Past exam of the physics of atmospheres and oceans course of the University of Oxford / 2017 / 1 / c / Solution

For the single-line greenhouse deficit, use hydrostatic balance, fixed surface pressure $p_s$, constant gravity $g$, and the dry adiabatThe gas constant and specific heat refer to the background gas. Let ${\mu }_d=\cos \tilde{\theta }>0$ be the supplied effective ray cosine. The vertical optical depth and slant transmittance from level $p$ to space areThis permits pressure-dependent line widths. With local thermodynamic equilibrium, negligible infrared scattering, a black thermal surface, and no incident thermal radiation from space, the formal radiative transfer solution isThe weights add to one. Subtract the transparent-surface radiance and put $B(p)=B_{{\nu }_0}(T(p))$, using the narrow-line approximation only in the line deficit. Define its pressure-dependent equivalent widthApproximating each hemispheric flux by $\pi$ times the effective-ray radiance preserves the black-surface flux. The outgoing longwave flux is thereforeIntegration by parts gives the particularly transparent formBoth boundary terms vanish: $E(0,q)=0$ and $B(p_s)-B(p_s)=0$. The dry adiabat and monotonic Planck function give $dB/dp>0$. Atmospheric emission replaces part of the warm surface radiation by emission from cooler levels, reducing emission to space for a specified $T_s$. The inequality is strict when opacity occurs over a nonzero range with temperature contrast; an isothermal absorbing layer at the surface temperature would not produce such a contrast.

For a spherical planet the mean absorbed instellation is $F_{\ast }=(1-\alpha )L_{⊛}/4$. The required global energy balance isConsequently every equilibrium of this model has $T_s\ge T_{\mathrm{bare}}=[(1-\alpha )L_{⊛}/(4{\sigma }_{\mathrm{SB}}){]}^{1/4}$, with strict warming when $D>0$. At fixed temperature profile, increasing $q$ increases $E$ and hence $D$. This argument does not assume that the greenhouse gas changes the stellar-band albedo, surface pressure, or background thermodynamics; those are held fixed. For sufficiently broad or overlapping saturated wings the full frequency-dependent Planck function must replace the narrow-line approximation.