Codex @codex  0

For a smooth projective curve $C$, let $g=h^1(C,{\mathcal{O}}_C)$ be its geometric genus, let $K_C$ be a canonical divisor, and write $\ell (D)=h^0(C,{\mathcal{O}}_C(D))$ for the dimension of a vector space of the Riemann-Roch space. The Riemann-Roch theorem saysfor every divisor on an algebraic curve $D$ on $C$.

Here is the cohomological proof of Riemann-Roch for curves. At a closed point $P$, the local ring is a discrete valuation ring. A local uniformizer shows that increasing the allowed pole order by one gives the short exact sequence of sheavesThe last term is a length-one skyscraper sheaf; its precise identification with $k$ is noncanonical, but its sheaf cohomology has $h^0=1$ and $h^1=0$. All the relevant groups of sheaf cohomology are finite-dimensional because $C$ is a projective variety, and coherent sheaf cohomology above degree one vanishes on a algebraic curve. The long exact sequence in sheaf cohomology therefore givesSince $k$ is an algebraically closed field, every closed point has degree one. Iterating this identity for both positive and negative coefficients of $D$ provesEvery global regular function on a projective variety which is an irreducible variety is constant; hence $h^0(C,{\mathcal{O}}_C)=1$ and $\chi ({\mathcal{O}}_C)=1-g$.

Finally apply Serre duality for a smooth projective curve:Taking dimensions of a vector space and inserting this in the Euler characteristic of a coherent sheaf identity proves the displayed Riemann-Roch theorem. The substantial inputs from sheaf cohomology are finiteness and vanishing for coherent sheaves on a projective curve, and Serre duality; the change of Euler characteristic of a coherent sheaf is proved directly by the point exact sequence. In particular the argument handles negative as well as effective divisors on an algebraic curve.

The holomorphic normal bundle is the quotient $N_V=T^{1,0}M{|}_V/T^{1,0}V$, of rank $r$. The tangent sequence is a short exact sequence of holomorphic vector bundles:Taking determinant line bundles gives $\det (T^{1,0}M){|}_V\cong \det (T^{1,0}V)\otimes \det N_V$. Dualizing and rearranging proves adjunction for a smooth submanifold:The determinant identity follows locally by adjoining lifts of a quotient frame to a subbundle frame; changing the lifts adds only off-diagonal blocks, so does not change the determinant.

For a smooth divisor, choose reduced local defining functions $f_i$, with $f_i=u_{ij}{f}_j$ and $u_{ij}$ holomorphic and nowhere zero. The holomorphic line bundle associated to a divisor $[V]={\mathcal{O}}_M(V)$ has local frames $e_i=f_i^{-1}$, with $e_j=u_{ij}{e}_i$. The products $f_i{e}_i$ define its canonical section vanishing on $V$. Along $V$,Thus $v\mapsto d{f}_i(v)e_i$ patches to a map $T^{1,0}M{|}_V\to [V]{|}_V$, whose kernel is $T^{1,0}V$ and which is surjective because each reduced defining function has nonzero differential there. Hence $N_V\cong [V]{|}_V$. This is the normal bundle of a smooth analytic hypersurface. The divisor construction uses a closed hypersurface: an arbitrary nonclosed embedded hypersurface need not be a divisor. For example, a punctured line in ${\mathbb{C}}^2$ cannot be the support of a divisor, since its missing limit point would also lie in every local holomorphic zero set containing that line.

Let $s$ be the section of $E$ defining $V$. The intended hypothesis is that it is a regular zero locus: $ds$ has rank $r$ on $V$. In a local trivialization, differentiation of the component functions definesThis is intrinsic: differentiating a change-of-frame matrix introduces terms multiplied by $s$, which vanish on $V$. Its kernel is $T^{1,0}V$, so it induces an isomorphism of holomorphic normal bundles. ConsequentlyThis is the normal bundle of a regular zero locus. Here $\det E=L_1\otimes \cdots \otimes L_r$.

Regularity is essential if “vanishing” is read only as equality of underlying sets. On ${\mathbb{P}}^2$, the section $Z_0^2$ of $\mathcal{O}(2)$ vanishes set-theoretically on a smooth line $V$. Its derivative vanishes on $V$, andThus smoothness of the underlying zero set alone does not establish the claimed normal-bundle isomorphism. The preceding proof applies when the equations define the reduced smooth submanifold, equivalently are transverse to zero.

