Past exam of the medicine course of the University of Oxford / 1867 / Second examination / Surgery and midwifery (No. VI.)

Original volume: Examination papers for the Degree of Bachelor of Medicine by the University of Oxford (1864–1867). Original scanned volume, PDF page 99. Oxford, December 1867.

Original questions are transcribed from the public-domain edition. Credit: Wellcome Collection; original supplied by Royal College of Physicians, London. Source and public-domain rights statement.

The answers distinguish the terminology and therapeutic possibilities of 1867 from present medicine. They explain general anatomy, physiology and clinical reasoning; no individual patient or examination findings are assumed.

What are the varieties of Dislocation of the Shoulder-joint, and what are the principles of treatment.

The glenohumeral joint combines a large humeral head with a shallow glenoid cavity. Its range of movement depends on the comparatively loose joint capsule; the glenoid labrum, rotator cuff and surrounding muscles provide stability. An injury can therefore lever the humeral head out of the glenoid cavity while tearing the joint capsule and sometimes the glenoid labrum or adjacent bone.

The historical names describe where the humeral head is found relative to the scapula and clavicle:

An 1867 answer would stress early recognition, relaxation of the muscles, and controlled traction with suitable countertraction or gentle leverage to guide the humeral head through the torn joint capsule. Anaesthesia made relaxation practicable. These are principles, not a reason to reproduce old forceful manoeuvres or indiscriminate pulley traction: force can produce a fracture or damage the axillary artery and brachial plexus.

Current assessment establishes the direction and associated fracture, usually with radiography in appropriate views. Before and after joint reduction, record pulse, perfusion, distal movement and sensation, including sensation over the lateral deltoid muscle supplied by the axillary nerve. A nerve injury accompanying joint dislocation makes prompt restoration of alignment especially important.^[ref] Joint reduction is performed by trained clinicians with suitable analgesia and, when needed, sedation or anaesthesia. Repeated forceful attempts are inappropriate; irreducibility or associated complex fracture requires specialist management.^[ref]

After joint reduction, reassess the axillary nerve and circulation and confirm alignment and relevant fractures with radiography. A temporary sling relieves pain, followed by progressive physiotherapy to restore movement and rotator cuff function. The balance is between recurrent instability and stiffness: prolonged immobilisation is not a universal solution. Recurrent instability, significant structural injury and persistent weakness require further assessment.^[ref]

Distinguish between Hydrocele and Scrotal Hernia.

A hydrocele contains fluid around the testis; a scrotal hernia contains abdominal contents that have descended through the inguinal canal. Their distinction rests on a combination of location, continuity with the inguinal canal, behaviour and light transmission.

The usual acquired hydrocele is a collection between the layers of the tunica vaginalis. A scrotal hernia is generally an indirect inguinal hernia: a sac of peritoneum, often containing intestine or omentum, follows the spermatic cord into the scrotum. Persistence of the processus vaginalis can permit either a communicating hydrocele or an indirect inguinal hernia, depending on the communication and its contents. Thus the underlying developmental route is related even though the usual clinical appearances differ.^[ref]

If examination leaves doubt, ultrasonography can establish whether the swelling contains fluid, intestine or a solid tumour, assess the testis and show continuity with the inguinal canal. A collection may obscure a diseased testis; demonstrating fluid does not finish the diagnostic task. Blind puncture is not an appropriate diagnostic shortcut when a hernia remains possible. Even an established hydrocele usually reaccumulates after simple aspiration, which also risks infection.^[ref]

Classify the Tumours called ‘Malignant.’

The quotation marks around “Malignant” matter. In 1867 the clinical grouping did not have a single settled boundary in histology. Infiltration, destructive growth, return after removal, spread to distant sites and progressive constitutional illness were warning features; hardness or rapid growth alone was not a sufficient definition. A contemporary review of an 1866 textbook explicitly disputed confused descriptions of hard and soft cancer, illustrating that this was already a live diagnostic controversy.^[ref]

A useful period classification, without pretending that every contemporary author drew the same boundaries, is:

Those are overlapping historical descriptive groups, not six mutually exclusive modern diagnoses. Nor does every growth historically called “sarcoma” meet the modern definition of sarcoma.

