Adjoint of a commutator Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-10-14
When compositions and adjoints are defined on the common test domain, reversing products gives . In particular a self-adjoint Dolbeault Laplacian and the mutually adjoint Lefschetz operators satisfy .
Bochner-Kodaira-Nakano identity Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-07
For the Chern connection of a Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle on a Kähler manifold, the two Dolbeault Laplacians differ by , where is its curvature form of a connection and is the adjoint Lefschetz operator. The curvature term controls vanishing estimates.
On a compact Hermitian manifold of complex dimension , , with complex-linear Hodge star, is a conjugate-linear bijection from Dolbeault Laplacian harmonic -forms to harmonic -forms. The identities and show that implies the same two equations for . Its square is . Thus these harmonic spaces have equal complex dimension even without the Kähler condition. The natural map is conjugate-linear, not complex-linear.
Dolbeault Green operator 2026-10-14
On a compact Hermitian manifold without boundary, this operator is the inverse of the Dolbeault Laplacian on the orthogonal complement of its harmonic forms and is zero on the harmonic space. Elliptic theory gives , with the harmonic projection, and ensures that sends smooth forms to smooth forms. It commutes with and ; their commutation with the Laplacian and orthogonality to its kernel give this by uniqueness of the inverse. If is -exact, then . On a Kähler manifold, the same operator serves the holomorphic Laplacian because .
The Lefschetz operator commutes with the bundle-valued Dolbeault Laplacian on the entire smooth form space exactly when the Chern connection is flat. The Lefschetz-Dolbeault curvature commutator gives one direction. Conversely test its curvature-wedge operator on degree-zero sections with arbitrary prescribed values at any point to force every vector-bundle curvature endomorphism to vanish.
For a -closed pure-type form orthogonal to harmonic forms on a compact Kähler manifold, let be the inverse of the Dolbeault Laplacian on the harmonic complement, zero on the harmonic space. The Kähler Laplacian identity makes it commute with and . Thus and . The mixed anticommutator gives . This is an explicit potential for the ddbar lemma, with one lower degree of each type; using the inverse of the Hodge Laplacian instead multiplies the displayed expression by four.
The Kähler Laplacian identity implies that every holomorphic function on a Kähler manifold is a harmonic function. On functions, and by degree, so both terms of the Dolbeault Laplacian vanish. Compactness is unnecessary. Changing the sign convention for the scalar Laplacian does not change this conclusion.
For a Hermitian holomorphic bundle over a Kähler manifold, let act by exterior multiplication. The bundle-valued Kähler identities give , and taking adjoints yields . This measures the failure of the bundle-valued Dolbeault Laplacian to commute with the Lefschetz operator.
On a Kähler manifold, the Lefschetz operator of a Kähler manifold commutes with the Dolbeault Laplacian:
Consequently, if is -harmonic, then every is also harmonic.
An almost complex structure is a smooth endomorphism with ; in particular the real dimension is even. Complexifying the tangent bundle splits it into the and eigensubbundles
interchanged by conjugation. On a complex manifold, these are locally spanned by and . An integrable almost complex structure is one arising from a holomorphic coordinate atlas. Its sections are closed under the Lie bracket. The obstruction is the Nijenhuis tensor
Expanding this expression in the two eigentypes shows that is equivalent to involutivity of . Holomorphic coordinates make this condition necessary; the Newlander-Nirenberg theorem gives its sufficiency for smooth . Integrability also gives , with and . The Dolbeault operator on defines its holomorphic vector bundle structure.
A real connection on a vector bundle on preserves when . Its complexification then preserves both eigensubbundles. Restricting to gives a complex connection . Conversely any complex connection on gives such a real connection by adjoining its conjugate on and restricting to the conjugation-fixed real tangent bundle. Equivalently, transfer through the real isomorphism . These operations are inverse. Preserving alone does not impose the holomorphic compatibility condition .
For integrable , the latter condition has a precise real-connection interpretation: the mixed-type torsion tensor vanishes. In holomorphic coordinates it says . Reality also gives . Since these coordinate fields commute, their torsion is zero. Conversely a -preserving real connection with zero mixed torsion has these two derivatives equal; they belong to opposite eigentypes, so both vanish, proving . This is the holomorphic tangent connection and mixed torsion criterion.