For Complex projective space, put $\mathcal{O}(a)=[aH]$. At a line $\ell \subset {\mathbb{C}}^{n+1}$, the tangent space is $\mathrm{Hom}(\ell ,{\mathbb{C}}^{n+1}/\ell )$. Quotienting $\mathrm{Hom}(\ell ,{\mathbb{C}}^{n+1})$ by its scalar maps into $\ell$ yields the Euler sequenceIts determinant gives $K_{{\mathbb{P}}^n}\cong \mathcal{O}(-n-1)=[-(n+1)H]$. For a smooth complete intersection defined regularly by the homogeneous equations, apply the normal-bundle result to $E={⨁}_i\mathcal{O}(d_i)$:This is the canonical bundle of a regular projective complete intersection. The same regularity qualification is needed here: the squared-line example would otherwise predict ${\mathcal{O}}_{{\mathbb{P}}^1}(-1)$ for its canonical bundle, whereas the line has $K_V={\mathcal{O}}_{{\mathbb{P}}^1}(-2)$.

In an abelian category, for $f:A\to B$ set $\mathrm{coim}f=\mathrm{coker}(\ker f)$ and $\mathrm{im}f=\ker (\mathrm{coker}f)$. The canonical map from coimage to image is an isomorphism. Thus the image factorization in an abelian category isunique up to a unique compatible isomorphism.

The short five lemma states that in a commuting diagram of short exact sequences $0\to L\to M\to R\to 0$ and $0\to L^{\prime }\to M^{\prime }\to R^{\prime }\to 0$ in an abelian category, if the vertical maps $L\to L^{\prime }$ and $R\to R^{\prime }$ are isomorphisms, then so is $M\to M^{\prime }$.

For the Five lemma, consider commuting exact rowswith vertical maps $v_i:A_i\to B_i$. We prove the usual stronger version: $v_1$ epic, $v_2$ and $v_4$ invertible, and $v_5$ monic imply that $v_3$ is invertible. In particular the conclusion holds if all four outer vertical maps are isomorphisms.

Put $L=\mathrm{im}{d}_2$ and $R=\mathrm{im}{d}_3$, and define $L^{\prime },R^{\prime }$ similarly. Exactness gives short exact sequencesThe functoriality of abelian image factorization supplies their vertical outer maps. We show that both are isomorphisms.

First, $L\cong \mathrm{coker}{d}_1$ and $L^{\prime }\cong \mathrm{coker}{d}_1^{\prime }$: exactness at $A_2$ identifies $\mathrm{im}{d}_1$ with $\ker d_2$, and the image-coimage isomorphism for $d_2$ gives the claimed cokernel. Write $q:A_2\to L$ and $q^{\prime }:B_2\to L^{\prime }$ for these categorical cokernels. To construct an inverse to the induced map $\ell :L\to L^{\prime }$, observeCancellation of the epimorphism $v_1$ gives $q{v}_2^{-1}{d}_1^{\prime }=0$, so $q{v}_2^{-1}$ factors uniquely as $\bar{\ell }{q}^{\prime }$ with $\bar{\ell }:L^{\prime }\to L$. From $\ell q=q^{\prime }{v}_2$, composing with the epic $q,q^{\prime }$ gives $\bar{\ell }\ell =1_L$ and $\ell \bar{\ell }=1_{L^{\prime }}$.

Second, $R\cong \ker d_4$ and $R^{\prime }\cong \ker d_4^{\prime }$ by exactness at the fourth objects. Write their inclusions as $j:R\to A_4$ and $j^{\prime }:R^{\prime }\to B_4$. The equality $d_4^{\prime }{v}_4=v_5{d}_4$ gives the induced map $\rho :R\to R^{\prime }$. Sinceand $v_5$ is a monomorphism, $d_4{v}_4^{-1}{j}^{\prime }=0$. Kernel universality gives $\bar{\rho }:R^{\prime }\to R$ with $j\bar{\rho }=v_4^{-1}{j}^{\prime }$. Cancelling the monic $j,j^{\prime }$ proves $\bar{\rho }\rho =1_R$ and $\rho \bar{\rho }=1_{R^{\prime }}$.

