Set
The triangle inequality makes Lipschitz continuous and hence a continuous function. Since is an isometric embedding,
so as . The function is therefore coercive, and the extreme value theorem on a sufficiently large compact interval gives a minimizing parameter.
Suppose both minimize , put and , and let
The restriction of between the two parameters is a geodesic from to . Let be its midpoint. In the geodesic triangle with vertices , the thin geodesic triangle condition gives a point on one of the other two sides with . By symmetry suppose . Then
so
But lies on and is a closest point, so . Therefore , which is stronger than the required
This is the closest point on a geodesic line in a hyperbolic metric space estimate.
For a continuous closed path , choose a continuous argument lift
Its winding number of a continuous closed path about zero is
For a piecewise smooth path this equals .
If , then
never vanishes, since . Thus is a homotopy through closed paths avoiding zero. By homotopy invariance of winding number, or directly by the dominated-perturbation lemma,
More generally, and are homotopic by paths in when there is a continuous function
with , , and for every . The winding-number theorem states that such a homotopy implies
For the Fundamental theorem of algebra, let with . For sufficiently large ,
for every . The dominated-perturbation lemma shows that has the same winding number as , namely . If had no zero, however,
would be a homotopy in from that loop to the constant loop , whose winding number is zero. This contradiction proves that has a complex root. This is the winding-number proof of the fundamental theorem of algebra.
Finally suppose that a continuous retraction existed. The boundary loop has winding number one, while contracts it to zero inside the disc. Composing this contraction with gives a homotopy through loops in from to the constant loop . Their winding numbers are respectively one and zero, contradicting homotopy invariance. Hence there is no such retraction, as in the winding-number proof of the no-retraction theorem.
Statement (iv) is true. Apply the Weierstrass approximation theorem separately to the real and imaginary parts of the continuous function on the compact interval . Combining the two real polynomial sequences gives complex polynomials converging uniformly to on .
For , the triangle inequality and the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality give
Thus is a continuous function. The unit sphere in the finite-dimensional Euclidean normed vector space is compact. Moreover, implies that the polynomial vanishes identically, so every coefficient is zero. Hence is strictly positive on the unit sphere. By the extreme value theorem, it has a positive minimum
The supremum norm is homogeneous. For ,
It follows directly that whenever .
Write each polynomial of degree at most as and define
This is a continuous function, and the reverse triangle inequality together with part (a) gives
Consequently is a coercive function. Choose so large that outside the closed Euclidean ball of radius . That ball is compact, so the extreme value theorem supplies a minimizer there. Then is a best uniform approximation to among polynomials of degree at most .
As printed, this part contains an indexing error. The displayed product ends at , but the hypotheses contain alternating intervals indexed by . On the first intervals the printed polynomial has sign , while on the last interval it has sign rather than the required . For example, when the printed product is the constant , which cannot reduce a negative extremum of on the final interval. The intended polynomial is
We prove the stated conclusion with this correction.
Each root lies in the gap between the st and th active intervals. Therefore has sign throughout . In particular, wherever , the numbers and have the same sign, and is nonzero.
Let
These are compact sets. On their union, the continuous function has a positive minimum. Hence, throughout some open neighbourhood of , subtracting a sufficiently small positive multiple moves strictly towards zero and gives . On the compact complement , continuity gives a uniform margin for some . Taking also
shows that there. Thus
for every sufficiently small .
It remains to prove necessity in the Chebyshev alternation theorem. Let be a best approximation of degree at most , put , and let . If has no sequence of extrema with alternating signs, its sets of positive and negative extrema can be collected, from left to right, into alternating compact groups with . Choose disjoint intervals containing those groups and separated by regions on which . After replacing by if necessary, they satisfy the displayed hypotheses. The corrected construction produces a polynomial of degree and a small such that
This contradicts the assumed optimality of . Therefore every best polynomial has the required alternating extrema.
Let
The function is continuous, with
The intermediate value theorem gives such that , and hence . This proves the fixed-point property of a closed interval.
Now suppose . For any , choose with and . Applying the intermediate value theorem to on the interval with endpoints gives a point with . Thus is a surjective function.
Define the continuous function
At the mesh points its values telescope:
If one term is zero, the result follows immediately. Otherwise the terms cannot all have the same sign, so there are mesh points at which is positive and negative. The intermediate value theorem between those points gives an with . Thus the telescoping increment lemma yields
Let be continuous on . Compactness makes it uniformly continuous. Given , choose such that
Choose a partition with mesh smaller than . The oscillation on every subinterval is then at most , so
The Riemann integrability criterion proves that every continuous function on is Riemann integrable.
A function is uniformly continuous if for every there is such that
for all .
Suppose uniformly and every is uniformly continuous. Given , choose such that
for every . Uniform continuity of supplies such that implies
The triangle inequality then gives . Thus the uniform limit theorem for uniformly continuous functions proves that is uniformly continuous.
Pointwise convergence is insufficient. On , the uniformly continuous functions converge pointwise to
which is discontinuous and therefore not uniformly continuous.
A function is holomorphic when it is complex differentiable at every point of the open connected set . Morera's theorem states that a continuous function on a domain is holomorphic if its integral around every triangle whose interior lies in the domain is zero.
