverse branches. For a smooth test function on the base, this formula gives
On a closed manifold these integrals are finite, and the finite sheet sum entails no convergence exchange. The right side tends to as by the initial property of the Riemannian heat kernel. Thus has the correct delta initial condition.
One can identify the operator exactly, also avoiding a noncompact uniqueness issue, by heat semigroup descent through a finite normal covering. If , the map is unitary onto the -invariant subspace of , because
Locally isometric pullback proves the second equality. Smooth compactly supported invariant functions descend, and averaging over the finite group gives the corresponding equality of the closed quadratic-form domains. Hence the Friedrichs extensions and their heat semigroups intertwine. The preceding integral is precisely that descended semigroup, proving
For the noncompact version, finite covering maps are proper, so compactly supported test functions have compactly supported lifts; the same form argument is valid. The canonical heat kernels are sub-Markovian, which bounds integrals against bounded test functions. All operations used above are therefore defined. In particular there is no factor in the kernel formula: integrating over the sheets already accounts for its normalization.
Now take a finite ambient group of isometries of a closed , and free Gassmann equivalent subgroups . Define the orbital integral
It is finite, and the conjugacy-invariance identity makes it a class function on . The heat kernel on a finite isometric quotient and the sheet-counting formula give the quotient heat traces
The averaging factor belongs here, since the cover has sheets. By Gassmann equivalence, the two subgroups meet each conjugacy class in the same number of elements, and summing these numbers also gives . Since is constant on each class, the two heat traces are equal for every .
Finally, a discrete nonnegative eigenvalue multiset is determined by its heat trace. Its zero multiplicity is . After subtracting the zero terms, the smallest remaining eigenvalue and its multiplicity are recovered from the leading exponential decay; subtract those terms and repeat. Compactness ensures only finitely many eigenvalues in any bounded interval, so this procedure recovers the entire multiset. We have proved the Sunada theorem:
The closedness assumption is used for this heat-trace deduction; on a general noncompact manifold one cannot replace it by a possibly infinite trace without further analysis.
If the initial manifold is not compact, the same isospectral conclusion can be interpreted for the canonical self-adjoint operators without taking an infinite trace. To see this, decompose the unitary representation of the finite group as , with irreducible and its multiplicity space. Commutation with the group makes the Laplacian act on each summand as , by the Schur lemma applied to its bounded resolvents. The projection onto the -invariant factor is , and its trace is therefore . Gassmann equivalence makes these dimensions equal. Unitary identifications , tensored with the identity on each multiplicity space, intertwine the restricted Laplacians. The normalized pullbacks identify those restrictions with the two quotient operators. This Sunada unitary equivalence without a finite heat trace proves equality of their full spectra, including continuous spectrum when present.
On a closed compact Riemannian manifold, the heat kernel for the positive Laplace-Beltrami operator is the smooth kernel of for . It solves and tends to the delta kernel as , so that
For an orthonormal eigenbasis with eigenvalues repeated according to multiplicity,
The exponential factors and elliptic regularity ensure smooth convergence for positive time. If a boundary is present, the same construction uses a specified boundary condition preserved by the covering; the closed-manifold case is the one needed below.
Let be the finite normal locally isometric covering map. The heat equation for on is the lift of the one for on . Integrate the lifted solution over a fundamental domain for the deck transformation group , splitting the integral over into its translates. This gives
There is no averaging factor in this kernel formula: each translate accounts for one lift of the integration variable. To verify it directly, the sum solves the lifted heat equation and its integral against converges to ; uniqueness of the heat solution identifies the kernel. Replacing either lift or only permutes the sum, since isometries preserve the heat kernel.
Integrating the diagonal and using the covering degree gives the heat trace formula
Suppose is contained in a finite group of isometries of . For , change variables and use invariance of both volume and the heat kernel. Then
Thus is a class function on , and for its conjugacy classes ,
Consequently, if are Gassmann equivalent and act freely, their orders are equal and the displayed class-by-class sums give for every . Equal heat traces determine equal eigenvalues with multiplicities: the least eigenvalue at which the multiplicities differed would give a nonzero leading exponential in their trace difference as , a contradiction. Hence the two smooth quotient manifolds are isospectral. This proves the Sunada theorem, with the free-action hypothesis ensuring that the quotients are manifolds rather than orbifolds. The theorem alone makes no nonisometry claim.
Use the defining property of the Frobenius complement: whenever . The induced character formula, extended linearly to any class function, is
For , a summand requires . The Frobenius intersection property forces . All remaining terms equal since is a class function on , so . At the identity,
Together these give
The zero identity value is essential: at nonidentity elements the intersection argument already gives the equality, whereas induction multiplies the identity value by the subgroup index.