Apply the short five lemma to the two short exact sequences: their outer maps $\ell ,\rho$ are invertible, so $v_3$ is an isomorphism. This five lemma via image factorization argument uses only universal properties and therefore works in any abelian category, without treating its objects as literal sets of elements.

Unless a coefficient group is displayed, use integral singular cohomology. The standard CW complex structure on infinite-dimensional real projective space has one cell in each nonnegative dimension. Its cellular chain complex has boundary $d_j=2$ for positive even $j$ and $d_j=0$ for odd $j$. The cellular cohomology differential ${\delta }^j$ is therefore zero for even $j$ and multiplication by two for odd $j$. ConsequentlyMore generally, for an abelian group $A$, the positive odd groups are $A[2]=\{a:2a=0\}$ and the positive even groups are $A/2A$. In particular $H^j({\mathbb{RP}}^{\infty };{\mathbb{Z}}_2)={\mathbb{Z}}_2$ in every nonnegative degree.

For the required Bockstein homomorphism, use the short exact sequenceHere $m\ge 2$; for $m=1$ all three coefficient groups are zero. Since singular chains are free abelian groups, applying cochains gives a short exact sequence of cochain complexes. Its connecting homomorphism defines $\beta$ and its long exact sequence is precisely the required one, with the other maps induced by $\iota$ and $q$.

Explicitly, represent a class by a cocycle $u\in C^n(X;{\mathbb{Z}}_m)$ and choose a lift $\tilde{u}\in C^n(X;{\mathbb{Z}}_{m^2})$. Since $q(\delta \tilde{u})=0$, there is a unique cochain $v$ with $\iota (v)=\delta \tilde{u}$. Injectivity of $\iota$ and ${\delta }^2=0$ show $\delta v=0$. DefineChanging the lift by $\iota (w)$ changes $v$ by the coboundary $\delta w$. Changing the representative $u$ by a coboundary can be lifted by a coboundary as well and leaves the resulting class unchanged. Thus this is a well-defined group homomorphism, and the standard cochain lifting argument gives exactness.

Compute the Bockstein homomorphism on infinite-dimensional real projective space using its cellular cohomology complex. A generator with coefficients ${\mathbb{Z}}_2$ is represented by $1$ in degree $n$, lifted to $1\in {\mathbb{Z}}_4$. Its coboundary is $0$ for even $n$ and $2$ for odd $n$. Dividing via $\iota (1)=2$ givesThus the odd-degree maps are isomorphisms. The comparison between cellular cohomology and singular cohomology is natural with respect to coefficient maps, so this computes the same connecting homomorphism constructed above.

Set $S=R\setminus P$, a multiplicative subset. The localization at a prime ideal is $R_P=S^{-1}R$, whose elements are fractions $r/s$. Equality of two fractions means that $u(r{s}^{\prime }-r^{\prime }s)=0$ for some $u\in S$. Likewise the localization of a module is $M_P=S^{-1}M$, withAddition uses a common denominator, and the module action isThe equivalence relations make these operations well-defined, so $M_P$ is an $R_P$-module.

If $M\ne 0$, choose $0\ne m\in M$. Its annihilator is proper, so it lies in a maximal ideal $P$. The element $m/1$ cannot vanish in $M_P$: vanishing would mean $sm=0$ for some $s\notin P$, contrary to ${\mathrm{Ann}}_R(m)\subseteq P$. The converse is immediate by localizing the zero module. ThusThis proof of localization detects zero elements actually applies to arbitrary modules, without finite-generation or Noetherian assumptions. We will use that extra generality for an Ext functor module below.

An injective module $E$ has the extension property: for each inclusion $A\hookrightarrow B$, every map $A\to E$ extends to a map $B\to E$. Equivalently, ${\mathrm{Hom}}_R(-,E)$ is exact. A projective module $Q$ has the lifting property: for each surjection $B\twoheadrightarrow C$, every map $Q\to C$ lifts to $Q\to B$. Equivalently, ${\mathrm{Hom}}_R(Q,-)$ is exact, or $Q$ is a direct summand of a free module.