The integrand is continuous jointly in on , so the displayed integral defines a continuous function. For any triangle , Fubini's theorem and the Cauchy integral theorem give
Morera's theorem therefore proves that is entire.
The function is holomorphic on but has no antiderivative there, because an antiderivative would integrate to zero around every closed curve whereas
This is the standard period obstruction to a holomorphic antiderivative.
Let and be the projection-valued measures of and . Using the projection , define
The scalar spectral measures converge weakly when
for every bounded continuous function and every . By the spectral theorem for normal operators on a separable Hilbert space, this is equivalent to
The assumed moment identities say precisely that this convergence holds for every monomial . It follows by linearity for every polynomial. For , the identity gives
so Markov inequality makes the positive measures tight. Higher even moments similarly control the tails of any fixed polynomial.
Given a bounded continuous and , choose so that the measure tails are uniformly small. The Weierstrass approximation theorem supplies a polynomial with
Moment convergence handles ; tightness and a sufficiently high even moment handle the two tails. Hence . The polarization identity then gives the same conclusion for . This proves weak convergence of scalar spectral measures.
The assertion fails if only is assumed. Let , let , take , and let
The reversal matrices are self-adjoint unitaries. For fixed ,
because the finite head of one vector is paired with the vanishing tail of the other. Thus the condition holds. However, , so
in general. Taking shows that the spectral measures do not converge weakly.
The Hahn-Banach theorem says that if is a linear subspace of a real normed space and is bounded and linear, then there is a bounded linear extension with .
For , the map is linear on and
so and . The assignment is visibly linear. If , define on by
It has norm one, and Hahn--Banach extends it to an of norm one with . Therefore
Thus the canonical embedding into the bidual is an isometry and
On , point evaluation has norm one for the norm, because a continuous function's essential supremum equals its supremum. Hahn--Banach extends it to . If were represented by some , then
for every continuous . Choose continuous with and support in . Absolute continuity of the integral makes the right side tend to zero, while the left side is always one, a contradiction. This singular functional on L infinity proves
The real Stone-Weierstrass theorem says that if is compact Hausdorff and is a subalgebra containing the constants and separating points, then is uniformly dense in .
Let be the uniform closure. Polynomial approximation to on a bounded interval shows that whenever . Hence is closed under
Given , separation and the constants provide, for each , a function in agreeing with at and . Compactness first combines finitely many such functions by minima to obtain one that agrees at and lies below everywhere; a second finite cover and maxima produces with . Thus .
The space is Banach because a uniform Cauchy sequence converges uniformly to a bounded continuous function. Compactness is essential: the algebra of bounded continuous functions having finite limits at both and contains constants and separates points, for example using , but its uniform closure has the same limiting property. It cannot uniformly approximate , so it is not dense in .
Fix and put . If , then
uniformly for . Multiplication by the bounded continuous function and integration therefore prove continuity of at .
Take to be the positively oriented unit circle and . By the Cauchy integral formula, inside the circle and outside it, so no continuous extension across exists.
For the final assertion, cover by finitely many sufficiently small closed axis-parallel squares whose slightly enlarged squares lie in , choosing the grid so that no boundary meets . Apply the square Cauchy formula to on every selected square and add the results. Integrals over shared edges cancel with opposite orientations. The remaining finitely many oriented boundary polygons can be split into contours , and their sum is
for every .
Pointwise, tends to according as . This limit is discontinuous, whereas a uniform limit of continuous functions is continuous. Convergence is therefore not uniform.
For a harmonic function , let
The divergence theorem gives
Since as , . Integrating the spherical averages in the radial variable gives the corresponding ball average, proving the mean value property for harmonic functions. If attains its maximum at an interior point, the average of the nonnegative function on every sufficiently small centred sphere is zero. Continuity makes constant on those spheres, and connectedness propagates that value through the domain. Thus the weak maximum principle for elliptic operators gives
For the derivative estimate, choose smaller than half the distance from to , and let be a smooth radial mollifier supported in . Writing its convolution in polar coordinates and using the spherical mean value property shows that on . Hence, for every multi-index ,
so Holder inequality gives
Suppose and are weak solutions with the same trace, and put . The weak formulation permits itself as a test function, giving
Thus is almost everywhere constant, and its zero trace makes that constant zero. This proves uniqueness.
The weak identity also says that in the sense of distributions. The Weyl lemma therefore gives and pointwise. The assumed continuity on retains the prescribed boundary values, so the weak solution is the unique classical solution in .
Fix a closed ball , and let solve the Dirichlet problem for the Laplace equation in this ball with boundary data . Put . The function is continuous, vanishes on the boundary, and inherits the restricted spherical mean identity because has the full mean value property for harmonic functions.
Suppose . Its maximum set is a nonempty compact subset of the open ball. Choose maximizing . For every sufficiently small radius in the sequence attached to ,
Equality of the average with the maximum and continuity imply that the whole sphere belongs to . Its point in the direction from through lies farther from than does; if , any point on the sphere does. Both cases contradict the choice of . Hence , and applying the same argument to gives .
Thus on every relatively compact ball. It is consequently harmonic and smooth locally, proving the local converse to the mean value property.
For , the triangle inequality and the fact that is an isometry give
Thus the displacement function is -Lipschitz, hence continuous.