The modern organising principle asks what cells are malignant. Carcinoma arises from epithelium; sarcoma arises in bone or soft tissue; melanoma arises from melanocytes; lymphoma and leukaemia concern blood-forming or immune cells. Other families include central nervous system and germ cell tumours. A solid lump is not essential for cancer. Within a family, histology, immunohistochemistry and appropriate molecular diagnostics refine the diagnosis. Tumour grade describes features of aggressiveness, whereas tumour stage describes extent of disease.^[ref]

This also corrects the old inference that recurrence must reflect a mysterious constitutional deposit: local residual disease and metastasis are distinct mechanisms, and an apparently circumscribed growth may already have disseminated.

What are the modes adopted for the cure of Hæmorrhoids? Describe the most frequent causes of the affection.

Normal anal cushions contain vascular channels and supporting tissue and help seal the anal canal. Haemorrhoidal disease is symptomatic enlargement, bleeding or displacement of these cushions, not simply the presence of normal veins. Internal haemorrhoids originate above the dentate line; external haemorrhoids lie below it in sensitive skin. This explains why an uncomplicated internal lesion can bleed painlessly, while an acutely thrombosed external lesion can be very painful.^[ref]

Constipation with hard stools and repeated straining increases pressure and shearing stress in the anal canal. Prolonged sitting on the toilet and frequent abnormal bowel movements can aggravate symptoms. During pregnancy, pelvic venous congestion and constipation may contribute. Historical explanations often emphasised “congestion” from sedentary habits, abdominal pressure or obstructed venous return. These contain plausible mechanical observations but do not establish every old dietary or constitutional theory. In particular, portal hypertension can produce rectal varices, which must not be equated with ordinary haemorrhoids.

An 1867 surgical answer should distinguish relief of irritation from destruction or removal of the troublesome tissue. Measures then used included regulation of the bowels, avoidance of straining, local cleansing and soothing or astringent applications, and reduction of a prolapsed internal mass where appropriate. Operative approaches included tying the base with a ligature so that the tissue sloughed, excision with control of haemorrhage, and destruction by a heated cautery or clamp-and-cautery apparatus. Historical chemical cauterisation belongs to the same destructive principle. These describe period practice; indiscriminate caustics, cutting without haemostasis and tissue strangulation below the dentate line are not a modern treatment scheme.^[ref]

In current care, increased dietary fibre, adequate fluid and better toilet habits are first-line measures; medicines may provide temporary symptom relief. Persistent internal haemorrhoids can be treated by rubber band ligation, sclerotherapy or infrared coagulation. Rubber band ligation interrupts the blood supply of a small portion above the dentate line and produces healing that fixes the displaced tissue. Advanced prolapse, substantial external disease or failure of less invasive treatment may justify haemorrhoidectomy; the operation must preserve enough intervening tissue to avoid anal stenosis.^[ref]

The usual internal severity grades describe prolapse: grade I does not prolapse; grade II returns spontaneously; grade III needs manual replacement; grade IV cannot be reduced. These grades help select treatment but do not measure every patient's burden.^[ref] Selected acutely thrombosed external haemorrhoids benefit from early excision; others settle with conservative treatment. A blanket promise of a permanent “cure” is inappropriate because recurrent provoking conditions and recurrent symptoms remain possible.^[ref]

Finally, rectal bleeding must be investigated on its own merits. Examination, including inspection and suitable assessment of the anal canal, determines whether haemorrhoids explain the symptoms; other causes include colorectal cancer and inflammatory bowel disease. Persistent bleeding must not simply be labelled “piles”.^[ref]

What is Astigmatism? how is it detected? and how remedied ?