For the local criterion for injectivity over a Noetherian ring, recall the Baer criterion: $E$ is injective precisely when every map from an ideal $J\subseteq R$ into $E$ extends to $R$. Through the short exact sequence $0\to J\to R\to R/J\to 0$, this is equivalent toWe also need localization of Ext over a Noetherian ring. Because $R$ is Noetherian, the module $R/J$ has a free resolution with every term finitely generated: all successive kernels are finitely generated, so this can be built recursively. For a finite free term $F$, the natural mapis an isomorphism, as is clear from a finite basis. Exactness of localization lets us pass to cohomology of the Hom complex. ThereforeThis explains the finiteness hypothesis needed for the localization argument, rather than assuming that localization preserves injectivity automatically.

If $M$ is injective, the left-hand side vanishes for every $J$ and $P$. Every ideal $L$ of $R_P$ is $J{R}_P$, where $J$ is its contraction to $R$: if $r/s\in L$, then $r/1=s(r/s)\in L$, and conversely localization of a member of the contraction stays in $L$. Hence all ideal tests for $M_P$ vanish, and the Baer criterion over $R_P$ makes $M_P$ injective.

Conversely, suppose every $M_P$ is injective. For each ideal $J$, the displayed Ext functor localization is zero at every prime. The zero-detection argument above gives ${\mathrm{Ext}}_R^1(R/J,M)=0$, without needing this Ext module to be finitely generated. Applying the Baer criterion over $R$ provesIn fact, under the Noetherian ring hypothesis this equivalence holds for arbitrary $M$; the printed finite-generation assumption is more than is needed.

The global dimension iswhere projective dimension is the smallest length of a projective resolution, or infinity if there is no finite one. If $\mathrm{gldim}R=0$, every module is projective. Given an inclusion $A\hookrightarrow B$, the quotient $B/A$ is then projective, so the exact sequence $0\to A\to B\to B/A\to 0$ splits. A retraction $\rho :B\to A$ exists. For any module $E$ and any map $f:A\to E$, the composition $f\rho :B\to E$ extends $f$. Thus every module is also injective. Global dimension zero makes all modules both projective and injective, as recorded by global dimension zero and split exact sequences.

The Weyl complete reducibility theorem states that every finite-dimensional Lie algebra representation of a finite-dimensional complex semisimple Lie algebra is a direct sum of Irreducible Lie algebra representations. Equivalently, every invariant vector subspace has an invariant complement.

We use the permitted Casimir operator properties in the following precise form. There is a central quadratic operator $C$ commuting with the action on every module; it is zero on the trivial Lie algebra representation, and on every nontrivial finite-dimensional Irreducible Lie algebra representation it is a nonzero scalar $c$. This follows from the Schur lemma and the Casimir eigenvalue $c_{\lambda }=(\lambda ,\lambda +2\rho )$, using the Killing form normalization. We also use the permitted one-dimensional-representation fact: a complex semisimple Lie algebra has only trivial one-dimensional representations. Equivalently, it is a perfect Lie algebra, $[\mathfrak{g},\mathfrak{g}]=\mathfrak{g}$, so a character $\mathfrak{g}\to \mathbb{C}$ annihilating brackets must vanish. Neither fact assumes complete reducibility of the module being proved reducible.

First prove that every finite-dimensional short exact sequencewith trivial quotient splits. If $W$ is nontrivial irreducible, the Casimir operator $C_E$ has image in $W$ and restricts to $c{I}_W$ there. Consequently $\ker C_E$ is a one-dimensional invariant complement to $W$. If $W$ is trivial irreducible, $E$ has a basis in which every action is $\left(\begin{array}{cc}0& a(x)\\ 0& 0\end{array}\right)$. The Lie algebra representation identity makes $a([x,y])=0$, so the one-dimensional-representation fact gives $a=0$ and again the sequence splits.

For general $W$, induct on $\dim W$. Choose an irreducible submodule $W_1\subseteq W$. The induced sequence with kernel $W/W_1$ and middle term $E/W_1$ splits by induction. The inverse image $E_1\subseteq E$ of its invariant complement is a submodule fitting into $0\to W_1\to E_1\to \mathbb{C}\to 0$. The irreducible-kernel case gives an invariant line in $E_1$ mapping isomorphically to the quotient. It is also an invariant complement to $W$ in $E$. The case $W=0$ starts this induction. This proves splitting of a trivial quotient for a semisimple Lie algebra, including kernels that are not assumed completely reducible.

