Past exam of the particle Astrophysics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 Paper 1 2 Solution 2026-10-20
Gravitational evidence requires much more nonbaryonic matter than can be supplied by ordinary luminous material or by the baryon abundance permitted by nucleosynthesis. A stable, electrically neutral massive particle is a plausible cold component. Thermal production followed by cosmological particle freeze-out gives an additional motivation: an annihilation rate near a weak-interaction scale can leave an appreciable relic abundance. This is a mechanism and search hypothesis, not proof that the dark matter must be a WIMP or have any particular elastic-scattering cross section.
The plotted regions are conditional WIMP interpretations of different measurements. The experiments use different targets and distinguish signal from background differently:
- DAMA experiment uses NaI(Tl) particle scintillation and seeks an annual variation of low-energy single-hit counts as the Earth's velocity through the halo changes. Multiple-hit events and other energy ranges provide controls, but particle scintillation alone does not identify every event as an electron or nuclear recoil. Converting the modulation into mass and cross section requires a halo model and nuclear-recoil quenching factor assumptions.[ref]New results from DAMA/LIBRA by R. Bernabei and others. abstract and single-hit annual-modulation analysis
- CoGeNT experiment uses a low-capacitance p-type point-contact germanium diode to reach low ionization thresholds. Low-energy event radiation spectrum and a possible annual modulation can suggest light dark matter, but surface charge collection, internal x-ray lines and threshold efficiency must be distinguished from bulk recoil events. Its 2011 modulation paper described a modulated component of unknown origin rather than an unambiguous particle identification.[ref]
- CDMS experiment measures phonons and ionization in cryogenic germanium or silicon. The smaller ionization yield of nuclear recoils and phonon timing help reject electron and surface events. The lowered-threshold germanium analysis improves low-mass sensitivity, at the cost of more difficult background discrimination near threshold; this explains why distinct 2010 and 2011 curves appear.[ref]Results from a Low-Energy Analysis of the CDMS II Germanium Data by CDMS Collaboration. abstract; low-threshold analysis and background discussion
- XENON100 uses a dual-phase xenon detector. A recoil produces prompt liquid particle scintillation, S1, and ionization electrons. A drift field transports the charge to the surface; extracted electrons produce gas electroluminescence, S2. Drift delay and the S2 light pattern reconstruct position, while S2/S1 statistically separates electron and nuclear recoils. An inner fiducial volume suppresses external radiation. Neutron and gamma calibrations establish recoil response and leakage, and low-light-yield calibration is particularly important for light WIMPS. Neutrons can themselves mimic nuclear recoils.[ref]The XENON100 Dark Matter Experiment by the XENON100 Collaboration. detector principle, signal reconstruction and calibration sections
The plot also includes CRESST experiment, whose cryogenic calcium-tungstate modules combine phonon and scintillation-light signals. Different nuclei contribute to its recoil interpretation. Its excess region is another conditional candidate region, not an extra confirmed detection.[ref]
Around ten GeV, the shaded regions favour cross sections roughly –, while the XENON100 solid curve and the improved low-mass CDMS curve cut into or exclude much of those regions under the common elastic, spin-independent WIMP-nucleus scattering interpretation expressed per nucleon. There is tension within that shared model; the plot does not show mutually confirmed discoveries. electron backgrounds, threshold response, nuclear-recoil quenching factors, channeling assumptions and the halo velocity distribution can shift interpretations. Changing the interaction model can also alter target comparisons, but cannot establish a WIMP by assertion. The 100-live-day XENON100 result itself reported candidates compatible with estimated background.[ref]
Dark Matter Results from 100 Live Days of XENON100 Data by XENON100 Collaboration. abstract; background-compatible candidates and elastic spin-independent limit
For a rough dimensional event estimate, givesIf a collider production cross section had this value, that small yield, before acceptance and backgrounds, would not support a likely discovery. The plotted nuclear-scattering cross section is not the LHC production cross section, however. Converting between them needs a mediator, couplings, parton distributions and production kinematics; a light stable WIMP would normally be inferred from missing transverse momentum with a visible recoil object, not a visible WIMP track. The mass makes pair production kinematically accessible, but the plot and integrated collider luminosity alone do not decide discovery probability.
For the relic estimate, define and . The sharp-freeze-out relic dilution model givesAssume stable particles, no subsequent annihilation, and . Conserved comoving particle number then givesThe present rest-energy density and its critical fraction areThus the supplied toy model yields a cosmologically substantial density, of the right broad scale to motivate a dark-matter candidate. It is not an independent precision prediction: is imposed and the abundance depends exponentially on it. If entropy degrees of freedom change, entropy conservation instead gives an extra factor in when using the photon temperature. The species content needed to evaluate that correction is not supplied. A realistic calculation also follows residual annihilations with the abundance Boltzmann equation rather than stopping exactly at equilibrium freeze-out.