For regular astigmatism, the two principal meridians of the eye are perpendicular and have different optical powers, commonly because the cornea has unequal curvatures. The crystalline lens can also contribute. A point object consequently does not form one sharp point image: the idealised paraxial optics gives two focal lines at different distances, perpendicular to one another, with an intervening region of blur. An ordinary spherical lens changes the focus in both meridians together and cannot by itself remove their difference. Irregular astigmatism, for example with a scarred cornea, lacks this simple pair of uniform principal powers.^[ref]

Several complementary observations reveal it:

The prescription must specify both the difference in optical power and its orientation. If the required correcting powers in the two principal directions are $R_1$ and $R_2$, choose the cylinder axis along direction 1. In the ideal thin lens model:Here $S$ is the spherical correcting power, $C$ the cylindrical correcting power and $\alpha$ the cylinder axis, all powers measured in dioptres. A cylindrical lens contributes no extra power along its axis and its full power perpendicular to that axis. For example, required corrections of $-1$ and $-3$ dioptres are supplied by a sphere of $-1$ dioptre and a cylinder of $-2$ dioptres, with its axis in the direction requiring the smaller negative correction. These are correcting powers, not the uncorrected eye's intrinsic powers; confusing the two reverses the intended correction.

Spectacles with this sphere-and-cylinder combination are the central historical remedy. Present options also include toric contact lenses, appropriate rigid contact lenses for some irregular cases, and selected refractive surgery. The suitability of these depends on the cause and condition of the cornea; a spectacle cylinder cannot generally cancel all irregularities of an irregular cornea.^[ref]

What are the causes of Phlegmasia dolens, and how would you treat it ?

Obstruction of major pelvic or thigh veins raises pressure in the channels draining the limb; fluid then accumulates in the tissues as oedema. Severe outflow obstruction can also impede lymphatic drainage. The pale, tense appearance accounts for “alba”. It differs from phlegmasia cerulea dolens, in which more complete obstruction, including collateral channels, produces a congested blue limb and can threaten arterial perfusion. A historical case description cannot automatically be assigned one modern diagnosis solely from its name.

The central causal mechanisms are slowed venous flow, injury to the vessel wall and increased tendency of the blood to clot. Pregnancy promotes hypercoagulability and pelvic venous compression; childbirth can add tissue injury, immobility and infection. Prior venous thrombosis, thrombophilia, prolonged immobility, operative delivery and severe systemic illness further increase risk. It is not confined to the puerperium or even to women. The serious consequences are extension of the thrombus, detachment into the pulmonary arteries as a pulmonary embolism, and chronic obstruction or valvular damage producing post-thrombotic syndrome.^[ref]

An historically informed explanation should recognise that nineteenth-century arguments concerned the relative importance of venous obstruction, phlebitis, lymphatic disease and puerperal illness. Rest, support and elevation of the limb, pain relief and local soothing applications belonged to the period's conservative repertoire. These could ease symptoms but did not provide effective anticoagulation. Neither the “milk leg” name nor the observation of puerperal infection establishes that every case is caused by milk displacement or by infected clot. The thrombotic and infective questions must be distinguished.

Current management begins with clinical assessment and compression ultrasonography. A normally patent vein collapses under appropriate transducer pressure; a thrombosed segment often fails to compress. Doppler ultrasonography adds information about flow, and suspected pelvic disease may require further imaging. A negative initial study does not close a strongly suspicious case; repeat or additional imaging may be needed. Fever and systemic illness prompt assessment for infection, while breathlessness, chest pain or collapse require urgent assessment for pulmonary embolism.^[ref]

Unless contraindicated, therapeutic low-molecular-weight heparin is the usual treatment during pregnancy. It limits further clot formation while the body's own processes deal with the existing thrombus; it is not an instant mechanical solvent. Management also provides analgesia, elevation and appropriate mobilisation once stable, with fitted compression for symptoms when suitable. Prolonged compulsory bed rest is not a general modern remedy. A threatened limb or suspected massive pulmonary embolism needs immediate specialist escalation; routine thrombolysis for every swollen leg would expose patients to unjustified haemorrhage.