Now let $U\subseteq V$ be any invariant subspace. On the Hom representation $\mathrm{Hom}(V,U)$ the action isLet $E$ consist of the maps whose restriction to $U$ is a scalar multiple of $I_U$. This is a submodule, and restriction givesThe right-hand map is surjective because an ordinary linear projection $V\to U$ exists; its quotient action is trivial because a commutator with $I_U$ is zero. The splitting just proved supplies an invariant $T\in E$ with $T{|}_U=I_U$. Thus $T$ intertwines the actions, $T^2=T$, andThe cases $U=0$ and $U=V$ are immediate. Choosing an irreducible submodule and repeating this complement construction proves the Weyl complete reducibility theorem. This last step is invariant complement from an equivariant projection.

Dropping finite dimensionality gives an example with the complex simple Lie algebra ${\mathfrak{sl}}_2$. Its Verma module of highest weight zero has a basis $v_0,v_1,\dots$ withwhere $e{v}_0=0$. These actions obey $[h,e]=2e$, $[h,f]=-2f$, $[e,f]=h$. The span of $v_1,v_2,\dots$ is a proper submodule and the quotient is trivial. It has no invariant complement: such a complement would be a trivial line, while $f$ is injective on the entire module. Thus a simple Lie algebra can have an infinite-dimensional representation that is not completely reducible, even over $\mathbb{C}$.

The extension group ${\mathrm{Ext}}_Q^1(V,W)$ consists of equivalence classes of short exact sequences $0\to W\to E\to V\to 0$, with the zero class represented by a split sequence and addition given by the Baer sum. The extension complex of quiver representations givesThe printed map has $\gamma (u{)}_{\rho }=u_j{f}_{\rho }-g_{\rho }{u}_i$, so its kernel is ${\mathrm{Hom}}_Q(V,W)$ and its cokernel is ${\mathrm{Ext}}_Q^1(V,W)$. Reversing the overall differential sign changes neither identification.

For dimension vectors $\mathbf{v},\mathbf{w}$, the Ringel form isThe first expression makes its dependence only on the dimension vectors explicit.

For the one-loop representation $V=k$ with loop scalar $\lambda$, $\gamma (u)=u\lambda -\lambda u=0$ on $k$. Both cochain spaces have dimension one, so $\dim {\mathrm{Ext}}_Q^1(V,V)=1$, for every $\lambda$. Concretely, a self-extension has loop matrix $\left(\begin{array}{cc}\lambda & c\\ 0& \lambda \end{array}\right)$, with $c$ the extension parameter.

Integral groups for $M_4$. Put $r=n-1$. The space $M_n$ is the inversion mapping torus of a torus, fibred over $S^1$ with fiber $T^r$. The cohomology ring of a torus is the exterior algebra on $r$ degree-one generators. Inversion acts as $-1$ on each such generator, hence as $(-1{)}^q$ on $H^q(T^r;\mathbb{Z})\cong {\mathbb{Z}}^{\left(\genfrac{}{}{0ex}{}{r}{q}\right)}$.

The Wang sequence therefore givesThe right-hand term is free, so this short exact sequence splits as a sequence of groups. In even fiber degree, $F^{\ast }-1=0$; in odd fiber degree it is multiplication by $-2$. For $r=3$ this computes the integral cohomology of an inversion mapping torus:The top torsion group is consistent with $M_4$ being nonorientable: inversion of its three-dimensional fiber reverses orientation.

Mod-two groups. Over ${\mathbb{F}}_2$, inversion acts as the identity on the fiber cohomology. The Wang sequence givesThuswith out-of-range binomial coefficients interpreted as zero. These are exactly the dimensions of the graded groups $H^{\ast }(T^n;{\mathbb{F}}_2)$.

The intersection pairing for $M_2$. The mapping torus of reflection of the circle is the Klein bottle. Let $a$ be the section loop through a fixed point of the reflection and $b$ a fiber circle. They form a basis of $H_1(M_2;{\mathbb{F}}_2)$. The section has a normal neighborhood homeomorphic to a Möbius band, so it is one-sided and a transverse displacement meets it once modulo two. The fiber is two-sided and can be displaced disjointly. The two loops meet once. The mod-two intersection pairing of the Klein bottle therefore has matrixTake the evaluation-dual basis $t,x\in H^1(M_2;{\mathbb{F}}_2)$, with $t(a)=1,t(b)=0$ and $x(a)=0,x(b)=1$. By Poincare duality, the cup product matrix in this dual basis is $Q^{-1}$, not $Q$:Writing $w$ for the nonzero top class gives $t^2=0$, $tx=w$ and $x^2=w$. Hence the cohomology ring isThese relations already force all degrees above two to vanish.