Full torsion-freeness imposes the additional symmetry in , and its conjugate. Such a -preserving torsion-free connection exists on any complex manifold: local holomorphic-coordinate flat connections have these properties, and a real partition of unity combines them globally. Preservation of and zero torsion persist because both conditions are affine in the connection. Conversely if is merely almost complex, a torsion-free connection preserving it forces : replace brackets by in the displayed tensor and use ; all terms cancel. Thus this connection condition detects integrability, without imposing any metric condition.
A Hermitian metric is a real Riemannian metric with . It induces a Hermitian metric on and the fundamental two-form . The unique Chern connection satisfies both and metric compatibility. In a holomorphic frame with metric matrix and coefficient-column convention, its matrix is . It need not be torsion-free when transferred to .
In holomorphic coordinates its coefficients are . Their symmetry in is equivalent to , which says . The conjugate gives . The result that a torsion-free Chern tangent connection characterizes a Kähler metric follows: the transferred Chern connection is torsion-free exactly when , the Kähler metric condition. In that case it equals the Levi-Civita connection, by uniqueness of the metric-compatible torsion-free connection. Equivalently a Hermitian metric is Kähler exactly when its Levi-Civita connection preserves . In the reverse direction implies , and zero torsion gives .
This explains the role of Kähler metrics: they make the real Riemannian and holomorphic connection theories coincide. A general complex manifold has torsion-free -preserving connections and has Hermitian metrics, but need not have a connection satisfying both requirements simultaneously. On a Kähler manifold, the Kähler identities then link the Dolbeault Laplacian and Hodge Laplacian, giving and the resulting harmonic Hodge decomposition theorem for compact Kähler manifolds.
Use both Kähler identities from the preceding parts, so that and . For odd operators , write . Direct expansion gives
Since , we obtain
Together with part (b), this proves the full Kähler Laplacian identity
Now take the exact form . Being -exact, it is orthogonal to the harmonic space, so , and it is also -closed. Choose for the Dolbeault Green operator of the Dolbeault Laplacian. Commutation gives . Therefore
Suppose also , and put , . The mixed identities and give
Thus is harmonic for the Dolbeault Laplacian. By the Kähler Laplacian identity it is also -harmonic and hence . But it is -exact, so
Consequently : the form is -closed.
For every harmonic form of the same bidegree as , . Harmonic spaces for the two Dolbeault Laplacians coincide, so has no -harmonic component. Apply the version of the Dolbeault Hodge decomposition. Since is -closed, it has no -coexact component either. Thus , with . We conclude the requested ddbar lemma:
For example is a choice, since the same Green operator serves . If or , the relevant negative-bidegree space is zero and the argument forces . Compactness, the absence of boundary and the Kähler condition are essential to this global harmonic argument.
The Hermitian metric induces pointwise Hermitian inner products on the exterior powers of the complex cotangent bundle, with different bidegrees orthogonal, and a positive volume form . Thus the global inner product on smooth differential forms of type is
Let be the formal adjoint of the Dolbeault operator, defined by integration by parts, and let . This Dolbeault Laplacian preserves bidegree, is elliptic and nonnegative, and has
On a compact Hermitian manifold without boundary, the Dolbeault Hodge decomposition on a compact Hermitian manifold says that the smooth harmonic space is finite-dimensional and
More precisely, there are the orthogonal harmonic projection and a Dolbeault Green operator taking smooth forms to smooth forms, with on harmonics and . Elliptic regularity ensures these are statements about smooth forms, not only completions. The Green operator commutes with and , since the Laplacian does and its inverse is unique on the orthogonal complement of the kernel.
Expanding gives
The three summands are orthogonal: harmonic forms are killed by both adjoints, and . If is -closed, its coexact component is orthogonal to every closed form; taking its inner product with shows that component has norm zero. Conversely the first two components are closed. Thus , with out-of-range form spaces taken to be zero.
Let , and use the complex orientation. Write for the real Riemannian metric underlying the Hermitian metric. Its fundamental form of a Hermitian manifold is
where in this convention. It is real and of type , since . Choose an adapted real orthonormal frame and its dual coframe . Then , giving the Riemannian volume form
We use the complex-linear Hodge star operator, the extension of the real metric star characterized on equal-degree forms by
It maps -forms to -forms and satisfies . It is distinct from the conjugate-linear map . In the adapted coframe the star of is the wedge product of all the other two-dimensional factors, with positive sign. Summing proves the Hodge star of the fundamental Hermitian form formula
This computation uses no closedness assumption on .
