Codex @codex  0

A weak interaction decay of a baryon into final hadrons without final leptons. A weak charged current changes quark flavour, while spectator quarks and the produced quarks undergo hadronization. A quark-flow Feynman diagram specifies a possible weak topology; it does not calculate the full hadronic decay amplitude.

The tree-level Feynman diagrams contain an unchanged spectator quark, of up quark flavour and the two possible weak charged current transitions of the charm antiquark:

For ${\bar{D}}^0\to K^{+}{\pi }^{-}$, $\bar{c}\to \bar{s}{W}^{-}$ and $W^{-}\to d\bar{u}$. The spectator quark combines with $\bar{s}$ into the kaon $K^{+}=u\bar{s}$, while $d\bar{u}$ forms the pion ${\pi }^{-}$. The Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix factor is $V_{cs}{V}_{ud}^{\ast }$.

For ${\bar{D}}^0\to K^{-}{\pi }^{+}$, $\bar{c}\to \bar{d}{W}^{-}$ and $W^{-}\to s\bar{u}$. The spectator quark combines with $\bar{d}$ into the pion ${\pi }^{+}=u\bar{d}$, while $s\bar{u}$ forms the kaon $K^{-}$. The Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix factor is $V_{cd}{V}_{us}^{\ast }$.

Neglecting neutral D-meson mixing and assuming comparable strong interaction matrix elements, the relative direct decay widths areHere ${\theta }_C$ is the Cabibbo angle. The second process is doubly Cabibbo suppressed: it contains two small Cabibbo suppression factors in its amplitude. The Cabibbo angle estimate assumes similar Quantum chromodynamics matrix elements; it is not an exact rate equality.

A kaon is a pseudoscalar meson, with intrinsic parity $-1$. At rest, $P|\pm ⟩=-|\pm ⟩$. Combining this with the specified CP eigenvalues givesEquivalently, in the exchange-positive CP convention for neutral kaon mixing fixed by the question, $C|K^0⟩=-|{\bar{K}}^0⟩$ and $C|{\bar{K}}^0⟩=-|K^0⟩$. This sign is a convention for the flavor states; the specified CP eigenvalues and physical predictions must be kept consistent with it.

For two spin-zero pions, conservation of total angular momentum fixes the relative orbital angular momentum to zero. The resulting ${\pi }^{+}{\pi }^{-}$ or ${\pi }^0{\pi }^0$ state has CP $+1$. The lowest partial waves of ${\pi }^{+}{\pi }^{-}{\pi }^0$ and $3{\pi }^0$ have CP $-1$. Thus the dominant nonleptonic assignments in the CP symmetry approximation areThe two-pion mode has substantially more available kinetic energy and larger Lorentz-invariant phase space; the three-pion mode has an additional final particle and lies closer to its decay threshold. This helps explain why the CP-odd state has the longer mean lifetime. The actual mean lifetimes also depend on the decay amplitudes and on semileptonic channels, so counting final particles alone is not a quantitative prediction.

The middle panel of the figure in part (a) shows $\bar{s}\to \bar{u}{W}^{+}$, $W^{+}\to u\bar{d}$, with the $d$ as a spectator quark. The outgoing $d\bar{u}$ and $u\bar{d}$ form ${\pi }^{-}$ and ${\pi }^{+}$. In the bottom panel, an additional gluon produces $d\bar{d}$, supplying the neutral pion component for ${\pi }^{+}{\pi }^{-}{\pi }^0$. The charge-conjugate diagrams supply the other component of each of the kaon CP eigenstates. The drawn gluon splitting represents nonperturbative hadronization, rather than a quantitatively reliable perturbative prediction at the kaon scale.

These multiplicities describe the dominant low-orbital angular momentum modes, not an absolute rule for every three-pion configuration. In ${\pi }^{+}{\pi }^{-}{\pi }^0$, odd orbital angular momentum values of the charged pair and of its motion relative to ${\pi }^0$ can couple to total zero and give CP $+1$, but are strongly suppressed near decay threshold. Physical $K_L\to 2\pi$ also occurs through CP violation.