Complementary nuclear-recoil signals
. Details. Past exam of the particle Astrophysics course of the University of Cambridge 2015 Paper 1 2 Solution Created 2026-10-20 Updated 2026-10-20
Particle candidate. A stable, electrically neutral weakly interacting massive particle can become nonrelativistic before cosmological particle freeze-out. Its annihilation rate per particle eventually falls below the Hubble parameter; the surviving comoving number then remains approximately fixed. A weak-scale annihilation cross section can give a cosmologically significant thermal relic. This is a mechanism and a parameter-scale motivation, not a guarantee that every weakly interacting particle has the right abundance.
supersymmetry supplies neutralinos, mixtures of neutral electroweak gauginos and higgsinos. If a neutralino is the lightest supersymmetric particle and R-parity is conserved, it cannot decay solely into Standard Model particles and is stable. Its electroweak interactions can make it a WIMP. Conservation of R-parity and a neutral lightest state are additional assumptions; R-parity violation, coannihilation, composition and resonant annihilation can substantially change the conclusion.
An underground test. XENON100 at Gran Sasso used a liquid-xenon target in a two-phase time projection chamber. A WIMP scattering elastically from a xenon nucleus could produce a low-energy nuclear recoil. The interaction makes prompt particle scintillation, S1, and ionization electrons. An electric field drifts the electrons upward; their extraction into xenon gas produces delayed electroluminescence, S2. The delay measures depth, while the S2 light pattern determines the transverse position. An inner fiducial volume suppresses surface backgrounds through xenon self-shielding; underground overburden reduces cosmic-ray muons, and shielding and material selection reduce radioactivity.[ref]
The XENON100 Dark Matter Experiment by the XENON100 Collaboration. Detector design, signal formation and background-rejection principles
The S2/S1 ratio separates most electron recoils from nuclear recoils. Gamma-source calibration maps the electron-recoil leakage; an americium–beryllium neutron source calibrates nuclear-recoil response and cut acceptance. Purity and position corrections must be measured, and selection fixed before unblinding the search region. neutrons can themselves produce single nuclear recoils, so discrimination is not perfect; material assays and transport simulations constrain this background. In the 224.6-live-day, 34-kg analysis, two candidate events were compatible with the expected background events. The result constrained scattering cross sections rather than establishing a discovery.[ref]
Dark Matter Results from 225 Live Days of XENON100 Data by the XENON100 Collaboration. Pages 2–4, calibration, blinded selection, neutron background and candidate counts
A predicted count also depends on the local dark matter halo density, distribution of velocities, recoil threshold and nuclear response. Thus a null result constrains a particle model under stated astrophysical assumptions; it does not exclude all dark matter. A collider missing-momentum signal would likewise need independent evidence for a cosmological lifetime.
Original functional schematic of prompt light and delayed charge readout in a two-phase xenon detector
. Details. Relic energy density in the stipulated freeze-out approximation. Let and . Writing the given distribution in energy units givesBy sharp-freeze-out relic dilution, after cosmological particle freeze-out conserve particle number, . In the approximation for the background bath,Inserting the printed inputs yieldsand henceThis is approximately of the stipulated dark-matter energy density, , so the toy calculation gives the right order and is close to the target. At fixed the cancellation of in is exact for the given prefactor, while the present energy density remains proportional to .
The equilibrium exponential must be evaluated at freeze-out, not at today's temperature: equilibrium no longer maintains the particle number afterward. More accurately, comoving entropy conservation gives and multiplies the displayed by , when both counts use the same bath-temperature convention. Thus is the constant- estimate supported by the supplied toy model. A refined abundance would require additional entropy degrees of freedom and annihilation history: realistic entropy release, gradual freeze-out and the model's annihilation channels matter.
Original calculation of the relic-density sensitivity to freeze-out parameter, with the printed mass and constant-entropy-degrees approximation
. Details. Past exam of the particle Astrophysics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 Paper 1 2 Solution 2026-10-20
supersymmetry relates bosons and fermions through fermionic symmetry generators. A main motivation is the Lorentz scalar hierarchy problem: related boson and fermion loop contributions cancel particular ultraviolet sensitivities in an exactly supersymmetric theory. soft supersymmetry breaking leaves residual sensitivity to the superpartner scale, so a very heavy spectrum does not automatically solve naturalness. Supersymmetric matter content can also improve gauge-coupling unification, and a stable neutral lightest superpartner can be a dark-matter candidate. None of these motivations is itself experimental evidence; supersymmetry must be broken if ordinary particles and their partners have different observed masses.