Use the integrated Hermitian inner product . The formal adjoints and are defined by and ; compact manifolds here have no boundary. The Hodge Laplacian and Dolbeault Laplacian are
The Dolbeault Hodge decomposition on a compact Hermitian manifold states that
is an orthogonal direct sum, with finite-dimensional . Each Dolbeault cohomology class
has a unique representative in . A form is harmonic exactly when both and vanish, since its Laplacian inner product is the sum of their squared norms.
Now let be the Hermitian Lefschetz operator and let be its pointwise adjoint. For of total degree and of degree , the defining inner products give
The wedge pairing is nondegenerate, so . Apply another star to the degree- form and use that the star and commute with conjugation. This yields
For degrees below two both sides vanish. The argument also identifies its bidegree as and does not require the Kähler condition.
Assume now that , so the metric is a Kähler metric. Start with the supplied Kähler identities relation . Since is real, conjugation gives , hence
The commutators are ordinary commutators because has even degree. Using we obtain, by direct expansion,
Conjugation gives as well. Expanding the two unmixed Laplacians and using gives the same operator:
Finally expand and ; the mixed terms just proved zero disappear. This derives the Kähler Laplacian identity
The Dolbeault Laplacian preserves bidegree. Thus the complex -harmonic forms of total degree split into their harmonic parts. The allowed real Hodge theorem, followed by complexification, gives
The real operator commutes with conjugation, which exchanges and . Therefore . For odd , no summand has , so they pair off in equal dimensions. This proves that all odd Betti numbers are even.
For , the Kähler form power is closed. If it were exact, say , then
by Stokes theorem. But has strictly positive integral on the nonempty compact manifold. Hence the powers of a compact Kähler form have nonzero cohomology classes, and
For an example take the Hopf surface
The dilation action is free and properly discontinuous: on a compact subset the radii are bounded above and away from zero, so only finitely many dilations can meet it. It is holomorphic, giving a complex manifold quotient; the annulus covers the quotient, proving compactness. The map
is a diffeomorphism . The Künneth theorem gives . This violates the necessary odd-degree parity, so this compact complex surface admits no Kähler metric.
Let be the Riemannian metric underlying the Hermitian metric and its compatible complex structure. The fundamental form of a Hermitian manifold is . It is a real alternating form of type . At a point choose an orthonormal real coframe adapted to , with of type . Then
The orientation here is the complex orientation. In coordinates for which , the same convention reads .
Use the complex Hodge star operator, the complex-linear extension of the real Hodge star operator. With the pointwise Hermitian inner product linear in its first variable, its defining identity is
for forms of the same total degree. It maps type to and satisfies in real dimension . It commutes with complex conjugation. These conventions distinguish it from the conjugate-linear Hodge star .
Write a top holomorphic-type form as , where . On each oriented two-plane, and , so the two-dimensional star of is . In taking the star of their product, regrouping complementary one-form factors across the two-planes contributes . Thus the Hodge star on top holomorphic forms is
This is pointwise and requires neither holomorphicity of the coefficient nor closedness of .
To compute the formal adjoint, take compactly supported forms of degree and of degree . The Stokes theorem gives
Since the degree of is , the identity for makes the right side equal to . Consequently the formal adjoint of in even real dimension is . Splitting by type, lowers antiholomorphic degree, while lowers holomorphic degree. Orthogonality of distinct types therefore yields
The argument applies locally with compact support, and globally without support restrictions on a compact manifold without boundary.
The Dolbeault Laplacian is . A form is -harmonic when it lies in its kernel. On a compact Hermitian manifold, the adjoint identities imply
Thus harmonicity is equivalent to both first-order equations vanishing. The Dolbeault Hodge decomposition on a compact Hermitian manifold states that the harmonic space is finite-dimensional and that smooth forms have the orthogonal direct-sum decomposition
To deduce the identification with Dolbeault cohomology, let and decompose . The closedness of makes it orthogonal to the entire image of . Taking its inner product with and using the orthogonality of the decomposition gives . Hence , so each cohomology class has a harmonic representative. If a harmonic form equals , its squared norm is , so the representative is unique. We have proved
For the complementary types, define . It maps to and is conjugate-linear. If is harmonic, then and by the adjoint formula. Conjugating the latter equation gives . Also, with ,
since . Therefore carries harmonic forms to harmonic forms, and makes it a bijection. This proves complementary Dolbeault harmonic types on a Hermitian manifold:
The metric supplies a natural conjugate-linear isomorphism. If a complex-linear isomorphism is desired, choose a basis of the first space and send it to the basis of the second, extending linearly. This last choice is not canonical; no Kähler assumption is needed for either the dimension equality or the harmonic bijection.
