Brachistochrone problem 2026-10-14
The brachistochrone problem asks for the curve along which a particle released from rest reaches a specified target fastest under a uniform gravitational field, without friction. With downward depth , conservation of energy gives speed and travel time . The Beltrami identity makes constant, leading to a cycloid. If only the horizontal endpoint coordinate is fixed, the natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint select the half arch ending at its deepest point, with depth and minimum time .
Positive compression contributes negative quadratic potential energy , while positive bending stiffness contributes . A plane wave has , so sufficiently long waves grow exponentially. For displacement-fixed, moment-free endpoints at , the natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint on the slope give as well as . The modes are , and the first Euler buckling of an elastic filament threshold is . For truly clamped ends, , the threshold is instead , with first static mode . More generally,
with the infimum taken over the specified endpoint class. At threshold there is a static zero mode and a marginal linear-in-time partner in the linear dynamics; above it the straight configuration is unstable.
The elastic energy minimized without forcing gives . With fixed , stationarity of gives : a bending eigenmode. A general admissible shape expands in these normal modes. The natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint are , while the clamp imposes .
Isoperimetric constraint 2026-10-06
An isoperimetric constraint fixes the value of an integral while optimizing another integral over functions. A constant Lagrange multiplier incorporates the constraint into the variational integrand, and the resulting Euler-Lagrange equation must be supplemented by the appropriate natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint. The name includes integral constraints more general than prescribed geometric length.
For a variation with but arbitrary , differentiation and integration by parts give
First choose variations supported inside the interval. The fundamental lemma of the calculus of variations gives the Euler-Lagrange equation. Then allow arbitrary endpoint variation to obtain the natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint:
Because has no explicit dependence on ,
Thus the Beltrami identity is , constant along an extremal.
For the brachistochrone problem, put , so conservation of energy gives the bead speed . Its travel time is
The Beltrami identity now gives for a positive constant . A descending cycloid parametrizes this relation:
The free endpoint has , hence . On the first descending arc this occurs at . Therefore
Along this arc and , so
The initial vertical tangent causes no divergent travel time: the quotient has the finite constant limit .
To verify global minimality, take any admissible wire graph of finite travel time below the release level, and let be its maximum depth. For , the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality gives
Indeed the two coefficients on the right, after multiplication by , form a unit vector. Since the path starts at depth zero and reaches depth , the weighted total variation is at least the integral over all depths from to . Consequently
The last inequality is minimized at . Our cycloid attains equality throughout: its depth increases to and . Thus it achieves the genuine minimum over the wire graphs, not merely a stationary time. Reflection handles a negative horizontal endpoint coordinate by replacing with .
For one small transverse displacement, the elastic energy of the elastic filament is
where is the filament bending modulus. Its first variation is
The clamped boundary conditions remove the left boundary terms. A force-free and torque-free tip permits independent and , so the natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint are : zero bending moment and transverse shear.
There is an important distinction between an energy minimum and a normal mode. The unloaded higher-order Euler-Lagrange equation is , whose only solution with these four boundary conditions is . A general fluctuating shape is a sum of modes, not one of the stated sinusoidal/hyperbolic functions. To obtain the clamped--free bending modes, extremize the bending Rayleigh quotient, or equivalently with a fixed norm. Its Euler-Lagrange equation is
This is the constrained variational characterization of bending modes. Its four characteristic roots are . Clamping gives and , hence
The free-tip conditions reduce to
Its determinant is , so nontrivial modes require
No zero mode exists, since a cubic satisfying the homogeneous clamp/free conditions is zero. The clamped-free bending spectrum starts with ; bisection or Newton iteration gives , so . Choosing and gives
The second boundary condition follows from the root equation, and is arbitrary until a normalization is chosen.