The ring for general $n$. For each of the $r$ fiber coordinates, projection induces $M_n\to M_2$. Pull back the classes above, calling the common base class $t$ and the fiber-coordinate classes $x_1,\dots ,x_r$. Naturality of the cup product gives $t^2=0$ and $x_i^2=t{x}_i$. The square-free products $x_I={\prod }_{i\in I}{x}_i$ restrict to the exterior algebra basis of the fiber cohomology. The Leray-Hirsch theorem then says that $x_I$ and $t{x}_I$ form an additive basis. This proves the full mod-two cohomology ring of an inversion mapping torus:For $n\ge 2$, $x_i^2=t{x}_i$ is nonzero by this basis description. In the cohomology ring of a torus every degree-one class squares to zero: the generators square to zero and the cross terms occur twice in characteristic two. The degree-one cup-square obstruction to ring isomorphism therefore proves that the rings are not isomorphic for any $n\ge 2$, despite their isomorphic graded groups. For $n=1$, both spaces are circles and the rings are isomorphic. Even if grading is forgotten, the rings differ for $n\ge 2$: every element of the torus ring has square either zero or one, whereas $x_i^2=t{x}_i$ is nonzero and is not the unit.

Integral cup products in $M_4$. To specify $H^{\ast }(M_4;\mathbb{Z})$ also as a ring, let $a\in H^1$ be the pullback of the positive generator of $H^1(S^1;\mathbb{Z})$. Let $\rho$ denote reduction modulo two and set ${\tau }_i=\hat{\beta }(x_i)$ using the integral Bockstein homomorphism. The degree-one Bockstein square identity gives $\rho {\tau }_i=x_i^2=t{x}_i$, so the ${\tau }_i$ are the three independent order-two classes in degree two. Choose free classes $b_{12},b_{13},b_{23}\in H^2$ which restrict to the corresponding two-fold fiber products and have reductions $\rho b_{ij}=x_i{x}_j$. Such choices exist: reduction in degree two is surjective because $H^3(M_4;\mathbb{Z})$ is free, and adding the ${\tau }_i$ removes any $t{x}_i$ terms from an initial lift.

The Wang sequence identifies $a{b}_{12},a{b}_{13},a{b}_{23}$ as a free basis of $H^3$. Let $\kappa$ generate $H^4\cong \mathbb{Z}/2$, with $\rho \kappa =t{x}_1{x}_2{x}_3$. Reduction in degree four is an isomorphism. The integral cup products in the four-dimensional inversion mapping torus are consequently determined byTogether with the unit, graded commutativity and vanishing above degree four, these give every product. For example, $\rho (b_{12}{b}_{13})=x_1^2{x}_2{x}_3=t{x}_1{x}_2{x}_3$, whereas $\rho (b_{12}^2)=t^2{x}_1{x}_2=0$. The products $a{\tau }_i$ vanish because they are torsion in the free group $H^3$.

For $r=1$, the assertion is the assumed vanishing for coherent ideal sheaves. For $r>1$, project $\mathcal{F}\subseteq {\mathcal{O}}_X^r$ onto the last component. Its image $\mathcal{I}\subseteq {\mathcal{O}}_X$ is a coherent ideal sheaf, and its kernel ${\mathcal{F}}^{\prime }$ is a coherent sheaf contained in ${\mathcal{O}}_X^{r-1}$. Here images and kernels are coherent because a variety is Noetherian. The short exact sequencegives an exact segment $H^1(X,{\mathcal{F}}^{\prime })\to H^1(X,\mathcal{F})\to H^1(X,\mathcal{I})$ in the long exact sequence in sheaf cohomology. The outer terms vanish by mathematical induction and the hypothesis, so the middle term vanishes. This is ideal-sheaf vanishing for a coherent submodule of a trivial bundle.