Let be the real Riemannian metric underlying the Hermitian metric, and let be the complex structure. The fundamental form of a Hermitian manifold is
The identity implies , so this is an alternating real two-form. Moreover . A two-form with this invariance has type : on two vectors of type , applying to both multiplies its value by , forcing that value to vanish; the same argument applies to type . Hence is a real -form.
Use the complex-linear convention for the complex Hodge star operator, extending the real star. The complex orientation and metric define , and
Here the Hermitian inner product is linear in the first argument. With this convention, on the even-dimensional underlying real manifold the formal adjoints are , and . A conjugate-linear star is another convention, but then the adjoint formulas must change accordingly.
The Hodge Laplacian and Dolbeault Laplacian are
Also write . They are nonnegative, since for example
The requested Dolbeault Hodge decomposition on a compact Hermitian manifold is a compactness statement: on a compact Hermitian manifold without boundary,
The harmonic space is finite-dimensional, and taking the harmonic representative induces an isomorphism . Compactness is essential to this formulation; it is not asserted on an arbitrary noncompact Hermitian manifold.
Now suppose is compact and Kähler, so . The permitted Kähler Laplacian identity is , making the three harmonic spaces identical in each bidegree. A -closed pure-type form has , since these two terms have different types. We will construct a Green operator potential for ddbar exactness, rather than invoking the ddbar lemma as the conclusion to be proved.
Let be the inverse of on the orthogonal complement of its harmonic forms, zero on the harmonic space. It is twice the Green operator of the Hodge Laplacian. The Hodge decomposition theorem and elliptic inversion give , with harmonic projection. It preserves bidegrees. The operators and commute with : the first follows from and , and the second directly from . They and their formal adjoints annihilate harmonic forms, so they preserve the orthogonal complement of the harmonic space. Consequently they commute with , by uniqueness of the inverse on the harmonic complement. Thus and are killed by both differential operators.
The assumed orthogonality makes . Applying the two Laplacians gives
We also need the mixed anticommutator, which follows from the permitted Laplacian identity rather than an extra unproved lemma. Expand using and . Since , its mixed terms sum to zero. Their two bidegrees and are distinct, so each vanishes separately, in particular . Hence
We have obtained the explicit answer
The positive assumptions on ensure these degrees are available. Conversely such a form is orthogonal to harmonic forms by integration by parts, so the same proof also explains the harmonic orthogonality criterion for ddbar exactness.
For injectivity of the Lefschetz operator on a Hermitian manifold on real one-forms, work at one point in a metric-orthonormal coframe with . If , a unitary change of coframe makes , . Then
since the displayed basis three-forms are linearly independent. Therefore has zero kernel. Injectivity on complex one-forms follows by taking real and imaginary parts, since is real. This pointwise proof of injectivity of powers of the Lefschetz operator for degree one does not require the hard Lefschetz theorem.
Closedness of gives . Using the permitted Kähler identities, specifically , gives
Multiplying by two proves . In particular the Lefschetz operator preserves harmonic forms and the injective map on one-forms restricts to an injection . The de Rham Hodge theorem identifies these real harmonic spaces with the corresponding real cohomology groups. Taking dimensions yields
The specified bidegree is the conjugate-linear Hodge star, not the complex-linear extension of the real star. If the pointwise Hermitian inner product is linear in its first argument, it is defined by
It is the real Hodge star operator extended complex-linearly and composed with complex conjugation; . On a compact Hermitian manifold,
is a positive definite Hermitian inner product on smooth forms. The formal adjoint is in this convention; the final star in this identity is present in the PDF but is corrupted in the TeX aid.
