Minimize the squared distance , which has the same minimizers as the distance. The Lagrange multiplier equations for the constraint are
The constraint gradient cannot vanish on this branch, since its second component is . Eliminate to obtain . Put ; then , so . But the constraint says , requiring and selecting . It follows that
To prove a global minimum on the whole branch, substitute into :
The arithmetic-geometric mean inequality proves this bound, with equality only when , namely . Thus the stationary point is the unique closest point on the required branch. Numerically it is approximately and its distance is in coordinate units.
Take a face on the flat base and let be its positive half-widths, with height . The upper vertices meet the spherical boundary at , and the rectangular parallelepiped has volume . A Lagrange multiplier gives
Multiplication by respectively shows . Positivity and the constraint give . Therefore
Boundary choices with a zero dimension give zero volume, so this is the maximum in this configuration.
The maximum-volume cuboid in a hemisphere also has a bound covering arbitrary orientations. Let be any box's half-edge lengths, its centre coordinates in its orthonormal edge basis, and the vertical unit-vector coordinates. Remaining above the base plane requires , so for at least one index. Its farthest vertex obeys
where containment supplies the first inequality. The arithmetic-geometric mean inequality applied to the three terms for and yields . Thus its full volume cannot exceed the value attained above; tilting cannot improve it. Boundary contact is allowed for the maximum; strict containment would give the same supremum.
The triangular roof has height and two slopes of length . Hence the area constraint and cost are
The wall height is fixed, so its cost is constant. Assume the physical case . Minimize subject to the area constraint by Lagrange multipliers:
Eliminating the positive common factors gives
Thus the optimum has and
Set , so the area constraint gives . Substituting into the preceding equation and multiplying by yields . Therefore
For a global check, the square of the total roof length is
Its derivative has the sign of . Since , and , it has one root in this interval, with decreasing before that root and increasing afterwards. This proves the unique global minimum, rather than merely a stationary design. The minimum roof length at fixed wall height and cross-sectional area is independent of and of the positive factor . If , every feasible shape has equal cost; the displayed conditions then describe a possible minimizer but are not necessary.
Figure 1.
An original cross-section construction showing the fixed wall height, roof rise and sloping lengths
. Details.
Maximizing the squared distance avoids differentiating a square root. The Lagrange multiplier equations for are
Adding and subtracting the first two gives and . The feasible stationary points therefore lie on or . The first case gives and squared distance . The second gives and , with squared distance .
The ellipse is compact and its constraint gradient does not vanish on the curve, so an extremum exists among these points. A direct global check is , using . Equality occurs when . Consequently
Assume positive corridor widths . Write the line through the two wall-contact endpoints in intercept form. Requiring it to pass through the inner corner gives
Its squared length is . Apply Lagrange multipliers to this function subject to :
Multiplying by and respectively eliminates the multiplier, giving . Substitute and multiply by :
The branch is geometrically inadmissible. Thus and . If and , the two intercepts become and , so
Along in the positive quadrant, as or , and this is its only stationary point. It is therefore the minimum of the longest sticks that fit at each orientation. A stick being turned must pass through every intermediate orientation, so this narrowest clearance is precisely the maximum carryable length, rather than a maximum of . This is the ladder around a right-angled corner problem, with a zero-width stick and wall contact allowed as in the ideal geometry.
Figure 1.
The critical ladder position touching the two outer walls and the inner corridor corner
. Details.
At a regular constrained stationary point, the Lagrange multiplier equations are , . Eliminating the multiplier gives
Thus the required Lagrange multiplier determinant condition in two variables is
If the constraint gradient vanishes, this determinant is zero automatically, although the regular multiplier theorem cannot be applied. The condition is necessary and is not sufficient to classify the constrained point. This addresses the original unnumbered task before part (a).
At a regular constrained stationary point, the change in along every allowed tangent direction must vanish. Thus its gradient is normal to the constraint curve, giving the Lagrange multiplier equations
provided . Solve these equations for , then classify the candidates using the constraint or a constrained second-derivative test. Points where the constraint gradient vanishes require separate analysis.
For variables and regular independent constraints , use one multiplier per constraint:
There are scalar equations in the unknowns. Independence of the constraint gradients is the regularity condition; boundary points must be treated separately when present.
Let the fixed positive volume be . For an interior constrained extremum, Lagrange multipliers applied to the energy give
Multiplying these equations by shows that . Since the lengths are positive, .
The arithmetic-geometric mean inequality proves this is the global minimum:
with equality exactly for equal sides. Thus the optimal shape is a cube, and .
Put and let the fixed constraint value be . For , the Lagrange multiplier equations give
Dividing removes and yields
To establish a minimum, rather than merely a stationary ratio, set and . Then and . The denominator squared is ; its derivative is , giving a unique maximum at , . The volume tends to infinity at either endpoint. This proves the stated ratio is the unique global minimum, as in the optimal cylinder for a reciprocal-square constraint.
