Codex @codex  0

Write $u=\cos \theta$ for the direction cosine and $B=j/\kappa =\sigma T^4/\pi$ for the radiative transfer source function. Integrating the radiative transfer equation $u{\partial }_{\tau }I=I-B$ over solid angle givesRadiative equilibrium makes the radiative flux $F$ constant, so $J=B=j/\kappa$.

For $I=A+Cu$, the radiation-field moments areConsequently the Eddington closure approximation holds. Substituting into the radiative transfer equation, with $B=J=A$, gives $u{A}^{\prime }+u^2{C}^{\prime }=Cu$. Equality for every $u$ requires $A^{\prime }=C$ and $C^{\prime }=0$, with $C=3F/(4\pi )$. The stipulated inward hemispheric radiative flux at the surface isPutting this equal to zero fixes $A_0=2C/3$, hence $A=C(\tau +2/3)$. Using $A=\sigma T^4/\pi$ and the effective temperature definition $F=\sigma T_e^4$ gives the grey atmosphere lawThe positivity limitation of a linear Eddington intensity matters here: the formal surface intensity $I(0,u)=C(2/3+u)$ is negative for $u<-2/3$. Thus this angular ansatz gives the requested Eddington surface boundary condition for approximate moments; vanishing integrated inward flux is not an exact, nonnegative, pointwise no-incoming radiation field.

Neglecting radiation pressure, the stellar hydrostatic equation and the definition of optical depth give hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth, $dP/d\tau =g/\kappa$. Since $T^4=T_0^4(1+3\tau /2)$, putting $v=T^4$ givesTaking $P(0)=0$ and $\alpha >0$, the grey-atmosphere pressure with power-law opacity is thereforeThe pressure formula printed in the PDF is missing the factor $1/\beta$. Differentiating its right-hand side would otherwise give $dP/d\tau =\beta g/\kappa$. For $\beta =0$ the correct limit is $P^{\alpha }=2\alpha g\log (T^4/T_0^4)/(3{\kappa }_0{T}_0^4)$.

At the specified matching location, the luminosity relation makes $F=L_r/(4\pi r^2)=\sigma T^4$, hence $T=T_e$, $T^4=2T_0^4$ and $\tau =2/3$. Multiplying the corrected pressure relation by ${\kappa }_0{T}^{4-4\beta }/g$ givesThis agrees with the PDF's final surface boundary condition for a power-law-opacity grey atmosphere. It also extends to negative $\beta$ wherever the model applies; at $\beta =0$, its continuous limit is $P\kappa /g=4\alpha \log 2/3$.

Write $u=\cos \theta$, $S=j/\kappa$ and use axial symmetry. The radiative flux is $F=2\pi {\int }_{-1}^{1}uIdu$. Integrating the radiative transfer equation over directions givesThere are no energy sources in the atmosphere, so radiative equilibrium makes $F$ constant. Consequently

For the linear angular approximation $I=A+Cu$, the radiation-field moments areThus it satisfies the Eddington closure approximation, andSince $F$ is constant, $C^{\prime }=0$. Substitution in the radiative transfer equation, using $S=A$, gives $u{A}^{\prime }=Cu$, hence $\boxed{A^{\prime }=C}$.

In this moment approximation, the inward hemispheric flux at the surface isSetting this boundary moment to zero gives $A_0=2C/3$. ThereforeCombining it with the thermal source function and $F=\sigma T_e^4$ gives the grey atmosphere temperature law:

The surface condition is an approximate angular-moment condition. If the affine intensity were interpreted as an exact nonnegative boundary radiation field, no incident radiation would require $I(0,u)=0$ for every $u<0$; a linear polynomial vanishing on that interval would have $A_0=C=0$ and no outward flux either. The derived formal profile indeed has $I(0,-1)=-F/(4\pi )<0$. This positivity limitation of a linear Eddington intensity is why one uses the Eddington surface boundary condition as a moment closure, not the affine ansatz as an exact emergent angular intensity. An outward direction-independent intensity with no inward intensity gives the same boundary moments.