State the relevant Hodge theorem as follows. On a compact manifold without boundary, the Dolbeault Laplacian is elliptic, self-adjoint and nonnegative. Its harmonic kernel is finite-dimensional, and smooth forms split orthogonally as this kernel plus the image of . There are the orthogonal projection and a smooth Green operator with
For any form , expand the Laplacian term to obtain
Harmonic forms are both closed and coclosed, since . They are orthogonal to both other terms; the two images are orthogonal because . This proves the Dolbeault Hodge decomposition
The closed forms are exactly the first two summands: if , then is orthogonal to the adjoint image, and conversely the first two summands are closed. It follows that every Dolbeault cohomology class has a unique harmonic representative. Negative or out-of-range bidegrees mean zero spaces. Compactness and the absence of boundary are necessary for this stated global decomposition.
Now assume a Kähler metric. Set and . The permitted Kähler identities, stated with signs, are
with ordinary commutators because has even degree. Thus , and
by . The companion identity gives in the same way.
Define and . Expanding and makes the two mixed anticommutators vanish, so . To prove equality of the latter two, substitute the same commutator formulas and use :
The displayed operators are identical. Therefore the Kähler Laplacian identity is
Let be a -exact form. It is closed and orthogonal to harmonic forms. The Dolbeault Hodge decomposition, or the Green identity with , therefore gives
For the Green construction, follows since commutes with ; equivalently the coexact component of a closed form vanishes. This yields exactly the stated factorization.
If also , put and . The identities already proved give
Thus is harmonic for and hence for . But it is -exact, so it is orthogonal to the harmonic summand in the Hodge decomposition theorem. Consequently , proving that is -closed.
Furthermore is orthogonal to the common harmonic space, since . Its -Hodge decomposition then has neither a harmonic term nor a coexact term: closedness kills the coexact term. Therefore for a form . It follows that
This proves the requested ddbar lemma, including the intermediate harmonicity and orthogonality steps. The hypotheses ensure that the potential has a valid bidegree.
Finally is a real closed form and is -exact. Integration by parts makes it orthogonal to every -harmonic form. By the Kähler Laplacian identity it is also orthogonal to the Dolbeault harmonic space; because it is -closed, the Dolbeault Hodge decomposition makes it -exact. Apply the proved ddbar lemma to get for a smooth complex-valued function. Reality gives , so averaging yields
With ,
The potential is defined up to a real constant on each connected component. This is a statement about cohomologous Kähler forms, not about an arbitrary pair of such forms.
The Hermitian metric on cotangent vectors is the dual metric, and its exterior-power metric is defined on decomposable vectors by the determinant of their pairwise inner products. Tensor this with the metric on . In a unitary coframe and unitary frame of , the forms obtained by wedging distinct holomorphic and antiholomorphic coframe elements and tensoring with a frame vector form an orthonormal basis. Let , and use inner products linear in the first variable.
The bundle-valued conjugate-linear Hodge star is characterized by contraction of the coefficients in
It is conjugate-linear, maps type to type , and uses the metric identification of with its dual. For total degree , the ordinary star-square rule gives
where is identified with . The conjugate-linear convention is essential for the bidegrees specified here.
If has degree and degree , the even degree of the real form gives
Since for , it follows that pointwise. Thus is the adjoint Lefschetz operator.
For holomorphic , differentiates coefficients in holomorphic local frames and uses the graded Leibniz rule on forms. Its bundle-valued Dolbeault adjoint is the formal differential operator
It lowers the antiholomorphic degree by one. To verify this on compact , define . For and , Stokes applied to the scalar -form yields
The star-square identity converts the right side into . Compactness and absence of boundary remove boundary terms. This establishes the asserted global adjoint relation on smooth sections.
The Dolbeault Laplacian , with , is formally self-adjoint. Consequently the adjoint of a commutator satisfies
For the part of the Chern connection, the explicit corresponding adjoint is
where is the part of the dual Chern connection. This is the same integration-by-parts formula in holomorphic degree.
Now assume the metric is Kähler. Since , commutes with . Taking adjoints proves
The scalar Kähler identities needed are
They extend to the bundle-valued Kähler identities
Here is a local justification of the extension. At any chosen point, take holomorphic normal coordinates for the Kähler metric and a holomorphic local frame of with and at that point. This is a Chern connection in a normal holomorphic frame. Such a frame is obtained first by normalizing the metric matrix at the point and then prescribing the holomorphic local frame change's first derivatives to cancel . The first-order operators and their formal adjoints at the point are then the scalar operators acting componentwise. The scalar identities therefore give the two displayed bundle identities there. Since the point was arbitrary, they hold globally.
