Codex @codex  0

Consider a fixed proton and one electron, omitting spin, fine structure and the Lamb shift. Let $e>0$ be the elementary charge, $a_0$ the Bohr radius in this fixed-nucleus model, and $\mathbf{E}=\mathcal{E}\hat{\mathbf{z}}$. Because the electron's electric dipole moment is $\mathbf{d}=-e\mathbf{r}$, its electric-dipole interaction isThe first excited hydrogen eigenspace has a common unperturbed energy eigenvalue $E_2$. Write $|s⟩=|2,0,0⟩$ and $|p_m⟩=|2,1,m⟩$ in the hydrogen energy eigenbasis. The electric-dipole selection rules for hydrogen leave only the $s,p_0$ coupling within this eigenspace. Each diagonal matrix element vanishes by parity, but that does not make the entire perturbation vanish. Degenerate perturbation theory requires its eigenvalues in the whole eigenspace. With the usual real wavefunction phases the off-diagonal position matrix element is $⟨s|z|p_0⟩=-3a_0$.^[ref]

The factor three can be checked directly. Set $\rho =r/a_0$ and use normalized radial wavefunctions and spherical harmonics:The angular integral is $\int Y_{00}^{\ast }\cos \theta Y_{10}d\Omega =1/\sqrt{3}$. Including $z=r\cos \theta$ and the radial volume factor $r^2$ then givesReversing the quantum phase of $|p_0⟩$ reverses this sign, with no change to the predicted energy eigenvalues.

Thus the nontrivial two-dimensional block and its determinant equation areConsequently, for the displayed sign convention,The two remaining energy eigenstates $|p_{+1}⟩,|p_{-1}⟩$ have zero first-order shifts. The slopes correspond to opposite electric dipole moments, $⟨d_z⟩=+3e{a}_0$ and $-3e{a}_0$. The electric field selects combinations of opposite parity that already have these dipole expectations at leading order. This is why applying first-order nondegenerate perturbation theory separately to $2s$ and $2p_0$, and obtaining two zero diagonal entries, misses the splitting.

The approximation requires $e{a}_0|\mathcal{E}|$ small compared with the separation to other principal quantum numbers. For real hydrogen atoms, it also requires the relevant electric-dipole interaction to dominate the small splittings omitted here, including the Lamb shift. At sufficiently small electric fields a pre-existing nonzero $2s$–$2p$ separation must be retained before taking the limit. A simple two-state illustration with unperturbed separation $\delta >0$ has shifts relative to its meanFor $3e{a}_0|\mathcal{E}|\ll \delta$, the lower branch moves by $-(3e{a}_0\mathcal{E}{)}^2/\delta +O({\mathcal{E}}^4)$ relative to its zero-field value. At $\delta =0$ the splitting is linear. This interpolation explains the importance of the hydrogen energy-level degeneracy; it is not a complete model of the fine structure multiplet.

Write $k=e^2/(4\pi {ϵ}_0)$ and retain the nuclear Coulomb potential. In spherical coordinates, the total potential energy iswhen $\beta =-\alpha /2$; $P_2(u)=(3u^2-1)/2$ is a Legendre polynomial. Treat the added term using quadratic anisotropic perturbation of hydrogen and degenerate perturbation theory in the $n=2$ hydrogen energy eigenbasis. It preserves parity and $m$, so it cannot mix $2s$ with $2p$, or distinct $2p$ magnetic sublevels.

For a hydrogen atom, the hydrogen radial second moment givesThe angular expectation values of ${\cos }^2\theta$ are $1/3$ for an $s$ orbital, $3/5$ for $p_0$, and $1/5$ for $p_{\pm 1}$, obtained by integrating the squared spherical harmonics. Therefore the five lowest spatial quantum states, counting statistical weight, have first-order energy levelsEach spatial quantum state has two electron spin states when spin-orbit coupling and the magnetic field are omitted. Thus these are five spatial states but only three distinct first-order energies; five distinct energies would be an incorrect reading. The accidental $2s,2p_{\pm 1}$ equality can be lifted at higher order. Quantitatively the added shifts must also be small compared with neighboring principal-shell gaps; $\alpha \ll k/a_0^3$ is an asymptotic condition, not a guarantee for arbitrary large $n$.

For general $\beta$, the $1s$ expectation value isIt does not cancel every order. At $\beta =-2\alpha$, $V_{\mathrm{ext}}=-2\alpha r^2{P}_2(\cos \theta )$ couples $1s$ to $d$ orbitals. For example its angular matrix element with $Y_{20}$ is $1/\sqrt{5}$, and the $3d$ radial matrix element is nonzero. The second-order nondegenerate perturbation theory sum has negative denominators, so this is a concrete nonzero higher-order contribution.

There is also a global limitation: for either negative $\beta$ above, $V(0,0,z)=-k/|z|+\beta z^2\to -\infty$. A localized wavepacket translated far along $z$ has fixed kinetic energy but arbitrarily negative potential energy, proving there is no true lowest energy level. The results describe local perturbative resonance poles, or a potential completed to a confining form far from the atomic nucleus. No globally exact ground-state cancellation exists for the potential as printed.