Past exam of the mathematics course of the year 2 of the natural sciences course of the University of Cambridge / 2019 / Paper 2 / 7

For an ordinary conservative mechanical system, choose generalized coordinates $q_i$ measured from a static equilibrium point. Assume the kinetic energy is quadratic in velocities and there are no velocity-dependent forces. Expanding about equilibrium, the linear term in the potential energy vanishes. Retaining only terms of total degree two gives the small oscillation LagrangianAn irrelevant constant has been dropped. Coordinate dependence of $M$ contributes only terms of third or higher total degree. The matrices $M,K$ are symmetric, $M$ is positive definite for independent coordinates, and $K$ is positive semidefinite at a stable equilibrium. The Euler-Lagrange equations areA normal mode has a fixed mode shape $\mathbf{v}$ and one time factor: $\mathbf{q}=\mathbf{v}Q(t)$. Its angular frequency $\omega$ solves the generalized eigenvalue problem $K\mathbf{v}={\omega }^{2}M\mathbf{v}$, with $\ddot{Q}+{\omega }^{2}Q=0$. Thus $\omega$ is the normal angular frequency, and the frequency in cycles per unit time is $\omega /(2\pi )$. A zero mode satisfies $K\mathbf{v}=0$; its time dependence is $Q=A+Bt$, describing an unopposed displacement or uniform drift rather than a restoring oscillation.

Label the equal masses $1,2$ and the mass $2m$ by $3$, in cyclic order. Let their equilibrium angles be $0,2\pi /3,4\pi /3$, with angular displacements $q_1,q_2,q_3$. Because the hoop has unit radius, its three arc lengths areThe springs themselves are constrained to the hoop, so these are arc lengths. If their common natural length is ${\ell }_0$, Hooke's law gives $V=\frac{k}{2}{\sum }_i({\ell }_i-{\ell }_0{)}^2$. Since the arc lengths have fixed sum $2\pi$, all terms linear in the $q_i$ cancel. Dropping the constant,Thus the unspecified common natural length does not affect the motion. The mass and restoring matrices in the generalized eigenvalue problem areExchange of the two equal masses separates symmetric and antisymmetric normal modes. Direct multiplication gives the complete setThe first is rigid rotation of all three beads: every arc length stays fixed, giving a zero mode. In the second, the equal masses move oppositely while the heavy bead stays fixed; the net force on that bead cancels. In the third, the equal masses move together and the heavy bead moves oppositely with equal angular amplitude. Both nonzero normal modes have zero total angular momentum. These are the normal modes of three beads connected by springs on a circular hoop with $M=2m$.

Use the mode shapes from part (b), and put $\omega =\sqrt{2k/m}$. The initial velocity decomposes asThere is no antisymmetric component because the initial state treats the equal masses identically. Initial displacements are zero, so the zero mode contributes a linear drift and the nonzero normal mode contributes a sine:In terms of actual angular positions,The conserved angular momentum is initially $2m\Omega$ and the total moment of inertia is $4m$, so the common angular velocity must be $\Omega /2$, agreeing with the drift. The relative displacements remain of order $\Omega /\omega$, even when the common angle becomes large. Hence small $\Omega /\omega$ preserves the cyclic ordering and small spring extensions at arbitrarily late times. In the ideal arc-spring model the displayed energies are exactly quadratic in the relative angles, so this motion remains exact while that ordering persists.