As in the diagram, an inscribed cylinder rests on , is coaxial with the paraboloid, and has its top rim on the curved boundary. Thus
Allowing contact with the boundary is the usual meaning of inscribed. Form the Lagrange multiplier function
At a nondegenerate stationary cylinder, its two derivative equations are
Eliminating gives . The constraint then gives and , so
The degenerate endpoints or have zero volume, consistent with the positive stationary value being the maximum. If the strict inequalities defining the open interior were interpreted as forbidding boundary contact, the same value would instead be a supremum approached by smaller cylinders.
Use the diagram's labels: are horizontal side lengths and is the height of the rectangular parallelepiped. Its four top vertices are at horizontal distance from the axis. Thus the contact constraint and volume are
Apply a Lagrange multiplier:
For positive dimensions, the derivative equations are
Substituting the last equation into the first two gives
Hence , and the constraint becomes . Therefore
These are the maximal cylinder and box in an elliptic paraboloid dimensions for the rectangular case. A horizontal rotation of the square footprint gives the same volume by rotational symmetry.
Let . Using Lagrange multipliers with gives
The third equation fixes . The first two then reduce to and . If , their solution and the constraint give
At , the second equation requires and makes the first inconsistent; at , it requires and gives the same inconsistency. Thus there is no constrained stationary point when . The constraint gradient never vanishes because its vertical component is one, so the multiplier condition has not excluded any regular constrained stationary points.
Write and use Lagrange multipliers for the particle-number and energy constraints. The stationary equations are
Thus . Finite normalization over infinitely many levels requires . Put , so . The geometric series gives
Therefore
For the energy constraint, use and , obtained by differentiating the geometric series. This yields
Recognizing the hyperbolic cotangent gives
The strict positivity of all occupations requires ; the paper's positivity assumptions alone do not guarantee this feasibility condition. For admissible energy the multiplier is uniquely . Equality is only the limiting state with all occupation in level zero, outside the stipulated strictly positive family; lower energy is impossible.
For rigor beyond formal multiplier equations, has fixed mean . The objective differs from times its information entropy only by the fixed constant . The maximum entropy distribution on the nonnegative integers is uniquely geometric at that mean, confirming the stationary family and its maximum character.
For a closed circular cylinder, and the volume constraint is . Use a Lagrange multiplier:
The stationary equations are
For , the second gives ; the first then gives . The constraint yields
and
To verify a global minimum, eliminate to obtain . It tends to infinity at both ends of and has , so its unique stationary point is the global minimum.
The base lies in the plane . Its circular rim lies on the sphere, so
Maximize the cone volume using the Lagrange multiplier expression
For a nondegenerate cone, the equation gives . The equation is , hence . Combining this with gives
Indeed, eliminating gives , which vanishes at the endpoints and has a unique positive interior maximum at . Thus
Because all variables are positive, the product constraint is equivalent to . The Lagrange multiplier equations for
are . Thus every equals , and the constraint requires . The candidate minimum is therefore
For a global justification, put . The objective becomes the strictly convex function on the affine constraint . A stationary point of this restricted convex function is its unique global minimum, establishing the claim without presupposing the desired inequality.
Finally take and divide the minimum bound by . This is the arithmetic-geometric mean inequality:
with equality exactly when all the positive variables are equal.
For a right prism with equilateral triangular ends, the triangle area is . Thus its volume and external area are
Apply the Lagrange multiplier method to with positive lengths. The stationarity equations are
The second gives . Substitution in the first then gives , or . The area constraint becomes
Consequently
The resulting volume is . As a check on the maximum, eliminating gives , whose second derivative is negative for every admissible positive ; volume also tends to zero at both degenerate boundary shapes.
At a regular constrained extremum, every tangent vector to the level set gives zero directional derivative of . Thus is perpendicular to the tangent plane, and must be a scalar multiple of its nonzero normal vector . The Lagrange multiplier equations are
One solves these four equations for , evaluates at the candidates, and classifies or compares the values as required. Points where , and any boundary or limiting cases of the feasible domain, require separate checks because the regularity argument does not cover them.
Use . The Lagrange multiplier equations are
Taking the dot product with gives , so .
If , the first and third equations give . The middle equation then gives , so . The norm constraint gives and . Thus the hottest points and their temperature are
The coldest points are
For , the equations give , , and hence the other two constrained stationary points are
They are saddle points of the restriction to the sphere: with and as local tangent coordinates there, changes sign in every neighbourhood. The surface is compact and smooth, so the listed extreme temperatures are global. Here “zero gradient on the surface” means zero surface gradient; the ambient gradient at the hottest and coldest points is normal to the sphere, rather than zero.
Introduce the second constraint and a second Lagrange multiplier . At points where the two constraint gradients are linearly independent, solve
These are five scalar equations for . The two constraint normal vectors span the normal plane to the feasible curve. Points where those gradients become dependent must be examined separately; the regular two-multiplier condition need not cover them.