The bending operator with these boundary conditions is positive and self-adjoint. Twice integrating by parts gives
Symmetry implies orthogonality when . Expand and use . Then
by the equipartition theorem. The supplied endpoint identity therefore yields the thermal bending fluctuations of a clamped filament:
To evaluate the sum, apply a tip force and minimize . The modified free-end conditions are and , and in the interior. Integration gives , so the tip-force compliance of a cantilever is . On the other hand, minimizing the modal energy minus gives and hence
Comparison evaluates the fourth inverse-power sum of the cantilever spectrum without truncating the modes:
The boxed variance is for the specified single transverse direction. An independent equilibrium check follows by differentiating the Gaussian partition function with respect to : at zero load, reproducing the same result from the static compliance. Keeping only the first normal mode gives about , roughly of the exact variance. With two independent equivalent transverse directions, their summed variance is twice the boxed result. The small-slope model requires , or small compared with the usual three-dimensional persistence length .
Take and a positive prescribed distance ; if , the zero-speed journey has zero cost. Minimize subject to and the isoperimetric constraint . Introduce a constant Lagrange multiplier and the integrand . For a variation with , integration by parts gives
The interior Euler-Lagrange equation is
When terminal speed is free, the same calculation also imposes the natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint:
One cannot drop this boundary term when interpreting an extremal as a genuine minimum. If , the interior condition makes constant; with a continuous zero initial speed and it cannot be attained. In that case Cauchy-Schwarz inequality gives the infimum , approached by speeds nearly constant except in a short initial layer. For , the derivative cost controls such layers and the natural terminal condition matters in parts (b) and (c).
For a variation ,
Integration by parts gives
For fixed endpoints, . The fundamental lemma of the calculus of variations therefore gives the Euler-Lagrange equation
A solution makes the first variation vanish for every admissible variation, so it is a stationary candidate; whether it is a minimum or maximum is decided by higher variations. If endpoint values are free, is arbitrary there, and the boundary term instead vanishes under the natural conditions
Thus the same Euler-Lagrange solution is stationary for all free-endpoint variations. These are the natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint.
For
the two equations are
Set and . Then
The conditions give
and hence the most general solution is
Free conditions at are . Adding and subtracting them gives
Thus . The zero solution exists for every , while nonzero solutions exist precisely when
For those values they form the one-parameter family
where is arbitrary. This is the free-endpoint normal mode of a coupled variational functional.
Take independent smooth variations and . Differentiating the functional and using integration by parts gives its first variation
First choose variations vanishing at the endpoints. To use the stated form of the fundamental lemma of the calculus of variations, take with arbitrary smooth , and similarly for . The lemma makes vanish, and hence makes the unweighted coefficient vanish in the interior; continuity extends this to the endpoints. Applying the same argument to gives the Euler-Lagrange equations
If either endpoint value of or is free, the corresponding variation there is arbitrary. The remaining boundary term gives the natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint: for a free value and for a free value at that endpoint. With both coordinates free at both endpoints, all four conditions apply.
For the specified integrand these equations reduce to
and the natural conditions are at each free endpoint. Eliminating gives
Its four independent modes give the full general solution
At zero, and . Vanishing forces , giving
At the two derivative conditions become and . Their coefficient determinant is nonzero, so . Thus the unique stationary extremal with all four natural boundary conditions is . The word extremal here means a stationary point of the functional; the indefinite integrand does not require this point to be a minimum.
When an endpoint's horizontal coordinate is fixed but its height is free, the natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint require there. In this problem,
Every admissible extremal is an upper circular arc with centre on , by part (b). Its tangent is horizontal precisely above its centre. Thus imposing the natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint at forces . The fixed height at gives , so
Its free endpoint height is . Positivity on the whole interval follows because the radicand is at least .
There can be no solution satisfying the natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint at both ends: an upper circular arc has only one point with a horizontal tangent, whereas the two endpoints have distinct horizontal coordinates. Therefore
For positive twice differentiable functions , the Euler-Lagrange equation for this functional reduces to . Thus and integration gives . The upper circular arc is a graph wherever its radicand is positive. A fixed horizontal endpoint with free height imposes , so that endpoint must lie above the centre. Distinct horizontal endpoints cannot both satisfy this natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint. The Beltrami identity alone also admits constant functions, which are excluded by the full Euler-Lagrange equation.
Adding a total derivative to a Lagrangian changes its action only by . Under fixed-endpoint variations, this boundary term is constant, so the Euler-Lagrange equations and their minimizing paths are unchanged. Componentwise, by equality of mixed partial derivatives. Endpoint freedom would require reconsidering the resulting natural boundary conditions for a free endpoint.