Use the outward orientation on the unit hemisphere and counterclockwise boundary orientation on the unit circle. With and , the vector line integral is
For the surface integral, and the outward unit normal vector is , since the radius is one. The cross product is
The integral of is zero by reflection symmetry. Using the same spherical polar coordinates as in ii, with , the other component is
Hence
verifying the vector-valued Stokes identity directly, component by component. The wedge symbol in the paper denotes the cross product here.
Write for the paper's . In a right-handed Cartesian coordinate system, the cross product is
It is perpendicular to both vectors, has norm , where is their angle, and has direction given by the right-hand rule when nonzero. Its norm is the area of the parallelogram spanned by the two vectors.
If , use that parallelogram as the base of the parallelepiped. Its perpendicular height is , where . Thus its volume is
If , both the volume and this scalar triple product vanish. If the cross product is nonzero, the scalar triple product vanishes exactly when lies in the plane spanned by . If it is zero, are linearly dependent, and adjoining still spans at most a plane. Consequently the three vectors are coplanar if and only if , including cases involving a zero vector.
Expand the first component using the definition of the cross product:
The added terms cancel in the last step. Cyclically permuting the component indices gives the other two components, proving the vector triple product identity
The vector triple product identity gives
Eliminate with iii to obtain the reciprocal basis involution:
This formula actually holds without the unit-length assumptions. Under those assumptions it also says ; normalizing this cross product alone would lose the sign of and could return .
Let be an arbitrary constant vector. By the cyclic identity for the scalar triple product,
Apply Stokes theorem to . Since is constant, the curl product identity gives
Consequently
For precision, the operator in the last line has components
The partial derivatives act on , with multiplying their values; they do not differentiate . Since the dot products agree for every constant , the cross-product form of Stokes theorem follows:
Here in the paper denotes the cross product, and the printed surface integral has its area element understood.
A normal vector to the plane spanned by is their cross product:
Dividing by this Euclidean norm gives the two possible choices of unit normal,
The two edge vectors based at are and . Their cross product is , with squared Euclidean norm . The triangle occupies half the corresponding parallelogram, so
Two directions in the plane are and . Their cross product is a normal vector. Moreover,
so cannot vanish. The required unit normal and offset are
Taking dot products with gives the same offset for all three points.
Take the dot product of the equation with . Since , we obtain . Next take its cross product with and apply the vector triple product identity:
Substitute and the known dot product, then rearrange:
Here the vectors and are real, so the denominator is positive. The formula also covers , giving . To check existence as well as uniqueness, write its numerator as . The vector triple product identity gives , so . Substitution verifies the original equation. This is an instance of the inverse of a scalar plus a cross-product operator.
The displacement vectors are and . Their cross product is , with Euclidean norm three. Thus either sign of
is a unit normal vector to the second plane, whose equation is . A direction vector for the intersection is the cross product of the two normal vectors:
It is orthogonal to each normal vector. Since both planes contain , the whole intersection line is , .
Take , and . The two plane directions are and . Their cross product is , so a normal vector is . The Cartesian equation of a plane is therefore
Each given point satisfies it, and the nonzero cross product confirms that the points determine a unique plane.
Choose a common origin at vertex , set and , and orient the remaining edge as . Then
This convention makes the interior angle between and equal to , and their lengths equal to the opposite side lengths and .
Figure 1.
Consistently oriented triangle edge vectors for the sine and cosine rules
. An original illustrative triangle with two vectors from vertex and their difference from to . Side labels are opposite the corresponding vertices. Details.
Take the dot product of the difference with itself. Since , the law of cosines follows:
The magnitude of the cross product of two edge vectors is twice the triangle's area . Applying this at each vertex gives . Divide by the nonzero product to obtain the law of sines:
Let , and . Cross products give plane normals and . Their dot product is and each has norm . Thus the acute angle between two planes is
This is also the interior dihedral angle here: perpendicular to the common edge , the interior wedge lies between the projected directions and . The two outward face normals instead make the supplementary angle.
The face has edge vectors and . Their cross product is , so choose the outward normal vector . The angle between vectors obeys
Reversing the chosen normal gives the supplementary angle ; the acute angle with the normal line is .
The magnitude of the cross product of two edge vectors is the area of their parallelogram. The triangular face occupies half of it:
Orient the triangle by the path . The cross product gives the positive normal vector. In the plane , the triangular region is , . The surface integral in Stokes theorem is therefore
For the boundary line integral, has , so contributes zero. On , and only is nonzero, so its contribution is also zero. Parametrize by , . Its contribution is
Thus both oriented integrals equal . Reversing the orientation would reverse both signs.
Use the vector triple product identity twice:
Subtracting cancels the common term, yielding
It is generally nonzero: the cross product does not satisfy the associative property.
The vector triple product identity and give
Apply once more. The term parallel to vanishes under its cross product with , leaving . The result includes .