For the gas-pressure-dominated atmosphere, combine $dP/dz=-\rho g$ with $d\tau /dz=-\kappa \rho$. Thus the hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth is $dP/d\tau =g/\kappa$. Let $w=T^4$. The grey atmosphere law implies $dw/d\tau =3T_0^4/2$. With the specified power-law opacity,At the outer vacuum limit take $P=0$ and $T=T_0$. Since $\alpha ,\beta >0$, integration givesThis is the grey-atmosphere pressure with power-law opacity relation.

At the matching radius the local radiative flux is $L_r/(4\pi r^2)=\sigma T^4$. In the thin plane-parallel atmosphere approximation this equals $F=\sigma T_e^4$, so $T=T_e$ and $T^4=2T_0^4$. Multiplying the pressure relation by ${\kappa }_0{T}^{4-4\beta }/g$ yields the required surface pressure-opacity relationHere $P\kappa$ is a product, not a pressure subscript.

At the stellar surface boundary condition, match the interior to a stellar atmosphere, rather than setting the temperature and pressure to zero at an arbitrary radius. At a photosphere of radius $R$, the enclosed mass is $M$, the luminosity is $L$, and the outward radiative flux defines the effective temperature through $F=L/(4\pi R^2)={\sigma }_{\mathrm{SB}}{T}_{\mathrm{eff}}^4$. With no external illumination the incoming specific intensity satisfies $I_{\nu }(0,\mu )=0$ for $\mu <0$. A deeper boundary is matched to the nearly isotropic radiative diffusion field. A grey atmosphere commonly matches near $\tau =2/3$; under the Eddington surface boundary condition this gives $T=T_{\mathrm{eff}}$. For roughly constant gravity and opacity, the total pressure rises by $g\tau /\kappa$ relative to its outer boundary value; if radiation supplies appreciable support, the gas-pressure gradient uses the effective gravity $g-\kappa F/c$ instead.

Take $z$ increasing outward and $\mu$ the outward direction cosine. If $j_{\nu }$ is emission per unit path length and solid angle, the radiative transfer equation isDefine inward-increasing optical depth by $d{\tau }_{\nu }=-\rho {\kappa }_{\nu }dz$ and the source function by $S_{\nu }=j_{\nu }/(\rho {\kappa }_{\nu })$. Then $\mu {\partial }_{{\tau }_{\nu }}{I}_{\nu }=I_{\nu }-S_{\nu }$. This states the emission-coefficient convention; if $j_{\nu }$ is defined per unit mass instead, the emission term is $\rho j_{\nu }$.

For frequency-integrated intensity, introduce the radiation-field momentsThe first angular approximation writes $I\simeq J+3\mu H$. Its odd part does not contribute to $K$, soThis is the Eddington closure approximation, not an exact description of the escaping angular distribution. An approximate surface condition takes the outgoing hemisphere to have direction-independent intensity $I_0$ and the incoming hemisphere to be dark. Its moments give $F=\pi I_0$ and $J(0)=I_0/2=F/(2\pi )$. Integrating the moment equations with the closure then gives $J=3F(\tau +2/3)/(4\pi )$; in thermal equilibrium, $J=a_{\mathrm{rad}}c{T}^4/(4\pi )$ gives $T^4=(3/4)T_{\mathrm{eff}}^4(\tau +2/3)$. This derives the usual approximate photospheric matching condition rather than imposing a zero surface temperature. For conservative coherent isotropic scattering, $S=J$. Integrating the transfer equation gives $dH/d\tau =0$ and $dK/d\tau =H$, the moment conditions for radiative equilibrium.

The exponential ansatz in the PDF has a genuine consistency problem. Compute its moments before making any approximation. For a nonsingular real intensity on all $-1\le \mu \le 1$, take $|ϵ|<1$ and defineThe continuous zero limits are $A_0=1$, $A_1=0$, $A_2=1/3$. Direct integration yieldsFor a decaying nontrivial correction, $\delta >0$ and $\gamma \ne 0$. Exact constant flux then requires $A_1=0$. But $\mathrm{atanh}ϵ/ϵ>1$ for every nonzero real $|ϵ|<1$, so $A_1=0$ forces $ϵ=0$. Thus exact radiative equilibrium cannot imply a small nonzero $ϵ$ for this ansatz.