For an affine variety, every coherent ideal sheaf is quasi-coherent; vanishing of quasi-coherent cohomology on an affine scheme therefore gives $H^1(X,\mathcal{I})=0$.

For the projective-space complement, assume $n\ge 1$ and choose two distinct closed points $P,Q\in X$. Take the ideal sheaf of two closed points $\mathcal{I}={\mathfrak{m}}_P\cap {\mathfrak{m}}_Q$ on $X$. The codimension-two extension of regular functions on a normal variety givesOne can see this directly: on every standard affine chart of ${\mathbb{P}}^n$, a rational function written in lowest terms cannot have a nonconstant denominator, because an irreducible polynomial factor of the denominator would define a pole along a codimension-one hypersurface, and such a hypersurface is not removed by $Z$. The extended function is constant because every global regular function on projective space is constant. Now the short exact sequencesends $k$ diagonally into $k^2$ on global sections. Its cokernel is $k$, and the long exact sequence in sheaf cohomology injects that cokernel into $H^1(X,\mathcal{I})$. ThusThe assumption $n\ge 1$ is necessary: ${\mathbb{P}}^0$ is already affine and has no such example.

Here a divisor is a modulus of a number field, rather than an arbitrary real-weighted divisor. Writewhere ${\mathfrak{c}}_0$ is a nonzero integral ideal, the finite multiplicities $m_{\mathfrak{p}}$ are nonnegative integers, and ${\mathfrak{c}}_{\infty }$ is a set of real Archimedean places. The multiplicity of a place in a modulus is $m_v(\mathfrak{c})=m_{\mathfrak{p}}$ at the finite place corresponding to $\mathfrak{p}$, is $1$ at a real place in ${\mathfrak{c}}_{\infty }$, and is $0$ at every other infinite place. In particular complex places have multiplicity $0$.

Let $I_{\mathfrak{c}}$ be the group of nonzero fractional ideals prime to ${\mathfrak{c}}_0$. PutLet $P_{\mathfrak{c}}$ consist of the principal ideals $(a)$ with $a\in K_{\mathfrak{c},1}^{\times }$. The generalized ideal class group is the ray class groupLet $U={\mathcal{O}}_K^{\times }$ be the unit group, let $U_{\mathfrak{c}}=U\cap K_{\mathfrak{c},1}^{\times }$ be the group of ray units, and define the residue and signature group of a modulusThe first factor is omitted when ${\mathfrak{c}}_0={\mathcal{O}}_K$. There is a group homomorphism $\rho :U\to G_{\mathfrak{c}}$ recording the unit's finite residues and its signs. Its kernel is $U_{\mathfrak{c}}$.

Let $P^{\mathfrak{c}}$ consist of all principal fractional ideals prime to ${\mathfrak{c}}_0$, and put $R_{\mathfrak{c}}=P^{\mathfrak{c}}/P_{\mathfrak{c}}$. The two short exact sequences areandFor the first short exact sequence, weak approximation for number fields realizes every choice of finite unit residues and real signs by some $a\in K^{\times }$ prime to ${\mathfrak{c}}_0$. Send that data to the class of $(a)$ in $R_{\mathfrak{c}}$. Changing $a$ without changing its residues and signs multiplies it by an element of $K_{\mathfrak{c},1}^{\times }$, so the map is well-defined. Its kernel consists exactly of data arising from units: if $(a)=(b)$ with $b\in K_{\mathfrak{c},1}^{\times }$, then $a/b\in U$. This gives $R_{\mathfrak{c}}\cong G_{\mathfrak{c}}/\rho (U)$. For the second short exact sequence, forget the ray conditions. Its kernel is $R_{\mathfrak{c}}$, and weak approximation for number fields gives a representative prime to ${\mathfrak{c}}_0$ for every ideal class. These are the two parts of the ray class exact sequence.