For confirmed pregnancy-associated venous thromboembolism, treatment usually continues through the rest of pregnancy and for at least six weeks after birth, with at least three months' treatment in total; the delivery plan must account for bleeding and anaesthesia. Antibiotics address a demonstrated or strongly suspected infective complication, not uncomplicated venous thrombosis itself.^[ref]

There is occasional Hæmorrhage from the Vagina during the last half of Pregnancy. Upon what causes may this depend? State the treatment to be adopted during the later months, and at or near the full term.

The source's “last half” includes a wider interval than the definition of antepartum haemorrhage from 24 weeks used by the cited British guideline. No diagnosis follows from intermittency alone.

In placenta praevia, the placenta covers the internal opening of the cervix. Development of the lower uterine segment and opening of the cervix disturb attachment at the placental margin, exposing maternal vessels. Bleeding is often painless and recurrent and can become severe after apparently minor episodes. In placental abruption, a normally situated placenta separates prematurely. Bleeding into the placental bed reduces exchange with the fetus; pain, tenderness and increased tone of the uterus are suggestive, but their absence does not exclude it. Some blood can remain concealed, making visible vaginal loss a poor measure of total loss.

In vasa praevia, vulnerable fetal vessels run through the membranes near the internal cervical opening. Rupture, particularly when the membranes break, can cause rapid fetal blood loss while the mother remains comparatively stable. Other causes include a blood-stained cervical “show” in labour, cervical ectropion, a cervical polyp, local infection, trauma, and occasionally a tumour of the cervix or vagina. These must be distinguished from placental bleeding rather than presumed harmless from a small volume alone.^[ref]

For an 1867 answer, the classic contrast is between “unavoidable” haemorrhage from placenta praevia and “accidental” haemorrhage from premature separation of a normally implanted placenta. The adjectives are historical classifications, not claims that either outcome is inevitable or that every placental abruption follows an accident. Period management sought to conserve maternal strength when slight bleeding settled, then accomplish delivery when recurrent loss or labour made waiting dangerous. For partial placenta praevia, rupture of membranes was used in suitable labour to bring the presenting part down against the bleeding region. For more extensive placenta praevia, vaginal plugging, dilation and turning to deliver the child were debated and used. Contemporary discussion shows disagreement about how long it was safe to temporise: an 1864 report describes both advocates of early delivery and arguments about plugs, dilating bags and turning.^[ref]

Those measures belong to the history of managing haemorrhage before modern operative safety, imaging and transfusion services. They must not be carried over as a modern algorithm: a vaginal plug can conceal continuing loss; attempted separation of the placenta or turning through placenta praevia can aggravate bleeding and endanger the fetus.

In current practice, the initial response to significant bleeding is hospital assessment with maternal resuscitation, monitoring, intravenous access and blood tests, with blood products available according to severity. Determine placental position by ultrasonography, assess the fetus according to gestational age, and look for local causes with appropriate examination. Do not perform a digital vaginal examination while placenta praevia remains a possible explanation until it has been excluded by ultrasonography. A carefully performed speculum examination and a skilled transvaginal ultrasound are different procedures; the latter is a safe, useful way to locate the placental edge. A normal ultrasound does not exclude placental abruption.^[ref]

During the later preterm months, a stable mother and fetus after bleeding has stopped may be managed expectantly under specialist supervision. The plan includes surveillance, correction of anaemia, readiness to return urgently, and individual decisions about admission and timing of birth. Corticosteroids are considered when preterm delivery is likely; they do not treat the bleeding. Ongoing major haemorrhage, maternal instability or serious fetal compromise can require delivery regardless of immaturity. This is not a policy of waiting for full term at any cost.