If R-parity is conserved, superpartners are produced in pairs and cascades end in a stable lightest supersymmetric particle. A neutralino LSP can escape the detector, giving missing transverse momentum. Colored squarks and gluinos can generate energetic jets, sometimes b-tagged jets and leptons, plus that imbalance. An inclusive supersymmetry search classifies broad event samples by jet and lepton multiplicities, transverse momentum sums and missing momentum, without requiring a fully reconstructed decay chain.
Background controls are part of the physics argument. Lost-lepton W and top events can be constrained using lepton collider control regions; invisible-Z production can be related to visible-Z or photon samples with appropriate transfer factors. Instrumental imbalance in multijet events needs detector-quality checks and data sidebands. An excess in a collider signal region should survive uncertainty in those extrapolations, efficiencies and luminosity, with independently defined validation regions and attention to the number of searches performed.
An exclusive supersymmetry search targets a more specific production mode and decay pattern. Electroweak chargino-neutralino production can yield three leptons plus missing momentum; a cascade through a slepton can yield a dilepton invariant-mass edge that constrains mass combinations. Such searches often have cleaner backgrounds but depend more strongly on branching fractions and intermediate masses. An endpoint does not necessarily determine every absolute mass without additional observables.
Different spectra require different strategies. For a compressed supersymmetric spectrum, small parent-daughter mass differences make the visible decay products soft. initial-state radiation can recoil against the pair and provide a trigger, supplemented by soft-lepton reconstruction. The ATLAS compressed-spectrum study explicitly uses small neutralino mass differences and initial-state radiation to define a dedicated search rather than applying a hard-lepton selection indiscriminately.[ref]
Search for electroweak production of supersymmetric states in scenarios with compressed mass spectra at 13 TeV with the ATLAS detector by the ATLAS Collaboration. arXiv:1712.08119, abstract and compressed-spectrum search strategy; methodological illustration published after this exam
If R-parity is violated, the LSP can decay visibly, so high-multiplicity jet or lepton channels may matter more than large missing momentum. CMS separately studied hadronic and leptonic final states for this reason.[ref]Searches for R-parity-violating supersymmetry in pp collisions at 8 TeV in final states with 0-4 leptons by the CMS Collaboration. CMS-SUS-14-003, abstract and independent lepton-multiplicity analyses
Long-lived particles instead motivate displaced vertices, disappearing tracks, abnormal ionization or time-of-flight measurements. Thus there is no single model-independent missing-energy cut that covers every supersymmetric spectrum.For the hypothetical relic-density calculation, use the supplied distribution and retain its prefactor exactly. Put , and . Thennumber density, denoted in the paper, is written here to distinguish it from a total particle count. The cosmological particle freeze-out temperature in energy units isAssume a stable nonrelativistic relic, negligible further annihilation and after cosmological particle freeze-out, using sharp-freeze-out relic dilution. Its comoving particle number is conserved, soThe particle mass cancels from this present number density under the stated approximation. Its present rest-energy density is , not merely :This is only 0.371% of the critical density, not a universe-closing component. The correct further comparison is with the measured dark-matter fraction, not an assumption that all critical density must be dark matter. In standard cosmology this abundance would be a small subcomponent, despite a possible collider discovery.
The exponential freeze-out sensitivity makes the result highly sensitive to . Also, thermal entropy release means is not exactly constant through the whole cosmic history. If total comoving entropy is conserved, the above number density acquires a factor , involving entropy degrees of freedom. Those degrees of freedom and a full annihilation history are not given, so no precise correction is justified from the supplied data.
The supplied cosmological particle freeze-out model is exponentially sensitive to the decoupling parameter
. Original calculation using only the stated mass, present temperature, and critical density. The marked point is ; the curve omits changes in entropy degrees of freedom and residual annihilation. Details.Establishing the nature of dark matter would require more than measuring a missing particle's collider mass. Measure its spin, charges, interactions, decay lifetime or stability limits, and annihilation or coannihilation processes; compare the resulting relic calculation with cosmological observations. Seek compatible direct nuclear-recoil signals and indirect annihilation or decay products, while controlling astrophysical and detector backgrounds. A collider-invisible lifetime need not be cosmologically long, and nonthermal production could change the abundance. A consistent particle identity, cosmological abundance and independent non-collider evidence are needed to connect the hypothetical discovery to the dark matter.