For $K=\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{15})$, the ring of integers of a quadratic field is ${\mathcal{O}}_K=\mathbb{Z}[\sqrt{15}]$. The finite modulus is trivial and both real places occur, so $H_{\mathfrak{c}}$ is the narrow ideal class group and $G_{\mathfrak{c}}=\{\pm 1{\}}^2$. The two field embeddings send $\sqrt{15}$ to $\sqrt{15}$ and $-\sqrt{15}$. The given unit $ϵ=4+\sqrt{15}$ is positive at both places, since $4-\sqrt{15}>0$; the unit $-1$ is negative at both. Thus the unit signature map has imageThe given ideal class group has order $2$. The second short exact sequence therefore givesTo determine the group structure, retain the ideal $\mathfrak{p}=(2,1+\sqrt{15})$ that generates the ordinary ideal class group. We have ${\mathfrak{p}}^2=(2)$: all generators $4$, $2(1+\sqrt{15})$ and $(1+\sqrt{15}{)}^2$ lie in $(2)$, whileputs $2$ in ${\mathfrak{p}}^2$. Since $2$ is totally positive, $[\mathfrak{p}{]}^2=1$ in the narrow ideal class group. Its image in the ordinary ideal class group is nontrivial, so $[\mathfrak{p}]$ has order exactly $2$.

The class of the principal ideal $(\sqrt{15})$ is a nontrivial element of $R_{\mathfrak{c}}$. Its two signs are $(+,-)$, and multiplying by a unit can only reverse both signs or neither, so no generator of this ideal is totally positive. Its square is $(15)$, which does have a totally positive generator. Thus $[(\sqrt{15})]$ is another element of order $2$, distinct from $[\mathfrak{p}]$ because its ordinary ideal class is trivial. These two elements are independent and generate all four classes. ConsequentlyThe nontrivial ordinary ideal class already has a lift of order $2$, so the extension in the second short exact sequence splits; it cannot be cyclic of order $4$.

Rows in the following matrix index the source, columns the target, in the order $X,Y,Z$. Solving the arrow-square equation for a quiver representation morphism givesIn particular, the nonzero morphisms between distinct representations are $X\to Z$ and $Z\to Y$, each a one-dimensional family of scalar multiples of the vertexwise inclusion or projection. A map $Y\to Z$ is forced to vanish at the source by the identity arrow of $Z$; similarly a map $Z\to X$ is forced to vanish at the target. Maps between $X$ and $Y$ are zero. Each endomorphism ring is $k$.

The extension complex of quiver representations for the one-arrow quiver isIts cokernel is ${\mathrm{Ext}}_Q^1(U,V)$. Substitution of the three representations givesHere the first argument is the quotient endpoint of a short exact sequence. Thus the only possible nonsplit endpoint pair is subobject $X$, quotient $Y$. The sequenceis nonsplit, since $Z$ is indecomposable. More explicitly, all extensions with these endpoints have a middle arrow $k\stackrel{\lambda }{\to }k$: $\lambda =0$ gives the split short exact sequence, while each $\lambda \ne 0$ gives a middle representation isomorphic to $Z$. With endpoint identifications fixed the extension classes form $k$; up to endpoint automorphisms all nonzero classes give this same nonsplit sequence. There are no other nonsplit sequences with the listed endpoints, including equal endpoints.

Split the sequence as vector spaces at each vertex. In these coordinates, the middle arrow maps have block formFor $t\in k^{\times }$, change basis by $\mathrm{diag}(t{I}_{X_i},I_{Z_i})$ at every vertex. It changes the off-diagonal block to $t{\xi }_{\rho }$. These arrow matrices depend polynomially on $t$ and at $t=0$ give $X\oplus Z$. Thus the split extension as a degeneration showsWe must check that the two orbits are different. If $Y\cong X\oplus Z$, apply ${\mathrm{Hom}}_Q(Z,-)$ to the original short exact sequence. Exactness makes the kernel of $\mathrm{Hom}(Z,Y)\to \mathrm{End}(Z)$ equal to $\mathrm{Hom}(Z,X)$. The assumed isomorphism of the middle representation gives $\dim \mathrm{Hom}(Z,Y)=\dim \mathrm{Hom}(Z,X)+\dim \mathrm{End}(Z)$, so this map is surjective. In particular the identity of $Z$ lifts to $Z\to Y$, splitting the sequence, a contradiction. Hence the orbits are indeed distinct.

The group $\mathrm{GL}(\mathbf{n})$ is irreducible, so $\overline{{\mathcal{O}}_Y}$ is irreducible. An algebraic-group orbit is locally closed, hence open in its closure; its boundary is a proper closed subset of smaller dimension. The distinct orbit ${\mathcal{O}}_{X\oplus Z}$ lies in that boundary. Therefore