Let . Its square and vanish, while
because the Chern curvature has pure type . Use the two commutators already proved to calculate
Taking adjoints, including conjugation of the scalar , gives the Lefschetz-Dolbeault curvature commutator
If , commutation follows. Conversely, vanishing of the commutator on all -valued forms implies for every smooth section of a vector bundle . At any point, a bump-supported local section can have any prescribed fiber value. Thus annihilates every vector in every fiber, forcing identically. This proves the flatness criterion from Lefschetz commutation; the test on degree-zero forms is why the assertion is made on the entire form space.
Let denote the sheaf of differential forms of type (p, q) printed in the PDF. Take the pointwise Hermitian inner product to be linear in its first argument, and use . The bidegrees in the question specify the conjugate-linear Hodge star: it is uniquely characterized by
Thus , and maps bidegree to . If is the complex-linear extension of the real Hodge star operator, then . The operator is real and on degree , so
Using the complex-linear star instead would give a different bidegree, ; keeping the convention explicit prevents that ambiguity.
The Hermitian Lefschetz operator is exterior multiplication by . Define pointwise by
It lowers bidegree by . In a unitary real coframe with , it is , the corresponding sum of interior product of a differential form operators. This gives its existence and identifies it as a smooth operator. On a compact manifold, integrate the pointwise equality against to obtain
No integration by parts is needed for this order-zero operator. Thus is both the pointwise and the global formal adjoint.
Write , and let denote the degree of the input form. The given Lefschetz commutator is . For the required formula is exactly this identity. If it holds for , the commutator derivation identity gives
The second commutator acts on degree , so the coefficient on the right is
This proves the commutator formula for powers of the Lefschetz operator
For injectivity of powers of the Lefschetz operator, is immediate. Suppose and . If or , then , and implies
The scalar is nonzero, since makes . Repeating with the smaller power shows . For , induct on , treating all cases as already established. The same commutator calculation yields, with ,
The induction hypothesis applies to on degree , since and . Hence with of degree . Moreover . Since , induction also makes injective on that degree, so and . All operators preserve restriction to open sets; the argument applies on every open set. Therefore is an injective morphism of sheaves whenever .
On a Kähler manifold, the Kähler identities, with the positive form convention used above, are
Taking formal adjoints conjugates the scalar and reverses the order in the commutator. Since , this gives
To derive the Kähler Laplacian identity, put and , so and . Write for an anticommutator. The Kähler identities say and . Therefore
because expansion leaves only terms containing or . Furthermore,
Expanding these expressions and using makes them equal. Since and , the mixed anticommutators already vanish, and consequently
Closedness of the Kähler form implies . Using the adjoint identity above,
The equality of the three Laplacians therefore proves each Laplacian commutes with .
For a compact Kähler manifold, the Dolbeault Hodge decomposition is the orthogonal decomposition
Here harmonicity for the Dolbeault Laplacian and for the Hodge Laplacian agrees by the preceding identity. If and , then . Taking its inner product with gives . Thus is cohomologous to . Conversely, a harmonic form is -closed, and a harmonic exact form satisfies . This proves existence and uniqueness of the harmonic representative and hence
These spaces are finite dimensional by the ellipticity of the Dolbeault Laplacian on the compact manifold.
Complex conjugation commutes with the real operator and interchanges the bidegrees and . It is therefore a conjugate-linear bijection of the harmonic spaces, proving Hodge symmetry. The real Hodge star operator commutes with , as does complex conjugation; hence their composition, our conjugate-linear Hodge star, sends harmonic -forms bijectively to harmonic -forms. Its square is the nonzero scalar established above. This proves Hodge duality, and gives
For the final hard Lefschetz isomorphism on Dolbeault cohomology, take and . This restriction is necessary to make the displayed power nonnegative. The Hermitian Lefschetz operator raises bidegree by , and the Lefschetz operator preserves harmonic forms; therefore
is well defined. It is injective by injectivity of powers of the Lefschetz operator, since . Hodge symmetry and Hodge duality give , so it is a bijection between finite-dimensional spaces of equal dimension. Because , the map on harmonic representatives agrees with exterior multiplication by on Dolbeault cohomology. We conclude
For , the corresponding valid statement is the inverse of the positive-power isomorphism from bidegree to ; a negative exterior-multiplication power is not defined.