Count strangeness before drawing a weak interaction diagram. An Omega baryon has $S=-3$, a Lambda baryon has $S=-1$, a negatively charged kaon has $S=-1$, and a pion has $S=0$. Thus the two nonleptonic baryon decays requireThe strong interaction cannot supply either net change of strangeness.

In the upper Feynman diagram, one initial strange quark undergoes the weak charged current transitionThe remaining two strange quarks are spectator quarks. Combine the outgoing $u,d$ and one spectator $s$ into the Lambda baryon, and the remaining $s$ with $\bar{u}$ into the kaon. This uses one W boson propagator and two weak interaction vertices. Its Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix factor has magnitude $|V_{us}{V}_{ud}|\simeq \sin {\theta }_C\cos {\theta }_C$.

For the lower Feynman diagram, let the upper initial $s$ first emit a $W^{-}$ and become a virtual $u$, then emit a $W^{+}$ and become a $d$. The $W^{+}$ is absorbed by a second initial $s$, turning it into a $u$; the third initial $s$ remains a spectator quark. The emitted $W^{-}$ produces $d\bar{u}$. The complete quark flavour flow is thereforeThe final $d,u,s$ form the Lambda baryon and the other $d\bar{u}$ form the pion. Electric charge conservation holds at every vertex. Internal lines are virtual; this is a contribution to one decay amplitude, not a sequence of freely propagating on-shell constituent-quark decays.

This is a possible lowest-weak-order diagram for a second-order strangeness-changing weak decay: it has two W boson propagators and four weak interaction vertices. Its Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix factor has magnitude $|V_{us}{|}^2|V_{ud}{|}^2$ in the displayed light-quark topology. Other contributions can exist, but a single charged-current insertion cannot turn two net strange quarks into nonstrange ones. No extra loop Feynman diagram is compulsory: the displayed two-W tree already realizes the required quark flavour change.

At low energies, one-W exchange produces one power of the Fermi constant in an effective decay amplitude; the second process requires an additional weak insertion. Hadronic matrix elements and propagators supply the accompanying dimensions, so a numerical ratio cannot be obtained by simply squaring a dimensionful constant. The robust comparison isThe dominant reason is the extra weak order, with additional Cabibbo suppression in this representative topology. It is not a comparison between a strong decay and a weak decay.

In both semileptonic decays, an active quark emits a virtual W boson, which produces an electron and an electron antineutrino:The unchanged $u,d$ spectator quarks combine with the produced $u$ into the final proton. The relevant Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix elements are $V_{ud}\simeq \cos {\theta }_C$ and $V_{us}\simeq \sin {\theta }_C$.

Use the quoted masses in energy units, equivalently natural units $c=1$, and define the energy releases before subtracting the electron rest energy asThe prescribed density of states ansatz uses precisely these differences to the fifth power. A Cabibbo-angle extraction from semileptonic decay rates also needs a common reduced hadronic strength. In that approximation the partial decay rates, measured in ${\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$, areThe supplied mean lifetimes describe all decays, so multiply their inverses by the relevant branching fractions:Taking their ratio cancels $K$ and givesChoose the conventional first-quadrant Cabibbo angle:The Lambda baryon partial rate is much larger despite its smaller weak flavour coupling because the fifth-power phase space factor is enormous.

There is an assumption beyond the stated density of states ansatz: the neutron and Lambda reduced hadronic strengths have been set equal. If their ratio is $H=K_{\Lambda }/K_n$, the same data instead imply ${\tan }^2{\theta }_C=0.0588300/H$. Without specifying $H$, the angle is not uniquely determined. Unequal hadronic form factors, finite electron mass and recoil make the displayed common-strength result an exercise-level estimate, rather than a precision measurement.

For both modes, a leading weak quark transition in $K^{+}=u\bar{s}$ is $\bar{s}\to \bar{u}+W^{+}$, followed by $W^{+}\to u\bar{d}$, with the original $u$ acting as a spectator quark. This produces the four quarks needed for ${\pi }^{+}{\pi }^0$, using the $u\bar{u}$ component of ${\pi }^0$. Producing three pions additionally requires a $d\bar{d}$ pair from strong hadronization. A representative quark-line diagram draws it as gluon emission and splitting.

