Past exam of the particle Astrophysics course of the University of Cambridge / 2015 / Paper 1 / 1 / Solution

Cosmological variables and conventions. The scale factor $R(t)$ describes the relative separation of comoving observers; dots denote derivatives with respect to cosmic time $t$. The Hubble parameter is $H(t)=\dot{R}/R$, usually time dependent; “Hubble constant” conventionally means its present value. Here $\rho$ is mass-equivalent density, so $ϵ=\rho c^2$ is energy density, while $P$ is isotropic pressure. $G$ is the gravitational constant and $c$ the speed of light. The constant $K$ specifies cosmological spatial curvature: with $R$ a length, $K=k{c}^2$ and $k=+1,0,-1$ describe closed, flat and open spatial geometries. Alternative normalizations of $R$ move a constant factor into $K$. In the printed equations $\Lambda$ has units ${\mathrm{s}}^{-2}$: it is $c^2$ times a cosmological constant defined in inverse square metres. This time-unit convention for the cosmological constant prevents a missing factor of $c^2$.

Continuity and the first law. Differentiating the first Friedmann equation with constant $K$ and $\Lambda$, and then eliminating $\ddot{R}/R$ with the second, givesThus, on an expanding or contracting branch,The relation extends continuously to a regular turning point. For a physical volume $V(t)=V_{\ast }{R}^3(t)$ bounded by fixed comoving coordinates, $\dot{V}=3HV$. Multiplication by $c^{2}V$ givesThis adiabatic work in a comoving volume is the first law of thermodynamics for adiabatic evolution with fixed entropy and no additional chemical work. It expresses local energy conservation, including pressure work. It does not assert that $U$ is constant: radiation loses internal energy as it does work; negative pressure makes $U$ grow during expansion. A generic expanding spacetime has no global time-translation symmetry from which a conserved total energy follows.

Constant scalar-field energy density. Setting $\dot{\rho }=0$ in the continuity equation, with $H\ne 0$, givesFor a homogeneous canonical scalar field, in units $c=1$, $ϵ={\dot{\varphi }}^2/2+V(\varphi )$ and $P={\dot{\varphi }}^2/2-V(\varphi )$. A stationary potential-dominated field has precisely this equation of state. A general evolving scalar field need not have $w=-1$; the constant-density assumption is essential.

Expansion at the stipulated Higgs energy density. With zero explicit $\Lambda$ and zero $K$, constant ${ϵ}_H$ givesThe plus sign selects the expanding branch; there is also a contracting solution. The scalar-field energy is already included in $\rho$, so adding it again as an explicit cosmological constant would double count it. Using $1\mathrm{GeV}=1.602176634\times 10^{-10}\mathrm{J}$ gives ${ϵ}_H=2.4033\times 10^{45}\mathrm{J}{\mathrm{m}}^{-3}$, ${\rho }_H=2.6740\times 10^{28}\mathrm{kg}{\mathrm{m}}^{-3}$ and $H_H\simeq 3.87\times 10^9{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$. ThereforeThis vacuum-dominated doubling time describes accelerated expansion in de Sitter spacetime, with $\ddot{R}/R=H_H^2>0$. The stipulated energy density exceeds the critical density in energy units used in Question 2 by $3\times 10^{54}$, so it cannot persist as the dominant component of the present universe. The calculation exhibits the cosmological constant problem: the absolute gravitational vacuum energy must be enormously smaller than such a particle-physics scale today. It does not establish that the Standard Model Higgs field actually remains constant or supplies a viable inflationary epoch.

The acoustic ruler and accelerated expansion. Before baryon drag becomes ineffective, pressure in the photon-baryon fluid drives acoustic waves around initial linear cosmological density perturbations. Their comoving sound horizon at the baryon drag epoch isAfter decoupling, this preferred separation survives in galaxy clustering as baryon acoustic oscillations: a peak in the two-point correlation function and oscillations in the matter power spectrum. Its value is calibrated by early-universe physics, commonly constrained by the cosmic microwave background. The SDSS luminous-red-galaxy measurement established a peak near $100h^{-1}\mathrm{Mpc}$; its use as a distance indicator depends on the ruler calibration rather than the length of an individual galaxy.^[ref]

For a ruler perpendicular to the line of sight and one parallel to it,where $D_M=(1+z)D_A$ is the transverse comoving distance and $D_A$ the angular diameter distance. These measure $D_M/r_d$ and $H{r}_d$, respectively. Comparing multiple redshifts tests the distance–redshift relation and expansion history. In particular,so sufficiently precise measurements of the shape of $H(z)$ can test $q<0$. In general relativity, accelerated expansion requires a sufficiently negative total $\rho +3P/c^2$; a positive cosmological constant supplies it.

A single acoustic angular scale does not independently determine acceleration, cosmological spatial curvature, the absolute sound horizon and the dark-energy equation of state. One combines redshift coverage with early-universe calibration and independent matter-density or distance information, comparing accelerating and nonaccelerating models. The galaxy selection function and redshift completeness must be modeled with random catalogues, survey covariance estimated with mock catalogues, and redshift-space distortions, galaxy bias and nonlinear broadening controlled. These tests distinguish a cosmological feature from a survey artifact. The evidence is the measured expansion history within an explicit cosmological framework, rather than the existence of an acoustic peak alone.