Use the convention for the scalar triple product. With as above, . The vector triple product identity gives
The Lagrange identity for the cross product, , also gives
Taking the dot product with the unit vector proves
Use the vector triple product identity
Since is a unit vector, put
Thus is the component of in the orthogonal complement of , and . A cross product is orthogonal to both its factors, so and . Consequently
All three pairs are orthogonal. This remains true when is parallel to : then and are zero vectors. Pairwise orthogonality does not assert linear independence in this case.
For , choose the uniform partition of an interval into pieces and its midpoint tags
Their arithmetic mean is exactly . Apply the given Jensen inequality with equal weights :
Multiplying by gives a midpoint Riemann sum on the left. Its mesh of a partition is , so the Riemann sum convergence theorem gives
For the equality is immediate. Together with part i, this is the Hermite-Hadamard inequality with the directions appropriate to a concave function.
The stated weighted inequality is the Jensen inequality for a concave function. Assume ; if , both sides of the required inequality are zero. Write with . Applying the weighted inequality at the two endpoints gives
Thus the affine function joining the endpoint values lies below . By monotonicity of the Riemann integral,
This is the lower bound in the Hermite-Hadamard inequality for a concave function.
We verify that the augmented partition of an interval in part i has vanishing mesh of a partition. Define for . Its derivative is
Since for , we have . The mean value theorem therefore gives
The appended interval has length , so for the augmented partition of an interval.
The sine is continuous, hence Riemann integrable on . By the Riemann sum convergence theorem, , using the fundamental theorem of calculus and the cosine antiderivative. As , the answer is
Set
The points strictly increase from zero to . With , the given expression is exactly the midpoint Riemann sum
for the partition of an interval of . The sine argument is precisely the midpoint tag, since it is half the sum of the consecutive endpoints.
For a fixed integration interval , append and choose the final tag . The resulting Riemann sum satisfies
This makes explicit the small final interval that the original sum omits.
A maximum or minimum can occur at an endpoint. The rule that a derivative vanishes at an extremum requires an interior extremum and differentiability there. The hypotheses give no two-sided derivative at the endpoints, and even an existing one-sided derivative need not vanish there.
For example, on has at and at , but at every interior point; its endpoint one-sided derivatives are also one. Its graph meets both horizontal bounding lines without being tangent to either. Thus the claimed conclusion about two zeros of the derivative fails.
There is a second logical issue: the argument never establishes two distinct extremizing points. For a constant function, the maximum and minimum coincide and may be represented by the same point. The constant function does have many stationary points, but that needs its own argument; it does not follow from counting the same selected point twice. In Rolle's theorem, equal endpoint values ensure an interior extremum when the function is nonconstant, which is the missing mechanism here.
The extreme value theorem gives finite real numbers
Since these values are attained, the set of strict upper bounds in the definition of is precisely , and the set of strict lower bounds in the definition of is precisely . They are nonempty and bounded on the required sides. By the definitions of infimum and supremum,
We give the explicit point . Repeatedly choose the left remaining third and then the right remaining third. After choices, the resulting closed interval is , where
These formulas follow from a finite geometric series. They show , and that both endpoints tend to . The point is also strictly inside each intermediate left third: its distance from is one quarter of the current length. It therefore never enters any assigned closed middle third or its endpoints, so .
Endpoint values in the Cantor function construction obey the same left/right choices, with halving in place of thirding. Thus
All these endpoints are in the domain of the partial function: is the right endpoint of a middle third assigned at round , and is the left endpoint of a middle third assigned at round .
Given , choose so that , and put . If and , then . The assumed monotonicity gives
Consequently . This proves directly, on the stated partial domain,
There are defined points arbitrarily close to , for example and , so the limit of a function is not vacuous. No continuous extension has been assumed. The residual here omits the endpoints that the question assigns values to; it is the usual Cantor set with those assigned endpoints removed.
Figure 1.
Assigned middle thirds and the nested intervals around that force the value
. Details.
The construction is the partial middle-third construction of the Cantor function. After rounds of assigning middle thirds, every remaining open interval has endpoint values
for some , and every such consecutive pair occurs. This follows by mathematical induction. Initially the endpoint values are . An interval with those consecutive endpoint values receives the value
on its closed middle third. Its two remaining open intervals therefore have consecutive endpoint values at denominator . All previously assigned endpoint values persist. Hence all even numerators at the next denominator were already present, and all odd numerators have just been assigned. Including the initial values zero and one proves
These are precisely the dyadic rational values between zero and one.
An explicit piecewise linear function is
The adjacent formulas agree at and , so the function is continuous, and . Any pair of points at distance can be written with . For every such ,
Thus their values are never equal. The horizontal chord of reciprocal-integer length conclusion does not extend to this distance.
For , choose , . For , define the continuous function
Its values at the grid points have the telescoping sum
If one summand is zero, we already have a zero of . Otherwise the summands cannot all have the same sign, so two of these values have opposite signs. The intermediate value theorem between their arguments gives with . Set , . Then
This is the horizontal chord of reciprocal-integer length property; the telescoping sum explains why reciprocal integers appear.
The intermediate value theorem states that if is continuous and lies between and , inclusive, then some satisfies . If lies strictly between the endpoint values, then lies in .
If there were no interior with , the symmetric derivative would be positive everywhere in . Part ii would make strictly increasing there. Choose . Continuity at the endpoints and monotonicity on the interior imply
contradicting . Hence such an exists.
If there were no interior with , then everywhere. Apply the same argument to the continuous function , whose endpoint values are equal. This is again impossible. Thus
The two points need not be distinct.
We prove the symmetric derivative criterion for monotonicity using an antiderivative. Fix and define
The fundamental theorem of calculus gives because is continuous. For each interior ,
Since , the definition of symmetric derivative gives such that for . Therefore, for ,
We next show that is a convex function. On any closed interval let be the affine function joining to . If were positive anywhere, the extreme value theorem would give a positive maximum at an interior point . For every sufficiently small , that maximum would imply
The affine function contributes zero to this symmetric difference, contradicting the strict positive inequality above. Thus on every such interval, exactly convexity.
For a differentiable convex function, secant slopes bound endpoint derivatives. Explicitly, the chord inequality at and at , followed by , gives
So is nondecreasing. If for some , monotonicity would make constant on , forcing for , a contradiction. Consequently : is strictly increasing. This proof requires no continuity of and never applies the ordinary mean value theorem to a merely symmetrically differentiable function.
Write the symmetric difference quotient as the average of two ordinary difference quotients:
If is differentiable at , both terms tend to the derivative . Hence the symmetric derivative satisfies .
The absolute value function is continuous, and because . Its right one-sided derivative at zero is and its left one-sided derivative is , so it is not differentiable at zero. Away from zero it is differentiable, hence has a symmetric derivative there as well. This supplies an example meeting the hypotheses on, for example, .
Take any . By differentiability implies continuity, is continuous on , and it is differentiable on . The mean value theorem gives for which
Therefore : is a nondecreasing function, which is the non-strict meaning of increasing here.
The mean value theorem states: if a real-valued function is continuous on a closed interval , where , and differentiable on , then there is with
A function is differentiable on if, for every , the finite limit of a function
exists. Here and is sufficiently small that . This limit of a function is the derivative of at .

There are unlisted articles, also show them or only show them.