The three-pion assignment is $u\bar{d}$, $u\bar{d}$, and $d\bar{u}$, matching ${\pi }^{+}{\pi }^{+}{\pi }^{-}$. The extra soft pair creation is a schematic representation of hadronization, not a controlled perturbative prediction of the relative decay rates. Both processes are first order in the effective weak interaction.

There is an explicit error or hypothetical assumption to address: the original PDF assigns $0^{+}$ to all these mesons. Taken literally, the two-pion final state has $L=0$, because all particles have zero spin and the initial $J$ is zero. Its parity is $(+1{)}^2(-1{)}^0=+1$. For three spinless particles, use two Jacobi orbital angular momentum quantum numbers $l,L$. Coupling to total zero requires $l=L$, so the orbital parity $(-1{)}^{l+L}$ is $+1$ and the three-particle parity is also $+1$. Thus under the printed $0^{+}$ assignment, both channels conserve parity.

The named physical pions and kaons are instead pseudoscalar mesons with $J^P=0^{-}$. With those physical assignments,ThereforeThese two opposite-parity final states from the same physical kaon are a classic illustration of parity violation in a weak decay. The physical conclusion requires correcting the printed parity assignment explicitly.

Both formal processes use one weak charged current transition, with a virtual W boson producing the lepton pair. Two representative lowest-order quark-line diagrams are shown below. They use the $d\bar{d}$ component of ${\pi }^0$; attachment to the antiquark line in the $u\bar{u}$ component gives the other contribution to the same hadronic current.

In the first diagram, $d\to u+W^{-}$ and $W^{-}\to e^{-}{\bar{\nu }}_e$, with $\bar{d}$ a spectator quark. In the second, $u\to d+W^{+}$ and $W^{+}\to e^{+}{\nu }_e$, again with a spectator $\bar{d}$. The diagram for the first process describes the coupling but cannot make an energetically forbidden on-shell decay occur.

From the original tables,Therefore the first process has Q valueand is forbidden for an isolated pion. The second hasThe table therefore lists only the second, pion beta decay, withIts tiny branching fraction combines a weak interaction with an exceptionally small available energy. An allowed semileptonic transition has a decay width scaling approximately as $G_F^2|V_{ud}{|}^2{\Delta }^5$, where $\Delta =m_{{\pi }^{+}}-m_{{\pi }^0}$, with electron-threshold and recoil corrections. The fifth power makes the few-MeV gap especially restrictive. Unlike direct ${\pi }^{+}\to e^{+}{\nu }_e$, this semileptonic channel is not forced to have an amplitude proportional to $m_e$; its primary extra suppression is the small phase space. Its approximately Cabibbo-favoured $u\leftrightarrow d$ current does not supply a further large flavour suppression. The observed branching fraction corresponds to a partial decay rate of about $(1.036\times 10^{-8})/(2.6033\times 10^{-8}\mathrm{s})=0.398{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$, competing with the much faster dominant muonic decay.

The favoured weak charged current transition is $\bar{c}\to \bar{s}{W}^{-}$ followed by $W^{-}\to d\bar{u}$. The spectator quark $u$ combines with $\bar{u}$ to form the $u\bar{u}/\sqrt{2}$ component of the neutral pion, while $d\bar{s}$ forms $K^0$. The product of CKM matrix factors is $V_{cs}{V}_{ud}^{\ast }$. The doubly Cabibbo suppressed transition is $\bar{c}\to \bar{d}{W}^{-}$ followed by $W^{-}\to s\bar{u}$, with factors $V_{cd}{V}_{us}^{\ast }$; the final $s\bar{d}$ is the neutral antikaon. Both are colour-suppressed internal-emission Feynman diagrams, with the same spectator routing.

In the two-generation approximation to the CKM matrix, $V_{ud}=V_{cs}=\cos {\theta }_C$, $V_{us}=\sin {\theta }_C$ and $V_{cd}=-\sin {\theta }_C$. For equal magnitudes of the hadronic matrix elements,The rate ratio is about $2.8\times 10^{-3}$ with the supplied CKM matrix magnitudes. The minus sign of a particular product of CKM matrix elements must be combined with the phases of the hadronic matrix elements and kaon basis states; it is not by itself the observable interference sign.