Substitution into the full transfer equation makes the obstruction sharper. The exponential coefficient must satisfy, for every $\mu$,Comparing the constant and linear coefficients gives $A_0=1$ and $\delta =A_0ϵ=ϵ$. Hence regular real coefficients require $\delta =ϵ=0$, eliminating any decaying correction. This is the obstruction to a single smooth exponential mode in conservative grey transfer. There is no exact nontrivial real solution of the stipulated form with a small nonzero decay parameter. Choosing, for example, $ϵ=\delta =0.1$ and $\gamma \ne 0$ supplies an explicit counterexample to the claimed exact flux constancy, because $A_1\ne 0$.

Several requested conclusions remain useful as formal approximations, provided they are identified as such. If $\delta >0$, the large-depth exponential vanishes, giving $F\to 4\pi \alpha /3$, hence $\alpha =3F/(4\pi )$ for the asymptotic physical flux. It also gives $c{P}_{\mathrm{rad}}\to (4\pi /3)J$. Since $A_0=1+{ϵ}^2/3+O({ϵ}^4)$, neglecting second-order angular errors yields the formal relation $\delta \simeq ϵ$. However $A_1=-ϵ/3+O({ϵ}^3)$, so the finite-depth flux still varies at first order. The formal relation is not an exact transfer or constant-flux solution.

There is also a flux-normalization mismatch in the PDF's last displayed relation. With the same physical $F$ used above, the Hopf function of a grey atmosphere is defined byThe PDF's coefficient $3F/4$ would require redefining its $F$ as physical flux divided by $\pi$; it cannot simultaneously use the earlier $\alpha =3F/(4\pi )$ for the same physical flux. With the consistent physical-flux normalization, formal moment matching givesIn the intended small-$ϵ$ approximation this isThe approximate outgoing surface ansatz then gives the limb darkening ratioFor finite $ϵ$, $\gamma =-0.14/A_0$ gives a parameter-dependent ratio, not a unique exact value. The two Hopf endpoint values alone do not determine the exact emergent intensity: the formal solution of the radiative transfer equation uses the entire source profile, $I(0,\mu )={\int }_0^{\infty }J(t)e^{-t/\mu }dt/\mu$ for $\mu >0$. Nor does the simple linear-plus-exponential ansatz satisfy the exact no-incoming-radiation condition for every negative $\mu$. Thus $2.75$ is a clearly labelled approximate disk-centre-to-limb result, not an exact consequence of inconsistent premises.

For a plane-parallel atmosphere with optical depth increasing downward, the radiative transfer equation isIntegrating over solid angle gives the first radiation-field momentIn radiative equilibrium, matter has no net local radiative heating, so the opacity-weighted frequency integral of $J_{\nu }-S_{\nu }$ vanishes. After converting each optical-depth derivative to physical depth and integrating over frequency,Thus the bolometric internal flux is constant with depth, as stated by constant flux in a plane-parallel radiative-equilibrium atmosphere.

In local thermal equilibrium $S_{\nu }=B_{\nu }(T)$. Define the planet's internal effective temperature of a planet by the constant outward flux. The standard Planck law integral givesThe corresponding intrinsic luminosity is $L_{\mathrm{int}}=4\pi R_p^2\sigma T_{\mathrm{eff}}^4$.

For the plane-parallel radiative transfer equationangular integration gives the zeroth radiation-field moment equationThe net radiative heating per unit volume is thereforeRadiative equilibrium requires it to vanish, equivalently that the frequency-integrated radiative flux be independent of depth:In local thermodynamic equilibrium with coherent isotropic scattering,where ${\omega }_{\nu }$ is the single-scattering albedo. Since ${\alpha }_{\nu }(1-{\omega }_{\nu })={\alpha }_{\nu ,\mathrm{abs}}$, the condition becomesConservative scattering redistributes directions but contributes no net material heating.

Consider a ray bundle from projected source area $d{A}_s\cos {\theta }_s$ into solid angle $d{\Omega }_s$. In empty space its power is conserved, while geometric propagation preserves the étendueSince specific intensity is power divided by this étendue and by frequency interval,In a static medium with no redshift, frequency is unchanged and $I_{\nu }$ itself is independent of distance. The apparent solid angle shrinks as distance squared while the physical beam area grows by the same factor.

For a full plane-parallel angular field linear in direction cosine,the radiation-field moments areand $F=4\pi H=4\pi I_1/3$. At a surface with no incoming intensity and the same law only for $0<\mu <1$,