At or near term, the cause determines the route. Persistent placenta praevia covering the internal cervical opening requires caesarean birth; repeated bleeding may require earlier delivery. Current 2026 guidance individualises timing for uncomplicated low-lying placenta or placenta praevia and advises considering planned birth no later than 37 weeks and 6 days. A low-lying placental edge that does not cover the opening requires individual assessment of whether vaginal birth is appropriate. These timings are present guidance, not an 1867 rule.^[ref]

With placental abruption, expedite delivery when indicated by maternal or fetal condition; caesarean birth is often required for a live compromised fetus when vaginal delivery is not imminent, while vaginal delivery may be appropriate in other circumstances. A local cervical lesion requires cause-specific management. Suspected rupture of vasa praevia is an emergency for urgent caesarean birth and neonatal resuscitation; an antenatally detected vasa praevia calls for planned birth before labour or membrane rupture.^[ref] The central distinction is therefore safe observation of a settled, stable preterm episode versus timely delivery for an ongoing hazard, not a single remedy for every late-pregnancy bleed.

What are the causes, consequences, and treatment of retained Placenta ?

After the fetus is born, contraction and retraction of the myometrium reduce the area of the placental bed. The placenta cannot shrink with it and normally separates through the maternal decidua. Continued contraction compresses the maternal vessels crossing the myometrium, providing an important mechanism of haemostasis. A fragment left attached can both expose bleeding vessels and interfere with effective contraction.

Three mechanisms organise the causes:

Consequences include immediate or delayed postpartum haemorrhage, hypovolaemic shock, anaemia, endometritis and sepsis. Retained fragments may delay normal shrinking of the uterus. Forceful pulling on the umbilical cord adds the risks of cord rupture and uterine inversion. Conversely, indiscriminate delay while bleeding continues can be fatal.

An 1867 answer would assess bleeding, the size and contraction of the uterus, whether separation had occurred and whether the outlet was obstructed. Emptying the urinary bladder, encouraging effective contraction and supporting the uterus were rational preliminary principles. If the placenta remained attached or trapped and the circumstances demanded intervention, manual removal with external support of the uterus was the principal operative resource. The historical difficulty was to distinguish a removable attachment from a dangerously adherent one. A September 1867 report describes an apparent “hour-glass” retention actually relieved by loosening a tight abdominal binder; it is useful evidence for examining the mechanism rather than trusting the diagnostic label.^[ref] The case is an observation, not proof that all retention has an external cause.

Current care monitors blood loss and maternal condition, secures intravenous access and obtains skilled obstetric help. With active third-stage management, failure to complete the third stage of labour by 30 minutes is prolonged; with physiological management, the cited NICE threshold is 60 minutes. These thresholds do not justify waiting through active haemorrhage or instability. A trained clinician may use controlled cord traction with uterine counterpressure under appropriate conditions; unopposed pulling is not the same technique.^[ref]

When removal is required, examination and manual removal take place with appropriate anaesthesia, aseptic technique, external support and readiness to manage haemorrhage. The placenta and membranes are checked for completeness; persistent bleeding prompts assessment for retained fragments, uterine atony, trauma and disordered clotting. Antibiotic prophylaxis accompanies manual removal. Give uterotonics for associated postpartum haemorrhage and to maintain contraction after removal, rather than repeatedly giving them as a substitute for removing a retained organ in a non-bleeding patient. WHO's 2025 recommendations advise preparing for manual removal after 30 minutes if the placenta remains undelivered and distinguish this decision from treatment of established postpartum haemorrhage.^[ref]

If no safe separation plane exists and placenta accreta spectrum is suspected, repeated forceful attempts to peel off the placenta can precipitate catastrophic haemorrhage. Escalate to an experienced multidisciplinary team and a haemorrhage plan. Definitive surgery, including hysterectomy, may be necessary; selected conservative management leaving the placenta in place requires specialist selection and follow-up. Current guidance explicitly advises avoiding attempted separation in women with a high probability of placenta accreta spectrum.^[ref] Thus the word “retained” identifies an urgent clinical problem, but the cause determines whether ordinary manual separation is safe.